A Revolta (Os Jogos da Fome, #3) by Suzanne Collins

Aug 26, 2010 Tina rated it it was ok · review of another edition

SPOILERS AHEAD!!

What. the. f***. Words can't begin to express my disappointment. I bought Mockingjay the first day it came out and I was preparing myself for a truly epic novel, one worthy of its predecessors. I loved The Hunger Games; it was fast-paced, thrilling, suspenseful. Catching Fire wasn't as good but it was still enjoyable (I was majorly impressed by the game arena). I wasn't let down by Catching Fire though; I figured it was just a transition novel, build-up to what would undoubtedly ...more

flag 4218 likes · Like · see review

View all 976 comments

Evie I agree with the love triangle part, I was on team Peeta cause I loved her and Gale’s best friend dynamic. But agreed I just didn’t care at the end ...more
Nov 29, 2019 02:14PM

Christine Batchelder I don’t think people truly understand the character Katniss. Yes in this final book she is displaying weakness, because she had been strong for so I don’t think people truly understand the character Katniss. Yes in this final book she is displaying weakness, because she had been strong for so long, and she is being personally attacked....without her one true light Peeta. Katniss is a survivor, she isn’t selfish, she cuts off her emotions so her family can survive. At a young age, this is why all the mental issues come along . It’s apparent to me that some of the readers didn’t understand this burden Katniss had it was an annoyance to you or an after thought it was her entire life if she was to have one. She was neglected forced to cut off her human instincts and connections to survive...her one real human connection after her fathers death (not prime or her mom because this was before the mental survival shift occurred) the first one was Peeta giving her the bread that’s why it’s so deep for her....she may not have described or knew what to call it but as typically with most teenagers she thought about him then from that moment forward it was fresh on her mind not because he was super hot or super talented and everyone else wanted him as much teenagers girls think but because he provided what she needed when she finally had given up...someone with emotion suppression like she had this is monumental in your life it sticks like glue. Gale came shortly after this and she started too unthaw it was described as a slow processes, Peeta was still on her mind at this point as with most young ppl you hold on to that crush or special person and keep track of them she did this in her emotionally closed off disoriented life. if Katniss never had that day with Peeta if she survived without him and that day didn’t exist with him her heart and mind would have been Gales I’d say. Or some other boy if her father hadn’t died.

She wasn’t sulking in this book, she was forced to deal with her emotions after years and years of closing them off not to mention they weren’t the best thing she was dealing with. Not just hunger and survival, but death, the death of friends at her own making. She finally was forced to connect with ppl Rue, Mags, Wireress and they died she blames herself. All the while shes had a close group of ppl in her life she thinks she can trust but this begins being tested because they now see she is 17 and human.Aka Gale loves her so he leaves out details about Peeta and district 13 to keep her safe to her it’s the first stab she isn’t sure she can 100% trust him, and she also knows that Gale doesn’t make her feel the way Peeta does. She typically thinks of Gale when she needs him....for her family because they have a survival pact, he is her best friend, but her body is telling her she loves Peeta she just doesn’t know what to do with that, especially after he is taken...if he hadn’t gone mutt...I think she would have given into loving being with him and she would be so damaged by end of the book.

She also does begin to realize she can’t do it on her own, she feels weak she has built layers and layers of protection. ( her self talk demonstrates this) Katniss knows how to live one way, by not feeling to much. Going through the motions. She cared for Primes all her life as a child and she knew she had to keep Her safe no matter the cost, I know she loved prime more then anything but I don’t feel she even let her guard down with Prime for years until the mocking jay book....which is significant to her last break down. She’s decided she wants to fight for Peeta then her decision to push forward, which she crushes when her pearl...(Peeta is being used and tortured because of her) then the mutt incident happens when he is back , she starts closing herself off again(now she is known by too many ppl and is their hope so it’s more difficult) she’s becoming human again, but she’s also closing herself off. She now has a huge list of who she cares about so that in itself is overwhelming....she can’t keep them all safe and she knows it...and the one she’s been mentally cherishing as her hope and savior Peeta keeping her strong is no more it was her one happy place in her messed up lonely emotionally closed off life. Gale is hard like her she knows he can take what she can take, but she craves the feeling ofnhope that Peeta gave her a glimpse of happiness, stability, endless hope in her once hopeless world. thats why she runs when she can’t have him, she wants to be able to close herself off like she used to do in the past, and she feels fighting in the war will do this for her...it’s what she knows, but she knows him now and she knows she loves him...she’s allowed herself to feel it many times sooooo she can’t emotionally detach and she is a major wreck. That’s why she gets mean, and short with Peeta. She’s hurting deeply and knows she wants him and craves his love and attention and he isn’t letting her in so she wants to hurt him back.

It’s amazing her an Peeta are able to have children and a life together. Her love for Peeta let her allow herself to give him children, and he helps mend her everyday. Emotional scaring like they have endured and physical for Peeta don’t just go away, the stay in the shadows, the beauty of their love is they balance one another out, so they can keep on living, and finding bits of happiness together.

The entire story, Peeta is the nutrition to Katnisses strength, it’s just not stated as such because it’s a story. it is mentioned by president snow. Hope gives ppl courage, and allows them to carry on. She killed coin because she knew the evil within her, and she knew they wouldn't let snow live, he was done as president lucky he died, win win. She was one step ahead because Of Snow. Her driving mission was to kill him, she wanted to end evil..she had the small aha moment in the garden with president snow... and it bloomed when they met with the other victors and Coin said her intentions. She wasn’t going to let that evil go on that was the point...anyway thank goodness Katniss had Peeta and Peeta had Katniss in such a cruel world! Gale yes she will always miss her friend, but he doesn’t need her to be happy He would survive without her, and it was easier for them to leave each other’s lives, after Primes death. They started drifting long before that but they had history family like history. To remove their pain(they both emotionally detach and move on) they are very much alike. ...more
Dec 09, 2019 09:18AM

Jan 28, 2010 Hope rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: reviewed, young-adult, cover-love, favorites, best-characters, thought-provoking, heroes-i-love, best-couples, 2010-reads, bittersweet

I’m never very good at predicting outcomes. Nothing I could’ve predicted would have been quite as good as this. Although I did get close (a very distant "close") on a few things, and I was right in saying that it wouldn’t be walking through a field of flowers and sunshine.

A book like this just couldn’t be.

It's good, and yet not good. Because it’s good in a very heartbreaking, chilling, haunting, intense way.

Katniss is a different person from the first two books. I found her softer, more ...more

flag 815 likes · Like · see review

Dec 03, 2009 Tatiana rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Recommends it for: anyone who prefers to think instead of obsessing over love triangles

Shelves: ya, dystopias-post-apocalyptic, favorites, 2010, 2013, 2014, 2015

Update 11/28/14. So, of course I had to read it again after getting only half of the story from the Mockingjay movie. Unsurprisingly, cried and cried again. My feelings basically remain the same about this installment. Structurally, the novel is quite messy. There is such a big game going on and Katniss' motivations and actions don't always make sense to me. But the ending is brilliant, especially the final chapters.

I need something to cheer me up ASAP.

Let's face it, a series is only as good ...more

flag 946 likes · Like · see review

Nov 25, 2015 Khanh, first of her name, mother of bunnies rated it it was ok · review of another edition

WHAT THE FUCK KIND OF AN ENDING IS THAT?! SERIOUSLY, WHAT THE FUCK KIND OF AN ENDING IS THAT?

Ok, short summary. This is day 3 of my Hunger Games binge after I watched the last movie last Saturday without knowing anything about the books and not having watched any of the movies. First book. Awesome. Second book. Glorious. Third book. FUUUUUUUU *wails out something that sounds like "fuck you, Peeta!!!!!!"*

So now I know what a Mockingjay is (and I can probably eat it), I know who Coin is, I know ...more

flag 878 likes · Like · see review

Feb 11, 2010 Annalisa rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: young-adult, sci-fi, dystopia, cover

3.5 stars

Well, hmmm. I'm not sure how to react to Mockingjay. I didn't love it and I'm not sure it satisfied me, but it was a disturbing read that will stick with me. Sadly, I can't say that I'll be recommending the series as fervently as I did after reading The Hunger Games. Not that the series isn't good, but I'm not longer sure it's for the masses of YA readers.

Like Catching Fire, Mockingjay took awhile for me to get into. When the pages turned into the triple digits and I wasn't hooked, I ...more

flag 514 likes · Like · see review

Feb 21, 2012 Kiki rated it it was ok · review of another edition

Shelves: dystopian, choking-noises, books-to-use-as-weapons, lost-the-will-to-live, love-stinks, ya, zombies

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. [This just in: the movie adaptation, Mockingjay: Part 1, was absolutely outstanding. I've seen both of the other movies for this series, and while I enjoyed them greatly, the third instalment was on another level entirely. It's one of the best movies I've seen in a very, very long time. Good job, movie people. You made a meh book into a stellar piece of cinema.]

