What do you think?
Rate this book
Derkholm #1
Fauler Zauber
In ihrem humorvollen High-Fantasy-Roman erzählt die preisgekrönte britische Autorin Diana Wynne Jones, wie sich eine magische Welt als lukrative Geschäftsidee entpuppt.
Ausnahmslos alle – die Zauberer, Soldaten, Bauern, Drachen und Elfen – haben die Nase voll von Mr. Chesneys „Pilgerfahrten“. Jahr für Jahr fallen Touristengruppen aus der benachbarten Welt ein, um ein klassisches Fantasy-Abenteuer zu erleben – mit allem, was dazu gehört: bösen Magierinnen, gefährlichen Drachen und dem furchteinflößenden Dunklen Fürsten. Stets werden andere Bewohner des Reiches dazu auserwählt, diese Rollen zu übernehmen.
Aber dieses Jahr reicht es den Leuten. Mr. Chesney mag einen mächtigen Dämon an seiner Seite haben, doch ein Orakel weiß Rat. Nun ist es an Zauberer Derk und seiner Familie aus Menschen und Greifen, den Verwüstungen Einhalt zu gebieten und ihre Welt zu retten.
Ausnahmslos alle – die Zauberer, Soldaten, Bauern, Drachen und Elfen – haben die Nase voll von Mr. Chesneys „Pilgerfahrten“. Jahr für Jahr fallen Touristengruppen aus der benachbarten Welt ein, um ein klassisches Fantasy-Abenteuer zu erleben – mit allem, was dazu gehört: bösen Magierinnen, gefährlichen Drachen und dem furchteinflößenden Dunklen Fürsten. Stets werden andere Bewohner des Reiches dazu auserwählt, diese Rollen zu übernehmen.
Aber dieses Jahr reicht es den Leuten. Mr. Chesney mag einen mächtigen Dämon an seiner Seite haben, doch ein Orakel weiß Rat. Nun ist es an Zauberer Derk und seiner Familie aus Menschen und Greifen, den Verwüstungen Einhalt zu gebieten und ihre Welt zu retten.
480 pages, Paperback
First published November 5, 1998
387 people are currently reading
16967 people want to read
About the author
Diana Wynne Jones
162 books12.1k followersDiana Wynne Jones was a celebrated British writer best known for her inventive and influential works of fantasy for children and young adults. Her stories often combined magical worlds with science fiction elements, parallel universes, and a sharp sense of humor. Among her most beloved books are Howl's Moving Castle, the Chrestomanci series, The Dalemark Quartet, Dark Lord of Derkholm, and the satirical The Tough Guide to Fantasyland. Her work gained renewed attention and readership with the popularity of the Harry Potter series, to which her books have frequently been compared.
Admired by authors such as Neil Gaiman, Philip Pullman, and J.K. Rowling, Jones was a major influence on the landscape of modern fantasy. She received numerous accolades throughout her career, including the Guardian Children's Fiction Prize, two Mythopoeic Awards, the Karl Edward Wagner Award, and the World Fantasy Award for Life Achievement. In 2004, Howl's Moving Castle was adapted into an acclaimed animated film by Hayao Miyazaki, further expanding her global audience.
Jones studied at Oxford, where she attended lectures by both C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien. She began writing professionally in the 1960s and remained active until her death in 2011. Her final novel, The Islands of Chaldea, was completed posthumously by her sister Ursula Jones.
Admired by authors such as Neil Gaiman, Philip Pullman, and J.K. Rowling, Jones was a major influence on the landscape of modern fantasy. She received numerous accolades throughout her career, including the Guardian Children's Fiction Prize, two Mythopoeic Awards, the Karl Edward Wagner Award, and the World Fantasy Award for Life Achievement. In 2004, Howl's Moving Castle was adapted into an acclaimed animated film by Hayao Miyazaki, further expanding her global audience.
Jones studied at Oxford, where she attended lectures by both C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien. She began writing professionally in the 1960s and remained active until her death in 2011. Her final novel, The Islands of Chaldea, was completed posthumously by her sister Ursula Jones.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,138 reviews
October 26, 2024
The feel of this book reminded me of Terry Pratchett - and coming from me, it’s quite a praise. Just like Pratchett, this is marketed as funny, and quite a bit of it is, but what’s underneath is seriously angry, in a way that people who get how the world works are bound to be.
