Average rating: 3.6/5 stars. A slightly-hotter-than-lukewarm score for this one.
Before the blockbuster series that would become an international phenomenon, A Game of Thrones, George R. R. Martin wrote short science fiction stories centered around love, loneliness, and giant dream-spiders.
I wasn’t blown away by this collection like I wanted to. I was left wanting more.
Perhaps what was most surprising to me is that Martin’s ideas aren’t unique or reality-shifting. He’s become so famous, but his writing is merely competent and never awe-inducing.
But Martin succeeds at characters and building emotion. The best stories in this collection are ones where Martin leans on those strengths, strengths that would later make him a household name. Stories like ”The Lonely Songs of Laren Dorr” and ”…For A Single Yesterday” rocket above the others by relying on a small cast of strong characters with strong philosophical differences. This creates a natural tension that sings.
Perhaps—and this is just conjecture—Martin was still feeling out his style here and that’s why some of these tales feel so uneven alongside each other. Or maybe this is how he is. This was my first full collection or book of his, so I’ll be interested to know as my adventures take me onward!
”This Tower of Ashes” - 4/5
Pretty solid start to the anthology. After a man’s ex-wife and her lover go to the bury the hatchet between them, the man takes them into the dangerous forest of their alien planet. Full of jealousy, angst, and dread, the story explores the idea of getting over the hurt of love lost.
I especially appreciated the mature turn of the main character. Even in the ambiguity of the ending, I loved how by the end he stands strong despite it all. Where the idea isn’t mind-blowing, it’s the way Martin writes characters that makes this story far above average.
”Patrick Henry, Jupiter, and the Little Red Brick Spaceship” - 3.75/5
I loved the way Martin framed this story: space salvagers discover a broken-down ship orbiting the Earth and the story of the ship slowly revealed. Not philosophically mind-blowing, teeming with rich ideas, or led by great characters, this story is function over form. A decent little idea that never overstates its simple premise.
”Men of Greywater Station” with Howard Waldrop - 2.5/5
This was far too long for what it was. And that’s saying something for a 38 page story. Whereas the idea of a fungal zombie attack on an alien research station. The characters were meh. The twist was meh. The execution was meh.
Mind you, it wasn’t bad. Just very wishy-washy, middle of the road, lame—whatever word tickles your fancy.
”The Lonely Songs of Laren Dorr” - 5/5
I loved this story. While so simple of a vignette, there was something so captivating about this fantastic world and these two leads. Star-crossed romance with a dark brooding male lead, while the female lead is a sleek, world-hopping woman desperate to find her one true love.
I am a sucker for fantastic/science fiction romance, so I was the target market for this story.
And just like a good short story, it had me yearning for more. I’ve been wondering what the wide appeal of Martin is. This story showed me.
”Night of the Vampyres” - 2/5
Now to a type of story I’m not the target market of. While the idea of a near-futures political thriller about racial tensions sounds plausible and interesting and intriguing, Martin’s focus lacks the oomph it would need to be truly great. I usually find dogfights to be too unwieldy to grasp—the action sequences often too quick and the tension too short. I found this story was no different than the norm.
I will admit that the political unrest, the ambiguity of the attack being a false flag attack, and the realism of political pundits saved this story from being one-dimensional and a 1/5.
Also—what a lame bait and switch! The “vampyres” are the names of the jets that are being flown. Here I was hoping for actual GRRM Vampyres.
”The Runners” - 4.5/5
Short, sweet, and to the point! This one felt like a classic 60s-70s short story: a simple idea, a quick presentation, and a nice twist to make you rethink it. Wish more of Martin’s stories were like this!
”Night Shift” - 2/5
This might be it. The worst story of the collection. Martin mentioned in the introduction—and yes, I am a nerd who reads introductions—that this was his earliest story in the collection. . .
Boy, can you tell. This story is inane and far too long for what it is, which is just showing the difference in the romance of spaceflight and the reality of spaceflight. Cut this story in half and you might just have a better story. But even then, it’s a very shallow concept of a story.
” ‘…For A Single Yesterday’” - 5/5
A solemn tale about rebuilding after losing it all. Framed after the apocalypse, a commune survives on the edge of the world. One of the big players of this commune is a guitarist who “timetrips” using a drug that lets him relive memories.
I loved the moral quandary of the drug. Should the guitarist be allowed to timetrip when the drug could be used to benefit the community better? Or should he be allowed to “visit” his love? Is it better to move on from hurt, or does that endanger your humanity?
Some very good questions and solid writing. Perhaps the best story of the collection.
”And Seven Times Never Kill Man” - 4/5
Not a bad way to end!
This final story was a bit long—40 pages—and at first dragged. But once it got going, it really went off.
The idea of some aggressive colonizer religion versus a peaceful native religion has been done before ad nauseam. That being said, Martin ends the story with a lesson: that these beliefs will turn inward and eat away at the aggressors themselves, turning on themselves.
I think this story could’ve been tightened up, but it still was well-done. Wish he’d have named the bitter speaker—or better yet told us how she did elsewhere in the galaxy.
But I guess that’s a sign of a good short story. You want more.