Those two stars are for the last ten pages, which were absolutely outstanding. Probably the best ten pages of the series. The 380 pages ...more

flag 360 likes · Like · see review

Dec 27, 2009 Michelle rated it liked it · review of another edition

i NEVER thought i'd ever rate this book below a 5...but here i am....and the only reason i gave it a three even is because the first two books of the hunger games were just SO GOOD they brought this one up...by three stars. honestly, i’ve waited so long for mockingjay to come out. i practically peed my pants on august 24th and now that i’ve finally finished the book (thanks to a full day of obsessive reading-meals not included) all i can feel is…annoyance. annoyance and disappointment. annoyance i NEVER thought i'd ever rate this book below a 5...but here i am....and the only reason i gave it a three even is because the first two books of the hunger games were just SO GOOD they brought this one up...by three stars. honestly, i’ve waited so long for mockingjay to come out. i practically peed my pants on august 24th and now that i’ve finally finished the book (thanks to a full day of obsessive reading-meals not included) all i can feel is…annoyance. annoyance and disappointment. annoyance that katniss let herself be so easily used, didn't really care about anything, and was idle for so much of the book. and disappointment that you never really get any closure with gale, peeta wasn’t there for a third of the book, and he “wasn’t himself” for almost all of it. but mostly just mad that nothing really happened for large portions of the book. like…katniss seemed kinda…stuck all throughout. i’ve always loved her because she was a character that didn’t break down easily but mental breakdowns seemed like her favorite activity in this book. she spent like a fourth of the book missing peeta but she never actually DID anything about it. and then when he was saved she barely even talked to him let alone tried to help him. okay *spoiler alert* one of the only bright spots of this book is finding out about finnick’s past. i was definitely surprised by all he had to say. it made me like him even more. i can honestly say he was the only character that didn't annoy me once in mockingjay…AND THEN HE DIED. i am SO MAD that finnick and cinna’s death were pretty much considered inconsequential. like yeah, katniss was sad, but neither of them got like a dramatic tragical death. it was just “yeah. they died. it sucks.” and that really bummed me out cause i LOVED them both. i thought finnick's death was three times as devastating as prims, mostly because i feel like we never got to know prim well enough to really mourn her death. but for finnick i had to go back and reread the page several times before i could actually accept that he had died. and even then i hoped he would magically pop to life again. and not a single tear shed for him from katniss? NOT. OKAY. even though this was the book where the most characters died, it was also the book where i didn't cry once reading it. mostly because katniss didn't seem to really even care about anything which sort of killed my sympathy and sparked annoyance instead. and yeahh…so back to the whole non-closure thing with gale? it was just so…anticlimatic and…lacking. i’ve been a peeta supporter since the first chapter of the first book and even i hated how katniss and gale ended. i don’t know. i just think that maybe i was expecting this last book to follow basically the same format as the hunger games and catching fire, and i’m just ridiculously (like seriously to the point where it’s pathetic) disappointed that it took such a different turn. …and now that i know the entire series is over so that’s the only ending i’m gonna get....:'(
katniss’s shining moment appeared near the end though. when she decided to shoot coin instead of president snow. it almost brought back the old hunger-games-and-catching-fire-rational-and-strong katniss. almost. but then she had to go and try to get herself addicted to morphine in a suicide attempt. bleh. i always knew this was a somewhat dark series, but this book was just. so. bleak. reading it was pretty much equivalent to cutting my wrists. perhaps no amount of writing could ever have helped suzanne collins live up to my sky high expectations of this book but still….

the book could have been better. a lot. better.
...more

flag 336 likes · Like · see review

Aug 24, 2010 Jayna rated it it was ok · review of another edition

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

flag 303 likes · Like · see review

Feb 09, 2014 Jayson rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: author-american, genre-science-fiction, 400-499-pp, genre-dystopian, genre-young-adult, read-in-2014, subject-war

(B+) 78% | Good
Notes: Rather than tell an interesting story, it’s meant above all to repulse us into reflection on the cruelty and horror of war.

flag 304 likes · Like · see review

Feb 17, 2010 Kat Kennedy rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: to-ya-or-not-to-ya, oppressive-dystopian-regime, kat-s-book-reviews

This review has spoilers!

Bitches...

What were you doing when you were 16? Checking your boobs each morning to see if the Boob Fairy had paid you a visit? Sneaking out of the house to the park down the street where you and your six friends would share a single can of beer and pretend you're drunk? Making out? Homework? Fighting with your parents? Watching scary movies?

Katniss is sixteen years old and she's been in two Hunger Games, fighting against twenty-odd opponents to the death. Then she ...more

flag 293 likes · Like · see review

Dec 30, 2009 Kaela rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. Mockingjay, the final book in Suzanne Collin's Hunger Games Trilogy. For a year, I had been anxiously waiting to read the about the adventures of the rebels, the hopefully happy ending. How wrong was I. There is an ending - but it is not as happy as most expected it to be. The rebels fought, they won. But in a sense, Collin's shows us that when violence is used to such extremes, no one wins; yes, a winner is declared - but the sadness and loss of both sides proves that no one really wins in Mockingjay, the final book in Suzanne Collin's Hunger Games Trilogy. For a year, I had been anxiously waiting to read the about the adventures of the rebels, the hopefully happy ending. How wrong was I. There is an ending - but it is not as happy as most expected it to be. The rebels fought, they won. But in a sense, Collin's shows us that when violence is used to such extremes, no one wins; yes, a winner is declared - but the sadness and loss of both sides proves that no one really wins in war. While reading this book, I felt almost as depressed as a sober Haymitch.

There is a lot of death throughout the book (I sobbed at Finnick's). However, even though there is so much death in this book, most of it comes to new characters; the leader of district 13, Coin; Bogg, one of Katniss's bodyguards; mostly new or unknown characters that pass on. But alot of the death-related sadness in the book comes not from individual characters, but more from Katniss's vivid description of the mass homicide that they are left with at the end of the war. The group of children murdered on President Snow's doorstep - Prim included. The workers trapped in the Nut, a mountain in district two. The hospital burned down in district eight. That, more than anything, sets such a depressing tone.

In my opinion, however, it wasn't death that made such a sad air around the book. Some of the tortures make it worse. Peeta's hijacking, Finnick's molestation, Johanna's physical pain. And to top the list, Katniss - expected to be the rock strong Mockingjay when all of this happens around her. All this pain that she goes though, and so much more, should make her deserve a happy life afterwards. However, instead of in the company of her surviving friends and family, she finds herself alone, in a burned-down district, sitting by the fire in her Victor's house. That, more that anything, saddens the reader. When Katniss deserves someone with her, to make her feel less alone, the only person to console her is herself. Yes, in the end she and Peeta end up together. But during the book, she is always alone.

Even though this book is a far departure from the first two books, I believe that Suzanne saved her own series. She, like Cinna, made sure that no one would forget the 'girl on fire'. When so many books have slightly bittersweet endings, this book is much heavier on the bitter, distinguishing itself from so many others. There is no Disney ending to the Hunger Games, and I believe that if there was one than it would ruin the message of the series.

Suzanne Collins created her third bittersweet masterpiece, completeing one of the most different and best trilogies in YA Fiction today.

**note** its beautiful writing, too. suzanne collins has a gorgeous voice. ...more

flag 284 likes · Like · see review

Dec 04, 2009 Heather rated it it was ok · review of another edition

Shelves: 2010

How do I begin to convey my disappointment? I suppose it all comes down to expectations and as mine were not met, I feel vastly underwhelmed, and a little bit devastated. When I read HungerGames, I was enthralled. I thought Katniss was intelligent, resourceful, and displayed tremendous strength in character. Moreover, Katniss’s arc appeared to parallel with the overall arc of the story/series. As Katniss grew more bold, so did the remaining characters and the uprising initiative. I expected this How do I begin to convey my disappointment? I suppose it all comes down to expectations and as mine were not met, I feel vastly underwhelmed, and a little bit devastated. When I read HungerGames, I was enthralled. I thought Katniss was intelligent, resourceful, and displayed tremendous strength in character. Moreover, Katniss’s arc appeared to parallel with the overall arc of the story/series. As Katniss grew more bold, so did the remaining characters and the uprising initiative. I expected this to continue in Catching Fire. However, Katniss appeared to stagnate, whereas the remaining characters and overall story arc continued on without her. By the end of book 2, Katniss was still in “survivor” mode, and failed to deliver anything beyond demonstration of those already proven survival instincts that we readers discovered in book 1. Nonetheless, my love for HungerGames left me with hope that Katniss would finally step into her role as not only a symbol of hope and rebellion against tyranny, but as a leader in an uprising that opposes oppression, and emboldens freedom of choice and will. Much to my dismay, it never occurs.

