What do you think?
Rate this book
Bring the Jubilee
Newly arrived from the sticks, Hodge Backmaker picks up an education as apprentice to a cynical printer who supports the underground "Grand Army" (the North hopes to rise again). Eventually our hero, a self-taught historian, joins an eccentric community of scholars & has a turbulent affair with a brilliant female physicist working on the mysteries of Time. She offers Hodge his big research opportunity: to visit 1863 & study the Battle of Gettysburg from a safe vantage. Fortunately or tragically, the place he chooses is rather crucial...
222 pages, Mass Market Paperback
First published January 1, 1953
158 people are currently reading
6012 people want to read
About the author
Ward Moore
75 books38 followersJoseph Ward Moore was born in Madison, New Jersey and raised in Montreal and New York City.
His first novel was published in 1942 and included some autobiographical elements. He wrote not only books but reviews and articles for magazines and newspapers.
In early 50s, he became book review editor of Frontier and started to write regularly for The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction. His most famous novel was Bring the Jubilee (1953), and his other works include Greener Than You Think (1947) and the post-apocalyptic short stories "Lot" (1953) and "Lot's Daughter" (1954).
His first novel was published in 1942 and included some autobiographical elements. He wrote not only books but reviews and articles for magazines and newspapers.
In early 50s, he became book review editor of Frontier and started to write regularly for The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction. His most famous novel was Bring the Jubilee (1953), and his other works include Greener Than You Think (1947) and the post-apocalyptic short stories "Lot" (1953) and "Lot's Daughter" (1954).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 273 reviews
April 3, 2017
Bring The Jubilee is about, well... imagine that the Confederacy won the American Civil War and… hey! Why are you backing away? Wait! I promise not to talk about McClellan and the Army of the Potomac! Trust me - this is a good book!
OK, for those of you who are still reading this review, I don’t blame you if you are put off by the Southern civil war victory that underpins the setting of Ward Moore’s book. In the age of Trump the nasty debates going on around flying confederate flags, the resurgence of certain racist groups and the ongoing culture wars can make a reader suspicious that a book like Bring The Jubilee is an attempt to hit them with a musket volley of partisan historical revisionism.
However, Moore's book is nothing of this sort. It’s a thoughtful, interesting take on the influence of the US Civil War and how things may have turned out differently. This isn't some hack-y what-if dime novel of the sort that drags you through a bunch of over-done civil war battles with the stars-and-bars flying proudly over the brave and chivalrous men of the righteous South as they fight the imperialistic Yankees. The world the narrator lives in - the remaining rump of the Northern states in the 1930s to 50s - is far removed from Gettysburg, and the world that Southern victory has created is a grim and troubled one.
Moore's novel, written in 1953, is a slow but compelling story centered on one unlikely protagonist – Hodgins Backmaker. Hodge has grown up in the defeated North, a country crippled by war reparations to the South, it's economy in ruins, its commercial life near non-existent. Indentured servitude is a common voluntary option for desperate citizens, and race relations are dire; African Americans are hated and driven overseas, blamed for the North's loss, while Asian Americans are near nonexistent after anti-Chinese pogroms in the late 19th century. Technology has stagnated to some degree without the dynamism and power of a unified USA - people in the 1930s and 40s have telegraphs to their homes and communicate via Morse code, and without Henry Ford's innovations cars are rare and expensive.
The Confederacy is a powerful empire, ruling Mexico, whose people it treats as subjects rather than citizens, and exerting great influence over its impoverished northern neighbor. The Southern victory in the war is seen by many as being inevitable in retrospect, much the same way as Northern victory is regarded today.
Hodge, who intriguingly notes at the book's beginning that he is writing his story in 1877, decades before his own birth, grows up in a small, hardscrabble town where his bookish nature makes him an outsider. When he comes of age he abandons his life and travels to a greatly diminished 1930s New York, still lit by gaslight and only populated by a million people, beginning a journey that takes the reader through a very different and much more difficult world than the one we know.
Hodge is a fairly passive character, a natural observer and a lens for us to view his world through. His journey eventually sees him becoming an historian and discovering a place filled with like-minded people, an escape from the grinding pressure of life in a failing US that no longer values intellectuals or pursuits of the mind (This sounded familiar to me- Moore may have inadvertently predicted this particular cultural shift, but located it several decades too early). It is here that he finally moves towards becoming a participant, rather than an observer, a shift that has calamitous personal consequences.
Bring The Jubilee is an entertaining read. It's a tour through a sad and brutal alternate world that I found quite convincing. Moore doesn't weigh his book down with too many what-ifs, or descriptions of battles, focusing instead on what life is like seventy years after the Civil War. Things get a little bit unlikely with Hodge’s (very much foreshadowed) time-travel towards the end of the story, but I enjoyed his journey nonetheless. The story overall is fairly sedate, but I found the setting quite compelling, and the pages turned easily and quickly. Moore writes well, and the world he created in Bring the Jubilee is one that I’m glad to have visited, despite being grateful that it never came to be.
OK, for those of you who are still reading this review, I don’t blame you if you are put off by the Southern civil war victory that underpins the setting of Ward Moore’s book. In the age of Trump the nasty debates going on around flying confederate flags, the resurgence of certain racist groups and the ongoing culture wars can make a reader suspicious that a book like Bring The Jubilee is an attempt to hit them with a musket volley of partisan historical revisionism.
However, Moore's book is nothing of this sort. It’s a thoughtful, interesting take on the influence of the US Civil War and how things may have turned out differently. This isn't some hack-y what-if dime novel of the sort that drags you through a bunch of over-done civil war battles with the stars-and-bars flying proudly over the brave and chivalrous men of the righteous South as they fight the imperialistic Yankees. The world the narrator lives in - the remaining rump of the Northern states in the 1930s to 50s - is far removed from Gettysburg, and the world that Southern victory has created is a grim and troubled one.
Moore's novel, written in 1953, is a slow but compelling story centered on one unlikely protagonist – Hodgins Backmaker. Hodge has grown up in the defeated North, a country crippled by war reparations to the South, it's economy in ruins, its commercial life near non-existent. Indentured servitude is a common voluntary option for desperate citizens, and race relations are dire; African Americans are hated and driven overseas, blamed for the North's loss, while Asian Americans are near nonexistent after anti-Chinese pogroms in the late 19th century. Technology has stagnated to some degree without the dynamism and power of a unified USA - people in the 1930s and 40s have telegraphs to their homes and communicate via Morse code, and without Henry Ford's innovations cars are rare and expensive.
