"Faust II" is the second half of Goethe's famous play, but it itself is not as famous. Though it provides the conclusion of the eponymous character's story arc, it is often skipped during stage production, and when the play was taught to me in high school, we didn't read Part Two. Even my friends who think Goethe is a genius have told me that Part Two shouldn't exist. Could an entire half of one of the greatest works of literature, something that took Goethe his entire lifetime to complete, actually be that bad?
I would say that Part One is certainly the foundation for the modern play, whereas this section is a lot harder to digest, coming across as mere disjointed tableaux and philosophical pagentry.
After the tragic climax of Part One, Faust wakes up in a pleasant field and seems to have no memory of his affair with Gretchen. Next thing we know, he and Mephistopheles are entertaining an incompetent emperor and his court with no explanation. For a long while, events don't seem to have anything to do with the compelling drama of the first part. We've got talking flowers, and Faust running around disguised as Plutus, and Mephistopheles inventing paper money, and all kinds of silly song and dance, making many readers wonder just what the hell is going on here.
The most recognizable scene from Part Two is likely when Faust enters the realm of "Eternal Mothers", symbolizing the constant creative force behind life, and brings back the shades of Helen and Paris to delight the Emperor. It is interesting that this is the first act he has done independently since he got involved with the Devil. In Part One, Mephistopheles refers to himself as the "negater," who has ended many lives, but as many as he kills, more are born. Faust hilariously asked him why he doesn't then try to do something else, pointing out the absurdity of the Devil's mission. Creation has already happened and Nature is an unstoppable force, but the Devil keeps trying to negate God's work in vain. Therefore, it is likely Faust is able to act more of his own accord in Part Two, because the Mothers represents this vital creative force of Nature, a primal realm in which the Devil has no authority or power.
After this scene, much of the play involves Faust searching for Helen, and eventually marrying her, because he has fallen in love with her ideal. It's a grand romance, far more epic in scale than Part One, involving all manner of monsters, demi-gods, and characters from classical mythology which represent psychological archetypes. I don't know how Goethe expected this ambitious play to be staged, since there seems to be a constant requirement for special effects and a huge cast for portrayals of countless personages, both humanoid and inhuman. There's explosions and earthquakes. There are centaurs, griffins, sphinxes, giant ants, hippocampi, and sea dragons. The god Proteus appears as a giant sea turtle before transforming into a noble and then into a dolphin. Characters ride atop sea-bulls and sea-rams--whatever they are. People burst into flames and disappear. There's even a little glowing homunculus floating around in a glass jar. It is quite chaotic and surreal. Overall, Part Two is much harder to understand than the first, and is also longer, so I understand why it might turn some readers off.
For me, however, this is where the play transforms from a memorable morality tale to one of the most quoted works of art in philosophy. The first part does not complete Goethe's arc for Faust. If experienced alone, you might assume that after Faust screws over Gretchen, he screws up his life, and ends up screwed in hell--which does not offer much new that we haven't seen before. As I hinted at in my review of Part One, I think what makes this play compelling is that Goethe's vision of Faust is so different from the traditional folklore regarding the character, as seen in the Marlowe version. Typically, the story of Dr. Faustus is a moral warning against hubris, and he gets his just punishment for dabbling in sorcery. Here, Faust is a sympathetic character, a good man who does not understand contentment for all his knowledge and skills. He is the embodiment of the Age of Enlightenment, and this play is a eulogy to the Enlightenment and a herald for the age of Modernity. As Nietzche has said, Socrates stood at the beginning of Enlightenment, seeing knowledge and truth as a promise, while Goethe's Faust is at rationality's exhausted end. For Faust, Enlightenment is a failed promise, with every new knowledge simply overturning what you thought you knew before, leaving the seeker stranded in an abyss of absurdity with no shore in sight. This is what makes him vulnerable to corruption by Satan.
But here's the most important concept from Part One that gets explained in Part Two. Spoiler ahead! Faust doesn't outright sell his soul to the devil like in other versions of the story. He makes a wager that Mephistopheles can have his soul IF Faust ever grows so tired of the absurdity of the neverending quest for knowledge that he gives up. In the end, Faust is saved. Why?Because Goethe is saying that we are not fools for wanting to learn more about ourselves and our world. It is what we do with that knowledge. Seeking vain pleasures and novel experiences misses the mark, but learning from our mistakes and pain and previous misconceptions and prejudices to better ourselves is a whole different kettle of fish. It's not enough to cram your brain with erudite references; it's how this knowledge transforms you from within. That's where wisdom emerges. Such is the ultimate way to serve God, because striving is part of human nature, so for God to bless humanity, God must bless such striving. You don't fully understand this until you've read Part Two.
And it is this second part that makes the entirety of "Faust" one of Goethe's most important achievements and a milestone in European thought, if not the book that red-pilled the entirety of Western civilization. Goethe chose to have Part Two inundated with figures of classical poets and characters because he was trying to depict how the evolution of art reflects the evolution of the human spirit. Perhaps not so ironically, "Faust" is a major step in the evolution of literature and of the world zeitgeist. He took one of the tenants of old school Christianity from one of the oldest books of the Bible (the Book of Job) and turned it on its head to give us an answer to the apparent absurdity of the modern era. It certainly deserves its place as one of the greatest works of poetry and fantasy ever written.
SCORE: While most readers will find Part One more accessible, I rated it a 4 out of 5. Part Two, while feeling more like a hallucinatory absence seizure, cements Goethe's life work as a philosophical and artistic masterpiece, and thus deserves the full 5 out of 5. It should certainly NEVER be skipped!
WORD OF THE DAY: Cohobate
SUGGESTED MUSICAL PAIRING: "Mephisto" by Depeche Mode