Perhaps I am mistaken, but I was under the impression that this series was meant to be about revolting against a corrupt, freedom suppressing government and replacing it with a new government that not only condones freedom in all its forms, but fosters it, allowing it to thrive. For this to be an achievable story arc, Katniss has to develop into something more than a resourceful hunter, shooter of arrows, and unpredictable pawn. She has to embolden herself, as the districts have had to embolden themselves, grab her title as MockingJay by the balls, and make her own choices, cut her own path, and shoot down those who stand in her way literally and figuratively. Otherwise what is the point of revolution if the very person who made it possible doesn’t follow through?

But in MockingJay we don’t get an emboldened Katniss, we simply get more of the same, actually, we get less than the same. When Katniss isn’t hiding in closets, passed out from injuries, strung out on morphine, or walking around the compound in a near catatonic state, Katniss will exert herself in her typical yet unpredictable brash reactor form, always manipulated by those around her. She still lacks control over her life. She isn’t a warrior in the rebellion, she is a weapon, a tool, a pawn. Other times she is completely useless all-together. She is dictated to and she may or may not deliver. Where did the potential leader go I ask you?

This late in the game, Katniss needed to grow as a character, to complete the story arc, if not her own character’s journey, properly. Katniss has been used to spur the other districts into revolution because she is supposed to possess strength in character as seen in the Hunger Games. She is now the face of the revolution, whether she meant to be or not. The districts have become inspired by the ball busting Katniss they perceive her to be, and it’s a lie. Turns out she isn’t opposed to being used as long as it’s people she knows calling the shots (District 13). I would have been fine with this course of events had they appeared in CatchingFire. But by the final installment, Katniss needed to be in charge of her own fate, to understand her role, to be a role model. Instead I felt as though I was reading the POV of a mentally unstable drug addict.

Then there is the rebellion itself. I was expecting carnage, war, suffering, and terror seen through the eyes of our previous heroine (Katniss) and hero (Peeta). Instead we suffer through ad campaigns and one unnecessary adventure that doesn’t occur until the last portion of the book, and even that is unsatisfying with all its useless deaths (Finnick and Primm). Frankly, Finnick was the best part of MockingJay and I couldn’t even mourn him properly as his face time was so minimal and his death so swift. But back on point, what was the purpose for Katniss’s man killing mission? Is she really so daft that she can’t see the bigger picture? Can’t she rise above baser human emotions, and the events that pertain only to her? Can’t she at least attempt to be worthy of the responsibility that has befallen her? Can’t she at least strive to earn it? And what’s most pathetic is that the revenge attempt that cost the lives of Finnick and Primm was all for nothing. Snow lives, until TB takes him. At least that’s what I assume happens, it never is very clear on how he died.

But my biggest question is, why does Collins hate Peeta? When she wasn’t making him an invalid in books 1 and 2, he shined. Now in book 3 he has forgotten his love for Katniss and has been programmed by the Capital to kill her. What the hell? Why? Why not let him finally prove his worth, achieve his greatness? Why did she have to make him someone’s bitch?

This book is a sham. A cop out. And it destroys the integrity of the previous books in the series. The characters fail to develop and even digress into wretched states. The ending is a crap shoot, and that epilogue was bullshit. I’m Team Peeta through and through, but I feel ripped off. Katniss didn’t choose him, she resigned herself to him because he was the one who came back for her. There was no declaration on her part, no acceptance or confession of her feelings. Peeta deserved better. We readers earned better.

To those of you reviewers who will scoff at my review, claiming that this book was perfect because it was "realistic", I say give me a break. This series was never meant to be a war documentary. It is a Young Adult Sceince Fiction book. This book contains mutant animals and insects for Christ's sake. In what reality other than "make believe" does a teenager fuel a rebellion? Millions of girls adore Justin Beiber but he isn't going to become the next president. We didn't wait on pins and needles for realism. That's not why readers devoured The Hunger Games. We fell in love because the plot grabbed a hold of our minds with an enthralling story filled with worthy engaging characters. Sadly, somewhere along the way, Collins lost track of the story she was telling and got off course by deciding to get preachy. I didn't want a victim for a heroine, I wanted a victor.

After two rather epic books, I expected more, these characters were worthy of more. It’s terrible what was done to them and to us for having to read it. While reading MockingJayI felt like Katniss, a pawn.
...more

flag 276 likes · Like · see review

Mar 25, 2010 karen rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: why-yes-i-ya

these are the things i have done for this book:

i have given up my birthday, waiting in line from 5 until its midnight release, braving the crowds and noise and commotion...

i have missed my subway stop and ended up taking the crappy way into work...

i have seriously considered calling out of work to sit at home and finish it...

i have read in elevators, while walking down the street, walking up the stairs, while eating dinner without even tasting it...

i have rushed my beloved dawn powell's book, ...more

flag 261 likes · Like · see review

May 15, 2014 Sean Barrs the Bookdragon rated it did not like it · review of another edition

Shelves: fantasy, sci-fi, 1-star-reads, y-a

Here's seven reasons why this trilogy sucks:

1. Katniss has the personality of a vegetable

description

2. Peeta is a needy little baker boy

description

I’ll never get over how the author can justify his camouflage techniques born as a result from his cake decorating experience……

description

3. The world is completely unacceptable and unbelievable.

No collective nation would be so morally depraved as to watch the murder of children for entertainment; I cannot accept this idea.

description

4. This book did not make me think, as ...more

flag 240 likes · Like · see review

Oct 26, 2010 Mike (the Paladin) rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: fantasy, rereading

Below is my original review. I'm leaving it as it's still essentially how I feel still. I have however decided that the overall story of the book rates a higher rating than I originally gave (you'll see below). The biggest problem for me was that Katniss seemed to grow some throughout the first and the second book, yet slid back and forth/up and down throughout this. I just didn't think it was still Katniss in some ways.

To each of course and I'd say try it yourself and see how you feel/what you Below is my original review. I'm leaving it as it's still essentially how I feel still. I have however decided that the overall story of the book rates a higher rating than I originally gave (you'll see below). The biggest problem for me was that Katniss seemed to grow some throughout the first and the second book, yet slid back and forth/up and down throughout this. I just didn't think it was still Katniss in some ways.

To each of course and I'd say try it yourself and see how you feel/what you think.

Some spoilers in review as I do discuss some things about the conclusion of the book.

***************** Spoilers in Review below *******************

(view spoiler)[ Okay, just us now...a lot of people loved this book. I'm not one of them. I liked the first book immensely, I also liked the second volume. I appreciate the inspiration behind the books. I considered 3 stars here, as there are times when some very good writing comes through. But in the end for me to say I really didn't like the book wouldn't fit with a 3 star rating. There were too many times I skimmed through this one, too many times I came very close to abandoning the read all together simply due to the story and it's telling.

If you read my review of the second volume in this trilogy you know that one of the things that bothered me most was the immature and selfish character of Katniss. I observed at the close of that volume that this had probably been intentional on Ms.Collins' part and that Katniss seemed to be growing out of it after the hard and troubling events at the end of said volume.

Well, Katniss had a relapse...big-time. Apparently in all the wars and all the revolutions and all the tragedies of all time NO ONE has suffered as she has. Am I the only one who got so tired of her constant bemoaning of her own fate...as the world is flying apart around her? She forces the rebels to take her back to her blasted and burned former home where she apparently wanders around saying things like "I brought this on you"... GOOD GRIEF. No Katniss, the people who dropped the bombs brought it on them...the people who ordered it brought it on...the people who have been forcing children to kill each other in arenas to hold the entire populace under their heel FOR GENERATIONS brought it on. The world didn't start when you were born Katniss.

The book becomes, it seems to me very much of a one trick pony with Katniss constantly discovering more pain and more woe. It turns into a story where the rebels seem often to be as bad as the oppressive government they seek to overthrow. A book that comes very close to one of those pompous tomes (and for that matter movies, short stories etc.) that defined itself as "anti-war" as if people sometimes get together and say, "hey, let's have a war." War is nothing more than an assault or an armed robbery writ large. Very few actually "want war" it doesn't make one extra righteous to say "I'm taking a stand against war!", just self-righteous. The choice in the story Ms. Collins wrote is the same as it has been often...war or enslavement. You can accept what your handed and live with it, let them take your goods... your children, or you can resist. The longer you wait to resist the worse it may be. Thus the 1 star rating. It seems to me Katniss is an annoying character who (I think) became badly one dimensional. There are a few bright spots and some good prose, but over all, I'm not taken with the book.

