Paul Levinson's Blog: Levinson at Large, page 141

December 31, 2019

The Aeronauts: Science Fiction of the Past



As long as I'm reviewing good 2019 science fiction movies about traveling off of this planet - I reviewed Ad Astra here yesterday - I might as well throw in a review of The Aeronauts before the year runs out,

Part of the story is true history.  James Glaisher was a meteorologist and an "aeronaut" who traveled further off the Earth - around 9500 meters - than anyone before him, in 1862, in a balloon that lifted him.  But in real history, his co-pilot was Henry Tracey Coxwell, not even mentioned in the movie, which had as Glaisher's pilot the fictitious Amelia Rennes.

That's what makes the movie science fiction.  But there's nothing fictitious about the real emotions Felicity Jones shows us as Amelia, working through her demons born of the loss and trauma she experienced from an earlier trip to the sky.   Indeed, in her partnership in explorations above the clouds she shares with Glaisher, she is the strong one, both psychologically and even physically in some breathtaking scenes.  In real history,  Coxwell saved the day after Glaisher passed out in the high altitude, but I have no idea if those two had conversations as meaningful as between Amelia Rennes and Glaisher in the movie.

The fiction in this scientific history of a movie calls for, once again, the important proviso that should accompany all docu-dramas: they're not the same as documentaries, which are themselves not the same as real history, since a documentary only tells us the part of the story that the filmmaker wants us to see.  But docu-dramas go one big fictional step further - they make up conversations, what real-life people do, and sometimes even make up characters from whole cloth.

That's what The Aeronauts serves us, though Amelia is said to be a composite of real women who flew in balloons in those days.   As far as I'm concerned, I don't care what parts are real and what parts of the composite are fictional.  The Aernonauts is an uplifting, inspiring movie, and I highly recommend it.


                                             Welcome Up: Songs of Space and Time


                                                      Touching the Face of the Cosmos

Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 31, 2019 14:30

December 30, 2019

Ad Astra: the 2001 of the 21st Century (So Far)



What better time to see Ad Astra than now, at the end of the second decade of the 21st century, when we still have made but a pittance of progress beyond our landing on the Moon in 1969?

In the "near future" of Ad Astra, we're established on the Moon and Mars - not well established, by any means, but good enough - and the story concerns Roy McBride's (Brad Pitt) trip to Neptune to find out what happened to his father, Clifford (Tommy Lee Jones).  Clifford was the first man to reach Jupiter and then Saturn, but he got hung up around Neptune, and most people don't know if he's dead or alive. 

Ray thinks he's alive, and he's right, which leads to the bigger story: is it worth leaving Earth, permanently, in the quest to find some alien intelligence, that Clifford is sure must be out there? Clifford's so sure that he begs Ray to let him float away in space, to die, rather than return to Earth with Ray.   In the decisive scene, Ray lets his father go, and Ray returns to Earth.  Because, having discovered there's likely no other intelligence out there, Ray wants to return to his home.

It's not the ending I wanted, but the movie was nonetheless powerful, and the ending was emotionally satisfying.  Indeed, Ad Astra was so good a movie, so different in the combination of individual personality and grand scale, that I'd say it's the 2001 of our 21st century, at least so far.

As to what I would have rather seen at the end: that would have been Ray refusing to let his father go, bringing Clifford back to Earth, where Ray could have unpacked, savored, and assessed his father's immense knowledge gathered over thirty years at the furtherest our species has ventured from Planet Earth.  Yes, Ray speaks of great stores of knowledge in the records his father kept, but there's nothing like actually talking to the person who made and kept the records to get the deepest and fullest picture of what he (or she) learned.

Nonetheless - great acting Brad Pitt, great movie by James Gray, see it.

                                             Welcome Up: Songs of Space and Time


                                                      Touching the Face of the Cosmos Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 30, 2019 21:04

December 29, 2019

Marriage Story: A Star Is Born, Almost Again




Marriage Story on Netflix, as you likely already know, is a divorce story, more specifically, a story of a couple who pretty much love each other, and have a son, splitting up.  In that sense, it's pretty much an old story, one we've seen on the screen many times, but it's lifted by strong acting from Adam Driver (just seen in Star Wars) as Charlie and Scarlett Johansson as Nicole, witty dialogue, and some primo scenes.

My favorite was Charlie and Nicole screaming at each other about why they split up, both brought to tears by the knowledge they already knew that they still loved each, and frustrated beyond belief that this had happened to them.  So, why did it happen?  That's the story of this Marriage Story.

