I was eager to read this holiday collection from Harlequin, as its set in the little-used Renaissance period. Unfortunately, it wasn't quite all I hoped it would be.
Christmas at Court by Blythe Gifford - ⭐⭐
Set between 1483-1485, our pair, Lady Alice and Sir John, find their marriage alliance in parallel with the upstart Henry Tudor and his promise to wed Elizabeth of York and overthrow Richard III. This story was about 90% intrigue and 10% romance, and I confess I was confused about how Alice's and John's relationship was so reliant on Henry's and Elizabeth's. Perhaps if this had been a full-length novel, the political crises could've been spaced out more evenly, and the romance given room to grow. As it is, Alice and John spent pretty much all of their time together doubting each other and their familial alliances, so I'm not really sure what they saw in each other, beyond the initial attraction and lust. I don't really believe they could've had a HEA, considering they barely knew each other and didn't really seem to trust each other. A disappointment, to be sure.
Secrets of the Queen's Lady by Jenni Fletcher - ⭐⭐
Set in 1540. I found this story totally unbelievable, unfortunately. Pippa, our heroine, was never able to get out of her own way, and her reasons for resisting Kit's woo were thin, at best. We romance readers are tired of heroes being treated badly by one woman in their life and swearing off marriage - and unfortunately, that's basically Pippa's stance here. Plus she makes a HUGE deal out of being 7 years older than Kit and how she thinks she'll just drag him down. Kit's no real prize, either; his answer to all of his woes is basically to run away. He doesn't care about being disowned by his family (!). He felt too modern for this time period altogether, wanting to forge his own path and marry a woman to be his partner. And he gives Pippa way too much latitude to hurt him, especially after she calls him a boy to his face. The cherry on top of this impossibly implausible cake? Anne of Cleves as matchmaker. Yeah, no, sorry, not buying that at all 😒
His Mistletoe Lady by Amanda McCabe - ⭐⭐⭐⭐
By far the best of the bunch, IMO. Set in 1554, at the Christmas Court of Queen Mary, this story is the perfect blend of court intrigue and holiday romance. We meet our pair, Catherine Greaves and Don Diego de Vasquez, as they arrive in London for very different reasons: Catherine and her mother are there to plead for her father's life - he's been locked in the Tower as a traitor as part of the Wyatt rebellion - while Diego has been summoned to gather intelligence about other plots against the Queen. The two meet and, more or less in spite of themselves, begin to fall in love in the midst of the holiday revelry. Diego's contact on the inside is none other than Catherine's father, a secret that's kept from everyone save about 3 people, which, being an honorable man, he thinks puts Catherine out of his reach. Diego is worldly and sophisticated, which Catherine thinks puts him beyond *her* reach. She's determined to make merry while she can, though, and Diego is only too happy to oblige.
There are quite a few steamy kisses - which seem out of place but could be put down to the passionate nature of the Spanish, I suppose 😄 - but otherwise, this is a well-rounded, believable romance. There's even a bit of action at the end, before the obligatory confessions of love. Well done to Ms. McCabe!