For me one of the most telling moment in the book was in a conversation between Gale and Peeta (the boy named after pocket bread) when they are having a conversation about which of them Katniss will eventually "choose" and Gale hits it on the head. He says she'll pick the one She can't survive without. Of course from Katniss we get the obligatory self recrimination, "am I that bad", well I don't need either of them, internal monologue..but (when proverbial push comes to proverbial shove) that is exactly what she eventually does.

In the end so far as I can tell after all that's happened, after all the death and loss the world still revolves around Katniss at least so far as Katniss is concerned. (hide spoiler)]

I found this an unsatisfying book and conclusion to what had been up to now a pretty good trilogy and if my children were still young I'd definitely discuss this one with them to see what they took away from it. Not my cup of tea, and puts my retention of the other two in my collection in question...I regret the money spent on this book and the time invested in it, a bad sign. The first book is a very good read, the second is pretty good, but this, the end volume is very, very weak. My opinion of course.

Update: Sadly this volume ruined the entire set for me. I sold all 3. ...more

flag 214 likes · Like · see review

Dec 18, 2010 Nataliya rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: i-also-saw-the-film, awesome-kickass-heroines, dystopia-postapocalyptic, for-my-future-hypothetical-daughter

All Katniss really wants is to not be "a piece in their games". But nobody apparently got the memo. Once again, she is a pawn in somebody's power games. Same shit, different day. Only the Gamemakers have changed.

The above are synonymous in the eyes of the Capitol. Or District 13, for that matter.

Even free from the clutches of the Capitol, Katniss still has a role to play - whether she wants it or not. This time it's Mockingjay, the face of the rebellion she unwittingly helped to bring. But the ...more

flag 204 likes · Like · see review

Dec 04, 2009 Meredith Holley rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: young-adult, classic-young-adult, influenced-me, chosen-girls, monsters, girls-rule, reviewed, best-of-the-year

I guess, sometimes our emotional bones need to be re-broken in order to set them right. Maybe this was a common experience for those who read this book, but a lot of its most emotional points were like reading a bizarre dream about the last few years of my own life. I’m not going to go into it because that would be, like, an unacceptable amount of over-share, even for me. That’s just to say that I have no ability to be objective about it. This story: real or not real?

I love Mockingjay like I ...more

flag 199 likes · Like · see review

Mar 05, 2014 Mohammed Arabey rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

أهلا بك في نهاية أهم ملحمات الديستوبيا في العصر الحديث

"Are you, are you
Coming to the tree
Where they strung up a man they say murdered three.
Strange things did happen here
No stranger would it be
If we met up at midnight in the hanging tree.”

"هل تأتي، هل تأتي الي الشجرة
حيث علقوا منها رجلا يقال أنه قتل ثلاثة
أشياء غريبة حدثت هنا ولكن لن يحدث الأغرب
في حال تقابلنا هنا بمنتصف الليل، عند مشنقة الشجرة"

الحبكة التي يراها البعض خطرا علي بعض انظمة الحكم

أحداث ثورية واقعية علي نظام فاسد ديكتاتوري، يمتص جهد

أهلا بك في نهاية أهم ملحمات الديستوبيا في العصر الحديث

"Are you, are you
Coming to the tree
Where they strung up a man they say murdered three.
Strange things did happen here
No stranger would it be
If we met up at midnight in the hanging tree.”

"هل تأتي، هل تأتي الي الشجرة
حيث علقوا منها رجلا يقال أنه قتل ثلاثة
أشياء غريبة حدثت هنا ولكن لن يحدث الأغرب
في حال تقابلنا هنا بمنتصف الليل، عند مشنقة الشجرة"

الحبكة التي يراها البعض خطرا علي بعض انظمة الحكم

أحداث ثورية واقعية علي نظام فاسد ديكتاتوري، يمتص جهد شعبه من أجل مصلحة ورخاء الأقلية الأثرياء، الطبقة العليا والرئيس وحاشيته

ثوار حقيقيون يريدون العدل، أو يريدون فقط الحياة الكريمة...يريدون حــياة حرة فحسب

ونوع أخر من الثوار، يريدون قصاصا دمويا فحسب، لا يقلون ديكتاتورية عن النظام الفاسد الحالي...قد يصل بهم الأمر لقتل الأبرياء فقط لأسقاط النظام والوصول للسلطة مكانه

وبين هذا وهذا، نوع فريد من الثوار... كاتنيس أيفيردين

وهي اعتبرها أقوي ما في الثلاثية..شخصية فريدة وضعت في ديستوبيا أورويلية..تكاد تكون واقعية

كـالجزء الثاني ستجد نفسك امام احداث تتشابه مع واقعنا في الربيع العربي المزعوم
احداث ثورية علي نظام فاسد ديكتاتوري بخداعه وتعذيبه وقمعه، ونجحت المؤلفه في أضافة مواقف كثيرة خلال هذا الجزء توضح فساد النظام -حتي فساد الأستغلال الجنسي للمشاهير والتي تتشابهه كثيرا مع ممارسات حدثت في مصر منذ اواخر الستينات علي يد المخابرات وحتي التسعينات
-المهم أن كل هذا بدون حشو وايحاءات والفاظ بذيئه كعادة الكتاب الشباب العرب-

بل ومفاجأة غريبة ستجد احداث تتشابهه كثيرا مع "موقعه الجمل" في مصر او حتي ضرب الاطفال بالكيماوي في سوريا ولن يكون هناك تأكيد في الأحداث من قام بها بشكل واضح لانه -دعونا نتحدث بصراحة- لا يوجد شئ مؤكد في لعبه الصراع علي العروش والكراسي القذرة ولعبة السياسة النجسة...فكما قلت كان هناك البعض مستعدا للتضحية القذرة ببعض الأبرياء في سبيل أسقاط النظام, وأعتلاء السلطة

حتي ان كان هذا يؤدي للتضحية الغادرة بالأبرياء
-وجاء الفيلم مباشرا بهذه النقطة بشكل ممتاز-
حتي الرئيس يدافع عن نفسه في الرواية بعد هذه الأحداث الدموية بـ "لم اكن انتوي البقاء في السلطة وكنت انتوي التنحي ,وأنا أخاف علي مصلحة الشعب وحياتهم"

كما ستجد هناك ثوار يطالبون بالدم من اجل الانتفام فحسب , يطالبون بديكتاتورية أخري, واذا لم توافق فانت "خائن وعميل" واعتقد انه اذا كانت "فلول" لها تعبير انجليزي لتم استخدامه في الاحداث

“Are you, are you
Coming to the tree
Where the dead man called out for his love to flee.
Strange things did happen here
No stranger would it be
If we met up at midnight in the hanging tree.”

"هل تأتي ,هل تأتي الي الشجرة
حيث نادي الرجل الميت حبيبته لتهرب
أشياء غريبة حدثت هنا ولكن لن يحدث الأغرب
في حال تقابلنا هنا بمنتصف الليل, عند مشنقة الشجرة"

ولندع الواقع الضائع,المقيت جانبا ولنبدأ بــ

الأحــداث
******
تبدأ بعد مرور وقت قليل من نهاية الجزء الثاني الرهيبة
ألا أنها لم تكن بنفس السرعة كالجزء السابق وكانت أبطأ كثيرا

كاتنيس بعد معرفتها بما حدث للقطاع 12, وانتقالها لثوار القطاع 13 , يتم تدريبها هناك بالرغم من حالتها النفسية السيئة لتكون رمزا للثورة, الصورة الدعائية لها, وتوافق لأمر واحد...فهي تريد العيش بحرية وكرامة... ولكن لا يمكن أن يحدث ذلك دون القضاء علي الرئيس " سنو" الذي احال حياتها الي جحيم ,ودمر حيوات اكثر

ولكن الاهم يجب انقاذ "بيتا" من ايدي الكابيتول كما انتهت الأحداث السابقة..ثم لتبدأ الحرب

وهذا هو اكبر عيوب الجزء الاخير .. ودون الخوض في تفاصيل بالأخص لهؤلاء المعتمدين علي سلسلة الأفلام

لان الاحداث تدور من وجهه نظر كاتنيس فحسب, بينما الاحداث الهامة والمبني عليها احداث الجزء الاخير من تخطيط للحرب والصراع لا تستلزم وجودها في البدايه, او وقوعها الدائم في صدمة من توالي الاحداث الصعبة التي لم تكن نهاية الجزء السابق سوي بدايه لها يجعلها لا تتابع كيف يدور الصراع
فجائت الأجزاء التي تمر بها في اثناء تلك الصدمات النفسية بطيئة جدا