The Confederacy is a powerful empire, ruling Mexico, whose people it treats as subjects rather than citizens, and exerting great influence over its impoverished northern neighbor. The Southern victory in the war is seen by many as being inevitable in retrospect, much the same way as Northern victory is regarded today.
Hodge, who intriguingly notes at the book's beginning that he is writing his story in 1877, decades before his own birth, grows up in a small, hardscrabble town where his bookish nature makes him an outsider. When he comes of age he abandons his life and travels to a greatly diminished 1930s New York, still lit by gaslight and only populated by a million people, beginning a journey that takes the reader through a very different and much more difficult world than the one we know.
Hodge is a fairly passive character, a natural observer and a lens for us to view his world through. His journey eventually sees him becoming an historian and discovering a place filled with like-minded people, an escape from the grinding pressure of life in a failing US that no longer values intellectuals or pursuits of the mind (This sounded familiar to me- Moore may have inadvertently predicted this particular cultural shift, but located it several decades too early). It is here that he finally moves towards becoming a participant, rather than an observer, a shift that has calamitous personal consequences.
Bring The Jubilee is an entertaining read. It's a tour through a sad and brutal alternate world that I found quite convincing. Moore doesn't weigh his book down with too many what-ifs, or descriptions of battles, focusing instead on what life is like seventy years after the Civil War. Things get a little bit unlikely with Hodge’s (very much foreshadowed) time-travel towards the end of the story, but I enjoyed his journey nonetheless. The story overall is fairly sedate, but I found the setting quite compelling, and the pages turned easily and quickly. Moore writes well, and the world he created in Bring the Jubilee is one that I’m glad to have visited, despite being grateful that it never came to be.
July 7, 2010
5.0 stars. THE BEST ALTERNATIVE HISTORY/TIME TRAVEL STORY I HAVE EVER READ!!!! This book has been on my "to be read" pile for years and I did not have overly high expectations when I finally opened the book. Well, I was blown away by both the writing and the story.
In brief, the plot concerns an alternate history in which the South won the Battle of Gettysburg and, eventually, the Civil War. Thus the story takes place in a world where the Confederate States of America is a separate, prosperous country and the United States of Ameirca is a poor, declining one.
I was very impressed by Ward Moore's style of writing and I thought his characterization was superb. Reading the book was a pleasure and I was actually sorry when I came to the end as I wanted the story to continue. If you are a fan of alternative history (or just of fan of great stories) pick this book up. You will not be disappointed. HIGHEST POSSIBLE RECOMMENDATION!!!
In brief, the plot concerns an alternate history in which the South won the Battle of Gettysburg and, eventually, the Civil War. Thus the story takes place in a world where the Confederate States of America is a separate, prosperous country and the United States of Ameirca is a poor, declining one.
I was very impressed by Ward Moore's style of writing and I thought his characterization was superb. Reading the book was a pleasure and I was actually sorry when I came to the end as I wanted the story to continue. If you are a fan of alternative history (or just of fan of great stories) pick this book up. You will not be disappointed. HIGHEST POSSIBLE RECOMMENDATION!!!
November 26, 2022
Here's a book that shouldn't be forgotten. Especially for fans of Connie Willis or Jodi Taylor, fans of historians going back in time because -- COME ON, WHAT HISTORIAN WOULDN'T WANT TO GO BACK IN TIME?
More importantly, the time this came out in the early 1950's should be an interesting fact. The kinds of time travel that had come out before were more adventure and less introspective. This one is very introspective. It's also very imaginative, rather dystopian, carefully philosophical and skeptical, and massively bookish. The main character is a serious observer and reader, and this is great because most of the book takes place in a world where the South won the Civil War.
The world is very different. Darker, rather horrible. And yet, intellectuals and skeptics do tend to find their way, even if it is in poverty and uneasy circumstances.
I'll say this for certain: this is one of the best great-grandaddy of all alternate timeline books. It's not an adventure. It's a philosophical discussion and an ultimate show/don't tell careful exploration of what might have been.
I'm very impressed.
More importantly, the time this came out in the early 1950's should be an interesting fact. The kinds of time travel that had come out before were more adventure and less introspective. This one is very introspective. It's also very imaginative, rather dystopian, carefully philosophical and skeptical, and massively bookish. The main character is a serious observer and reader, and this is great because most of the book takes place in a world where the South won the Civil War.
The world is very different. Darker, rather horrible. And yet, intellectuals and skeptics do tend to find their way, even if it is in poverty and uneasy circumstances.
I'll say this for certain: this is one of the best great-grandaddy of all alternate timeline books. It's not an adventure. It's a philosophical discussion and an ultimate show/don't tell careful exploration of what might have been.
I'm very impressed.
May 9, 2015
Bring the Jubilee: A brilliant alternative history where the South prevailed
Originally posted at Fantasy Literature
Bring the Jubilee is a fairly obscure alternate-history story published in 1953 in which the South won the "War for Southron Independence". In this world, Robert E. Lee succeeds Jefferson Davis as the second president of the Confederacy in 1865. The Confederacy steadily expands its empire through Mexico and South America. Its chief rival is the German Union, which splits control of Europe with the Spanish Empire. In response, the Confederacy has allied with Great Britain, creating two opposing empires that straddle the Atlantic.
Strangely enough, slavery was abolished but minorities continue to face persecution, and poverty is rampant in the United States, the former Union states of the North. Other than a rich landowner minority, most people are indentured to their owners, effectively a form or slavery. In addition, the combustible engine, light bulb, and aircraft were never invented, instead they have steam-powered minibiles (the equivalent of cars) and dirigibles, so horses or trains are still regularly used for transportation. The telephone was also not invented, so the telegraph is the main means of communication.
The main character is a directionless youth named Hodge Backmaker who leaves his impoverished life in the countryside of Wappinger Falls, Pennsylvania to move to New York, one of the few cities in the North to still thrive in a North America dominated by the Southron Confederate States. He comes to NY eager to get into a university, only to immediately be robbed of his possessions. Though great luck he manages to find work at a bookshop, reading almost constantly to educate himself. He develops a close relationship with the proprietor, who turns out to be in league with the Grand Army, a subversive organization devoted to restoring the United States to its former greatness.
The story then takes a sudden turn, as Hodges decides to leave NY and join a small progressive intellectual co-op in rural Pennsylvania. He pursues his dream of becoming a historian dedicated to studying the war between the North and South, gets involved in a love triangle, and then encounters a device that could help him very directly in his research, with totally unexpected consequences…
The story is extremely well-written, informed by the initially ignorant but intellectually-hungry mind of Hodge. His desire to pursue pure knowledge for its own sake in a poor, downtrodden North that has been left to decay after losing the war, and where blacks, Asians, Jews and other races are treated cruelly and with contempt, is not what you would expect of an alternate history tale centered around the Civil War.
