Let's Play: How To Make An Ominous-Sounding Mystery Title

Posted by Marie on April 2, 2018
Goodreads Mystery & Thriller Week 2018

Mystery & Thriller Week is sponsored by Penguin Random House Audio. Enjoy the suspense on audio.

Mainstream mystery titles have the uncanny ability to turn the ordinary into the ominous. Like a macabre version of Mad Libs, sometimes all a title needs is a combination of a person and a place to achieve maximum foreboding. The Body in the Library, The Couple Next Door, and The Woman in the Window are all prime examples of this. And if you want to turn the terror up a notch, you can never go wrong with adding the word "girl" to let readers know that trouble isn't too far away.

The rules to this game are simple: Match your birth month and birth date to the chart below. Then stand back for that spine-tingling (or snicker-inducing) effect. Who knows? Your title could be the next big name in the mystery genre!



What's your bestselling mystery title? Share it with us in the comments!


Comments Showing 1,051-1,100 of 1,633 (1633 new)


message 1051: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Tahera wrote: "The Liar at the Farmer's Market.....Loll we all know who that would be :P"

SAME!! :)


message 1052: by Fiqa (new)

Fiqa Kharshah The Shadow on the Midnight Train


message 1053: by Wealie (new)

Wealie The ‘Imposter in the parking garage’ just seems a bit pedestrian to me 🤪


message 1054: by Elizabeth (new)

Elizabeth The Liar on the Steamboat.


Anaguevara123456gmail.Com The Widow in the Landfill.


message 1056: by Jazz24 (new)

Jazz24 The Body in Room no. 8 !!

Poor room no. 8, what did it do to you ?!


message 1057: by Imogen (new)

Imogen The Shadow Under the Stairs.

Harry Potter spin-off?


message 1058: by George (new)

George Evil at the Abandoned Theme Park (Book 1 in the Scooby Doo adult series)


message 1059: by Naw (new)

Naw The Imposter on Flight 42

X) sounds promising


message 1060: by Farai (new)

Farai The Widow on the Midnight Train


message 1061: by Brian (new)

Brian The Widow at the DMV. It was the perfect crime ... until she tried to get the title to his Lamborghini.


message 1062: by Jody (new)

Jody The Shadow in the Panic Room


message 1063: by Rory (new)

Rory Kerr Murder on the midnight train


message 1064: by Angel (new)

Angel Couper Death in the fun house. Scary.


message 1065: by Karolina Kat (new)

Karolina Kat "The Shadow on the Cruise Ship" - I'd love for it to be a Poirot novel, or maybe Holmes-one? It definitely sounds like one of the classic British crime stories.


message 1066: by lucie (new)

lucie The Shadow on the Steamboat

doesnt sound so bad


message 1067: by Lisa the Tech (new)

Lisa the Tech The Widow in the Cemetery. Ghostly with a dash of sorrow. I like it.


message 1068: by Jamie (new)

Jamie Girard Evil in the Vitamin Aisle...lol


message 1069: by Kaki (new)

Kaki The Stranger at the Botanical Garden. Odd but it could be good....


message 1070: by Danielle (new)

Danielle Teo The Shadow in the Waiting Room


message 1071: by Hayley (new)

Hayley The Stalker in the Fun House


message 1072: by Nithya (new)

Nithya Murder in the Funhouse

Sounds like an episode from Supernatural :D


message 1073: by Jessica (new)

Jessica The Woman Under the Stairs...


message 1074: by JuanMi (new)

JuanMi The Stranger in the Meat Locker


message 1075: by Kristen (new)

Kristen Peppercorn The Widow in the Casino. I would not read that if you paid me. lol

My mom's is The Liar in Room No. 8. Now that I might read.


message 1076: by Elda (new)

Elda Mengisto The Widow in the Waiting Room


message 1077: by Readaholic Jenn (new)

Readaholic Jenn The body in the cemetery


message 1078: by Les (new)

Les The Imposter at the Abandoned Theme Park


message 1079: by Bea (new)

Bea The Body at the empty zoo, boriing!


message 1080: by Zachary (new)

Zachary The Devil in the All Night Diner
Ya know, I like it


message 1081: by Kira (new)

Kira Baker The Stalker in the Landfill...
Can I get a nomination for worst title?


message 1082: by Emily (new)

Emily Death at the Empty Zoo

That's a good trick, seeing as empty implies there's no one around to get killed or to do the killing on account of the zoo being empty.

Of course, the easy way out would be for the zoo to be "empty" because it's under construction and is thus not yet open or housing any animals, making the killer and/or killee likely to be employees or the owners or something. But that doesn't sound nearly as compelling. In fact, that seems rather mundane really.


message 1083: by Laura (new)

Laura Murder in the Emergency Room!
Actually does sound like a great read and something I could tackle.
And you?


message 1084: by Marc (new)

Marc Childs Death in the Landfill.....lol


message 1085: by Karen (new)

Karen Smithson The Stranger in the Warehouse


message 1086: by Ulla (new)

Ulla The woman in the meat locker
How ugly! I don't like that. Especially as I am a vegetarian.


message 1087: by Ulla (new)

Ulla Haley wrote: "The Woman on the Steamboat" That's a nice one


*Curlyheadme* But I'll answer to Josie! The Body At The DMV ;)


message 1089: by Imani (new)

Imani Nov 7th: The Stalker at the DMV.

How curious and ironic. I can't drive and Stalker behaviors frighten me the most.


message 1090: by Noah (new)

Noah Wanhala The Body on Flight 42

If I could pick one I'd use: The Woman at the Empty Zoo


message 1091: by Andrew (new)

Andrew Evil In The Wardrobe!

When can I buy it?!?!


message 1092: by Emily (new)

Emily Thrash The Widow in the Broom Closet.

I like it better the way I misread it first...

The Window in the Broom Closet.

Now that's creepy.


message 1093: by N.E.C.C. (new)

N.E.C.C. The Shadow at the Car Dealership.


ฅ⁠^⁠•⁠ﻌ⁠•⁠^⁠ฅ The stranger under the stairs


message 1095: by Giancarlo (new)

Giancarlo Marquez The Stranger on the Midnight Train.


message 1096: by Giancarlo (new)

Giancarlo Marquez Ruth Ann wrote: "The Stalker at the Botanical Garden"

I'd buy that.


message 1097: by Alondra (new)

Alondra Miller The Stranger in the Broom Closet

*wonders why someone would hide in a broom closet*


message 1098: by Candy (last edited Apr 06, 2018 09:26AM) (new)

Candy Evil in the Warehouse ... sounds like another public service film :)

My sister's is The Devil on the Midnight Train ... I like hers better!


message 1099: by Candace (new)

Candace The Woman at the DMV


message 1100: by Brian (new)

Brian Evil at the two-star Hotel


back to top