********************
مقارنة لا بد منها

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Vs. Mockingjay
**********************************************
Vs
شعرت طوال الاحداث بانني امام نسخه اخري من اخر اجزاء هاري بوتر, حيث يتشابهه الاثنان في ان الخيط الاساسي في الاحداث الذي ظل ثابت في الاجزاء السابقه لينقلب ويتغير تماما في جزءه الأخير
--------------------------
أولا: تغيير جذري في تسلسل وأماكن وقوع الأحداث بين الجزء الأخير والأجزاء السابقة

هاري بوتر كل جزء يبدأ بانتهاء الصيف ثم المدرسة وايام الدراسة و حتي الامتحانات
ماعدا الاخير لا يوجد مدرسة ولا امتحانات والاحداث بعيدة تماما عن مكان المدرسة التي اعتدناها طوال الاجزاء السابقة

في العاب المجاعات دائما هناك الحصاد ,ثم التدريب , ثم ساحه القتال.. ولكن هنا في الجزء الأخير الامر اختلف تماما, لا حصاد, التدريب مختلف تماما والقتال في شوارع العاصمة "الكابيتول" والذي اعتقد انه من وجهه نظري اكثر الاجزاء الغير مقنعه بالنسبه لي, فوصف الأكشن به كان صعبا جدا بالأخص في وصف كيف تمت كل تلك الصراعات في شوارع الكابيتول,وهذا يحتل مساحة ضخمة من الجزء نفسه

قد يكون الصراع بشوارع العاصمة "الكابيتول" دمويا كالأرينا "ساحات القتال" ولكن يظل الوصف مطولا ومرهقا ومختلفا عن نوعية الجزئين السابقين

كما ان هناك تطويل شعرت به منذ بداية الاحداث حتي مابعد منتصف الرواية
-كما قلت الاحداث من وجهة نظر كاتنيس فحسب-
اما تتداعيات النهايه فكان الجزء "الاكشن" بها غريب , حتي الوفيات به كانت "متسارعة" فلم اشعر بالحزن الا تقريبا بعد الاحداث الرئيسية وقبل الخاتمة الجميلة
Bittersweet
وهذا ايضا يتشابهه مع هاري بوتر وكثرة الوفيات في جزءه الأخير

وهذا ذكرني ايضا بنهايه روايه

Divergent (Divergent, #1) by Veronica Roth

والتي فاقت كميه الوفيات اكثر من هنا بالرغم من انها مازالت في جزئها الاول, كما ان اكشن "حرب الشوارع" لم يكن مقنعا بالأخيرة ايضا

--------------------------
ثانيا : كلمات تؤثر القلب Always VS Real or Not Real

يبدو ان كل عشاق هاري بوتر شعروا بان تلك الكلمة -دائما- تعتبر كعلامة مسجلة لسناب في اخر مشاهده في الجزء الاخير من هاري بوتر, قصة الحب الخالدة بالرغم من مأسويتها

هنا ايضا تم أستخدامها بشكل رومانسي جدا ولكن يظل استخدام المؤلفة ل"حقيقي ام لا" هو اكثر ماشدني بهذه الرواية وأثر في بطريقة ممتازة و"اوريجينال" جدا ليكون مسجل لقصة الحب هنا والتي تبادلها الأثنين
حقيقي أم لا

وقد استخدمها بيتا وكاتنيس كثيرا في الاحداث مما يمنحك نوستاليجا للجزئين السابقين

"You’re still trying to protect me. Real or not real,” he whispers

وقد وظفتها بشكل رائع خلال الاحداث فعلا حتي نهايتها , وأثرت في جدا

--------------------------
ثالثا : الخاتمة EPILOGUE

تتميز هنا في العاب المجاعات ان اخر فصل في النهاية اقوي وملائم بشكل اروع للسلسلة, بعكس نوعا ما في هاري بوتر والتي كان بها "كلاشيه" النهاية السعيدة المعتادة -وحتي ندمت عليها لاحقا جي كي رولينج في أمر رون وهرميوني

أعجبني جدا النهاية لكل الشخصيات "التي بقيت علي قيد الحياة فقط بالطبع" وحتي نهاية الطاغي /الطغاة

والسؤال المعلق...هل فعلا القادم سيكون أفضل؟
أعتقد ان النهاية جائت واقعية
وكيف تؤثر الثورة في نفوس البعض
سواء بالايجابية او بالسلبية

-وظهور القط في النهاية كما ببداية الرواية جعلني اتأثر كثيرا , المشهد تم تقديمه بشكل ممتاز في الفيلم الأخير-

“Are you, are you
Coming to the tree
Where I told you to run, so we’d both be free.
Strange things did happen here
No stranger would it be
If we met up at midnight in the hanging tree.”

هل تأتي ,هل تأتي الي الشجرة"
إلي حيث قلت لكي أن تهربي ,لنكون سويا أحرار
أشياء غريبة حدثت هنا ولكن لن يحدث الأغرب
"في حال تقابلنا هنا بمنتصف الليل, عند مشنقة الشجرة

--------------------------

رابعا وأخيرا : حكايه الاخوه الثلاثه و حكاية شجرة المشنقة

قصة, هي دائما قصة من التراث الموروث في عالم الرواية..قصة تتردد منذ بداية الجزء الأخير
قصة قد تشعر انها قدر البطل حتي يتمرد عليها بثورته

في هاري بوتر قصه الاخوه الثلاثه كانت تصور ان النجاح والنصر يحتاج الي "مقاومات الموت" بالهروب منه بعباءة أخفاء..حجر أعادة الحياة أو عصا القوة ولكن الامر لم يكن هكذا ابدا بالرغم من انك ستعتقد في الجزء الاخير عند ذكرها ان "مقاومات الموت" هي طريقته للنصر

اما في هنا فأغنيه شجرة المشنقة, والتي أرويها لكم بلغتها الأصلية منذ بداية الريفيو اوحت للبطله ان الهروب من هذا الجحيم والاستبداد لن يأتي سوي بترك الجحيم تماما والاستسلام للعدم,الموت..وذلك قبل النهاية

وهي من اقوي الاجزاء بالرواية ايضا واعجبتني جدا بالرغم من طابعها التشاؤمي , الا انها للاسف تليق بالاشياء الغريبة التي تحدث الان في العالم الحقيقي,والتي تعدنا للأسف كالاغنية ان الاغرب بالفعل يحدث..ولكن الرواية تدعو لعدم الأستسلام..عدم الهرب بهذه الطريقة..وهذه هي قيمة الرواية وقوتها..قوة كاتنيس أيفيردين

“Are you, are you
Coming to the tree
Wear a necklace of rope, side by side with me.
Strange things did happen here
No stranger would it be
If we met up at midnight in the hanging tree.”

هل تأتي ,هل تأتي الي الشجرة"
أرتدي عقدا من الحبال , جنبا الي جنب معي
أشياء غريبة حدثت هنا ولكن لن يحدث الأغرب
"في حال تقابلنا هنا بمنتصف الليل, عند مشنقة الشجرة

****************************************************
النهاية
*****
ولندعنا من كل هذا التشاؤم ولنري ماتفوقت فيه بحق المؤلفه
وما بدأت به الريفيو, الشخصيه الثوريه الاقوي في روايات الديستوبيا من وجهه نظري
وتطور شخصيتها من أروع وأدق التطورات في الروايات من ذلك النوع

لم تأتي ثورتها وتمردها امرا مبالغ فيه, برعت المؤلفه في رسم كيف بدأت كواحده لا تفكر سوي في الهروب للعيش مع اهلها فحسب في الغابه بعيدا عن اي شئ..ثم إلي تحولها رمزا حقيقيا للثورة, وكيف تم في البداية استخدام الرمز بشكل "مهين" للفكره الثورية بحجه الدعاية , ولكن بشخصيتها وتلقائيتها تحولت الي شعلة ثورية حقيقية بعيدا عن الزيف والنفاق
تحولت الي طائر حر, يرفض القمع والاستبداد أيا كان مسماه
الفتاة المشتعلة اشعلت اللهب في الفساد واللاانسانية ,وحلقت كطائر حر

حلقت بعيدا عن الطغيان...اي نوع من الطغيان
طغيان حاكم , او طغيان ثوري جامح
ليس للانتقام وانما...لحياه للبشريه اجمل, قد لانصل ليوتوبيا, ولكن فقط نحاول الا نجعلها ديستوبيا

قد يكون الجزء الثالث هو الاقل تفضيلا بالنسبة لي "ازيد من 3 نجوم بقليل" ولكن السلسلة بوجهه عام وتطور شخصية كاتنيس والنهاية هي ماجعلت التقييم يعلو,ويجعل السلسلة من وجهه نظري فعلا تستحق القراءة كواحدة من اجمل الروايات الثورية

سافتقد جدا القراءه لكاتنيس ايفيردين..وسماع صوتها وهو يترنم...تلك الانشوده

"Deep in the meadow, under the willow
A bed of grass, a soft green pillow
Lay down your head, and close your sleepy eyes
And when again they open, the sun will rise.

