Dear Nathan

Questions About Dear Nathan

by Erisca Febriani (Goodreads Author)

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Dear Nathan, please sign up.

Answered Questions (2)

Hi i really want to ask those who has read the story (either on wattpad or the book version). Does it really resemble Esti Kinasih's Jingga dan Senja book in terms of story line, backgrounds story, plots, and else? Thank you
Jasmine Yes. Erisca has said that the story was 'inspired' by Jingga dan Senja. And then she said it was her real love story with her ex. But at the end, she …moreYes. Erisca has said that the story was 'inspired' by Jingga dan Senja. And then she said it was her real love story with her ex. But at the end, she didn't mention in her novel that the story was 'inspired' by Jingga dan Senja. She mentioned Devil Besides You instead. Why? Because a lot of people, especially Jingga dan Senja lovers, have known that her novel resembles Jingga dan Senja. They have already protested but Erisca claimed that it was her own story. FYI, she also wouldn't like to be critised. How pathetic. What kind of author is she??(less)
flag
kenapa agak mirip dengan cerita trilogi jingga dan senja karya esti kinasih ya ?? saya penggemar novel esti kinasih, tp cukup bagus untuk karya penulis awal. mungkin karna esti kinasih lebih berpengalaman jadi karya juga lebih kuat dan alurnya juga lebih bagus.. mulai dari karakter nathan yg mirip dengan karakter Ari di trilogi jingga dan senja. dan banyak bagian lain nya
Jasmine Baru nyadar?? Aku udah lama bgt tau kalo novel Dear Nathan ini plagiat Jingga & Senja series. Kenapa aku berani bilang plagiat? Karna kenyataannya ema…moreBaru nyadar?? Aku udah lama bgt tau kalo novel Dear Nathan ini plagiat Jingga & Senja series. Kenapa aku berani bilang plagiat? Karna kenyataannya emang gitu kok. Dari storyline, karakterisasi tokoh, gaya bahasa, dll yg dipakai Erisca di novel Dear Nathan banyak ambil dari Jingga & Senja series. Bahkan penggunaan diksi di cerita Dear Nathan, Erisca jg niru2 Kak Esti. FYI aja, dulu Erisca sendiri bilang kalo cerita Dear Nathan 'terinspirasi' dari Jingga & Senja. Tp dia terinspirasinya salah. Erisca nggak bisa membedakan yg mana 'inspirasi' & yg mana 'plagiat'? & jatohnya ya gini. Tapi dimana2 yg original emang jauh lebih bagus... :)(less)
flag

Unanswered Questions (3)

About Goodreads Q&A

Ask and answer questions about books!

You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.

See Featured Authors Answering Questions

Learn more