As usual I've read each tale, as I've come to it. The first two are Saintly classics, the last one less so.
The Man who was Clever
I’m going to admit to being a bit confused with the tangled chronology of all this. In the introduction, Charteris says that these are the first Saint tales, however this is the third book (but apparently one of those books does make direct reference to events in these stories, so that don’t sound right). No doubt it’s just a matter of when the stories were written versus whatever order the publisher decided to put them out in, although alternatively it might be a ruse by Templar himself to confuse and befuddle us before he makes his big move.
That confusion though might help to explain e how it is that even though this is clearly set up as being The Saint’s first tale, it feels so fully formed. The Saint’s manifesto is already there in the most fulsome and lucid terms (fortunately he does drop the big and worthy speeches about it though); there’s his mastery of disguise and the long game and close quarter combat; the Saintly Gang are here; and we have a cameo from Patricia Holm. In short it is the kind of fresh, energetic and rollicking fun that you’d expect from a Saint story, with no faltering or tottering of any description. Simon Templar can impose himself from nowhere into a room, and so it feels appropriate that his debut tale arrives not as a rough sketch, but already brilliantly shiny and polished.
It’s just a shame he hasn’t met Teal yet….
The Policeman with Wings
Given the way the series developed, it must have been a source of bitter regret to Charteris that the first conversation between Mr Teal and The Saint actually takes place without witnesses. In fact, so does the second one. This is by any measure bizarre. After Simon, Teal is the most fully realised and crucially important character in these stories. What’s more when Teal finally does arrive on the page – at their third encounter – he is already his fully formed, lugubrious self. Like Simon in the previous tale, he isn’t a pencil sketch which needs work, but already fully developed to every gum chewing mannerism. It’s a crime then, as great as Simon’s most daring exploits that we don’t get to see the first moment they laid eyes on each other. With what carefree and gay witticism did Simon first greet Teal? And, after a lazy eyed moment on contemplation, how did Teal respond?
A frequently tense and delightful yarn of kidnapping, jewel theft and true love. Even for a Saint tale, it feels somewhat on the slight aide, but there’s no doubting the entertainment value.
The Lawless Lady
Reading a tale with the relatively uncharismatic Dicky Tremayne at the centre just slaps it into the reader’s face just what a stroke of genius Charteris had when he created Simon Templar. This adventure on the Mediterranean is perfectly serviceable, but the only bits which sparkle are the beginning and the end, when The Saint – as he always does – rivets us charmingly to attention.