Stay In and Read with 51 of This Year's Coziest Mysteries!

Posted by Sharon on October 11, 2023


The phrase “cozy mystery” is a useful neologism; it’s the emerging consensus term for mystery stories where the sex and darkness are toned down, and any violence takes place off page. It’s a kinder, gentler style of crime fiction. Cozy mysteries are a nice option for those of us who like to puzzle over a whodunit without all the bad vibes and viscera.
 
We’ve collected here a generous batch of new cozy mysteries, all published (or hitting shelves later) in 2023. This time around, we’ve sorted the contemporary mysteries from historical fiction. Returning fans will note some familiar names, like Jessie Q. Sutanto, Richard Osman, and Nita Prose, whose debut novel, The Maid, won last year’s Goodreads Choice Award for Best Mystery.
 
Scroll down, browse around, and savor the illustrations—for some reason, cozy mysteries tend to have really great cover art (and the punniest titles of any genre). It’s a weirdly consistent thing. Consider this one, or this one, or especially this one. If anything you see here inspires further sleuthing, add the book to your own Want to Read shelf.
 
 

2023's Contemporary Cozy Mysteries


2023's Historical Cozy Mysteries



Do you love a cozy mystery? Let us know what you're reading in the comments below!


Comments Showing 1-32 of 32 (32 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Julia (new)

Julia Modde Great List! But I wonder: where are the Sci-Fi Cozy Mysteries? I loved „Spare Man“ and „Mimicking of known success” - and I need to know: is there more like those out there?


message 2: by Law (new)

Law I just saw The Last Devil to Die at my library, can't wait to read it! Do I have to read the previous books if that's part of a series or can I read it as a standalone?


message 3: by Abi (new)

Abi North Law wrote: "I just saw The Last Devil to Die at my library, can't wait to read it! Do I have to read the previous books if that's part of a series or can I read it as a standalone?"

With his past 3 books in the series, they all have stand alone plots so you might be able to. It depends how much you want to fully understand the characters and who they are. There might be some mentions to things that have happened in previous books however. Overall, the other 3 i found really enjoyable and would recommend giving them a go


message 4: by Crissy (new)

Crissy So many great reads have been added to my fall tbr pile!


message 5: by Melanie (new)

Melanie Law wrote: "I just saw The Last Devil to Die at my library, can't wait to read it! Do I have to read the previous books if that's part of a series or can I read it as a standalone?"

You're missing out on so much fun if you don't! I highly recommend them.


message 6: by Brandon (new)

Brandon Harbeke You aren't kidding about the gorgeous cover art in this article. That is some truly outstanding work!


Me, My Shelf, & I Law wrote: "I just saw The Last Devil to Die at my library, can't wait to read it! Do I have to read the previous books if that's part of a series or can I read it as a standalone?"

Definitely read the others first. The first book is the weakest in the series, the fourth book made me sob non-stop for twenty minutes (and I don't think I've ever cried at a book before).


message 8: by Kelly (last edited Oct 11, 2023 08:25AM) (new)

Kelly Hartz The Last Devil to DieI would definitely start at the beginning of this wonderful series! You don't want to miss a thing! And many of the characters recur through the series so you'd be missing out if you don't read them in order.


message 9: by Mar (new)

Mar Every single time goodreads posts something mystery related, my mood always goes up. Gotta give all these a chance


message 10: by dany (new)

dany THANK YOU for separating contemporary and historical


message 11: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl H. Julia wrote: "Great List! But I wonder: where are the Sci-Fi Cozy Mysteries? I loved „Spare Man“ and „Mimicking of known success” - and I need to know: is there more like those out there?"

