Rachel Alexander's Blog, page 206
May 21, 2019
May 20, 2019
anthropologist-on-the-loose:
tarvek-sturmvoraus:
anthropologist-on-the-loose:
genderqueergerudo:
...
In my art history class we’re discussing museums and repatriation and I am so fucking angry
Just wait until I have some free time, I’ll post my favorite whiny bitch responses from European museums.
First, a fun fact: “It is noted in the report that some 90% of African cultural heritage currently exists outside of the continent and is displayed in major Western museums.” So keep that in mind when reading these.
Let’s get this party started, shall we?“Contrary to the sanctified treatment of objects in these museums, there have been cases in Africa where artworks have temporarily left the museum to be used in rituals.”
Europeans, clutching their pearls: But it is Art, it cannot be soiled by the hands of the masses who created it!!Then I read a big long paragraph from a French museum director that in summary reads: Hey everyone, let’s start from scratch and pretend colonialism never happened. That good? Does that work for everyone? Awesome.“…cultural objects from the area which is now Iraq are being used to promote BP [Oil], which supported the 2003 invasion of Iraq.”
So y’all just gonna an oil company sponsor an exhibit of dubiously obtained Iraqi artifacts? Cool, cool, no colonialist undertones there.“[D]irector of the British Museum Hartwig Fischer said that while the museum’s trustees were open to all forms of cooperation, “the collections have to be preserved as whole.””
You mean, all those collections donated from wealthy individuals who pillaged the entire world? If you really believe this I’ve got a simple solution for you: return the entire damn collection.“Unlike Nazi-looted art, what was taken in the former colonies are not recognized as criminally obtained under international law.”
Hi yeah what the actual fuckThen there’s the Parthenon Marbles, and if you don’t know, it’s a whole big Thing with a near comical backstory. But this post is long enough as is, and I don’t want to bore you. In short: Britain has bunch of the carvings and statues that were left in the Greek Parthenon, and Greece wants them back. Here are some choice bits from the British Museum’s current official stance on the marbles:
“Archaeologists worldwide are agreed that the surviving sculptures could never be re-attached to the structure.”
That is??? Not the issue??? No one is suggesting this???“acting with the full knowledge and permission of the Ottoman authorities”
Really? You sure about that? Because it seems like no one else agrees with you on that. Also, even if there was clear permission, saying “The empire that conquered Greece told us we could take them” doesn’t exactly strengthen your case.“the Greek authorities have now removed all the architectural sculptures from the Parthenon to the Acropolis Museum. They have thus completed a process begun by Lord Elgin 200 years ago”
Are… are you suggesting that Greece only wants to preserve its heritage because you wanted to first? Seriously? I’d be damn careful about touting yourself as paragons of historical preservation, Britain.“The Museum is a unique resource for the world: the breadth and depth of its collection allows the world’s public to re-examine cultural identities and explore the connections between them.”
And how did your collection get so big, might I ask? Oh, you don’t know? Because you’re not willing to do the research on how most of these artifacts were acquired? Fascinating.“This display does not alter the Trustees’ view that the sculptures are part of everyone’s shared heritage and transcend cultural boundaries.”
Guys I’m dying they sound like an entitled white boy in an intro to philosophy classBy the way, this document that is less than 1,000 words mentions that the public can view the them “free of charge” no less than 3 times.
Fun times.
I actually was given a C minus in this class in my undergrad for calling out museums for being whiney about repatriation. My professor HATED me and we would get into heated arguments about how stolen artifacts needed to be returned. God those were the days….lol FYI this professor Dr.Wilson got mad one day and told me to go back to Mexico and asked me if I was legal. I know this anger…lol
Greece’s Acropolis museum is literally a huge fuck you to the British Museum. The New Acropolis Museum opened in 2007. It looks amazing
Since you can’t dig anywhere in Greece (especially right by the Acropolis) without hitting ruins or artifacts, they built a glass floor so that visitors can see the ruins below the building.
A huge part of the design for the new building was to emphasize that Greece is ready and capable of caring for the Elgin Marbles (a huge defense the British Museum will give is that colonized countries don’t have the resources to care for the artifacts properly). So they went out of their way to make this as clear as possible.
The top floor of the building is entirely devoted to the metopes and friezes around the Parthenon. Like, so devoted that they even oriented the top floor to align with the actual Parthenon
So if you walk around the floor, everything is oriented as if you were walking around the actual Parthenon.
So the two ends of the floor are dedicated to the two pediments. And they were very particular with how they’re displayed.
