Stephen Roney's Blog, page 267

A Breton Carol

Did you know that Celine Dion was Breton? Did you know that Jacques Cartier was? Pack of Celts...




'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.

The Pelican Chorus

And why not link it here?





'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.

Hunting the Wren

Hunting the wren on the Isle of Man

Another tradition for this second day of Christmas. The wren is hunted in Ireland, Scotland, Wales, the Isle of Man, Britanny, southern France, and Spain. And Newfoundland.



The significance of the wren is probably the same as the significance of the Christmas tree: it is one of the very few birds that do not migrate south for winter. And so they are a symbol of life beyond death; of the resurrection.

Hunting the wren in Dingle, Kerry.
The traditional Scottish song:

The traditional English song:


Irish version by the Chieftains:



'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.

On the Feast of Stephen

Here's a traditional song specifically for this second day of Christmas.



'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.

Christmas: Day 2

Contrary to a common belief, it is STILL CHRISTMAS. There are Twelve Days of Christmas, and St. Stephen's Day is only day 2.

Bob and Doug remind us.



'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.

Cultural Relativism

Dante's Inferno

I not sure anything could be more sinister than the current idea that morality is culturally relative. But that seems to have become a dominant position. Even my friend Cyrus has bought it—and Cyrus is a very intelligent guy.

If morality is culturally relative, decided by some consensus within a culture to suit its own purposes, we have no business objecting to Hitler and the Nazis. The Nuremberg Trials were not legitimate. It was accepted within that society to kill all Jews. If we object, we are simply being cultural imperialists and showing our intolerance.

Not, of course, that there is anything necessarily wrong with intolerance or imperialism, right? After all, they too might be sanctioned by our culture...

So too with slavery, or child sacrifice, or torture, or suttee, and so forth.

There are other problems with the premise. Suppose you live in one of the anti-slavery counties in the antebellum US South. So, if you hold a slave, you are immoral locally, moral at the state level, and immoral at the federal level? The same act at the same time is both moral and immoral.

Most people, it seems, avoid moral choices by going along with what everyone around them is doing, and doing the same. This is an attempt to justify that attitude. But it is unjustifiable. It is lynch mob morality. It is the attitude that makes mobs in general so dangerous: if everyone else is smashing windows, tonight, I can smash windows.

It would make you a willing executioner in Hitler’s Germany.

It would make Oskar Schindler a moral reprobate.

Or Socrates. Or Qu Yuan. Or Jesus Christ.

Is just going along and never making individual moral choices immoral? Dante thought so. He put all such people in the first circle of Hell.

God thinks so too, according to the New Testament: “I know your works, that you are neither cold nor hot. I wish you were cold or hot. So, because you are lukewarm, and neither hot nor cold, I will vomit you out of my mouth.” (Revelations 3:16).

Literally, this says it is better to be deliberately evil than to just go along—at least you are acknowledging morality. That means there is some hope for you. None so guilty as the “innocent bystander.”

Worse than doing evil is denying the existence of evil.




'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.

The Boar's Head

'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.

Abortion and Crime

From The Economist.

A famous study suggests that legalized abortion has been responsible for the otherwise mysterious drop in crime we have seen over the past few decades.

The study has been challenged; as with any science, and especially social science, that has obvious political implications, you cannot trust it.

But it seems plausible enough that it would be so.

This does not amount, however, to a justification of abortion.

If it were, it would also justify eliminating poverty by killing the poor.

What it should do it alert us to more compassion for those who fall afoul of the legal system. They are usually not the real criminals, but desperate young men.

The real criminals are rarely punished.
And the better way to reduce crime is to do something about dysfunctional parenting.

'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.

Once Kingston in a Fog of Time 2019

'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.

The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples

Podcast version...



The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples'Od's Blog: Catholic and Clear Grit comments on the passing parade.