It's actually a little more Nicole's than Charlie's story, since she initiated the break-up.  She couldn't abide her creative life being subsumed by Charlie's, something he was for the most part blissfully unaware of.  I guess to make her leaving more believable and better motivated, he does sleep with another woman - though only "once," as he would and does tell us, and Nicole as well.

But the deeper story is how can two creative people have a life together?  This was explored beautifully in A Star Is Born, more than once, four times, to be exact, but that was a special case of marriage of an aging star and a rising starlet (or singer), which story very different than Marriage Story, where Charlie is only a bit ahead of Nicole in his success.  So maybe Marriage Story can be best understood as a compressed Star Is Born, though likely not.

Driver also does some impressive singing in the movie, of a Stephen Sondheim song no less.  Which raises another point.  There's a studied hipness in this movie.  But it's done so well that it doesn't seem studied.

Anyway, romantic that I am, I would've liked to have seen the two together at end, and who knows, since this isn't A Star Is Born, that could actually happen, notwithstanding Nicole's boring boyfriend.




Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 29, 2019 20:46

Dublin Murders: You Can Go Your Own Way



My wife and I just finished the first (and so far, only) season on Dublin Murders on Starz.  It's a strange, compelling BBC series set in - of course - Dublin, and I hope it's the first of more to come.

It has a pace and focus and intensity all its own.  Although the two murder cases are solved by the end, they're solved in a way that leaves much more open than we find at the end of most other American, British, or for that matter, any murder series made anywhere in the world.  Whether that's due to a strict adherence to the novels of Tanya French upon which this season was based, I couldn't say, as I haven't read the novels.  But I very much like this very different way of telling two interlocking stories.

As is often the case, though, in stories dubbed this or that murder or murders, the narrative is really much more about the detectives investigating the cases than the murders.  In this case, Rob Reilly and Cassie Maddox, very well played by Killian Scott and Sarah Greene, are a very compelling if ill-fated team, or are very compelling because they're ill-fated, both individually and as a team and, just for good measure, as a romantic couple.   Rob is really Adam, a boy who witnessed a murder and escaped - a murder in the same woods in Dublin where, back now in his new identity as the English detective Rob, he's investigating a murder that happened in the same woods.  He's investigating this with and against the best advice of his partner, Cassie, who is also damaged goods herself, having as a child been in the back seat of a car in which her parents drove into a stag (a male deer) and were killed.  She makes up a character, Lexie, who turns out to be real and ... well, I don't want to give too much away, in case you haven't seen Dublin Murders, which you should (and if you haven't, you probably shouldn't have read this far, anyway, but, in any case, don't read any further).

I will say that I don't like the way the finale handled their love affair - or, at least, the love Rob wanted to profess when he asked Cassie to call him back.  I mean, a series of things getting in the way of professing one's true love was already old hat after Jane Austen did it so well in her novels.

Will there be another season of Dublin Murders?  There should be.  Will it have all new characters?  I pretty much hope not, because I want to see more of Rob and Cassie, but I'll watch it anyway.




Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 29, 2019 20:08

Ray Donovan 7.7: Back Story



Tonight's episode 7.7 of Ray Donovan provided another reason for me to like this season the best.  In the case of this episode, it offered one of the best backstories I've seen on any series, period.

Especially the acting.  The guy (Bill Heck) who played young Mick had his (Jon Voight as Mickey's) mannerisms down pat.  His voice even sounded so much like Mickey's, it could have been Voight's overdubbed - for all I know, it was.  And the story this young Mick brought us finally gives us some crucial missing pieces in what makes the family Donovan tick.

In our present time, Mickey played by Voight tells us near the end of the episode that he's finally grown up - that everything we've seen him go through and do in these seven seasons has profoundly changed him.  Made him a, well, more responsible adult, even if that responsibility entails murder and whatever it takes.

And we get Ray's story, too.  The young Ray, wanting to kill his father.  This Ray (played by Aidan Pierce Brennan) is also given an excellent performance by someone who literally has a lot of Ray's (Liev Schrieber's) ways of looking at the world.  And our present Ray is changing in significant ways, too.  Under Molly's good influence, he refrains from killing someone who, at least in Ray's world, would have been better off dead.

