May 14, 2010: Edit! Done with this book!
Sometime early May: I'm going to be...ambitious and try to review all the short stories in this anthology. There are 40 stories though, so I may fall off midway. I'm only on story #17 now...
All the stories in this book are reprints of short stories focusing on cats, so there was nothing originally written for this anthology. I've read a few of the short stories present in this anthology and there are definition familiar names and authors. Prior to each story there's a little blurb about each author and how they came up with the story's idea.
1. "Through the Looking Glass" (excerpt) - Lewis Carroll
Funny. I started this anthology after watching the film Alice in Wonderland with Johnny Depp, Helena Bonham Carter and Alan Rickman. (Totally overhyped.) This was way back in March, during Spring Break. Well, damn, I've been bad at reading this book...
Argh, need to focus on this review. Right. Well, I was unable to separate myself from the movie (which may be based on Lewis Carroll's book but he didn't have any input on how it was done) while reading the story. I also didn't like it was an excerpt of a bigger story... The excerpt was mostly monologue by Alice and monologues tend to make me glaze eyed.
2. "No Heaven Will Not Ever Heaven Be..." - A.R. Morlan
This story reminded me of the numerous cats/kittens calendars out there. (Not surprising.) The end of the story could be a little disturbing, but I found it a little sweet.
3. "The Price" - Neil Gaiman
I've already read this story. I remember upon the first time I read it I went "Whoa." The blurb says this story is "a lovely mystical, powerful, and moving tale that Gaiman admits is also more or less true." I did find the story mystical. It plays upon the power or mystery of the black cat without making the black cat too whimsical or stereotyped. I like the last line, because it makes the narrator more believable to me.
4. "Dark Eyes, Faith, and Devotion" - Charles de Lint
Charles de Lint is a name I’m familiar. I think I’ve some of his short stories in other anthologies, though have yet to pick up on his own anthologies or books. I really liked this story. It builds up the narrator’s character well, and Luisa. Sometimes I get annoyed or peeved when a first-person perspective can run over into too inner monologue, but this one didn’t do that so much.
5. "Not Waving" - Michael Marshall Smith
I’m not familiar with Smith, but this story was just…wow. It’s powerful, and believable. It also shows that relationships are not clear-cut, as much as we’d like it to be. (Though the cheating was still wrong. Someone deserves the respect of knowing if their partner cheated on them – it doesn’t matter if it didn’t go all the way to sex.) Relationships are not logical – emotions can’t be weighed and we can’t know ahead of time what the benefits of an action would be. I was rooting for what the narrator decided to give up, but another part understood why he chose he did. I really wish I could discuss this story with someone else, because I’d like to know what others thought. It’s a sad story, but powerful. I wonder if the narrator found happiness in the relationship the end of the story presents, or if it was only “I am content.” (I personally find a difference between “being content” and “being happy.”)
6. "Catch" - Ray Vukcevich
Oh, my God. This story. I wasn’t sure if I should be horrified for what the cats went through or just going “WTF?” The juxtaposition of the narrator’s job with his wife and the problem he currently has with his wife was neatly done. Still…this is a very WTF story. I’d like for Vukcevich (an unknown author) to continue on about this universe and how the preposterous profession Desmond and Lucy are in come to be! I could totally see how Desmond would be blind to what he did wrong. He equates their baby with the cats, and doesn’t think just because the baby is his, (and a human) it’s anything different from past cat encounters he and his wife have had. Damn, it is hard to write this review without spoilers! This is another story I’d like to talk about with someone because my interpretation could be wrong, and I could be wrong in agreeing with Lucy’s reaction to what Desmond did…
7. "The Manticore Spell" - Jeffrey Ford
I’ve already read this story in another anthology and I believe I wasn’t particularly impressed with it then.
I remember taking a big break from the book after this story. :-S I was busy with other things to read, and schoolwork, but it’s disappointing to know I was easily turned off from the anthology because of one story I was unimpressed with.
8. "Catskin" - Kelly Link
I’ve read of Kelly Link’s work in other anthologies. This story impressed me. It is definitely…original. The narrator’s aside comments to the reader weren’t as annoying as it could have been, so kudos to Link. Her interpretation of what a cat is original, that’s for sure. And what witches are, too. At first I was intrigued about the universe the story was based in, and was interested in reading more stories centered there. Upon a second thought, I think this story was enough. Not in a bad way “enough” but that it’s a good peak and anything more might not as good as this story. (Like sequels that really suck after the first movie. Sequels that were made only because the first one made a lot of money at the box office though critically and plot-wise they are quite horrible. *cough*piratesofthecaribbean*cough*)
9. "Mieze Correct an Incomplete Representation of Reality" - Michaela Roessner
I had to giggle while reading this story. I learned about Schrödinger’s Cat paradox a few years ago so the story actually made sense. Congrats to Roessner for writing a thought-provoking story.