Here it’s safe, here it’s warm
Here the daisies guard you from every harm
Here your dreams are sweet and tomorrow brings them true
Here is the place where I love you.

والي ريفيو للثلاثيه معا ان شاء الله

محمد العربي
من 5 مارس 2014
الي 16 مارس 2014

________________________________________
تحديث في 22 نوفمبر 2014
بعد مشاهدة الفيلم

ينبغي أن اقول ان الفيلم فعلا تفوق علي الرواية في هذا الجزء بالأخص, اشعر دائما ان كاتبي السيناريو يحاولوا سد العيوب ليروا السلسلة كاملة بنهايتها بعكس المؤلف الذي قد يقع منه قليل من الأحداث

كعودة شخصية أيفي مثلا والتي افتقدها جدا بالرواية, لتكون موجودة منذ بداية الجزء الثالث
وبالطبع كما قلت ان الاحداث من وجهة نظر كاتنيس فقط في جزء هام كهذا جعل بعض الملل يتسرب إلي أثناء القراءة , ولكن الفيلم قام بتلافي هذا حيث يقدم الأحداث من أكثر من وجهة نظر وليس من جهة كاتنيس فحسب

أما أكثر ما عجبني فهي جملة علي لسان الراحل "فيليب سيمور هوفمان" في دور بلاتشر أنه غير كلمة حبل الي أمل في تلك الأنشودة التي غنتها كاتنيس...بدلا من حبل المشنقة حولها الي أمل

وهذا يتلائم بالتأكيد مع نهاية الرواية...بالطبع دون مشانق
لا تستسلم أبدا للموت, لم يكن قتل النفس أبدا حرية

أثرت في الأغنية جدا بصوت كاتنيس, وسعدت عندما حاولت تعديل الريفيو أن وجدت أني قد أشرت لها من قبل مشاهدة الفيلم فلم أقم سوي بتعديل بسيط في الريفيو وأضافة ترجمة لها بدلا من الاغنية بالانجليزية فحسب

أثرت الأغنية بشكل أقوي في بسبب الحوادث المؤسفة التي صرنا نراها بشكل دائم...نسأل الله أن يخرجنا مما كل هذا الوجع
ويحسن ختامنا

“Are you, are you
Coming to the tree
Wear a necklace of HOPE, side by side with me.
Strange things did happen here
No stranger would it be
If we met up at midnight in the hanging tree.”

هل تأتي ,هل تأتي الي الشجرة"
أرتدي عقدا من الأمال , جنبا الي جنب معي
أشياء غريبة حدثت هنا ولكن لن يحدث الأغرب
"في حال تقابلنا هنا بمنتصف الليل, عند مشنقة الشجرة

“Are you, are you
Coming to the tree
Where I told you to run, so we’d both be free.
Strange things did happen here
No stranger would it be
If we met up at midnight in the hanging tree.”

هل تأتي ,هل تأتي الي الشجرة"
إلي حيث قلت لكي أن تهربي ,لنكون سويا أحرار
أشياء غريبة حدثت هنا ولكن لن يحدث الأغرب
"في حال تقابلنا هنا بمنتصف الليل, عند مشنقة الشجرة

رابط للأغنية بصوت جينيفر لورانس / كاتنيس أيفيردين وموسيقي الرائع جيمس نيوتن هاورد

ملحوظة في 21 نوفمبر 2015

الجزء الثاني من الفيلم كان مؤثرا بشكل رهيب
اكثر من رائع
حتي الاكشن فيه افضل من الكتاب
ولكن يظل النهاية ملائمة تماما للكتاب ومقدمة بشكل عبقري يحبس الانفاس

لا تفوت قراءة تلك السلسلة
ولا مشاهدة افلامها ...more

flag 187 likes · Like · see review

Jul 26, 2018 ~Poppy~ rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

“You love me. Real or not real?"
"Real.”

"Friend. Lover. Victor. Enemy. Fiancee. Target. Mutt. Neighbor. Hunter. Tribute. Ally. I'll add it to the list of words I use to try to figure you out.”

“Stay with me.
Always.”

flag 184 likes · Like · see review

Dec 25, 2009 Melissa ♥♫ rated it really liked it · review of another edition

This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here. This review is supposed to be hidden by the spoiler alert, but everyone is yelling at me telling me I spoiled the whole story so idk I'm really confused and I've checked that the review is hidden like 3 times and I do have it checked to "hide entire review because of spoilers" so I'm just putting this here, honestly this is probably the least spoiling review...if that makes sense. Sorry to anyone who's enjoyment of the book was ruined, just go find other reviews to read, nobody's perfect.

Also I This review is supposed to be hidden by the spoiler alert, but everyone is yelling at me telling me I spoiled the whole story so idk I'm really confused and I've checked that the review is hidden like 3 times and I do have it checked to "hide entire review because of spoilers" so I'm just putting this here, honestly this is probably the least spoiling review...if that makes sense. Sorry to anyone who's enjoyment of the book was ruined, just go find other reviews to read, nobody's perfect.

Also I changed some parts because, again, the review should be hidden but...yeah
Parts I change are lower case in the middle of the caps, it should be pretty obvious
*I hope I changed all the parts that people were upset about with spoilers and just let me know is anything else is a spoiler.

OMG I CANNOT BELIEVE all those people DIE!!!!!!!!!
AND the end with gale/petta thing
AND Katniss DOESN'T EVEN CARE what happened?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!
I MEAN AT FIRST I WAS A TOTAL TEAM GALE BUT THEN I WAS LIKE WELL PEETA IS OKISH I GUESS MAYBE BUT AS LONG AS GALE STILL HAS THAT SPECIAL BOND AND HES HER BEST FRIEND AND HES THE ONE SHE CONFIDES IN AND STUFF AND SHE LOVES HIM AS A FRIEND THAN OK FIND GO MARRY PEETA!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
CANNOT BELIEVE THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I AND DID SC HAVE TO KILL ALL THOSE PPL?????
AND WHAT HAPPENS TO HAYMITCH?
I WISH THEY HAD MORE OF HAYMITCH'S HUMOR
THIS BOOK NEEDED MORE HUMOR, MORE HAYMITCH
THE BOOK WAS STILL REALLY GOOD AND I REALLY LIKED THE PARTS WITH PREZ COIN AND PREZ SNOW AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
THE BOOK WAS DEFINITELY NOT THE BEST I'D SAY THE SERIES BOOKS GO LIKE THIS
gale might as well have died
i also wanted more finnick and annie

1.)Catching Fire
2.)The Hunger Games
3.)Mockingjay

if u read this sorry about all the caps

UPDATE
ok so first yeah sorry again for my caps lock but I don't think I should change it as it reminds me how strong my feelings were then I guess so i don't hate Peeta now. But yeah no favoritism here haha
So Katniss as a mother was... strange, weird, it felt wrong
the whole voice and feel of the ending where katniss is talking and says "the girl knows" it just felt awkward with Katniss as a mom and since it was 1st person she also sounded so disconnected (as Hannah commented below Katniss sounded lifeless and I agree) like she didnt even bother to call her kids by their names just "the girl" I still need 2 get used to it
and wow i said like a lot ...more

flag 168 likes · Like · see review

Feb 02, 2010 Baine rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: favorites, books-i-own

"THERE IS NO DISTRICT 12."
Period. End of sentence. End of story. Biggest. Cliffhanger. Ever.
Oh. my. gosh.

I CANNOT WAIT!!! August 24... Someone could tell me the world was ending August 23rd and i'd say, no it isn't! Mockingjay isn't out yet, stupid! The world can't end! What about August 25th? Hah! well i'll have red it by then, so im good.

Was it just me or did everyone else frantically flip the pages after finishing Catching Fire? I was like,
NOOOO! That cannot be how she ended it! DANG that ...more

flag 150 likes · Like · see review

Feb 12, 2010 Penny rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: dystopian, grrrl-power, penny-s-favorite-books, starcrossed-lovers, ya-fiction, reviewed-books

Updated! November 25, 2014 New 2nd addendum below the 1st addendum. Further thoughts/explanations as to why I gave this book five stars at the end of the original review. Warning: addendum contains some spoilers.