The funny part of it is supposed to be Jones making fun of moth-eaten fantasy cliches — or rather of people expecting those cliches in a fantasy book. But for that I invite you to pick up a sort-of companion to this, a classic — The Tough Guide to Fantasyland, a pseudo-encyclopedia/guidebook to the travelers on tours to generic Fantasyland, with the highlights including STEW ("what you are served to eat every single time"), HORSES ("It therefore seems probable that they breed by pollination"), MISSING HEIRS ("At any given time, half the COUNTRIES in Fantasyland will have mislaid their Crown PRINCESS/PRINCE") and BANDITS ("employed by the Management to make the early stages of the Tour more interesting"). That book is indeed hilarious both for fantasy writers and fantasy readers.
But this book is not that. Here we get to see those actually living in that “Fantasyland”, a place which Mr. Chesney, a cynical businessman from the world uncannily similar to our own, has enslaved to his wishes and uses for his enrichment, mostly through running very expensive Pilgrim tours for those from “our” world who desire genetic Fantasyland experience, willing to throw away huge amounts of money to fight the Dark Lord. The denizens of the Fantasyland, meanwhile, every year are obliged to provide the tour experiences that cost them lives and livelihoods while Pilgrims get to wave swords round and a few “expendables” among them get conveniently dispatched. But this year the patience of everyone has worn thin, and while wizard Derk (who’d rather be doing some magical genetic engineering any day) is forced to take up the Dark Lord mantle a series of events that may topple Mr. Chesney’s cold business rule is set in motion.
This could have been a fun adventure romp, or a biting satire, an overtourism and colonialism critique, or a light-hearted parody of fantasy genre — but in Jones’s hands it becomes not just all that but also a deeply human story, touching on the family ties and family fears, and people reaching their breaking points in decidedly non-stereotypically-heroic ways. What starts as a promise of fun parody grows to something much more serious, but subtly, low-key, and yet with a bucketload of uneasy tension.
This book somehow pulls off the trick that for me tends to fail in other books - combining gentle humor moments of flying pigs and homicidal geese with unexpected whiplash scenes of assault and marriage breakup and murder. Usually such tonal shift would have given me a whiplash, but here for me it underscored the contrast between wanting to live a normal human life and the devastation that the invasion of Fantasyland by unscrupulous businessmen brings. It’s tense and uneasy more than anything, and I appreciate the skill with which Jones does it.
And yet it never stops to being just a message story. It’s an actually GOOD story, and that’s what makes it stand out and avoid didactic boredom. Jones trusts her readers, whatever their ages may be, to think for themselves, and I appreciate it.
5 stars. It’s my 3rd time reading it, and it never gets stale.
Buddy read with Nastya.
——————
Also posted on my blog.
The funny part of it is supposed to be Jones making fun of moth-eaten fantasy cliches — or rather of people expecting those cliches in a fantasy book. But for that I invite you to pick up a sort-of companion to this, a classic — The Tough Guide to Fantasyland, a pseudo-encyclopedia/guidebook to the travelers on tours to generic Fantasyland, with the highlights including STEW ("what you are served to eat every single time"), HORSES ("It therefore seems probable that they breed by pollination"), MISSING HEIRS ("At any given time, half the COUNTRIES in Fantasyland will have mislaid their Crown PRINCESS/PRINCE") and BANDITS ("employed by the Management to make the early stages of the Tour more interesting"). That book is indeed hilarious both for fantasy writers and fantasy readers.
But this book is not that. Here we get to see those actually living in that “Fantasyland”, a place which Mr. Chesney, a cynical businessman from the world uncannily similar to our own, has enslaved to his wishes and uses for his enrichment, mostly through running very expensive Pilgrim tours for those from “our” world who desire genetic Fantasyland experience, willing to throw away huge amounts of money to fight the Dark Lord. The denizens of the Fantasyland, meanwhile, every year are obliged to provide the tour experiences that cost them lives and livelihoods while Pilgrims get to wave swords round and a few “expendables” among them get conveniently dispatched. But this year the patience of everyone has worn thin, and while wizard Derk (who’d rather be doing some magical genetic engineering any day) is forced to take up the Dark Lord mantle a series of events that may topple Mr. Chesney’s cold business rule is set in motion.
“If I ever bred a piranha with a hyena, I’d call it a Chesney,” Derk said.
This could have been a fun adventure romp, or a biting satire, an overtourism and colonialism critique, or a light-hearted parody of fantasy genre — but in Jones’s hands it becomes not just all that but also a deeply human story, touching on the family ties and family fears, and people reaching their breaking points in decidedly non-stereotypically-heroic ways. What starts as a promise of fun parody grows to something much more serious, but subtly, low-key, and yet with a bucketload of uneasy tension.