10. "Guardians" - George R. R. Martin
George R. R. Martin is an author I’ve heard a lot about. I bought the first book in his Games and Thrones series a few years ago upon someone’s recommendation but never started it… Eventually I gave it away because it was just taking up space and if I was serious about reading it, I could always borrow it from the public library.
I approached this story with open curiosity. Reading it reminded me of Asimov’s Foundation where Trader Hober Mallow solves a Seldon Crisis with his knowledge of economics and trade, which seems at odds with what the crisis is about. In Martin’s story, Haviland Tuf is an ecological engineer and a specialist in biological warfare and he intends to solve a problem on the world of Namor of sea monsters. The solution and cause of the sea monsters is unexpected. The inclusion of cats in this story is peripheral though important. You don’t really see it until Tuf chooses to release that information.
11. "Life Regarded as a Jigsaw Puzzle of Highly Lustrous Cats" - Michael Bishop
I really didn’t understand this story… And that is all I can say…
12. "Gordon, the Self-Made Cat" - Peter S. Beagle
I’ve heard of Beagle, and I’ve read the limited first draft edition of his The Last Unicorn . I haven’t read any of his other books, however. I think I’ve read some of his short stories in other anthologies. I really enjoyed this short story. It’s whimsical but also serious in the underlying message. It’s a little disappointing how Gordon’s life ended up, but it’s very realistic of how stories passes through a closed society and how sometimes if the majority believe in something/feel something, the truth isn’t enough to change the mind.
13. "The Jaguar Hunter" - Lucius Shepard
I’ve read a few of Shepard’s short stories, including one in a ghost anthology. It scared the beejesus out of me, I’ll say that. It took me several pauses to finish it.
This story filled me with ambivalence. I like the mythos present but it seemed a little too strong in the sentiment that modern inventions and the modern lifestyle is inherently evil. That seems a little one-sided to me. But I did like the jaguar and how it figured in the story. :)
14. "Arthur's Lion" - Tanith Lee
Generally I’m really fond of Tanith Lee’s short stories and storytelling skills. This story had an interesting premise, for sure. I can absolutely see the picture that scared Arthur into his nightmares about the lion. How the narrator turned it around so Arthur would no longer be scared and be driven by the lion was really innovative.
15. "Pride" - Mary A. Turzillo
Turzillo is an unknown author but I absolutely loved this story. I found it deep and complex. The relationships between all three characters are believable and while brief (compared to a novella or a novel), I felt for all of them. It also briefly touches on bioethics and humane treatment on experimented animals. It didn’t go far in that direction, but I think that would have diverted the story from what it intended to do. I think this story was one of the better ones for showing the magic and strength and awe humans feel when looking at/touching/thinking about felines.
16. "The Burglar Takes a Cat" - Lawrence Block
Carolyn has a whole bunch of responses and arguments against taking care of rats in other ways than a cat… A lot of it is about how inhumane poison is, or traps or yadda yadda. And yet…she thinks it’s perfectly a-okay to de-claw a cat. Correct me if I’m wrong, but…isn’t de-clawing like snipping off a bone and not a fingernail? WTF, mate. Granted this short story was written in 1994 so maybe back then they didn’t know that. Anyway, this story is an excerpt from a Blocks’ novel The Burglar Who Traded Ted Williams. This short story doesn’t expand on the background of the burglar part, but I did enjoy Carolyn’s rhetoric about “a Woman With Cats.” Haha, I can actually see that in our society. Heh. Overall, it was a cute excerpt and I liked it better than the beginning excerpt from Carroll’s novel.
17. "The White Cat" - Joyce Carol Oates
I’ve heard of Oates but have yet to read her writings. Well, I definitely wouldn’t tell people who like cats to read this story since it begins with Mr. Muir planning to kill Miranda, the cat he gave his wife as a gift. And his various attempts to do so. Well, I wouldn’t recommend this story for people who get angry or hurt about people hurting cats/pets. So…yeah…
18. "Returns" - Jack Ketchum
Ah, this was a pretty sad short story. :( It’s another story I wouldn’t recommend for people who don’t like cats being hurt, harmed or euthanized.
19. "Puss-Cat" - Reggie Oliver
I’m not entirely sure of the ending but it didn’t detract me from liking the story. I generally don’t like the narrative style of someone retelling an event like it’s a one-sided conversation, or an interview, but it worked well in this case.
20. "Cat in Glass" - Nancy Techemendy
Strange…I got the feeling of déjà vu during a paragraph near the end of this story, yet I don’t recognize the overall story at all. This one…the father’s note confused me…until I reread it and…oh, dear… Did she… OH. Damn. Well…that’s just…wow, sad… (in the unfortunate way).