I wouldn't even have known about this book if it weren't featured in David Pringle's Science Fiction: The 100 Best Novels and I'm glad I read it. It presents so many brilliant little details of his alternate world, but the main story revolves around the life and thoughts of the main character, so that I often felt prevented from seeing the bigger picture of his alternate world, and despite the depth of characterization, this book could have been longer and more complex, taking more time to explore his concept, and most likely have made a greater impact in the SF field. If he was writing today, I think it would have been just the first book in a long and successful series. As it is, it's a "minor" classic that few people have read, and I’d like to change that.
Originally posted at Fantasy Literature
Bring the Jubilee is a fairly obscure alternate-history story published in 1953 in which the South won the "War for Southron Independence". In this world, Robert E. Lee succeeds Jefferson Davis as the second president of the Confederacy in 1865. The Confederacy steadily expands its empire through Mexico and South America. Its chief rival is the German Union, which splits control of Europe with the Spanish Empire. In response, the Confederacy has allied with Great Britain, creating two opposing empires that straddle the Atlantic.
Strangely enough, slavery was abolished but minorities continue to face persecution, and poverty is rampant in the United States, the former Union states of the North. Other than a rich landowner minority, most people are indentured to their owners, effectively a form or slavery. In addition, the combustible engine, light bulb, and aircraft were never invented, instead they have steam-powered minibiles (the equivalent of cars) and dirigibles, so horses or trains are still regularly used for transportation. The telephone was also not invented, so the telegraph is the main means of communication.
The main character is a directionless youth named Hodge Backmaker who leaves his impoverished life in the countryside of Wappinger Falls, Pennsylvania to move to New York, one of the few cities in the North to still thrive in a North America dominated by the Southron Confederate States. He comes to NY eager to get into a university, only to immediately be robbed of his possessions. Though great luck he manages to find work at a bookshop, reading almost constantly to educate himself. He develops a close relationship with the proprietor, who turns out to be in league with the Grand Army, a subversive organization devoted to restoring the United States to its former greatness.
The story then takes a sudden turn, as Hodges decides to leave NY and join a small progressive intellectual co-op in rural Pennsylvania. He pursues his dream of becoming a historian dedicated to studying the war between the North and South, gets involved in a love triangle, and then encounters a device that could help him very directly in his research, with totally unexpected consequences…
The story is extremely well-written, informed by the initially ignorant but intellectually-hungry mind of Hodge. His desire to pursue pure knowledge for its own sake in a poor, downtrodden North that has been left to decay after losing the war, and where blacks, Asians, Jews and other races are treated cruelly and with contempt, is not what you would expect of an alternate history tale centered around the Civil War.
I wouldn't even have known about this book if it weren't featured in David Pringle's Science Fiction: The 100 Best Novels and I'm glad I read it. It presents so many brilliant little details of his alternate world, but the main story revolves around the life and thoughts of the main character, so that I often felt prevented from seeing the bigger picture of his alternate world, and despite the depth of characterization, this book could have been longer and more complex, taking more time to explore his concept, and most likely have made a greater impact in the SF field. If he was writing today, I think it would have been just the first book in a long and successful series. As it is, it's a "minor" classic that few people have read, and I’d like to change that.
September 14, 2013
An interesting novel based on the idea and in the world where the South won the American Civil War and how America would look and how this affects the rest of the world.
September 28, 2009
What a wonderful surprise this was. Ok, my expectations should have been high starting another book in the SF Masterworks series but I hadn't heard much talk of this author and wasn't overly bowled over by the premise. This is an alternative history story, what might have happened if the south had won the American civil war.
The speculations are themselves quite interesting, The American north becoming impoverished and backward, allowing the European colonial powers to carry on dominating the world stage for longer, the Confederate south becoming powerful, conquering Mexico. Also of interest are the different technological paths that are explored leaving the world (in 1952) without aeroplanes, cars and electricity but far more developed in other ways such as in hot air balloons and gas utilisation.
More interesting though is the story of the central character Hodge. A natural book-worm and academic who grows up in a world that has no place for such impractical people. At first he merely wants to read and learn about the world, to take no active part in its affairs, nor take sides with those political and agitating forces mobilising around him. Can he merely observe and chronicle or is inaction itself just another form of action, a choice that may shape events one way or another? And does he really have a choice or is freedom itself merely an illusion?
A superbly written tale with well drawn characters and a pleasing narrative style. Now I can't wait to check out what else this author has to offer.
The speculations are themselves quite interesting, The American north becoming impoverished and backward, allowing the European colonial powers to carry on dominating the world stage for longer, the Confederate south becoming powerful, conquering Mexico. Also of interest are the different technological paths that are explored leaving the world (in 1952) without aeroplanes, cars and electricity but far more developed in other ways such as in hot air balloons and gas utilisation.
More interesting though is the story of the central character Hodge. A natural book-worm and academic who grows up in a world that has no place for such impractical people. At first he merely wants to read and learn about the world, to take no active part in its affairs, nor take sides with those political and agitating forces mobilising around him. Can he merely observe and chronicle or is inaction itself just another form of action, a choice that may shape events one way or another? And does he really have a choice or is freedom itself merely an illusion?
A superbly written tale with well drawn characters and a pleasing narrative style. Now I can't wait to check out what else this author has to offer.
July 6, 2017
Not quite 4 stars. Lots of philosophical discussion....predetermination versus free will....passive versus active participant. The South has won the Civil War. What is left of the North becomes what we would call today a third world country. Not only is this an alternate history novel, but it is also a time travel novel.
May 22, 2015
Ward Moore’s Bring the Jubilee is a fairly obscure alternate-history story published in 1953 in which the South won the "War for Southron Independence." In this world, Robert E. Lee succeeds Jefferson Davis as the second president of the Confederacy in 1865. The Confederacy steadily expands its empire through Mexico and South America. Its chief rival is the German Union, which splits control of Europe with the Spanish Empire. In response, the Confederacy has allied with Great Britain, creating two opposing empires that straddle the Atlantic.
Strangely enough, slavery was abolished but minorities continue to face persecution, and poverty is rampant in the United States, the former Union states of the North. Other than a rich landowner minority, most people are indentured to their owners, effectively a form of slavery. In addition, the combustible engine, l... Read More: http://www.fantasyliterature.com/revi...
Strangely enough, slavery was abolished but minorities continue to face persecution, and poverty is rampant in the United States, the former Union states of the North. Other than a rich landowner minority, most people are indentured to their owners, effectively a form of slavery. In addition, the combustible engine, l... Read More: http://www.fantasyliterature.com/revi...