This book somehow pulls off the trick that for me tends to fail in other books - combining gentle humor moments of flying pigs and homicidal geese with unexpected whiplash scenes of assault and marriage breakup and murder. Usually such tonal shift would have given me a whiplash, but here for me it underscored the contrast between wanting to live a normal human life and the devastation that the invasion of Fantasyland by unscrupulous businessmen brings. It’s tense and uneasy more than anything, and I appreciate the skill with which Jones does it.
And yet it never stops to being just a message story. It’s an actually GOOD story, and that’s what makes it stand out and avoid didactic boredom. Jones trusts her readers, whatever their ages may be, to think for themselves, and I appreciate it.
“No living creature has the right to claim wisdom. There is always more to find out. I should know that. I imagine you know it, too, Wizard.”
“I’ve never ever felt wise,” Derk said frankly. “But I suppose it is a temptation, to stare into distance and make people think you are.”
“It’s humbug,” said the dragon. “It’s also stupid. It stops you learning more.”
5 stars. It’s my 3rd time reading it, and it never gets stale.
Buddy read with Nastya.
——————
Also posted on my blog.
August 23, 2017
Full review now posted!
Original review can be found at Booknest.
You’ve probably heard it said that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. I think that’s true to an extent, but there is an art form that goes beyond imitation that, when done well, can often be the best representation of that which it set out to mock. Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen is a perfect example of this. She set out to mock gothic literature, which she did beautifully, but what impresses me so much about that story is that she managed to craft a near-perfect gothic novel as the vehicle for her parody. Thus far, it remains my favorite example of a gothic novel, even though the entire book was written as a way to poke fun of the genre.
In Dark Lord of Derkholm, Jones accomplishes the same for classic fantasy, particularly the subgenre of portal fantasy. Here, we have a beautifully crafted fantasy world that basks in its own cliches. But there’s something plaguing this world: Mr. Chesney, a business mogul from a magic-free planet that must be ours, has basically enslaved this lovely world to his Pilgrim Tours, a way for people from our world to experience a fantasy adventure. While the residents of this fantasy world are supposedly reimbursed from their troubles, everyone is miserable and just wants out of the contract binding them to Mr. Chesney. So they select as the Dark Lord for this year the bumbling, affable, country-bumpkin Wizard Derk, with hopes that he’ll fail so miserably that Mr. Chesney will give up and go home. But Chesney has more invested in this world than they know. And Derk has built for himself a wonderfully supportive and capable family, including five griffins, and they are determined to help him succeed. Hilarity ensues.
This was such a funny book. It’s categorized as YA, but it felt more like some weird hybrid of middle grade and adult fantasy because of the tone. I don’t know how to describe it exactly except to say that the protagonists didn’t feel like YA protagonists. I loved watching Jones take cherished cliches and turn them on their heads. The cast of characters she built were incredibly varied, and the vast majority of them were very likable and sympathetic. I especially loved the Derk’s seven children, two human and five griffins. The siblings’ relationships with one another were wonderful. The premise of the book was very tongue-in-cheek, but Jones managed to insert an impressive amount of drama into such a short little book. So much was happening, and there were very few dull moments. (The marching, though. Too much marching.) Also, there were plot twists! Ones that I actually didn’t guess!
After the first couple of chapters, I stopped thinking of this as a parody and started thinking about it as a legitimate fantasy novel in its own right. The only book I had read by Jones prior to this was Howl’s Moving Castle, which is one of my favorites. I’m so happy that I enjoyed this. It wasn’t perfect, but it was still fantastic. I’ll definitely be reading its sequel, Year of the Griffin!
Original review can be found at Booknest.
You’ve probably heard it said that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. I think that’s true to an extent, but there is an art form that goes beyond imitation that, when done well, can often be the best representation of that which it set out to mock. Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen is a perfect example of this. She set out to mock gothic literature, which she did beautifully, but what impresses me so much about that story is that she managed to craft a near-perfect gothic novel as the vehicle for her parody. Thus far, it remains my favorite example of a gothic novel, even though the entire book was written as a way to poke fun of the genre.