A lot of this season, especially in the unpacking of those prior lives that bring the lives of our current characters into clearer focus, has the feel of a final season.  I'm very glad that it apparently isn't.  Because knowing what we now know of Mickey, and Ray, it will be more riveting than ever to see where there are next season, after this one concludes.  And we haven't even seen what else this current season has to teach us.

See also Ray Donovan 7.1: Getting Ahead of the Game ... Ray Donovan 7.2: Good Luck ... Ray Donovan 7.3: "The Air that I Breathe" ... Ray Donovan 7.4: Claudette and Bridget ... Ray Donovan 7.5: Bing! ... Ray Donovan 7.6: Phone Booths and Cellphones

See also Ray Donovan 6.1: The New Friend ... Ray Donovan 6.2: Father and Sons ... Ray Donovan 6.4: Politics in the Ray Style ... Ray Donovan 6.6: The Mayor Strikes Back ... Ray Donovan 6.7: Switching Sides ... Ray Donovan 6.8: Down ... Ray Donovan 6.9: Violence and Storyline ... Ray Donovan 6.10: Working Together ... Ray Donovan 6.11: Settled Scores and Open Questions ... Ray Donovan Season 6 Finale: Snowfall and Mick

See also Ray Donovan 5.1: Big Change  ... Ray Donovan 5.4: How To Sell A Script ... Ray Donovan 5.7: Reckonings ... Ray Donovan 5.8: Paging John Stuart Mill ... Ray Donovan 5.9: Congas ... Ray Donovan 5.10: Bunchy's Money ... Ray Donovan 5.11: I'm With Mickey ... Ray Donovan 5.12: New York

See also Ray Donovan 4.1: Good to Be Back ... Ray Donovan 4.2: Settling In ... Ray Donovan 4.4: Bob Seger ... Ray Donovan 4.7: Easybeats ... Ray Donovan 4.9: The Ultimate Fix ... Ray Donovan Season 4 Finale: Roses

And see also Ray Donovan 3.1: New, Cloudy Ray ... Ray Donovan 3.2: Beat-downs ... Ray Donovan 3.7: Excommunication!

And see also Ray Donovan 2.1: Back in Business ... Ray Donovan 2.4: The Bad Guy ... Ray Donovan 2.5: Wool Over Eyes ... Ray Donovan 2.7: The Party from Hell ... Ray Donovan 2.10: Scorching ... Ray Donovan 2.11: Out of Control ... Ray Donovan Season 2 Finale: Most Happy Ending


And see also Ray Donovan Debuts with Originality and Flair ... Ray Donovan 1.2: His Assistants and his Family ... Ray Donovan 1.3: Mickey ... Ray Donovan 1.7 and Whitey Bulger ... Ray Donovan 1.8: Poetry and Death ... Ray Donovan Season 1 Finale: The Beginning of Redemption


It started in the hot summer of 1960, when Marilyn Monroe walked off the set of The Misfits and began to hear a haunting song in her head, "Goodbye Norma Jean" ... Marilyn and Monet

Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 29, 2019 19:33

December 28, 2019

You 2: Killer Charm



Well, it's rare that a mystery or thriller surprises me with almost all of its twists, but the second season of You, now streaming on Netflix, did just that.  And with the same wit and style that lit up the first season, maybe even more.  All of which adds up to a highly, often immensely, enjoyable second season of this literate and introspective serial killer.

Joe Goldberg worked in a bookstore in New York City in season one.  Now he's trying to establish a new identity out in LA.  He employs his time-honored way of making things happen: he locks a guy up in his basement and assumes his identity.  Just before he falls in love with Love.  Well, Joe was already in love with love, certainly obsessed with it. but this Love is Love Quinn, perfectly played by Victoria Pedretti, whom I last noticed in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood.

But she's just outstanding in You, down to that smile she gives us when she realizes that she's finally getting Joe to sleep with her.  Her character is complex, to say the least, and I actually liked her even more than Guinevere Beck in the first season, as Joe's all-consuming passion.

[big spoilers ahead]

And the plot is brilliant.  Here are some of the surprises I didn't get:  Joe letting the real Will go - the guy whose identity Joe stole.  The best surprises are well-motivated, and this one was a logical result of Joe wanting to really be a good person, as part of his love for Love.  The cop killing Forty at the end, and, for that matter, Forty figuring out that Joe killed Beck et al back in New York.  Candace's deployment was not surprising, but very well played.

