Horror Recs by Place
A Prayer for Owen Meany

Questions About A Prayer for Owen Meany

by John Irving (Goodreads Author)

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about A Prayer for Owen Meany, please sign up.

Answered Questions (26)

Would this book be interesting for a non-Christian? How serious are the religious undertones?
Neil Procter I'm an atheist and this is one of my favourite books. Yes it is about one person's belief in a supreme being coming as the result of the events he wit…moreI'm an atheist and this is one of my favourite books. Yes it is about one person's belief in a supreme being coming as the result of the events he witnesses, but it is not a Christian tract. I don't know what John Irving's religious beliefs are but I wouldn't dare assume form this book that he is a believer. It is a fiction, whose narrator has found reason to believe in God through the events that befall him. If an author wrote a book about a vicar it wouldn't mean it was a book just for Christians.(less)
flag
I am afraid of large books because I usually rent from the library, and I never seem to finish them on time, regardless of myself taking them out again. I am a pretty slow reader. How long did it take to read this book?
Nina You're right Magdalen, it is a very slow read and he repeats a lot. I got impatient at how long it was taking me, but I more or less enjoyed it. I lov…moreYou're right Magdalen, it is a very slow read and he repeats a lot. I got impatient at how long it was taking me, but I more or less enjoyed it. I love the movie Simon Birch which was "inspired" by this book and that movie only includes about 20% of the book and changes a lot.

Oh, just as a random comment, it always surprises me to see on literary sites such as this, the mis-use of the word "it's" when "its" is correct. If you are unsure of its usage, simply replace "it is" and see if the sentence still works....English grammar 101 people.(less)
flag
There is so much foreshadowing hinting that Mr. Fish is Owen's father that I'm sure he is despite the book never saying so. What do you think?
Dawn Gosse I think you didn't finish the book.…moreI think you didn't finish the book.(less)
flag
There are many 5-star ratings for this book-- my question is in two parts: (a) Is there anyone here who is non-religious who rated it 5 stars? (b) Those who rated it 5 stars, did you rate it that highly because of its religious themes, in spite of them, or do you consider them not relevant to your rating?
Fenrir I am an atheist and I rated it 5 stars. "I am a Christian because of Owen Meany" -- I choose to read this as "I am a Christian FOR of Owen Meany".
The…moreI am an atheist and I rated it 5 stars. "I am a Christian because of Owen Meany" -- I choose to read this as "I am a Christian FOR of Owen Meany".
The strong religious belief of the narrator can be understood not as an act of faith, but as an act of love. He believes so that he can bear witness to his friend’s life, to give testimony, to honor it. In that sense, the religious aspects become inherently social and that is something even I can understand. The religious content has not bothered me once, even though I personally don’t believe, it’s all just part of a brilliant book.

(less)
flag
I couldn't help but hear the voice of Atticus Shaffer (known for playing Brick in The Middle) as Owen Meany. He would still be young enough to play the adult Owen. What do you think? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XC2VGUVvvAg
Debby Marschman That is an excellent comparison! I can totally hear Owen as Brick, maybe a little louder but the same voice. Owen was short and compact, I can't recal…moreThat is an excellent comparison! I can totally hear Owen as Brick, maybe a little louder but the same voice. Owen was short and compact, I can't recall if Brick was short for his age... They did make a movie adaption of this called "Simon Birch" in 1998. I haven't seen but plan to(less)
flag

Unanswered Questions (2)

About Goodreads Q&A

Ask and answer questions about books!

You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.

See Featured Authors Answering Questions

Learn more