Wow there sure are a lot of things missing.
They left space for where the Elgin Marbles should be. All of the pieces are labelled. For all of the missing pieces, there is a sign saying that that piece is in the British Museum. It’s pretty hard to miss when entire sections are not there.
That entire floor is just to show that they all belong together. The pediments need to be back together. Get your shit together British Museum
You missed my favorite part of the museum:
They have separate room devoted to these statues, with a spotlight shining on the empty spot where the sixth one is supposed to be. It was the saltiest museum I have ever been to, and I was living. My favorite part was when the tour guide pleaded to us to write to the British Museum and ask them to return the artifacts, and an older man from India muttered under his breath, “Ha! Good luck with that.”
That aside, it’s also one of the most beautiful museums I have ever been in. The architecture is stunning. If you ever get a chance, absolutely go to it.
For those who don’t know the story behind why all these Greek statues are in Britain, buckle up for a wild ride.
The Parthenon has a storied history, obviously, as it is was an incredible temple in a major Mediterranean port. It had started to show wear and tear over the years, and different people had attempted at various points to “save” it, or at least save the carvings. Most of the time, these attempts did more harm than good.
Then along comes Thomas Bruce, a Scottish nobleman more commonly know as Lord Elgin. Between 1799-1803 he acts as British ambassador to the Ottoman empire, which controlled the entire region that is now Greece. He gets really interested in the old works of the classical civilizations and asks the Sultan of the Ottoman empire if he can undertake an extensive study and recording of the art at the Acropolis in Athens. Not only does the Sultan say yes, his agreement states that Elgin can “take away any pieces of stone with old inscriptions or figures thereon.” It is agreed by all parties who are not the British Museum that the Sultan was referring only to the various pieces that were scattered across the ground, but not anything still standing.
Elgin interpreted this wording to mean, “Take anything you want. Go absolutely hog wild.” So he did. He sawed many of the marble carvings off the building to make them easier to transport, which did damage to both the carvings and structure of the building itself. Here’s my favorite part: one of the ships he was using to transport the marbles sank. When Elgin found out, he sent a letter to local authorities asking them to retrieve the cargo, which he referred to as “stones of no interest to anyone but myself.”
He took literal metric tons of artwork, which he wanted to use to decorate his home back in Britain. Except he poured so much money into this project that he went into debt and had to sell the marbles. Parliament bought them (which was not a popular decision at the time) and put them in a public museum. Then in 1832 Greece won its independence from the Ottoman Empire, and the marbles have been a point of contention in Greek-British relations ever since.
Here’s another quote from the British Museum displaying an astonishing degree of ethnocentrism!
“The public display of the sculptures from spring 1807 encouraged Hellenists in their love of ancient Greece while, at the same time, it inspired the Philhellene movement in its sympathy for the inhabitants of modern Greece and their struggle for independence.”
The most recent volley in this fight was Britain saying, “well, we can’t give you the marbles, your museum is too dinky to display them in their full splendor.” In response, Greece built the above museum.
As many people mentioned in the comments, Black Panther was fantastic in that it brought the issue of museums and repatriation into the public view. Now with more voices joining in, hopefully change can happen more quickly.
You left out the part where the document giving Elgin permission to take them may or may not be a forgery, also!
This was a part of this I was not familiar with! And wow! I looked into it, and there is decent evidence that the agreement from the Sultan was faked! This story just keeps getting better and better!
floralls:
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE
by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE by Clive Nichols
IRIS CAYEUX , FRANCE
by Clive Nichols
May 18, 2019
mjalti:
ancientgreeksuggestions:
use more olive oil
I didn’t even notice the url I was just like...
use more olive oil
I didn’t even notice the url I was just like damn they’re right.
May 17, 2019
Just saw the ask abt the PG version of Hades and Persephone. What was the ace retelling that you read, if you don’t mind sharing?
Oh, man… I know I saw it on AO3 a while ago but can’t for the life of me remember the title. Your googling is just as good as mine at this point. If it helps, I know the word “asexual” was actually used within the text of the story itself.
Would you say that sex is absolutely 100% part of a good Hades x Persephone retelling? Like, would a totally PG version just feel... I complete?
Yes.
With the exception of a really good ace retelling I read, absolutely yes.
There’s this Hades x Persephone book on prime reading called Eighth House. Have you read it? If so, what’d you think/would you rec it? If not, d’you think I ought to give it a shot?
Give it a shot!! It’s by my friend Eris Adderly. There’s an undercurrent of bondage in it, just to warn you, but I absolutely loved it.
