Up to My Knees In Mud

By the time you read this I will be in Bonnie Scotland and, judging by weather reports, up to my knees in rain and mud. I will be cold and wet and happy--and very likely a little hung-over from the night before.  :-)

A lot of the other kind of mud was slung my way this past week. Although I did not make the decision to reveal my identity lightly, was braced for disapproval, disappointment, even distaste...I have to admit I was taken aback by the hysteria and vitriol that boiled and bubbled for nearly a week. Slopping over not just me, but the entire M/M community. A community that prides itself on "understanding," "acceptance," "tolerance," and "compassion."

It turns out that--for a few--a prism is just a one dimensional photo on a blog page.


Many cruel and cutting comments from people who know the power of words. Aimed not just at me, but at any one who dared to speak up on my behalf.

A lot of talk about "authenticity" from people who believe it's a body part. In fact, a couple of gentlemen of the genre came perilously close to stating a straight man would have more authenticity writing gay romance than any woman ever. Because it's all about the bass, 'bout that bass, 'bout that bass. 

A lot of assumptions. Because I am a happily married woman today...I must have always been so. I must have always been this person. Never kissed the wrong boy. Never kissed a girl at all. Never wondered, never worried, never feared, explored, tested, loved and lost...

I was in junior high the first time I was called "lesbo." I was so naïve, so sheltered I didn't even know what it meant--except that it was clearly the worst thing a girl could be.

How is this anyone's business but my own? How is it some people feel they have the right to interrogate me about things my own husband has never felt the need to question?

It has been horrifying and yet fascinating to watch people who know absolutely nothing about my work history or my personal life pronouncing judgment. Feeling comfortable and self-satisfied in their self-righteousness. "Weighing in" and never asking themselves...do I actually have the facts? Am I distorting the facts to fit my own agenda?

I'm a private person, but I tried to share some of the facts in this interview, because I know some people are still genuinely confused and unsure and hurt.

But there really isn't a lot more that I can say--although, like Columbo, here I am with "Just one more thing..." Though they sang louder and did a better job of clapping along with the chorus, the people who believe this kind of "deception" should be punishable by banishment and bankruptcy are a minority. I remain overwhelmed and moved by how much support and kindness I've received during the past week.

Even people who were disappointed and bewildered and hurt reached out to say I won't stop reading you. Don't stop writing. Support from my peers--which means so much--but even more support from readers, so many readers--readers being the people who maybe know me best because they've read my work and they understand what I've been saying all these years. Probably have formed a reasonable idea of who I am--without ever knowing who I kissed.

As painful as this was, I don't regret being honest about who I am. I haven't asked anyone for anything, but...do you really think it was easy to do what I just did?

Okay, fine that was then, but why didn't she drop the veil sooner?

Think about this: for a long time dropping the veil would have meant nothing. I wasn't earning enough here to matter. I chose to drop the veil when I actually have something--a great deal--to lose. I am willing to risk it all. And despite the shrieks of outrage, I don't have any second thoughts on revealing my identity. I don't regret it. It had to be done.

I have a New Adult book coming out in a couple of months. It's a funny story, a nutty story, a silly story. But at heart it's a story about a boy coming to terms with who he is. It's a coming out story. And it occurred to me while writing Jefferson Blythe, Esquire that I could not let that book be published, could not respond to the inevitable reaching out from younger readers--readers the age of my own nieces and nephews--while concealing my truth. That I am a woman. And that my own journey has not always been easy, but I have found my own way. Sometimes by doing as society bade me. Sometimes by following the road less traveled.

Does authenticity come from destination or from journey?

I guess it depends on who you ask. My journey continues.


 
26 likes ·   •  7 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on September 25, 2015 01:00
Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Spiderorchid (new)

Spiderorchid I've always thought that the people who feel the need to rant about others who are not "authentic" (how very '70s by the way - I had hoped society had evolved beyond that cliché), must be very insecure and frustrated thmeselves. There will always be idiots. And hopefully, there will always be writers like you who entertain their readers with intelligent, funny and enjoyable books. It doesn't matter who you are or how you choose to live your private life (it's private after all) - it's your work that matters, which is great and something you can be proud of. Please, keep the good work going! ^_^

My favourite quote concerning all that gender uproar:
"Nobody is perfect."
(If Billy Wilder got it in 1959, why can't people get it now?)


message 2: by A.r. (new)

A.r. Felt a lump in my throat and a few tears there, for you, for me, for so many others....
I don't know how my enjoyment of the m/m genre would have developed without your input, Josh L. Just.... Don't stop the music now... not while we're havin' a good time!

P.s. Kick starter, Patheron or whatever, you give the word and we will come! Oh Boy will we come!


message 3: by Pepón (last edited Sep 27, 2015 07:25AM) (new)

Pepón I am one of those readers that thinks knowing about an author is an important part of reading. In m/m romance, knowing if it is a man or a woman writing allows me to understand, and process better phenomenons like the "self-lubricating, ever receptive & pain free anus", the "evaporating semen", the lack of hair in men (I have the impression men and women lust differently about he male body, see yaoi versus bara), and so on. When I read such things, in my head, they do not mean the same if it's a man or a woman writing. So, yes, knowing about my author has a certain importance.

On the other hand, I have to accept the image the author wants me to have, how s/he wants me to perceive and interpret his/her work. I have no "right" whatsoever to know or "discover" his/her real identity and opinions. S/He has the same right to privacy than everyone else. The pen-name is an old and proven institution in literature, why wouldn't you have a right to it? I don't understand the whole uproar.

So, I am glad to know now you are a woman, as it helps me a bit to understand your writing, but that does not change anything. Your books are still amazing! I hope you keep writing for many years.


message 4: by Misty (new)


message 5: by JR (new)

JR I've read just about every piece that was published about your "coming out". I get it, I really get it, everyone's views, but as I said maybe I'm too old, maybe have have bigger things in my life than to be bent out of shape about the gender of an author. For me "the Book is the Thing". If a gorilla could write like you do, it would be fine by me. Maybe some day this community will practice what it preaches and believe in equality, tolerance, and that gender or who loves who doesn't matter. Keep writing, 'cause I'll keep reading.


message 6: by Donna (last edited Sep 30, 2015 10:11AM) (new)

Donna The stories are all that matter to me. I love authors because I love their stories. I read books written by men and women and what gender they are does not determine what books I read. People that rant about women writing about male main characters or about men writing about female main characters are not supporting equality for all human beings. If I wanted "authenticity" or "real" in my stories and characters, I would read a nonfiction book. I prefer fiction books and books that let me escape from the real world for a while.

I've read a lot of wonderful stories in the M/M genre that were written by women and I fell in love with the characters and their stories. I've also read stories in the M/M genre written by men and loved them just as much.


message 7: by Larry (new)

Larry Hoyt Always have loved your books, and have no idea why the revelation of your gender identity should change that. Thanks for all the hours and days of entertaining me, past, present, and future.


back to top