In Dark Lord of Derkholm, Jones accomplishes the same for classic fantasy, particularly the subgenre of portal fantasy. Here, we have a beautifully crafted fantasy world that basks in its own cliches. But there’s something plaguing this world: Mr. Chesney, a business mogul from a magic-free planet that must be ours, has basically enslaved this lovely world to his Pilgrim Tours, a way for people from our world to experience a fantasy adventure. While the residents of this fantasy world are supposedly reimbursed from their troubles, everyone is miserable and just wants out of the contract binding them to Mr. Chesney. So they select as the Dark Lord for this year the bumbling, affable, country-bumpkin Wizard Derk, with hopes that he’ll fail so miserably that Mr. Chesney will give up and go home. But Chesney has more invested in this world than they know. And Derk has built for himself a wonderfully supportive and capable family, including five griffins, and they are determined to help him succeed. Hilarity ensues.
This was such a funny book. It’s categorized as YA, but it felt more like some weird hybrid of middle grade and adult fantasy because of the tone. I don’t know how to describe it exactly except to say that the protagonists didn’t feel like YA protagonists. I loved watching Jones take cherished cliches and turn them on their heads. The cast of characters she built were incredibly varied, and the vast majority of them were very likable and sympathetic. I especially loved the Derk’s seven children, two human and five griffins. The siblings’ relationships with one another were wonderful. The premise of the book was very tongue-in-cheek, but Jones managed to insert an impressive amount of drama into such a short little book. So much was happening, and there were very few dull moments. (The marching, though. Too much marching.) Also, there were plot twists! Ones that I actually didn’t guess!
After the first couple of chapters, I stopped thinking of this as a parody and started thinking about it as a legitimate fantasy novel in its own right. The only book I had read by Jones prior to this was Howl’s Moving Castle, which is one of my favorites. I’m so happy that I enjoyed this. It wasn’t perfect, but it was still fantastic. I’ll definitely be reading its sequel, Year of the Griffin!
April 30, 2014
Just over six years ago I met the person I want to spend my entire life with, in that time I was very quickly made aware of her affection towards the fantasy author Diana Wynne Jones and regularly told to give her a try. Being such a considerate husband I finally relented on the proviso that she choose me one that wasn't for kids, wasn't too massive and was one of her better novels. Apparently the first two choices are already lent to a friend of ours and so I was provided with a well loved copy of this Derkholm book. I quite enjoyed it, not that I'm surprised by this fact, she's a highly awarded and regarded author in the genre by all those in the know, and those that don't know are quite probably the type to gush over something interminably "epic".
The Dark Lord of Derkholm is actually just the wizard Derk, prophesied by an oracle to be the chosen one, the wizard who would finally bring the world peace and free it from an evil overlord who holds the world in his vice-like grip via a portal from Earth. Derk is an outcast in the wizard community, a man who prefers to invent interesting new creatures rather than focus on more every day spells such as conjuring feasts and enchantment. Every year a wizard is chosen to be the Dark Lord for a series of tourist parties from Earth arranged by the villainous bean counter Mr Chesney, a position of great importance as you're responsible for keeping the entire planet organised to service the tourists or face death by Chesney's pocket demon. How the hell did she come up with this stuff? Derk has help from his loving family of wizards in training and magical creatures adopted as children, even the genetically altered flying pigs are dragged in to things despite their only real desire in life to nuzzle their father, Derk.
The plot is labyrinthine, the characters plentiful, the prose incredibly playful, but it is the interraction between the many members of Derk's family that provide the real pleasure of this novel, they're all interesting and unique creations and they all have their own relationships with each other, factions and favourites etc, but as it's still technically a novel aimed at the teenage market they're all very loving towards each other when all is said and done. The other great skill displayed is that of world building without info dumps, the information is provided in short bursts as it naturally comes up in each chapter, sometimes only obliquely referenced and other times actually experienced by a character, in direct contrast to one of the major issues I have with most other books in the fantasy genre, "epic" books that take six pages to discuss the history of a valley that you'll never come across again in an entire sixteen novel sequence type of thing.
I won't be reading more of this stuff I'm sure but I had a great time discovering Diana Wynne Jones all the same.
The Dark Lord of Derkholm is actually just the wizard Derk, prophesied by an oracle to be the chosen one, the wizard who would finally bring the world peace and free it from an evil overlord who holds the world in his vice-like grip via a portal from Earth. Derk is an outcast in the wizard community, a man who prefers to invent interesting new creatures rather than focus on more every day spells such as conjuring feasts and enchantment. Every year a wizard is chosen to be the Dark Lord for a series of tourist parties from Earth arranged by the villainous bean counter Mr Chesney, a position of great importance as you're responsible for keeping the entire planet organised to service the tourists or face death by Chesney's pocket demon. How the hell did she come up with this stuff? Derk has help from his loving family of wizards in training and magical creatures adopted as children, even the genetically altered flying pigs are dragged in to things despite their only real desire in life to nuzzle their father, Derk.
