I don't agree with everything in this book. I find some sections to be overly repetitive. I question some of the charts.
So why did I rate this 5-star?
Because, for me, his methods work. This is where the rubber meets the road. This is the easiest and most effective fasting that I have ever done. I have done every kind of fast. I used to do a 24-hour fast (water only) regularly one day a week while I was at home with 3 toddlers. So I can tell you that the body appreciates the rest from digestion, my energy level was not affected, and I barely noticed that I was fasting. I have done an extended water-only fast in which an incurable condition disappeared from my body. At the end of that period, my body felt so good that I wished I did not have to eat again. I had seen the difference between how my body was supposed to function and how it functioned when I ate foods to which my body was sensitive. Of course, I did eat again. I was hungry. I am not stupid. :) But I am merely saying that sometimes the body needs a rest in order to get on with its task of healing. I did switch to more organic and nutrient-dense food and I did eliminate some foods completely.
Of course, if we ate as we were intended to, with only 2 or 3 meals a day instead of permanent snacking, we would be doing enough "fasting" and would probably never need to add a fasting program to our lives.
As a medical doctor, the author includes testing for markers to show how the body is improving through fasting. He has a program in which people can ease into fasting gradually and has the schedules printed in the book.
He offers "assisted" fasting in which people consume a fat in a hot beverage or some salted homemade beef broth to make fasting easier. He shows how this does not get the body out of "fasting mode".
And he shows you the differences in speed of results using each different method and time line.
He also encourages you to select one of his programs in which you can continue to take prescription medication and nutritional supplements.
And he tells you to use common sense. Let your body, not your will power, determine the length of your fast. If your body says to quit, then quit. Next time, you will go longer.
He also tells you that there are some people who should never fast.
I do disagree with his methods in some ways, for example, the recipes that he includes to help people begin eating after a fast. I cannot use most of these recipes because they include pork, nightshades, dairy, most fruits and all food with lectins. I can make substitutions because I commonly make them to accommodate my Type O blood. But many people cannot eat these foods without negative effects. So if they fail in this fasting, they might be failing for the wrong reason. They might be eating the wrong foods for their metabolic/blood type or foods to which they have sensitivities.
The major reason for fasting in this book is to restore health. However, as a side effect, people usually lose weight.
At one time, when I knew nothing about eating for your blood type or the 12 different metabolic types or lectins, I used the Hilton Head Metabolic Diet very successfully. However, I made my meals ahead of time and would eat the same lunch every day for a week. As the book said, I weighed myself every morning and had a consistent weight loss of between 0.1 and 0.2 pounds per day, always losing at least 2 pounds per week. But during the week that I ate chili for lunch, I had no weight loss. I was puzzled. I was following the recipes in the book. But I later discovered that chili has everything that I cannot eat (except for beef)--tomatoes, green peppers, chili powder and legumes. All of these foods have lectins which are harmful to many people who are Type O-non secretors. I omitted the chili for lunch and got on track again.
If I followed Dr. Fung's recipes, I would not lose weight and I would have pain in my joints.
So for some people, these recipes might not work.
I also think that he is not helping people get through the beginning stages of discomfort in initial fasts. There are many methods such as saunas and Epsom salt baths that help with the Herxheimer reactions of detoxing. He could have explained how getting rid of addictions (caffeine, sugar and simple carbs) before beginning fasting would make the fasting easier.
Fasting is not difficult. The body appreciates times of rest from digestion.
People might confuse the discomfort of withdrawal with the discomfort of not eating and quit. But if they were told to change their eating habits to remove most simple carbs, sugar, and caffeine first and transition to a high fat, low carb diet before the fast, then the fasting experience would be almost pleasant.
I am not saying that people should maintain a high fat, low carb diet constantly. There are many people much more knowledgeable than I am who are on both sides of this issue. I personally believe that, if we ate naturally from food available locally, we would be burning glucose in the summer to store fat for the winter and we would be burning fat in the winter. So we would not always be in ketosis. Ketosis happens in the winter months. Hibernating bears are in ketosis. But this seasonal eating pattern is simply my opinion.
I feel that people who use a high fat, low carb diet for a few days before they begin to fast will have an easier experience because, in fasting, after a few days, the body has to switch to burning fats because glycogen stores are consumed in a few days. It is easier, in my opinion, to switch to HFLC eating first, then begin fasting. It is easier to go through 1 change at a time.
I never expect to find a book that contains all the information on a subject. The author always must draw the line somewhere.
But I am glad that I read this book. Dr. Jung has opened my eyes to the specific healings that can occur in the body through fasting... and these are many serious, generally considered incurable diseases such as diabetes 2. He has made fasting much easier with the use of fats or broth in small amounts during a fast that will not switch the body from fasting to digestion. He has developed programs that help people ease into fasting and extend the length and frequency of their fasting.
I will be incorporating some of his ideas into my lifestyle permanently.
What more could I expect from a book? I am glad that I read it.