July 23, 2025
Check out my full, spoiler free, video review HERE.
This is an alternate history, science fiction novel, where the Confederate South won the Civil War. Most of the novel takes place 80+ years after the war, so we can see some of the long-term effects this has had on the US as well as the rest of the world. There is excellent world building throughout the novel that seems well thought out. Besides all that, there is also a great coming of age story of our main character as he tries to find his way in this depressed world as well as some time travel elements. This is the best alternate history novel I’ve read, and I highly recommend it.
This is an alternate history, science fiction novel, where the Confederate South won the Civil War. Most of the novel takes place 80+ years after the war, so we can see some of the long-term effects this has had on the US as well as the rest of the world. There is excellent world building throughout the novel that seems well thought out. Besides all that, there is also a great coming of age story of our main character as he tries to find his way in this depressed world as well as some time travel elements. This is the best alternate history novel I’ve read, and I highly recommend it.
February 13, 2012
I read this years ago, when I devoured the whole corpus of SF. I enjoyed it then, and when I picked it up again after decades on the shelf, I was surge I'd like it even more.
I now know a great deal more about America and I've been to Gettysburg. I'm not entirely sure that possessing Little Round Top would have swung the whole war, but it would certainly have changed the entire tone of the battle if Lee had secured it on the first day.
But we don't get there for a long while. Moore takes his time, setting the scene, filling in the history of the defeated North and giving us tantalising glimpses of affairs in the wider world. It's a hard life in what's left of the USA, and the penniless protagonist is lucky to find shelter and employment with an oddbod bookseller.
Drawn into shadowy affairs, things turn sticky, and has he really escaped to a better place when he falls in with some arcadian academics? There's sex and spice, history and conflict before the fateful trip into the past, to stand at a turning point in history.
I love time travel stories. Apart from the sense of anachronism - "Good morrow, milord, can'st inform me whereabouts of a batterymonger?" - there are all the delightful possibilities and paradoxes. What happens if you accidentally - or deliberately - kill your own ancestor? If you can change the past, will you also change the future, or is the universe self-repairing?
Moore sketches in the outlines of this puzzling world that is at once past and future. The 1930s as they never were. But might have been. And he gives us enough details to illustrate how odd it could have been. If the USA had not been a prosperous and inventive hub of industry during the latter Nineteenth and early Twentieth Centuries, what technologies might have gone undiscovered? No Henry Ford to bring motoring to the masses.
No Wright Brothers to bring us flight. No Edison, no Bell to harness electricity.
I'm reminded of Stephen King's recent expedition into time travel, where we find out what ramifications JFK had on the world. A single point in time where history teeters. A man in a Dallas warehouse, another in a peach orchard. Ordinary people in ordinary places, and yet the world forks.
This is one of the classics of science fiction and time travel. It is - paradoxically - timeless.
I now know a great deal more about America and I've been to Gettysburg. I'm not entirely sure that possessing Little Round Top would have swung the whole war, but it would certainly have changed the entire tone of the battle if Lee had secured it on the first day.
But we don't get there for a long while. Moore takes his time, setting the scene, filling in the history of the defeated North and giving us tantalising glimpses of affairs in the wider world. It's a hard life in what's left of the USA, and the penniless protagonist is lucky to find shelter and employment with an oddbod bookseller.
Drawn into shadowy affairs, things turn sticky, and has he really escaped to a better place when he falls in with some arcadian academics? There's sex and spice, history and conflict before the fateful trip into the past, to stand at a turning point in history.
I love time travel stories. Apart from the sense of anachronism - "Good morrow, milord, can'st inform me whereabouts of a batterymonger?" - there are all the delightful possibilities and paradoxes. What happens if you accidentally - or deliberately - kill your own ancestor? If you can change the past, will you also change the future, or is the universe self-repairing?
Moore sketches in the outlines of this puzzling world that is at once past and future. The 1930s as they never were. But might have been. And he gives us enough details to illustrate how odd it could have been. If the USA had not been a prosperous and inventive hub of industry during the latter Nineteenth and early Twentieth Centuries, what technologies might have gone undiscovered? No Henry Ford to bring motoring to the masses.
No Wright Brothers to bring us flight. No Edison, no Bell to harness electricity.
I'm reminded of Stephen King's recent expedition into time travel, where we find out what ramifications JFK had on the world. A single point in time where history teeters. A man in a Dallas warehouse, another in a peach orchard. Ordinary people in ordinary places, and yet the world forks.
This is one of the classics of science fiction and time travel. It is - paradoxically - timeless.
November 10, 2017
One of the first 'If south had won the war' novels, and still one of the best. The book has aged quite well, and it's still an engaging read. In this short novel you will find no decisive battle descriptions, no grand army movements, in fact, it's situated in time two generations after the 'War of southron independence', and is narrated by a historian.
This is definitely one of the most enjoyable books about alternate history I've ever read, and I wonder what took me so long.
This is definitely one of the most enjoyable books about alternate history I've ever read, and I wonder what took me so long.
May 5, 2017
Excellent Alternate History / Time travel short story.
December 31, 2014
This book is quite good. While it is dated and the characters are rather flat, the setting was just awesome. Granted, I don’t really believe the Northern states would have been the ones suffering had the South separated – the North had far more industrialization and most trade ports; the South only had a few major exports and a lower population. And had they continued with slavery, major trade countries such as a Britain would have eventually stopped trading with them entirely. The North also borders Canada, which, as we know, is a major trading partner too, without having the pay to ship the items by boat across an ocean. But, aside from that, the detail that was provided regarding the major and minor differences was fantastic. Things like not having cars (because, presumably, Ford’s assembly line wasn’t invented) as well as various facets of psychology and human rights made sense the way Moore described them in the alternate reality. The time travel part of it was kind of dumb though, because it didn’t really make sense. Then again, this book was written in the mid-50s, so the fact that it included time travel at all was pretty fun. And while the characters were rather flat, at least the female characters weren’t fragile things there simply to sleep with the main character (well, they kind of did, actually, haha). Barbara was a little insane, granted, and the other two weren’t too far from being stereotypes, but at least they had a voice and something of a personality. Overall, a neat little book if you a) enjoy/don’t mind pre-postmodern literature b) enjoy time travel c) like American History d) wanted to cram in one more book before the end of the year to meet your Books Read goal :)
April 21, 2025
An abridged version of Bring the Jubilee was published in the November issue of F & SF in 1952, and the complete novel came out the following year in paperback from Ballantine and in hardback from Farrar, Strauss, & Young, curiously simultaneously. It was one of the first alternate history science fiction novels and has long been recognized as one of the most important books in the history of the genre. It asks the question "What if the South had won the Civil War?" and answers it quite intelligently as well. It's not an action-oriented story, but rather a careful analytical and extrapolative work. It's a first-person narrative, and Moore shows, sometimes quite subtly, the differences in Hodge's world and ours rather than simply listing events and consequences. Hodge isn't a character that it's possible to warm up to easily, and his three romantic interests are all quite flawed, but it's a very thought-provoking and enjoyable story. I enjoyed re-visiting it via a fine LibriVox performance.
