date
newest »

message 1:
by
Samhain
(new)
Dec 20, 2018 04:49AM

reply
|
flag




In no other profession would a four year delay be tolerated on a project which was "months" away from completion. Also a prioritization of a side history novel over the main series is crazy.
As the show has overtaken the novels, I believe the author has lost interest in his books since the world would already know the ending of the series.
Anyway, this is the last I will talk about this topic. Opinions will differ and let's agree to disagree here.

I'm over it and done with this series, I don't owe him anything either.

Writing isn't exactly like paperwork when you work in an office and if you don't respect the deadline, you obviously messed up. Writing is an art and if George R.R. Martin didn't respect his fans and the world he created, The Winds of Winter would have been released since years, because he would have think "Who cares if I'm not satisfied about it yet? Fans want it, I'll just write whatever can be sold and bring me more fans and money." I'm personally glad that he's not a fraud and that he cares so much.
In case you forgot, A Song of Ice and Fire isn't yours. It's his child, it's the world and the characters that he created and not being able to finish it for years now is much harder for the one who created it than for the fans.

Thank you!! Someone finally said it like it is. Artists show respect and love for their fans by giving them the best art they can get out of themselves. I'd rather read the book GRR thinks is his top quality in twenty years than read a bad or even an okay book right now. It's a massive series which has grown a lot bigger than him, it makes sense he would have a hard time feeling like "this is it, this version is the one we're publishing". If anything, he must be stuck in a perpetual "not-good-enough-given-the-expectations-from-both-the-fans-and-I" loop...

100% Agree. No one is forcing anyone to read or not read his books.


Dance with dragons : 12 july 2011
GOT season 1 : 17 april 2011