uuugghhhhhhhh
This book was not good. It was recommended to me as one of the scariest books that person had ever read, which, lol. It had enjoyable moments--in the beginning, it seemed like it was going to be a fast-paced supernatural thriller, grounded in the reality of two cops just doing their jobs--but it quickly became very, very boring. Sluggish. Ill-paced. The pacing really was its most damnable trait (though far from its only one). The narrative was bogged down by perspectives from literally every character--the protagonists, their friends, their spouses, their superiors, random cops on the street, pedestrians, murder victims only present for a page and a half, those victims' relatives, this is not an exaggeration--as well as telling the same sequences over and over again. First you'd hear it from Becky's POV with jumps into the heads of people around her; then you'd get the same sequence narrated by the werewolves; then maybe you'd get it again from a third party, ruminating on it; then maybe you'd get it again from Becky as she thought about it for a second time. The story was bloated with unnecessary characters and diversions, subplots that never came to fruition, hysterically misplaced romantic tension, pages upon pages of characters calmly pondering that romantic tension while literally in fear for their lives, throwaway characterizations that served no purpose but to demonize the people you weren't meant to sympathize with or uplift the ones you were, and oh my god, the wolves! The utterly ridiculous, noble savage wolves!
The concept was interesting: rather than a supernatural creature, part man, part wolf~, the wolfen are evolutionary marvels, offshoots of actual wolves some millennia ago that then developed into perfectly engineered apex predators. That's a good take on werewolves I haven't seen before, and one that neatly eliminates the tiresome trope of the pained, cursed man beneath the wolf skin, or the struggle in those hunted of killing another human being. But boy, that did not make up for everything else that was wrong with this book. The two protagonists were just dreadful, two-dimensional, deeply uninteresting cops who never seem to make mistakes, at least by reputation, which is really all we have to go on with everything from their police record to their interpersonal relationships. Apparently Becky and Wilson are the greatest cops on the force, possibly in the entire world; apparently Becky and her husband are happy and satisfied until her partner confesses his sudden and inexplicable obsession with her (that isn't then met with shock and disgust that the gross old man who has literally been treating her like a secretary and chauffeur has been doing so because he really just loves her so very much). But do we ever see that on the page? Nope. Becky and Wilson fuck up and lose their standing in the force almost immediately when they latch onto the werewolf case. Becky and Dick only interact a few times and are cool at best, except the one time they have really vigorous sex for some?? reason??? The entire thread of political corruption and sweeping things under the rug gets dropped about two-thirds of the way through; the Dick-Becky-Wilson love triangle exists almost entirely in Becky's and Wilsons thoughts about the Dick-Becky-Wilson love triangle.
But more than anything else, this book was just flat out boring. The prose was staid and stiff, prosaic and about as interesting to plod through as plain, soggy oatmeal. Constant telling rather than showing. Instead of seeing two characters interact with the tension between them, we are treated to 8 or 12 paragraphs of inner dialogue of them ruminating on the tension between them. Over and over and over again. For a book of less than 300 pages, it would not end, and though a lot seemed to be happening, none of it jumped off the page, none of it grabbed you and held on. Not even the climax, which, I guess, was supposed to be exciting? But was mostly our intrepid heroes standing in the cold, and the werewolves being noble and angry and sad. And then more standing, and then a shootout that didn't make much sense, ended abruptly, and--the book was over. What???