November 16, 2024
A classic alternate history and time travel story.
April 16, 2020
Distopía bastante sencilla y viaje en el tiempo engañaso, tan solo está en el último 5 por 100 del libro y lo utiliza engañosamente para cerrar con un final impactante.
Es la aventura de un chico que viaja para ir aprendiendo de los libros que encuentre y de las personas que le enseñen. Cuyo objetivo es ir a la universidad.
Lo único positivo del libro es el final
Es la aventura de un chico que viaja para ir aprendiendo de los libros que encuentre y de las personas que le enseñen. Cuyo objetivo es ir a la universidad.
Lo único positivo del libro es el final
September 26, 2024
This 1953 novel is both an alternate history and time travel science fiction. In the years since, it has been in print through a succession of publishers, and will now be released in ebook format by Open Road Media. I received a kindle format version at no cost, prior to release, in return for publishing an honest review.
American Civil War alternate histories are a staple of the genre, probably the best known being MacKinlay Kantor’s If The South Had Won the Civil War (1961), and more recently Harry Turtledove’s Southern Victory series (1997-2007). There have been numerous stories which employ versions of this concept, and even anthologies thematically focused on it. But Bring The Jubilee predates all of the above, has been cited as inspiration for Philip K Dick’s The Man in the High Castle (1962), and should be seen as critical in the popular establishment of alternate history as a subgenre.
In the novel, the point of departure (POD) from our own universe is the Battle of Gettysburg turning to a Confederate victory. But rather than reading like a faux history book (If The South Had Won the Civil War), and rather than giving a blow-by-blow of the conflict itself (Southern Victory), Moore immerses his story immediately in the resulting rump 3rd world United States two generations after the conclusion of the “War of Southron Independence.” In the person of young Hodge Backmaker, we first see his native backwater Wappinger Falls, and a much-diminished New York City where he works in a bookstore/printer shop. Eventually he finds his way to a semi-utopian community in the Pennsylvania countryside, where time travel capability is developed.
As a character, Hodge is believable and interesting. While not the central focus of the story, his sexual relationships with women are surprisingly forthright for 1950s writing. At the time of the book’s release, critics referred to it as “Bohemian”, which of course had nothing to do with Bohemia. As a result, the narrative has a much more contemporary feel. But this brings us to the character I found to be outstandingly not believable – Barbara Haggerwells. She is a brilliant physicist, but also seems to be a sexual predator who has cowed the entire Haggershaven community to her will. I guess there just was no good model for a polyandrist female character at the time; she comes across as irrationally needy and always gets her way.
I enjoyed the exchanges between characters regarding the philosophical nature of time and cause/effect, as well as some political observations that seem as true today as at the time this was written. This is a read for thinkers, and while the ending was what I was expecting, the getting there was most entertaining. If only, if only, Barbara was written better.
American Civil War alternate histories are a staple of the genre, probably the best known being MacKinlay Kantor’s If The South Had Won the Civil War (1961), and more recently Harry Turtledove’s Southern Victory series (1997-2007). There have been numerous stories which employ versions of this concept, and even anthologies thematically focused on it. But Bring The Jubilee predates all of the above, has been cited as inspiration for Philip K Dick’s The Man in the High Castle (1962), and should be seen as critical in the popular establishment of alternate history as a subgenre.
In the novel, the point of departure (POD) from our own universe is the Battle of Gettysburg turning to a Confederate victory. But rather than reading like a faux history book (If The South Had Won the Civil War), and rather than giving a blow-by-blow of the conflict itself (Southern Victory), Moore immerses his story immediately in the resulting rump 3rd world United States two generations after the conclusion of the “War of Southron Independence.” In the person of young Hodge Backmaker, we first see his native backwater Wappinger Falls, and a much-diminished New York City where he works in a bookstore/printer shop. Eventually he finds his way to a semi-utopian community in the Pennsylvania countryside, where time travel capability is developed.
As a character, Hodge is believable and interesting. While not the central focus of the story, his sexual relationships with women are surprisingly forthright for 1950s writing. At the time of the book’s release, critics referred to it as “Bohemian”, which of course had nothing to do with Bohemia. As a result, the narrative has a much more contemporary feel. But this brings us to the character I found to be outstandingly not believable – Barbara Haggerwells. She is a brilliant physicist, but also seems to be a sexual predator who has cowed the entire Haggershaven community to her will. I guess there just was no good model for a polyandrist female character at the time; she comes across as irrationally needy and always gets her way.
I enjoyed the exchanges between characters regarding the philosophical nature of time and cause/effect, as well as some political observations that seem as true today as at the time this was written. This is a read for thinkers, and while the ending was what I was expecting, the getting there was most entertaining. If only, if only, Barbara was written better.
September 25, 2015
Bring the Jubilee is told in two parts, entirely from the perspective of Hodgins "Hodge" Backmaker, citizen an alternate timeline United States. As a reader and historian, Hodge ponders many facts about the timeline - the Confederate states won the war and thrived afterward, the former United States stagnated, and the German Union won the Emperor's War (1914-1916).
In the first section of the book, Hodge leaves home and has adventures. Much is revealed about his character and some of the political climate, but not much. He also meets proponents of two different philosophies, allowing the author to comment on free will. This section is not as interesting to read, and it has been said that much of this past parallels the authors life.
In the second section, Hodge rescues a young woman in distress and joins a self-sufficient collective of scholars and intellectuals. Here the story really builds, gathering in action, more politics, a love interest, and eventually the invention of a time machine. Who better than history Hodge to travel back and observe the Battle of Gettysburg, where the South won the war?
This books is expanded from a novella released a year earlier, and I suspect the second section is the majority of that story. I found the novel a bit lacking for the added pieces, though it was included in David Pringle's list of the 100 best science fiction novels, among other accolades. I plan to track down the novella (collected in The Best Alternate History Stories of the 20th Century) for reading soon.
In the first section of the book, Hodge leaves home and has adventures. Much is revealed about his character and some of the political climate, but not much. He also meets proponents of two different philosophies, allowing the author to comment on free will. This section is not as interesting to read, and it has been said that much of this past parallels the authors life.