I've thought long and hard as to how I should review this book. For starters I feel I need to say upfront, this book is not for everyone. Mockingjay is the darkest book of the Hunger Games trilogy, containing excess violence, brutality and ugliness. People die. It would be naive to ...more

flag 148 likes · Like · see review

Apr 02, 2015 Kai rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: finished-series, owned

One taught me pain

flag 137 likes · Like · see review

Jun 21, 2017 Khurram rated it really liked it · review of another edition

This book is a page turner; the revolution is in full swing. Katniss must accept the responsibility of becoming the Mockingjay the symbol of the revelation. The main problem I have with this book is similar to the first book many of the battle scenes do not make sense to me, they are as confused as Katniss' mental state. As interesting as the book was to read I just could not give it 5 stars simply for the confusion of so many of the scenes. Other thing that do not make sense is the rebels are ...more

flag 137 likes · Like · see review

Jan 20, 2010 ★ Jess rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Recommends it for: Fans of 'The Hunger Games' and 'Catching Fire'

Shelves: books-i-own, read-in-2010, dearest-old-favourites, 4-stars-loved-it, read-in-2012

Spoilers.

When I first read 'Mockingjay' I was a silly little fourteen year old, drunk up on the fast paced action and immediate danger Katniss faced in the first two novels. Given her weakness and exclusion from important events, not to mention my almost 12 month wait for its release, I was bitterly disappointed.

Perhaps, reading now, I appreciate Mockingjay more because of my lower expectations. Perhaps it is because I can look at it in a new light. Perhaps its both.
I will not delete my ...more

flag 135 likes · Like · see review

Jul 09, 2012 Maureen rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

This series will never get old for me - it's fantastic.
I like the ending a lot better after rereading it I have to say!

flag 133 likes · Like · see review

Feb 11, 2010 Amelia, the pragmatic idealist rated it it was ok · review of another edition

Shelves: 2010, dystopian, series-books, annoying-characters, ya-kids-teen, point-of-view-girl, just-the-worst

2013 edit: Time can do a lot to influence my opinion of books. In some cases, time goes on and I end up appreciating a book more than I did originally, like Ender's Game or The Great Gatsby. But in other cases, time actually diminishes my opinion of certain books.
I'm so sick of all this HG-movie hype. Seriously. Ms. Collins' novels were thought-provoking, but not *that* much. I'm left to wonder if I read the same books as everyone else. Collins' writing style doesn't have that much depth. And I ...more

flag 131 likes · Like · see review

Dec 04, 2009 Arlene rated it it was amazing · review of another edition

Shelves: dystopic, young-adult, read-2010, ya-dystopic, favorites

There is so much I love and despise about this book and my brain is still in a mindfog trying to sort out some of the catastrofuck that just occurred. But first and foremost I must say… hats off to Suzanne Collins for penning an epic finale of courageous and daring proportions!! Wow she really spared no expense in ending The Hunger Games series with a final installment that will leave a lasting impression! Collins is without a doubt FEARLESS.

I am still in complete and absolute shock as I There is so much I love and despise about this book and my brain is still in a mindfog trying to sort out some of the catastrofuck that just occurred. But first and foremost I must say… hats off to Suzanne Collins for penning an epic finale of courageous and daring proportions!! Wow she really spared no expense in ending The Hunger Games series with a final installment that will leave a lasting impression! Collins is without a doubt FEARLESS.

I am still in complete and absolute shock as I contemplate the events I never imagined would occur actually took place in this book; characters I never fathomed would be sacrificed, found their final chapters in this installment; and paths I took for granted would be avoided were actually taken. As I read chapter after chapter, I quickly realized that I should give up trying to anticipate Collins' next moves and just expect the unexpected. Collins demonstrated time and time again that she owned this story, and she was not going to compromise her ending with unicorns and rainbows. It was truly out of control at every turn but perfectly executed!!

In this final installment of Mockingjay, the most deadly and costly games are launched as the district rebels and the Capitol fight to the bloody finish for power over Panem. Katniss Everdeen continues to be the pawn, but as the games unravel, it’s never quite clear what side she should be playing for and who she should trust. Gale, her lifetime friend, continually makes moves that in the end cost Katniss dearly. Peeta, the person that put his life on the line for her time and time again, becomes a weapon in the games putting her at risk as she fights to survive this deadly powerplay.

I had so many favorite characters in this book, but as soon as I let my guard down, they were pulled from my grasp and ripped to shreds. In the end, I feared caring too deeply for any of them and found I began distancing myself emotionally from the story. It was such a psychological ride that I felt completely spent in the end.

There were so many endearing moments in this book, such as Katniss’s Crazy Cat game, the moment she realized she needed Haymitch emotionally and he wrapped his arms around her, her revealing moment that Prim was no longer the little sister with the ducktail she need to tuck and protect, and her real or not real response to Peeta’s final question.

I loved Finnick Odair in this book and his back-story broke my heart. His reunion with the one person he loved was heart rending and that’s not all, but you’ll have to read to find out more about this hidden gem of a character that I never anticipated would surface at this final hour.

This book ends with a dark and painful journey for Katniss and I found myself struggling with what she was going through as a result of her involvement in the revolution. There were moments that I wanted to give up right along side with her, and as I was nearing the end of the story, I couldn’t fathom a resolution I felt she deserved. And, I'm still questioning whether she got it...

There is so much more I want to say about this book, but as I said, I’m spent! ...more

flag 129 likes · Like · see review

Jun 09, 2013 Ahmad Sharabiani rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: science, fiction, romance, 21th-century, young-adult, fantasy

Mockingjay (The Hunger Games #3), Suzanne Collins
Mockingjay is a 2010 science fiction novel by American author Suzanne Collins. After the events of Catching Fire, Katniss Everdeen, her mother, her sister Primrose Everdeen, mentor Haymitch Abernathy, and her friends Finnick Odair and Gale Hawthorne, along with the survivors from District 12, adjust to life in the underground District 13, headquarters of the rebellion in Panem. Katniss reluctantly agrees to act as "the Mockingjay”–the symbol of Mockingjay (The Hunger Games #3), Suzanne Collins
Mockingjay is a 2010 science fiction novel by American author Suzanne Collins. After the events of Catching Fire, Katniss Everdeen, her mother, her sister Primrose Everdeen, mentor Haymitch Abernathy, and her friends Finnick Odair and Gale Hawthorne, along with the survivors from District 12, adjust to life in the underground District 13, headquarters of the rebellion in Panem. Katniss reluctantly agrees to act as "the Mockingjay”–the symbol of the rebellion–for rebel propaganda, on the condition that District 13 President Alma Coin grant immunity to all surviving Hunger Games tributes, including Katniss' friend Peeta Mellark and Finnick's lover Annie Cresta. Coin, however, insists on flipping for Katniss's other demand: the right to personally execute Panem President Coriolanus Snow. Peeta is tortured by the Capitol to demoralize Katniss. A rescue team extracts Peeta along with the other captured victors, but discover that he has been brainwashed to fear and despise Katniss. He attempts to kill her, and is restrained under heavy guard while medics seek a cure. Finnick and Annie marry in a propaganda effort. Katniss and Gale are sent to persuade District 2 to join the rebellion. Gale’s controversial strategy results in a decisive victory over District 2, enabling a final assault against the Capitol itself. Katniss is assigned to a squad and sent with a film crew to shoot propaganda. President Coin also sends Peeta, still dangerous and unpredictable; Katniss suspects Coin wants her dead for her lack of support and growing influence. While filming in a supposedly safe Capitol neighborhood, the team's commander Boggs is fatally wounded; before dying, he gives Katniss the team’s command. She decides to infiltrate the Capitol and kill Snow, telling her team that this was Coin's secret plan; she later reveals the lie, but the team sticks with her. In the ensuing urban warfare, many of Katniss's comrades, including Finnick, are killed. As the last of her squad reaches Snow's mansion, a hoverplane bearing the Capitol seal drops bombs among a group of children being used as human shields. Rebel medics, including Prim, rush in to help the injured children, and the remaining bombs detonate. Prim is killed, and Katniss sustains severe burns.

