Discovery Institute's Blog, page 503

Marsupials Embryos Develop Differently From "Virtually Every Other Vertebrate"

The 2011 edition of Ken Miller textbook Biology states, "Similar patterns of embryological development provide further evidence that organisms have descended from a common ancestor." (p. 469) But what happens when supposedly similar types of organisms have very different patterns of embryological development? Would that count as evidence against common ancestry? In fact, researchers are finding striking differences in the development of vertebrates. A recent ScienceDaily release from...

Peer-Reviewed Pro-Intelligent Design Article Endorses Irreducible Complexity

In a peer-reviewed paper titled "Evidence of Design in Bird Feathers and Avian Respiration," in International Journal of Design & Nature and Ecodynamics, Leeds University professor Andy McIntosh argues that two systems vital to bird flight--feathers and the avian respiratory system--exhibit "irreducible complexity." The paper describes these systems using the exact sort of definitions that Michael Behe uses to describe irreducible complexity:

[F]unctional systems, in order to operate as...

Even More From Jerry Coyne

In my last post I reported that University of Chicago evolutionary biologist Jerry Coyne, who had critiqued my recent Quarterly Review of Biology article concerning laboratory evolution studies of the last four decades and what they show us about evolution, had asked several other prominent scientists for comments. I replied to those of experimental evolutionary biologist John Bull. In a subsequent post Coyne discussed a recent paper by the group of fellow University of Chicago biologist...

Icons of Evolution 10th Anniversary: Jay Richards

Peer-Reviewed Pro-Intelligent Design Paper Suggests "Agents" and "Choice Contingency" Needed to Explain Life's Programming

A 2009 peer-reviewed scientific paper by David Abel in International Journal of Molecular Sciences titled "The Capabilities of Chaos and Complexity" asks, "If all known life depends upon genetic instructions, how was the first linear digital prescriptive genetic information generated by natural process?" The author does not consider himself per se a proponent of intelligent design, and warns materialists that there is an easy solution to the challenges posed by intelligent design: "To stem...

"Conservative" Scientists Take on Climate Change Deniers?

Whenever the old stream media report on someone who is supposedly "conservative" but who nevertheless agrees with them, you can be pretty sure a snow job is coming.

On January 6, Neela Banerjee reported (in the Seattle Times and elsewhere) about conservative scientists who nevertheless . . . wait for it . . . believe in climate change. Wow! (Of course, "believe in climate change" is the confusing euphemism for believing that we are catastrophically altering the natural climate -- which always ...

Of Birds and Men

Proponents of evolutionary theory assume that human beings as well as every other living creature evolved through natural selection. They theorize that humans evolved from an ape-like ancestor and cite various archeological examples of possible pre-homo sapiens in hopes of filling in the missing links leading up to today's version of human. Evolutionary biologists, therefore, tend to look towards the past to find confirming evidence of what they presume to be true, humans evolved...

Of Darwinism and Islamism

This is not a blog about foreign affairs, but I came across a refreshing and illuminating piece on the New Republic website that, in the context of talking about Islam and terrorism, suggested to me a reason for hope in the Darwin debate. In the current culture of science, where the 19th-century materialist Church of Science rules and the congregation bows obediently, what's needed is a modernizing reformation. Doubts about Darwinism are part of that. We can draw a parallel to past...

Does the NCSE Target Faith Viewpoints?

A recent blog post here at ENV by Michael Egnor, "Why Doesn't the NCSE Have an Atheism Project?," stated that "for quite a while; people of faith have long been the target of NCSE litigation." To be fair to the NCSE, I don't think that Egnor's statement is exactly accurate; however, the truth is probably just as bad, or worse. It would be more accurate to say that the NCSE targets people who adhere to a certain purported faith and has eagerly supported litigation against those people....

BIO-Complexity Paper Shows Many Multi-Mutation Features Unlikely to Evolve in History of the Earth

Doug Axe of Bioogic Institute has a new peer-reviewed scientific paper in the journal BIO-Complexity titled "The Limits of Complex Adaptation: An Analysis Based on a Simple Model of Structured Bacterial Populations." The purpose of this paper is to mathematically determine just how long it takes to evolve traits that require multiple mutations before any adaptive benefit is conferred on the organism.

To put this question in context, the ability of Darwinian evolution to produce features that ...