The one big twist I sort of saw coming - indeed, the biggest twist in the season - was Love killing Delilah, etc.  I put her at the top of the list via process of elimination, behind Love's parents, all higher as would-be protectors of Joe than Joe himself, which have been too obvious.  And I can't say I was thrilled by the very very ending, with Joe starting to fantasize about the neighbor we don't really see.  But, hey, that's just entree to the next season.

All of this is brought to life not only by great acting - the scenes with Joe (also perfectly acted, by Penn Badgley) and Love are nonpareil - but sparkling dialogue, mostly from Joe, often interior, as when he grumbles that "this is what I get for trying to out-tech a teenager" (Ellie) or "the robots are not our friends".  Yeah, though Joe is social media-literate enough, his true talent are words and word-play in the Victorian tradition, and thus he's often challenged by latest tech, all of which adds to his charm.

And charming might be one of the best words to describe this second killer season.

See alsoYou: Review from an Unconflicted Fan

Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 28, 2019 10:45

December 26, 2019

Welcome Up: Songs of Space and Time nearly here!

Paul Levinson[image error]

Happy Chanukah, Merry Christmas, Happy New Year!  My new LP Welcome Up: Songs of Space and Time -- my first new album since Twice Upon A Rhyme in 1972 -- is almost here!
In fact, advance copies of the CD, with all eight songs, are available here.  There's also complete information on the writers of the songs, and the musicians, and all the lyrics (scroll down) at that link. Also, here's a video of a little concert I did with songs from the album at a science fiction convention in Philadelphia last month.
[image error]
Old Bear Records will be officially releasing the LP on digital, vinyl, and CD on February 7, 2020, and digital will go up on Bandcamp on January 17.  If you're a dj or music journalist (including citizen journalists and reviewers with blogs), send me an email and I can give you access to the digital album and/or an advance CD right now.
[image error]
And stay tuned for announcements of a series of concerts, mostly at science fiction conventions, I'll be doing in the Spring.

Music Play Song Samantha (rough mix, from Welcome Up) Play Song If I Traveled To The Past (rough mix, from Welcome Up)MORE MUSICPress
"Sundial Symphony, “Merri Goes Round” (words by Paul Levinson, music by Ed Fox)…Another track where the British Invasion tips its hat to Brian Wilson on the way to San Francisco, circa 1967. This one will feel fresh and familiar to you, all at once. Sundial Symphony, “Looking For Sunsets (In The Early Morning)” (words by Paul Levinson, music by Ed Fox) …The album wraps up with another nod to psychedelic San Francisco, with a Jefferson Airplane dynamic in its sing-along chorus."— Mike DeAngelis, There Once Was A Note, Oct 12, 2019
Connect ReverbNation    Twitter    Instagram    Facebook  Update Contact Info      Unsubscribe      Report Abuse      Privacy  

Physical inquiries can be sent to: 65 Shirley Lane, 9146596160, White Plains, NY, 10607, USA
If our email is in your Spam/Junk Folder, please add Levinson.paul@gmail.com to your address book.

Powered by  Fan Reach 


Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 26, 2019 10:14

December 24, 2019

The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel 3: Op-ed, Closet, and Lenny



What better night to review the third season of Mrs. Maisel (on Amazon Prime Video) - the third night of Chanukah - and, at the same time, Christmas Eve!  I loved all three seasons, and it may be because my wife and I just finished watching this, but I loved this season the best.  The acting was brilliant, hilarious, and better than ever!

Just some story highlights, and some analyses and questions below -


Mrs. Maisel and Lenny Bruce- why didn't she sleep with him?  It looked like he wanted to.  She's definitely attracted to him.  So ... she didn't want to do anything that might somehow throw her career off-course?   (I won't say of course, just off-course, because of course I'm not sure.) But it is ironic, given what happened at the end.Fact-checking and continuity:  Abe talks about an op-ed in The New York Times - but it's 1960 or 1961, and, hey, even if was 1965 that would be wrong.  The first New York Times op-ed didn't appear until 1970.  (Ok, I'm a Professor of Communication and Media Studies - at Fordham University - so I would know this.  But, memo to Mrs. Maisel production - get your details right.)I'm still trying to decide what ratio of Johnny Mathis and Jackie Wilson best describes Shy Baldwin?  I'm thinking maybe 80% Mathis?  Not 100%, because, on occasion, Shy has a nice burst of rock in his singing.Regarding Shy, my wife called it that Midge went over the top with her jokes which came too close to outing Shy.  I was thinking if you didn't already know it, you might just think she was riffing on his effeminate elan (didn't Saturday Night Live once have an hilarious skit on the effeminate heterosexual?).  In any case, what happened was Susie's fault for not being there to calm Midge down.  And once she's up on stage, a different part of her brain takes over - a part that bounces ideas around like basketballs, and makes her brilliant, but which doesn't think of consequences.Susie at least came through for Midge with Midge's money.  But now that Shy's contract is gone, what she will use as collateral?All of this has the makings for a great fourth season, which I'll 100% be reviewing!  Happy Chanukah, Merry Christmas, and Happy New Year!   
See also The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, Seasons 1 and 2: Triumph for Risks and Laughter