The plot is labyrinthine, the characters plentiful, the prose incredibly playful, but it is the interraction between the many members of Derk's family that provide the real pleasure of this novel, they're all interesting and unique creations and they all have their own relationships with each other, factions and favourites etc, but as it's still technically a novel aimed at the teenage market they're all very loving towards each other when all is said and done. The other great skill displayed is that of world building without info dumps, the information is provided in short bursts as it naturally comes up in each chapter, sometimes only obliquely referenced and other times actually experienced by a character, in direct contrast to one of the major issues I have with most other books in the fantasy genre, "epic" books that take six pages to discuss the history of a valley that you'll never come across again in an entire sixteen novel sequence type of thing.
I won't be reading more of this stuff I'm sure but I had a great time discovering Diana Wynne Jones all the same.
December 8, 2016
http://bookslifewine.com/r-dark-lord-...
DNF at 45%
I've been sitting on Dark Lord of Derkholm for a while now. Initially I really liked it and found it humorous. It reminded me of Pratchett's DiscWorld a bit (in its humor only).
So color me shocked when I ran into a vaguely worded but pretty obvious gang sexual assault. There was no need for it but it still happened. I was shocked to find something so...dark in a humorous book.
The gang (rape?)/sexual assault just...threw me out of the book and I put it down.
That was in Jan 2015.
It's now December 2016...and I decided to call it quits. I hate rape and sexual abuse.
DNF at 45%
I've been sitting on Dark Lord of Derkholm for a while now. Initially I really liked it and found it humorous. It reminded me of Pratchett's DiscWorld a bit (in its humor only).
So color me shocked when I ran into a vaguely worded but pretty obvious gang sexual assault. There was no need for it but it still happened. I was shocked to find something so...dark in a humorous book.
The gang (rape?)/sexual assault just...threw me out of the book and I put it down.
That was in Jan 2015.
It's now December 2016...and I decided to call it quits. I hate rape and sexual abuse.
October 14, 2023
I had forgotten how utterly brilliant and hilarious this book was. Listening to the audiobook (a very fine production), I found myself walking around grinning, laughing out loud, and wanting to punch Mr. Chesney. All the feelings!
January 4, 2020
Rereading via the Audible audiobook which is very good. I'd forgotten so many details and, indeed, the whole second half of the book since I first read this back in 2011. It is such a fun and enjoyable book. Original review below.
=========
Imagine that your world has real elves, dragons, wizards, and all those items necessary for a good fantasy tale. Then imagine that an enterprising person from an "otherworld" much like ours stumbled through a portal and discovered this real "fantasy" world.
Forty years later you might have a problem much like that in this book where Mr. Chesney's Pilgrim Parties come on tour wanting to enjoy a classic fantasy adventure. The only problem is that Mr. Chesney's contract is so airtight that it devastates the fantasy world and everyone is at their wits' end trying to fulfill their obligations. So when the Light Oracle and the Dark Oracle tell the ruling council what to do to end this devastation, no one asks questions.
Except, that is, for Wizard Derk since part of the requirement is that he becomes this year's Dark Wizard. He's a mild mannered wizard who only wants to develop new forms of animals, but finds his life turned into an increasing spiral of trying to overcome chaos.
This is a unique concept for a story that hooked me from the beginning. When you add in Diana Wynne Jones' brand of humor you will understand why I read this book in a dead heat in one day, occasionally cackling with laughter ... which everyone got used to as the day progressed. I will never again be able to say, "when pigs fly" without cracking up.
Get this book and read it.
UPDATE
I'm rereading this for some light bedtime entertainment. Will it be as enjoyable the second time around? Let's find out. The answer to that question: yes. Yes it is.
=========
Imagine that your world has real elves, dragons, wizards, and all those items necessary for a good fantasy tale. Then imagine that an enterprising person from an "otherworld" much like ours stumbled through a portal and discovered this real "fantasy" world.
