What do you think?
Rate this book


172 pages, Paperback
Published August 1, 2002
Perhaps I was expecting too much from very early (pre-Civil War) science fiction. But the stories don't seem to have aged as well as similar gothic / science fiction stories from contemporaries like Mary Shelley or Edgar Allen Poe. The 19th century casual racism is all too prominent and cringeworthy, the language often seems way too flowery, and character motivations often feel at least a bit "off".
For example, starting with the title story, "The Diamond Lens", while it may be interesting to have the narrator and primary character be the prototypical mad scientist, . Add in some anti-semitism on top, and the motivation is sickening. I suppose the idea is to portray just how obsessed the narrator is, but it still doesn't feel right.
As other reviewers have noted, "The Wondersmith"'s whole "gypsies vs. Christians" plot is really offensive, with the villains being too broadly painted and cartoonish. I know this is considered an early robots attacking story, but it seems more a possessed doll story.
So, some interesting early speculative fiction, but marred by storytelling choices that have not aged at all well, even by standards for contemporary works.