In the second section, Hodge rescues a young woman in distress and joins a self-sufficient collective of scholars and intellectuals. Here the story really builds, gathering in action, more politics, a love interest, and eventually the invention of a time machine. Who better than history Hodge to travel back and observe the Battle of Gettysburg, where the South won the war?
This books is expanded from a novella released a year earlier, and I suspect the second section is the majority of that story. I found the novel a bit lacking for the added pieces, though it was included in David Pringle's list of the 100 best science fiction novels, among other accolades. I plan to track down the novella (collected in The Best Alternate History Stories of the 20th Century) for reading soon.
May 30, 2013
An alternate history tale in which the South won the Civil War. The main part of the story takes place some 60 years after the war and the United States (just the North) has fallen into disarray after its disastrous loss to the South. I found this part of the book fascinating, with interesting speculation on how the state of the world changes if the United States breaks up (if a bit outlandish at times).
August 2, 2011
This is a time travel book, published in the 1950s, and often mentioned as one of the greatest works of science fiction ever written. I admit to being underwhelmed, although--perhaps--that author's idea was seminal at the time he wrote this story.
The main character, Hodge, lives in an America where the South won the Civil War, and the North is an underdeveloped, economically depressed, powerless nation of poverty, crime, ignorance, and hopelessness. Hodge becomes a historian and travels back through time where he inadvertently changes the outcome of the Battle of Gettysburg, changing the course of history into what is our current timeline, and damning himself to remain in the past forever since the person who invented the time machine he utilized is never born.
There is no action in this story, and the majority of Hodge's life is boring. The author threw in a few famous names but had them doing wildly different things with themselves in the alternate time line (Eugene O'Neil is an Anglican priest, for example, while Carl Jung in the Chief of the Swiss police).
This may have been both fresh and remarkable back in the 1950s, but I found it very slow. For a much more interesting take on alternative timelines, I suggest Phillip K. Dick's The Man in the High Castle or Jack Finney's Bid Time Return. This book was a bit of a snore.
The main character, Hodge, lives in an America where the South won the Civil War, and the North is an underdeveloped, economically depressed, powerless nation of poverty, crime, ignorance, and hopelessness. Hodge becomes a historian and travels back through time where he inadvertently changes the outcome of the Battle of Gettysburg, changing the course of history into what is our current timeline, and damning himself to remain in the past forever since the person who invented the time machine he utilized is never born.
There is no action in this story, and the majority of Hodge's life is boring. The author threw in a few famous names but had them doing wildly different things with themselves in the alternate time line (Eugene O'Neil is an Anglican priest, for example, while Carl Jung in the Chief of the Swiss police).
This may have been both fresh and remarkable back in the 1950s, but I found it very slow. For a much more interesting take on alternative timelines, I suggest Phillip K. Dick's The Man in the High Castle or Jack Finney's Bid Time Return. This book was a bit of a snore.
October 26, 2012
Oh...chissà perché ero un po' prevenuta verso questo libro, avevo il sospetto che fosse noioso. Forse dopo aver letto qualche recensione, chissà...E invece è stata una lettura molto, molto gradevole, interessante, colta, e pure avvincente in una maniera particolare, sobria ed elegante direi.
Ward Moore scriveva davvero bene, sono contenta di aver scoperto questo scrittore.
Consigliatissimo, soprattutto agli amanti del genere ucronico.
Ward Moore scriveva davvero bene, sono contenta di aver scoperto questo scrittore.
Consigliatissimo, soprattutto agli amanti del genere ucronico.
September 16, 2011
This is the best alternate history of the civil war books I've ever read and one of the best, and earliest, alternative history books in general.
July 13, 2017
Review to follow.
February 8, 2019
Historia alternativa de la guerra de independencia americana y viajes en el tiempo, todo junto. No está mal.
July 3, 2017
Bring the Jubilee is one of the earliest alternate histories, set in a United States that lost the American Civil War after a decisive Confederate victory at Gettysburg. The South has gone on to forge its own empire sprawling across Mexico and Central America, a center of learning and culture that rivals the British Empire and German Union. Meanwhile, the impoverished North lies divided and embittered after the failures of their generals and Lincoln, having undergone its own Reconstruction to become a destitute nation of wealthy landowners ruling over indentured workers. Politics are divided between Whigs (promoting trickle-down Reaganomics) and incompetent Populists. Even though slavery has been abolished, minorities face persecution, unjustly blamed for defeat by way of Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation.
Into this setting comes Hodge, a young man striving to become a scholar in a backwater village that offers him nothing but indentured servitude at the local mill. Directionless but with plenty of ambition, Hodge sets off with his few belongings for New York, a seedy and pale shadow if its real-world self. To follow his dream of becoming a historian of the War of Southron Independence, Hodge is pulled into the machinations of a subversive—almost terrorist—organization called the Grand Army, which eventually sends him off to an isolated research institute of higher learning. Little does Hodge know, but the experiments going on at this facility may unintentionally reshape his world…
The first half of Bring the Jubilee is something like a meandering travelogue; it reminds me of those future histories from the ’30s, in that it’s more interested in displaying its fantastic setting rather than developing a deep or complex character or plot. To be fair, the setting is well-realized and vivid, offering a cornucopia of ideas for its impressive setting without giving too little or too much detail. The world is lived-in and realistic, down to the petty cruelties heaped upon minorities in a run-down and decaying North. The story takes a sudden turn about halfway through, focusing more on Hodge, his love interest Catty, and the research station, which is where the real meat of the plot begins—it’s a spoiler, but realizing that the novel is also a time-travel novel gives you some idea where Moore is taking the story. He takes that path and does it well, and the end result is an impressive novel that offers plenty to think about.
Though I can criticize the novel for its thin plot and characterization—Hodge is something of an everyman turned passive narrator until nearly the end of the novel—I can’t under-emphasize how awesome its setting was. Moore’s brilliance here was a simple one: he took history and flipped it, switching the roles of the Southern and Northern halves of the United States after the culmination of the American Civil War. We don’t see every detail of this imagined world, but the snippets we do see are striking, and I’m still impressed by a post-Reconstruction North tearing itself apart during a 1942 election where Thomas E. Dewey (of “Dewey defeats Truman” fame”) wins the Whig nomination and election. It’s that attention to detail that impresses me as a history buff, though those who aren’t as familiar with the minutia should still find plenty to enjoy here.