21. "Coyote Peyote" - Carole Nelson Douglas
Well, damn, I really really like this story. An aspect of it is pretty damn horrific, but it ended strongly so kudos.
22. "The Poet and the Inkmaker's Daughter" - Elizabeth Hand
I far prefer Elizabeth Hand as a short story writer than a novel writer. (Though to be fair, I’ve only read one of her novels.) I really loved this story. The take on a Japanese myth is very sweet and simple. Its simplicity is fitting and, yeah, one of the stories I really love.
23. "The Night of the Tiger" - Stephen King
Mmm, nice build up. I liked the believability of the narrator’s tone and fear of Mr. Indrasil and his -_- about Mr. Legere. The last line, though, I found so predictable it just…deflated the story for me. Sorry, Stephen King, this story was promising but it went “pfffft.”
24. "Every Angel is Terrifying" - John Kessel
I was a little lost at the beginning of this story, because Kessel says “ ‘The cat was the only survivor of the family in Flannery O’Connor’s harrowing short story ‘A Good Man is Hard to Find,’ so it was natural for me to carry it along into this story.” Well, okay…that just made me a little more treipidatous about reading the story, in case the author wasn’t smooth enough and I felt I had to read O’Connor’s short story in order to make sense of this story.
This story dips high and low. It is definitely a memorable short story, for some thoughts Railroad has during the story that repulsed me, and for the ending. I’m not sure what I think happened.
25. "Candia" - Graham Joyce
This is one of the slightly more creepy tales in this anthology, while also a bit sad, too.
26. "Mbo" - Nicholas Royle
Yeah…this is one of the more graphic stories in this anthology. A little daunting, and it makes me more wary about mosquitoes…
27. "Bean Bag Cats (R)" - Edward Bryant
The format of this story are memos sent between two people. I went “:-O” when I read what product they were going to advertise/make. Well, I’ve heard people make complaints about their cats pertaining to the selected features mentioned in this story.
28. "Antiquities" - John Crowley
I’ve heard of this author before. Someone gifted me his novel Little, Big but unfortunately it had to be left in Asia before I could finish it. (All my books made my luggage too heavy for flying.) This story mentioned Bastet in a sidenote, and I thought the overall feel of the story was very different from the others.
29. "The Manticore's Tale" - Catherynne M. Valente
I’ve read this book this short story is excerpted from. (Valente’s first The Orphan’s Tale book). Makes me miss the two books, but they’re packed up in storage. :( I’m biased in thinking this short story is good, though it feels a bit empty without the other stories and layers from The Orphan’s Tale: In the Night Garden. The Manticore’s tale of her birth is richer when interspersed with other characters’ stories.
30. "In Carnation" - Nancy Springer
Wow, this story is just splendid. At first I was a little put off by the cat character, but then realized that was just who she was. Or what she was… As I read more into the story I grew more awed by the depth of the characters and story. I really, really love this story.
31. "Old Foss is the Name of His Cat" - David Sandner
I felt déjà vu when reading this story. Ah! I just Googled it. It’s from the first Clockwork Phoenix book. Yes, I still found this story confusing the second time reading…
32. "A Safe Place to Be" - Carol Emshwiller
This story I found a bit bewildering. It started off well, but as it went on, I felt myself going “okay…gotcha…seems repetitive…” It was a ho-hum short story in my mind.
33. "Nine Lives to Live" - Sharyn McCrumb
Danby’s reincarnation! Oh, I like this story, for all the plot points towards an impending death. Hee. I love this story for its simple and unpretentious tone.
34. "Tiger Kill" - Kaaron Warner
So, this story was very disturbing to me. It’s not for those who are for animal rights, and female rights, though those are the point of the story according to the pre-story blurb from the author about the story. I was very unnerved reading it, and was glad I read it in a safe place (the public library during afternoon hours).
35. "Something Better than Death" - Lucy Sussex
It’s a tour story… Frankly, I found it dull to read.
36. "Dominion" - Christine Lucas
It’s a story about the origin of cats! This is another story I really enjoyed reading. :D
37. "Tiger in the Snow" - Daniel Wynn Barber
I had to re-read the ending in order to understand the story. It’s a little sad, and it reminded me of an earlier story in this anthology, “Cat in Glass.”
38. "The Dweller in High Places" - Susanna Clarke
Sphinx story!! The riddle was really cute at the end.
39. "Healing Benjamin" - Dennis Danvers
Wow, just wow. I really loved this story. The build-up is well done in this story, and I had hopes for a different outcome, but the ending is very fitting and it comes in a full circle.
40. "The Puma" - Theodora Goss
I’ve read Theodora Goss before, in her collection of short stories.
I think I would have enjoyed this story more if I had read The Island of Dr. Moreau. Though the story picks up afterwards, I still felt a little lost. The premise of this story was intriguing and the ending goal. I think “Healing Benjamin” would have been a stronger ending to the anthology.