The Vexations by Caitlin Horrocks, fiction about composer Erik Satie and his family in the Belle Époque

A beautifully melancholic tone permeates this finely written debut novel from acclaimed short story author Horrocks. More than biographical fiction about French avant-garde composer Erik Satie (1866-1925), it’s a multi-perspective saga about the Satie siblings and their circle, and how their lives touched and diverged over decades.

After their father abandons them in 1872, Eric (the original spelling), Louise, and Conrad live with their grandmother in Normandy, until Louise is later sent to stay with her great-uncle. The three never regain their childhood closeness. Now calling himself Erik, the composer pursues music in Paris, and struggles to rise above the cabaret scene, his erratic behavior giving him a “problematic level of fame.” Louise marries into a prominent family yet suffers significant losses.

Erik’s story looks beyond the “tortured genius” stereotype to something more nuanced and real, while both Louise and painter Suzanne Valadon, Erik’s one-time companion, personify different aspects of being a woman alone. The bleakness of the themes of loneliness, family separation, and thwarted expectations sits in counterpoise to several couples’ deep love and the creativity that produces innovative art.

The Vexations was published in August 2019 by Little, Brown; I'd reviewed it for Booklist's July issue. I confess I hadn't run across Erik Satie before picking up the novel and have since read that he's considerably more familiar a name in Europe than in the US. Louise, Erik's sister, is apparently so little-known that she isn't mentioned in Satie's Wikipedia entry; reading it, you'd think Conrad was his only sibling. I found her story the most poignant and was glad to discover it.
3 likes ·   •  9 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on August 24, 2019 06:08
Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)    post a comment »
dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Gary (new)

Gary Inbinder Excellent review, Sarah; fascinating subject. Les Maisons Satie in Honfleur is a recommended place to visit for the composer's admirers who happen to be in the vicinity.

https://www.ot-honfleur.fr/je-profite...

P.S. Satie makes a brief cameo appearance in The Devil in Montmartre. ;)


message 2: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Thanks, Gary, for your comments and the museum recommendation. I would love to visit in person. The descriptions of Honfleur and Le Havre in the novel were memorable. I've visited Normandy before but not either place.

I'll have to pull out my copy of Devil in Montmartre to find Satie now! At the time I read it, I didn't know who he was, so the cameo must have passed me by :)


message 3: by Gary (new)

Gary Inbinder Sarah wrote: "Thanks, Gary, for your comments and the museum recommendation. I would love to visit in person. The descriptions of Honfleur and Le Havre in the novel were memorable. I've visited Normandy before b..."

You're welcome, Sarah. Apropos Honfleur and Le Havre, they figure prominently in the denouement of my third Inspector Lefebvre mystery, "The Man Upon the Stair."

Regarding Satie's cameo in "Devil", it's brief enough to cite here:

Sir Henry watched Émile go out the door, then turned to Lautrec. “Poor fellow. I diagnose a case of Virginie on the brain. I suppose he’s sweet on her.” Lautrec muttered, “Perhaps.” He turned his attention to a slender man walking toward the piano. “You see the man who’s about to play?” Sir Henry screwed a monocle into his eye and gazed across the smoke-filled hall. “Yes; who is he?” “His name’s Satie; not bad, really. The crowd listens when he plays.”

Inbinder, Gary. The Devil in Montmartre: A Mystery in Fin de Siècle Paris (p. 32). Pegasus. Kindle Edition.


message 4: by Sarah (new)

Sarah That's great - thanks for including the excerpt and citation.


message 5: by Gary (new)

Gary Inbinder Sarah wrote: "That's great - thanks for including the excerpt and citation."

You're welcome. :)


message 6: by Alex (new)

Alex Adam I hope that you are able to visit Honfleur and Le Havre someday, Sarah. Many immigrant ancestors of Americans left through the port of Le Havre in the 19th century (Satie's time!), including many Germans and Austrians, in addition to French and Belgians and others. It's fun to see those two cities and pretend to be looking through our ancestors' eyes as they took that big step toward America.


message 7: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Thanks for that information, Alex - I hadn't realized Le Havre was such a large emigration port, but that makes sense given its location. I hope so too!


message 8: by Gary (new)

Gary Inbinder A century ago my mother's family--my grandparents, mother, uncles and aunt--immigrated to the US on The French Line's La Lorraine, which made regular transatlantic runs from Le Havre to New York.

Here's another cite from one of my Inspecter Lefebvre novels, this time taken from a section describing the Le Havre docks ca. 1890:

The dockland appeared like a waterfront forest overgrown with tall masts and towering cranes. The place echoed with the sound of steam whistles on vessels of various types, sizes, and national origins and from stationary engines powering the derricks that hoisted tons of freight, loading and emptying the vast cargo holds. The world’s produce—raw materials, finished goods, and foodstuff—flowed into and out from the bustling entrepôt. An immense amount of human traffic also passed through the port, many bound for the Americas aboard the great French Line steamers.

Inbinder, Gary. The Man Upon the Stair: A Mystery in Fin de Siecle Paris . Pegasus Books. Kindle Edition.


message 9: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Pretty neat to have that mental picture of what the port was like in the 1890s. Thanks, Gary!


back to top