Bring the Jubilee is a complex and thoughtful novel, and while it’s shallow in some places it has surprising depth in others. I would love to see a little more added to this novel—a little more insight into Hodge, more complexity, more world and setting details, more of everything—but alas, those fall beyond the limitations of 1950s publishing which limited most novels to under 200 pages. That desire to see more isn’t a condemnation of the novel, which is arguably in the top 20 of its era; it’s the wish from a fan to improve upon a novel already so close to perfection. Bring the Jubilee is the kind of novel that a non-SF fan would greatly enjoy, and those who read extensively in the genre could do worse than dig out this old gem and give it a go.
Into this setting comes Hodge, a young man striving to become a scholar in a backwater village that offers him nothing but indentured servitude at the local mill. Directionless but with plenty of ambition, Hodge sets off with his few belongings for New York, a seedy and pale shadow if its real-world self. To follow his dream of becoming a historian of the War of Southron Independence, Hodge is pulled into the machinations of a subversive—almost terrorist—organization called the Grand Army, which eventually sends him off to an isolated research institute of higher learning. Little does Hodge know, but the experiments going on at this facility may unintentionally reshape his world…
The first half of Bring the Jubilee is something like a meandering travelogue; it reminds me of those future histories from the ’30s, in that it’s more interested in displaying its fantastic setting rather than developing a deep or complex character or plot. To be fair, the setting is well-realized and vivid, offering a cornucopia of ideas for its impressive setting without giving too little or too much detail. The world is lived-in and realistic, down to the petty cruelties heaped upon minorities in a run-down and decaying North. The story takes a sudden turn about halfway through, focusing more on Hodge, his love interest Catty, and the research station, which is where the real meat of the plot begins—it’s a spoiler, but realizing that the novel is also a time-travel novel gives you some idea where Moore is taking the story. He takes that path and does it well, and the end result is an impressive novel that offers plenty to think about.
Though I can criticize the novel for its thin plot and characterization—Hodge is something of an everyman turned passive narrator until nearly the end of the novel—I can’t under-emphasize how awesome its setting was. Moore’s brilliance here was a simple one: he took history and flipped it, switching the roles of the Southern and Northern halves of the United States after the culmination of the American Civil War. We don’t see every detail of this imagined world, but the snippets we do see are striking, and I’m still impressed by a post-Reconstruction North tearing itself apart during a 1942 election where Thomas E. Dewey (of “Dewey defeats Truman” fame”) wins the Whig nomination and election. It’s that attention to detail that impresses me as a history buff, though those who aren’t as familiar with the minutia should still find plenty to enjoy here.
Bring the Jubilee is a complex and thoughtful novel, and while it’s shallow in some places it has surprising depth in others. I would love to see a little more added to this novel—a little more insight into Hodge, more complexity, more world and setting details, more of everything—but alas, those fall beyond the limitations of 1950s publishing which limited most novels to under 200 pages. That desire to see more isn’t a condemnation of the novel, which is arguably in the top 20 of its era; it’s the wish from a fan to improve upon a novel already so close to perfection. Bring the Jubilee is the kind of novel that a non-SF fan would greatly enjoy, and those who read extensively in the genre could do worse than dig out this old gem and give it a go.
November 15, 2024
One does not have to search for long in the alternate history genre to discover works premised on a Confederate victory in the American Civil War. Yet they would be hard pressed to find one as good as Ward Moore’s novella. Though it wasn’t the first work situated in such a world, it’s by the far the best ever written, not the least because Moore understands that the premise that defines a work of alternate history needs to be the starting point for a story rather than merely the sum of one.
Moore demonstrates this by centering his narrative around Hodgins “Hodge” Backmaker, a dreamer coming of age in mid-20th century America. Only Hodge’s America looks nothing like the one with which his readers are acquainted. Thanks to its defeat in the “War of Southron Independence,” the United States has been reduced to an impoverished shell of its former self. As Americans wallowed in the remnants of their once-proud nation, the Confederates expanded south to dominate the rest of the hemisphere and became a major world power. Rampant postwar inflation has forced many Americans to accept “indentures” that are little different from the slavery the Confederacy has abandoned, while the free minority struggle just to survive.
Hodge’s life exemplifies this struggle. Desperate for learning beyond the meager opportunities available to him, he sets out for New York City, where he stumbles into a new life entangled with conspirators and Confederate agents. His efforts to break from it by seeking out educational opportunities brings Hodge into contact with an idiosyncratic commune dedicated to intellectual exploration, which welcomes him into the fold. Settling at last into his studies of the war that reshaped the continent, he is offered a unique opportunity to acquire answers to his many questions about it, and one that proves far more momentous than even he can imagine.
The tale Moore tells in his novella is one that mixes together masterfully a variety of elements, from bildungsroman to suspense. Holding it all together is the character study of his protagonist, who moves through his life as an observer rather than as an activist. Whenever Hodge is confronted with opportunities to do something, his fear of asserting himself against seemingly inevitable events repeatedly holds him back. The beautiful irony of Moore’s denouement is that it is this very paralysis of action which brings about the most momentous change of all, implying that our very presence in the world makes us an agent of change. It’s a timeless message that elevates Moore’s work over virtually every other one of its type, and provides an example of the possibilities contained within the alternate history genre in the hands of someone who knows how to write a well-rounded story.
Moore demonstrates this by centering his narrative around Hodgins “Hodge” Backmaker, a dreamer coming of age in mid-20th century America. Only Hodge’s America looks nothing like the one with which his readers are acquainted. Thanks to its defeat in the “War of Southron Independence,” the United States has been reduced to an impoverished shell of its former self. As Americans wallowed in the remnants of their once-proud nation, the Confederates expanded south to dominate the rest of the hemisphere and became a major world power. Rampant postwar inflation has forced many Americans to accept “indentures” that are little different from the slavery the Confederacy has abandoned, while the free minority struggle just to survive.
Hodge’s life exemplifies this struggle. Desperate for learning beyond the meager opportunities available to him, he sets out for New York City, where he stumbles into a new life entangled with conspirators and Confederate agents. His efforts to break from it by seeking out educational opportunities brings Hodge into contact with an idiosyncratic commune dedicated to intellectual exploration, which welcomes him into the fold. Settling at last into his studies of the war that reshaped the continent, he is offered a unique opportunity to acquire answers to his many questions about it, and one that proves far more momentous than even he can imagine.
The tale Moore tells in his novella is one that mixes together masterfully a variety of elements, from bildungsroman to suspense. Holding it all together is the character study of his protagonist, who moves through his life as an observer rather than as an activist. Whenever Hodge is confronted with opportunities to do something, his fear of asserting himself against seemingly inevitable events repeatedly holds him back. The beautiful irony of Moore’s denouement is that it is this very paralysis of action which brings about the most momentous change of all, implying that our very presence in the world makes us an agent of change. It’s a timeless message that elevates Moore’s work over virtually every other one of its type, and provides an example of the possibilities contained within the alternate history genre in the hands of someone who knows how to write a well-rounded story.