It all started in the hot summer of 1960, when Marilyn Monroe walked off the set of The Misfits and began to hear a haunting song in her head, "Goodbye Norma Jean" ...  Marilyn and Monet Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 24, 2019 15:16

December 22, 2019

Ray Donovan 7.6: Phone Booths and Cellphones



Some profound media theory in tonight's episode 7.6 of Ray Donovan, from the mouth of the redoubtable Sandy.  She remarks, when a cellphone is the object of discussion, that she prefers phone booths to cellphones, because of, well, the things that a man can do for a woman in a phone booth but not in a cell phone.  Of course, that could also well be what a woman can and can't do for a woman in a phone booth, but I'm guessing that's not or wasn't the way Sandy rolls.  It is true, and now a great point of historical observation, that cell phones have all but eliminated phone booths, though based on my casual observation, they just may be making something of a comeback in New York City.  Whether it's for the reason Sandy stated ... ok, enough of that already.

Meanwhile, we got another good hour of story on tonight's episode.  Smitty continues to be in fine form, and he and Terry had some outstanding scenes, from the bathroom to the car.  I'm really not liking Detective Perry.   She left Terry alone, not really able to drive his car.  She has to know, given how much attention she's given to the Donovans, that he has Parkinson's.  At very least, she must have seen him shaking.  And her boss told her to drop the case.  I'd say she's out of control, lacks a heart, or both.

The closing scenes with Ray and Daryll were significant and top-notch, too.  The two have always had something of a tension or a history between them.  At this point, Daryll is also more upset than usual because he killed someone.  And he doesn't appreciate Ray trying to interfere with what Daryll, Sandy, and Mick are doing.  But accusing Ray of racism is unexpected.  What Daryll saying that just to rile himself up, or has Ray really been racist to Daryll?  Condescending, yes.  But I'm not sure I'd say racist.  And that's what made those scenes so interesting.

This whole season has a subtly different, more psychologically sensitive approach than the earlier seasons.  That's maybe one of the reasons I'm liking it as one of the best.

See also Ray Donovan 7.1: Getting Ahead of the Game ... Ray Donovan 7.2: Good Luck ... Ray Donovan 7.3: "The Air that I Breathe" ... Ray Donovan 7.4: Claudette and Bridget ... Ray Donovan 7.5: Bing!

See also Ray Donovan 6.1: The New Friend ... Ray Donovan 6.2: Father and Sons ... Ray Donovan 6.4: Politics in the Ray Style ... Ray Donovan 6.6: The Mayor Strikes Back ... Ray Donovan 6.7: Switching Sides ... Ray Donovan 6.8: Down ... Ray Donovan 6.9: Violence and Storyline ... Ray Donovan 6.10: Working Together ... Ray Donovan 6.11: Settled Scores and Open Questions ... Ray Donovan Season 6 Finale: Snowfall and Mick

See also Ray Donovan 5.1: Big Change  ... Ray Donovan 5.4: How To Sell A Script ... Ray Donovan 5.7: Reckonings ... Ray Donovan 5.8: Paging John Stuart Mill ... Ray Donovan 5.9: Congas ... Ray Donovan 5.10: Bunchy's Money ... Ray Donovan 5.11: I'm With Mickey ... Ray Donovan 5.12: New York

See also Ray Donovan 4.1: Good to Be Back ... Ray Donovan 4.2: Settling In ... Ray Donovan 4.4: Bob Seger ... Ray Donovan 4.7: Easybeats ... Ray Donovan 4.9: The Ultimate Fix ... Ray Donovan Season 4 Finale: Roses

And see also Ray Donovan 3.1: New, Cloudy Ray ... Ray Donovan 3.2: Beat-downs ... Ray Donovan 3.7: Excommunication!

