Adam Thierer's Blog, page 178

Google's Lobby Shop Creates Need for Itself

"Live by the sword, die by the sword."

"Play with fire and you might get burned."

Those are lines that sprung to my mind as I read this FT article noting how Google's support for 'net neutrality regulation has transmogrified into a push for "search neutrality." Such regulation would be aimed directly at Google's heart throat nuts business model.

(I was the first to discuss "search neutrality" here on TLF. Ignore Adam's comment.)

But sloganeering is cheap. Let's take a minute to try and...

Is a Massive Taxpayer-Funded Propaganda Machine Really a Good Idea?

Earlier this year, while I was preparing this mega-filing to the Federal Communications Commission in its "Future of Media" proceeding, I read Uninhibited, Robust, and Wide-open: A Free Press for a New Century, by Lee C. Bollinger, who is the president of Columbia University.  I had planned on reviewing it since I try to review almost every book I read, but it was hard for me to believe that anyone would take this book too seriously, so I just moved along.

I hate to be that dismissive of...

FTC Enforcement of Corporate Promises & the Path of Privacy Law

Adam and I have been pretty hard on the FTC's current leadership for pushing to dramatically expand regulation of online data use with little thought to the impact on ad-supported media, while in the next breath opening the door to dramatic expansion of direct government support of media, and all the while seeking sweeping new regulatory powers from Congress.

After all that complaining (and bashing their Soviet Realist-style statue, "Man Controlling Trade"), you might think we had it in for...

Second Circuit: Pacifica Is Outdated, All Media Deserve Full First Amendment Protection

The Second Circuit just threw out the FCC's broadcast indecency rules—which had led to heavy fines for "fleeting expletives"—as "unconstitutionally vague, creating a chilling effect that goes far beyond the fleeting expletives at issue here." What's ultimately most important about this decision is not what the court did, but what it said: The Constitutional framework that has allowed broadcast censorship has been rendered obsolete by the rise of the Internet and parental empowerment tools...

The Seven Deadly Sins of Title II Reclassification (NOI Remix)

Better late than never, I've finally given a close read to the Notice of Inquiry issued by the FCC on June 17th.  (See my earlier comments, "FCC Votes for Reclassification, Dog Bites Man".)  In some sense there was no surprise to the contents; the Commission's legal counsel and Chairman Julius Genachowski had both published comments over a month before the NOI that laid out the regulatory scheme the Commission now has in mind for broadband Internet access.

Chairman Genachowski's "Third Way"...

How America's Hugo Chavez Fan Club Plans to 'Reform' Our Media Marketplace

[cross-posted from BigGovernment.com]

In the battle over media and communications freedom, no group poses a more serious threat to a free and independent press than the insultingly misnamed regulatory activist group Free Press. Along with their founders, the prolific neo-Marxist media theorist Robert W. McChesney and Nation correspondent John Nichols, Free Press has engaged in relentless agitation for a truly radical media and communications policy agenda, and their influence is now...