June 8, 2025
Bring the Jubilee by Ward Moore is an alternative history science fiction plus time travel. To be honest, I didn’t expect time travel would be included in this book, and thus In the previous chapters which the protagonist, Hodge frequently had the conversation with Roger Tyss about the theory of time, in the later chapters, Barbara also had argued with Hodge about the same theory, which is all set to the crucial plot of Hodge traveling to the point when the north and south were trying to take Little Round Top the hill. And it had changed everything in the history about the Sounthron war ( according to the known history it is the civil war). Furthermore, he accidentally has destroyed maybe the only parallel universe where time travel existed. This book adds and changes multiple elements in the alternative history after the South America won the war. It’s fascinating for me to read about the story, even though the character developments and plots are the designed or the introduction of the altered America history.
About the time travel part is the most intriguing element in the book, the protagonist required Barbara sent him to the past in order to be the spectator of the battle of Gettysburg. Ironically, his action has stimulated the tragic event of eradicating Herbert Haggerwell, the founder of Haggershaven from the history. Not only he wouldn’t be able to go back to his timeline, also he destroyed the universe he was from. Hence he had been staying in the altered time of America for the rest of his life. The elderly Hodge wrote the book is for trying to convey the message to the people might be from other universes. For the audiences like us we wouldn’t believe what Hodge believes that the alternative universe with the Time Machine. However, this enigmatic story is the story that will be remained in our mind for a long time, and start thinking what if the history had chosen different path.
Highly recommend Bring the Jubilee to the readers who want to read an alternative history in Science fiction form of story telling.
About the time travel part is the most intriguing element in the book, the protagonist required Barbara sent him to the past in order to be the spectator of the battle of Gettysburg. Ironically, his action has stimulated the tragic event of eradicating Herbert Haggerwell, the founder of Haggershaven from the history. Not only he wouldn’t be able to go back to his timeline, also he destroyed the universe he was from. Hence he had been staying in the altered time of America for the rest of his life. The elderly Hodge wrote the book is for trying to convey the message to the people might be from other universes. For the audiences like us we wouldn’t believe what Hodge believes that the alternative universe with the Time Machine. However, this enigmatic story is the story that will be remained in our mind for a long time, and start thinking what if the history had chosen different path.
Highly recommend Bring the Jubilee to the readers who want to read an alternative history in Science fiction form of story telling.
May 4, 2019
I learned about this book a few years ago. I have kept an eye out for it ever since. For many years I had yet to find a copy in the wild. Until this past February I stumbled across it in a bookstore in Tallahassee called My Favorite Books. If you're ever in that area you should check them out.
"What if the South won the Civil War?"
In this post civil war world the United States still exists, but it is a pitiful shadow of what is was. The Confederacy is a sprawling empire.
The story begins in 1877 although our protagonist wasn't born until 1921. Hodgins McCormick Backmaker is our guide through this unfamiliar landscape. I cannot remember ever identifying with a character as much as I did with Hodgins.
The story is told from first person perspective and is essential Hodgins attempts to get along and find an education in this post war land. People Indenture themselves to make a living. Inventions and historic events are drastically different than the ones we know.
Very little to no science fiction in the story. Just putting that out there.
This editions cover could have used a little more inspiration.
The Confederate battle flag behind the capital building really just calls attention to the book. The settings in the story only takes place in the United States not the Confederacy. So that's misleading.
Lincoln never appears in the book but he graces the cover with some Union soldiers. Go figure.
Recommended!
"What if the South won the Civil War?"
In this post civil war world the United States still exists, but it is a pitiful shadow of what is was. The Confederacy is a sprawling empire.
The story begins in 1877 although our protagonist wasn't born until 1921. Hodgins McCormick Backmaker is our guide through this unfamiliar landscape. I cannot remember ever identifying with a character as much as I did with Hodgins.
The story is told from first person perspective and is essential Hodgins attempts to get along and find an education in this post war land. People Indenture themselves to make a living. Inventions and historic events are drastically different than the ones we know.
Very little to no science fiction in the story. Just putting that out there.
This editions cover could have used a little more inspiration.
The Confederate battle flag behind the capital building really just calls attention to the book. The settings in the story only takes place in the United States not the Confederacy. So that's misleading.
Lincoln never appears in the book but he graces the cover with some Union soldiers. Go figure.
Recommended!
August 18, 2016
Wow. Here is a gem I never knew. What a strange, sad, logically consistent world Moore builds here, redolent of chance, regret and disjunction. I think perhaps The man in High Castle owes this book a considerable debt.
This story considers the hoary trope 'what if the south won the war?' not only before most of the other well known treatments of the subject (Guns of the South, etc), but in a emmersive and engaging way. The sad defeated United States--disemboweled and at the mercy of the other great powers--is quite affecting, yet out of these ashes, our protagonist crafts a life of loveliness that reminded me in many ways of Twain's Connecticut Yankee. And the third act plays in many ways much the same, but with a strange and vital inexorableness, underscoring the ying and yang of the protagonists' two patrons.
How this never got made into a film I couldn't tell you. Adapted with even journeyman skill, it would be engrossing. An adaptation with merit and intelligence comparable to the source would be considerable more than that.
This story considers the hoary trope 'what if the south won the war?' not only before most of the other well known treatments of the subject (Guns of the South, etc), but in a emmersive and engaging way. The sad defeated United States--disemboweled and at the mercy of the other great powers--is quite affecting, yet out of these ashes, our protagonist crafts a life of loveliness that reminded me in many ways of Twain's Connecticut Yankee. And the third act plays in many ways much the same, but with a strange and vital inexorableness, underscoring the ying and yang of the protagonists' two patrons.
How this never got made into a film I couldn't tell you. Adapted with even journeyman skill, it would be engrossing. An adaptation with merit and intelligence comparable to the source would be considerable more than that.
June 30, 2018
I was expecting a pedestrian alternate history tale, given the era of the novel and the relative obscurity of the author.
What I got was a rather complex affecting novel. With some great and believable world building, complicated characters acting in adult ways, and a historical denouement that makes our historical reality seem unreal.
In short, I liked it.
Required reading for alternate history fans. Seriously. Don’t walk. Run.
What I got was a rather complex affecting novel. With some great and believable world building, complicated characters acting in adult ways, and a historical denouement that makes our historical reality seem unreal.
In short, I liked it.
Required reading for alternate history fans. Seriously. Don’t walk. Run.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 273 reviews