تاریخ نخستین خوانش: روز دهم ماه می سال 2014 میلادی
عنوان: زاغ مقلد - عطش مبارزه جلد سوم؛ نویسنده: سوزان کالینز؛ مترجم: شبنم سعادت؛ تهران، افراز، 1392، در 407 ص؛ موضوع: داستانهای نویسندگان امریکایی - سده 21 م

هشدار: اگر هنوز این کتاب را نخوانده اید، و میخواهید خود آن را بخوانید، از خوانش این نگاره خودداری کنید، ؛
در کتاب سوم «کتنیس» به همراه خواهرش «پرایم» و دوستانش، «فینیک» و «گِیل»، در تأسیسات زیرزمینی منطقه ی سیزده، به سر می‌برند، که به شدت توسط شورشیان علیه پانم سازمان‌دهی شده‌ است. سرانجام «کتنیس» می‌پذیرد، که به عنوان «زاغ مقلد»، به نماد شورش بدل شود، به این شرط که رئیس‌جمهور «کُوین»، به همگی پیش‌کش‌های بازمانده، و همچنین به «پیتا ملارک (دوست کتنیس)»، و «آنی کریستا (معشوقه ی فینیک)»، ایمنی دهد. «کتنیس» و شورشیان، می‌دانستند «پیتا» زنده است، هرچند توسط کاپیتول شکنجه می‌شود، که با اینکار «کتنیس» را کنترل کند. هنگامی که «کتنیس» موفق به فرار شد، «پیتا» در «آرنا» ماند، و رژیم کاپیتول او را شستشوی مغزی داد، تا با انجام کارهایی برنامه‌ ریزی‌ شده، ترس و نومیدی را در «کتنیس» افزایش دهد. در یک عملیات نجات، نیروهای منطقه ی سیزده موفق می‌شوند، «پیتا» را نجات دهند، اما او اقدام به قتل «کتنیس» می‌کند، و پس از آن از او، با تزریق آرام‌بخش نگهداری می‌کنند. با پیشنهاد یک استراتژی بحث‌ برانگیز توسط «گیل»، پیروزی قاطعی در منطقه ی دو، به وجود می‌آید، و باعث می‌شود، شورشیان یورش پایانی خود، به سوی کاپیتول را آغاز کنند. «کتنیس» هم، به همراه یک تیم فیلم‌برداری، و نگهبان، به نواحی نسبتاً آرام‌تر جبهه، اعزام می‌شود، تا فیلمی تبلیغاتی بسازد. رئیس‌ جمهور «کوین» اجازه می‌دهد، «پیتا» هم در این سفر، او را همراهی کند، هرچند او هنوز خطرناک، و غیرقابل پیش‌بینی است. «کتنیس» به رئیس‌جمهور «کوین» شک دارد؛ او با نفوذ بیش از اندازه و هواداران بسیاری که «کوین» دارد، حمایتی از ادامه ی ریاست خویش نشان نداده‌ است. در حالیکه آن‌ها در یک محله ی ظاهراً پاکسازی شده، به سر می‌بردند، «باگز (فرماندهٔ تیم)»، در اثر موانعی که کاپیتولی‌ها، پیش از خروجشان، در ویرانه‌ ها کار گذاشته‌ اند، کشته می‌شود. پیش از مرگ، او مسئولیت گروه را، بر عهده ی «کتنیس» می‌گذارد. «کتنیس» در اینجا تصمیم می‌گیرد، شخصاً به کاپیتول رفته، و رئیس‌ جمهور «اسنو (رهبر دیکتاتور کاپیتول)» را بکشد، و تیم او هم به دنبالش می‌روند. در جنگ شدید شهری، بیشتر رفقای «کتنیس»، از جمله «فینیک»، کشته می‌شوند. هنگامیکه او به عمارت «اسنو» می‌رسد، یک هواپیما، بمب‌هایی را با چتر، در میان گروهی از کودکان کاپیتولی، که به عنوان سپر انسانی، در اطراف عمارت بودند، پرتاب می‌کند، و برخی از بمب‌ها منفجر می‌شوند. نیروهای امداد شورشیان (از جمله پرایم، خواهر کتنیس)، برای یاری به کودکان آسیب‌ دیده، با عجله وارد معرکه می‌شوند، اما اینبار بقیه بمب‌ها با تأخیر منفجر شده، و تلفات سنگینی به امدادگران می‌زند. «پرایم» کشته می‌شود، و «کتنیس»، با سوختگی شدید، جان سالم به‌ در می‌برد، اما شورشیان موفق به فتح کاپیتول می‌شوند. «کتنیس» در دوره ی بهبودی خود، عمیقاً از مرگ خواهرش در رنج است. او به دیدن «اسنو»، که حالا زندانی شده، می‌رود. «اسنو» ادعا می‌کند، که «کوین»، مسئول بمباران اخیر بوده، و چنین استدلال می‌کند، که «کوین» با اینکار، قصد داشت واپسین حامیان دیکتاتوری کاپیتول را، یکجا به قتل برساند، و «اسنو» می‌گوید، که در قبال شرط مصونیت خود، این بمباران را پذیرفت، و انجام داد. «کتنیس» وحشت‌زده می‌شود؛ او متوجه می‌شود، که خواهرش در عملیاتی کشته شده، که در آن از تاکتیک پیشنهادی «گیل» استفاده کرده‌ اند، هرچند اینبار، برای یک هدف غیرنظامی. «کتنیس» در مورد دخالت احتمالی «گیل»، از او پرسش می‌کند، ولی او ظاهراً چیزی نمی‌داند. «کتنیس» به این نتیجه می‌رسد، که «کوین» قصد دارد، تحت نام جمهوری، به جایگاه سابق «اسنو» دست یابد، و وضعیت پیشین را حفظ کند. در روزی که قرار است «اسنو» اعدام شود، «کوین» که حالا رئیس‌جمهور موقت است، از پیشکش‌های باقیمانده می‌پرسد، که نظرشان درباره ی برگزاری دوره‌ ای جدید، از بازی‌های گرسنگی، با شرکت فرزندان رهبران پیشین کاپیتول چیست. «بیتی»، «آنی» و «پیتا» رای مخالف می‌دهند، در حالیکه «یوحانا» و «انوباریا» رأیشان مثبت است. «کتنیس» پس از آن‌ها می‌گوید: «به خاطر پرایم، بله.» «هِیمیچ» هم می‌گوید: «من با زاغ مقلد هستم.» هنگامی که «کتنیس» برای اجرای حکم اعدام «اسنو» آماده می‌شود، او چلّه ی کمان را به سوی سینه‌ اش می‌کشد، تا نشان دهد قصد کشتن «اسنو» را دارد، اما در لحظه ی آخر می‌چرخید، و تیر را به سمت «کوین» پرتاب می‌کند. او بلافاصله پس از کشتن «کوین»، اقدام به خودکشی می‌کند، اما «پیتا» جلوی او را می‌گیرد. «کتنیس» را دستگیر می‌کنند، و تا پایان شورش‌های آتی، در زندان نگاه می‌دارند. در پایان این قضایا، «اسن»و دیگر مُرده است. «کتنیس» به دلیل جنون، از مجازات مرگ می‌گریزد، و او را به منطقه ی دوازده می‌فرستند. ماه‌ها بعد، «پیتا» و برخی دیگر از بومیان پیشین منطقه ی دوازده، به آنجا بازمی‌گردند. «پیتا» به تدریج خاطرات عشقش به «کتنیس» را بازیابی می‌کند. این دو با یکدیگر کتاب خاطراتی درباره ی آنچه رخ داده می‌نویسند. «پیتا» همچنان گاهی به خاطر شستشوی مغزی، میان حقیقت و دروغ فریفته می‌شود، و «کتنیس» هم هنوز در خواب، در اثر دیدن کابوس، فریاد می‌کشد. بیست سال پس از آن رویدادها، «کتنیس» و «پیتا»، دو فرزند به دنیا می‌آورند. «کتنیس» نگران روزی است، که بچه‌ ها در مورد دخالت والدینشان در بازی‌ها و جنگ بپرسند، و کوشش می‌کند، با تلقین چیزهای خوب به خودش، از این اضطراب بکاهد. نهایتاً کتاب با این جمله از «کتنیس» به پایان می‌رسد: «…اما بازی‌های بسیار بدتر از این هم وجود دارند.» ا. شربیانی ...more

flag 119 likes · Like · see review

Feb 05, 2011 Emily May rated it really liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: 2011, young-adult, dystopia-utopia

4.5 stars

flag 108 likes · Like · see review

topics	posts	views	last activity
When in the books do you think Katniss realized her love for Peeta?	28	813	Dec 12, 2019 07:00AM
YA Buddy Readers'...: Mockingjay (The Hunger Games #3) by Suzanne Collins - Restarting December 12th 2019	181	295	Dec 12, 2019 05:21AM
What made you cry?	94	411	Nov 04, 2019 07:27PM
Mocking Jay Part 1	1	1	Oct 31, 2019 09:35AM
Mockingjay	1	1	Oct 29, 2019 07:15PM
Most upsetting death in The Hunger Games trilogy?	129	997	Oct 25, 2019 01:35PM
Question	2	39	Oct 07, 2019 09:25AM

See a Problem?

Preview — A Revolta by Suzanne Collins

A Revolta

(The Hunger Games #3)

Get A Copy

Friend Reviews

Reader Q&A

Lists with This Book

Community Reviews

new topic
Discuss This Book

Readers also enjoyed

Videos About This Book

Genres

About Suzanne Collins

Other books in the series

Books by Suzanne Collins

Trivia About Mockingjay (The H...

Quotes from A Esperança