I read a lot of Diane Vallere's cozies, but haven't tried her Sylvia Stryker Space Case Mysteries Box Set since I'm not really into sci-fi. I did also find a list of 9 other cozy sci-fi books by googling "sci-fi cozies". Hope you find some good reads!


message 12: by Cheryl (new)

Cheryl H. Thank you for the cozy mystery lists. I will be adding a bunch from each section to my TBR.


message 13: by Sue (new)

Sue I'd also add The Mystery of Treefall Manor to that list. I finished it a recently and can't stop raving about it!


message 14: by Kirinna (new)

Kirinna Nothing is more cozy to me than reading Sherlock Holmes pastiches and getting sent back to Victorian London to solve cases, but I'll check some of these out as well they seem lovely!


message 15: by Jocelyn (new)

Jocelyn Julia wrote: "Great List! But I wonder: where are the Sci-Fi Cozy Mysteries? I loved „Spare Man“ and „Mimicking of known success” - and I need to know: is there more like those out there?"

Have you read Station Eternity by Mur Lafferty?


message 16: by Lucía (new)

Lucía Ok, ok, I do love a cozy mistery. Perfect for an autumn reading.


message 17: by Laurien (new)

Laurien Berenson What a great group of books! Thank you.


message 18: by Katie (new)

Katie Mastering the Art of French Murder is set in the 50's, so definitely not a contemporary book. The premise is that the main character is a neighbor of Julia Childs. A great book, though!


message 19: by Rachel (new)

Rachel Law wrote: "I just saw The Last Devil to Die at my library, can't wait to read it! Do I have to read the previous books if that's part of a series or can I read it as a standalone?"
I highly recommend reading the previous books first.


message 20: by Heidi (new)

Heidi Law wrote: "I just saw The Last Devil to Die at my library, can't wait to read it! Do I have to read the previous books if that's part of a series or can I read it as a standalone?"

Better to read the series, as many of the previous characters and murders are referenced.


message 21: by Pauli (new)

Pauli Julia wrote: "Great List! But I wonder: where are the Sci-Fi Cozy Mysteries? I loved „Spare Man“ and „Mimicking of known success” - and I need to know: is there more like those out there?"

Check out "Station Eternity" by Mur Lafferty. If you like that, "Chaos Terminal" is the second book in the series, coming soon. My


message 22: by Ellery (new)

Ellery Adams What a fabulous list! Love the gorgeous covers and clever titles.

Thank you for including Paper Cuts!


message 23: by Sally (new)

Sally Looking forward to Murder Most Royal. I read the first 2 books in this series and found them delightful. Sad that we've lost our protagonist.


message 24: by Jeanie (new)

Jeanie Jackson Really get tired of every book that is recommended looking the same. I find myself turning away books that are probably great because they are mostly from the same time period, one I do not care for, and they all look alike and are not very attractive. Covers matter.


message 25: by Morgan (new)

Morgan Morgal Mastering the Art of French Murder is definitely a historical cozy mystery!! It takes places in Julia Child's time in France! It is both a cozy mystery and a fun retelling of her original book on French cooking


message 26: by Imani (new)

Imani I found two new books I want to read thanks to this list! Hooray!


message 27: by rimaaaa (new)

rimaaaa Julia wrote: "Great List! But I wonder: where are the Sci-Fi Cozy Mysteries? I loved „Spare Man“ and „Mimicking of known success” - and I need to know: is there more like those out there?"

These sound so cute!! Adding them to my to-read thank you!


message 28: by Joy (new)

Joy Violin Conspiracy


message 29: by Joan (last edited Oct 25, 2023 10:15AM) (new)

Joan Law wrote: "I just saw The Last Devil to Die at my library, can't wait to read it! Do I have to read the previous books if that's part of a series or can I read it as a standalone?"

Law wrote: "I just saw The Last Devil to Die at my library, can't wait to read it! Do I have to read the previous books if that's part of a series or can I read it as a standalone?"


message 30: by Joan (new)

Joan I suggest reading them in order. The characters develop over time.


message 31: by Kate (new)

Kate Fellowes Thanks for this fabulous TBR list! I've already read a few of them, but others are new-to-me authors, which is always so exciting. I especially love finding an author with a backlist, because it means hours and hours of reading by the window--the perfect definition of winter sport, IMHO.


message 32: by Deb (new)

Deb Law wrote: "I just saw The Last Devil to Die at my library, can't wait to read it! Do I have to read the previous books if that's part of a series or can I read it as a standalone?"

Best to read in order. You’ll love each and learn the story behind the characters.


back to top