And see also Ray Donovan 2.1: Back in Business ... Ray Donovan 2.4: The Bad Guy ... Ray Donovan 2.5: Wool Over Eyes ... Ray Donovan 2.7: The Party from Hell ... Ray Donovan 2.10: Scorching ... Ray Donovan 2.11: Out of Control ... Ray Donovan Season 2 Finale: Most Happy Ending


And see also Ray Donovan Debuts with Originality and Flair ... Ray Donovan 1.2: His Assistants and his Family ... Ray Donovan 1.3: Mickey ... Ray Donovan 1.7 and Whitey Bulger ... Ray Donovan 1.8: Poetry and Death ... Ray Donovan Season 1 Finale: The Beginning of Redemption


It started in the hot summer of 1960, when Marilyn Monroe walked off the set of The Misfits and began to hear a haunting song in her head, "Goodbye Norma Jean" ... Marilyn and Monet Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 22, 2019 17:54

December 20, 2019

Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker: Tipping into the Mystic



So here's where I am regarding the nine episodes of Star Wars: I thought the first trilogy, by George Lucas, was fabulous - every bit as good, and maybe even better, than the other trilogy of that era, The Godfather (the third part of which, coming along almost 20 years later in 1990, not as good as the first two).  And I thought, contrary to a lot of critics, that the second Star Wars trilogy, also by George Lucas, in the movie theaters at the turn of the 20th into our 21st century and a little after, was every bit as good as the first trilogy, and at times even better.

And then there's the third trilogy (episodes VII-IX), of which The Rise of Skywalker is the third and final installment (episode IX), the creation of J. J. Abrams.  It takes place after the first trilogy (episodes IV-VI), which took place after the second trilogy (episodes I-III).  The second trilogy was thus a prequel, usually more difficult to do in a narrative than a sequel.  Which meant Abrams had a somewhat easier job than Lucas.   And, though I enjoyed this final trilogy ... now that it's concluded, I just think all of it just wasn't quite on the level of the first two.

This was a result of both the acting and the storylines.   In the first Star Wars trilogy (that is, the middle three episodes in terms of the time the story takes place), the acting was mostly campy, but lit up by some really high quality acting by Alec Guinness.  In the second Star Wars trilogy (the prequel), the acting by Natalie Portman, Ewen McGregor, Liam Neeson, and Samuel L. Jackson was downright excellent, and often incandescent.  In the third trilogy, just concluded, the acting returned to mostly campy, and the non-campy acting by Adam Driver and Daisy Ridley, especially in the finale, was strong and effective enough but not on the level of Portman and McGregor.

Indeed, the most appealing part of this third trilogy was the return of Harrison Ford, Carrie Fisher, Mark Hamill, and Billy Dee Williams in their original roles.   This was done well in terms of the acting.  But, in the final episode, the storylines in which they returned were a little ham-handed and under-explained.  In the first trilogy (episodes IV-VI) shown in theaters, one character, Obi-Wan, returns in a major way after he dies, and that worked very well in the narrative.  In third episode (IX) of the third trilogy, which debuted in theaters tonight, Ford, Fisher, and Hamill each return, and that was too much. And there were parts that were more muddled than need be in the part of the plot that centered around transitions from life to death and back again.  In the powerful scene in which Kylo brings Rey back to life, it wasn't clear if she was really dead, or if Kylo was dead and his appearance was an expression of Rey's unconscious.  It wasn't even completely clear whether Palpatine was dead or alive.  I know all nine movies were more mythic than literal, but the ratio of the final trilogy went a little too far towards the mythic, especially in this final episode.

All of that said, The Rise of Skywalker was enjoyable enough, and my wife and I will no dubt see whatever comes next on its opening day, whenever that arrives.   Our kids, who weren't born when my wife and I saw the first trilogy, were with us when we saw the second trilogy, and tomorrow are seeing the end of the third trilogy with their families. I'll be interested in finding out how they liked it.

See also Star Wars: The Force Awakens: Shakespearean and Fun ... Star Wars: The Last Jedi: Enjoyable Birds and Storylines

And see also Ten Reasons to Like the Clones

Paul Levinson's books ... Paul Levinson's music
 •  0 comments  •  flag
Share on Twitter
Published on December 20, 2019 20:04

Levinson at Large

Paul Levinson
At present, I'll be automatically porting over blog posts from my main blog, Paul Levinson's Infinite Regress. These consist of literate (I hope) reviews of mostly television, with some reviews of mov ...more
Follow Paul Levinson's blog with rss.