She writes of rivers and swamps with an appalling ignorance of geography and physics.
Review of Kindle edition
Publication date: May 23, 2017
Publisher: Tor.com
Language: English
ASIN: B01MRJW3OS
Fantastic idea for a fun alternate history romp ruined by poor prose, lack of character development, an ignorance of the traits, habits and physiology of the hippopotamus (an inexcusable failing considering that the story idea is based upon hippopotami or hippopotamuses, as you choose.), a complete ignorance of geography, an apparent ignorance of the direction in which water runs (that would be downhill. North to south when dealing with the Mississippi, its tributaries and related swamps. Water is contained on the uphill side of a dam, not the downhill side.). Throw in some twenty first century politically correct sexuality for seasoning rather than importance to the plot and you have an unpalatable mess.
I wrote that the politically correct sexuality is not important to the plot. However, after reading some recent reviewers, I reflected on this and perhaps I was wrong. Promoting the LGBTQ, etc. agenda maybe the main purpose of Ms Gailey's writing. Even so, she should have paid more attention to the plot, geography, and physics.
I can't say that it was boring. Being disgusted, amazed, unhappy, incredulous and a bit angry is not the same as being bored. I hope she doesn't go back and correct the geographic and physics problems. They are just too funny as is.
Addendum 1/31/24: Amazon has removed this review. The message was the usual, "consult community guidelines." I also noticed that, according to the Amazon description, this piece of poorly written nonsense is, "A Finalist for the 2017 Nebula Award for Best Novella." Well, so much for the Nebula awards being a reliable guide to scifi.