Forty years later you might have a problem much like that in this book where Mr. Chesney's Pilgrim Parties come on tour wanting to enjoy a classic fantasy adventure. The only problem is that Mr. Chesney's contract is so airtight that it devastates the fantasy world and everyone is at their wits' end trying to fulfill their obligations. So when the Light Oracle and the Dark Oracle tell the ruling council what to do to end this devastation, no one asks questions.
Except, that is, for Wizard Derk since part of the requirement is that he becomes this year's Dark Wizard. He's a mild mannered wizard who only wants to develop new forms of animals, but finds his life turned into an increasing spiral of trying to overcome chaos.
This is a unique concept for a story that hooked me from the beginning. When you add in Diana Wynne Jones' brand of humor you will understand why I read this book in a dead heat in one day, occasionally cackling with laughter ... which everyone got used to as the day progressed. I will never again be able to say, "when pigs fly" without cracking up.
Get this book and read it.
UPDATE
I'm rereading this for some light bedtime entertainment. Will it be as enjoyable the second time around? Let's find out. The answer to that question: yes. Yes it is.
May 29, 2012
From what I'd heard, this is meant to be a parody of the tropes of traditional fantasy - and all the tropes do seem to be represented - but , as a parody, I expected it to be much funnier than it was. Maybe it's just because when I think of parody I think of "lovingly tongue-in-cheek" but this book took itself far too seriously, in my opinion, to really be a funny send-up.
Coupled with that is the fact that there are just so many characters and things going on and it's hard to follow or to really emotionally connect with any of the characters. I mean, I get that part of the plot of the story was that there was so much going on and things were getting out of everyone's control... but it just seemed like it was too much. And there was one thing towards the end which tipped it over the edge - i.e.
Speaking of too much and too serious, there was some dark stuff that happened in this book, but it's all sort of glossed over either by magicking it away or by it not really happening.
I probably would've rated this a 2-star read for most of the book, but I liked the ending. It was a bit pat and even a touch anti-climactic, but it was a big 'ole HEA type fest which tugged the old heart strings.
Still, overall, it's probably 2.5, bumped up to three for leaving off with happy jujube vibes.
Coupled with that is the fact that there are just so many characters and things going on and it's hard to follow or to really emotionally connect with any of the characters. I mean, I get that part of the plot of the story was that there was so much going on and things were getting out of everyone's control... but it just seemed like it was too much. And there was one thing towards the end which tipped it over the edge - i.e.
Speaking of too much and too serious, there was some dark stuff that happened in this book, but it's all sort of glossed over either by magicking it away or by it not really happening.
I probably would've rated this a 2-star read for most of the book, but I liked the ending. It was a bit pat and even a touch anti-climactic, but it was a big 'ole HEA type fest which tugged the old heart strings.
Still, overall, it's probably 2.5, bumped up to three for leaving off with happy jujube vibes.
March 4, 2014
The Dark Lord of Derkholm is one of those novels that provides an entertaining story as well as subverting the typical ideas and expectations of the fantasy genre. Diana Wynne Jones is one of those authors who writes wittily and absurdly at the same time, weaving bizarre ideas together into a mix that perhaps should not work as well as it does.
The overall concept of this novel is one which hinges around the idea that people from our world (or at least a world very similar) travel across worlds into a fantasy land populated by peaceful groups of elves, wizards, dragons and so forth. The tourism company that manages these escapades happens to have made an arrangement with the people of this world, that every time a group is brought across a show of fantasy might and magic must be performed. A show that leads the tourists to believe that this world is one of magical battles and dark, evil lords. A kind of roleplaying adventure if you will.
The year in which the story begins features the Wizard Derk having been chosen to become this year's archetypal Dark Lord. Of course it also so happens that the inhabitants of this magical land have had enough of the tours, despite the tour organiser being backed by a powerful demon and so a plan begins to turn this year's tour into a means of removing the tours altogether.
I mentioned that this novel plays on the archetypes of fantasy cleverly. It does so by providing a world which pretends to be what people expect from a fantasy land, when in reality the inhabitants of this world are a little more settled and realistic than all of that. It is this subversion of fantasy that leads to plenty of humour and also plenty of clever moments within the book, and the major reason why I can recommend this novel as a fantasy book to investigate.
January 6, 2015
3.5 stars. Almost 4.0 (As I write this review, I'm actually rounding up to 4)
This was a fun read. I liked it better than Howl's Moving Castle, which I'd read earlier in 2014. There was a nice mixture of wit and magic, and some characters I could really get behind.
The concept was absurdly brilliant - a fantasy world used as a theme park by Pilgrim Parties that come to live the adventure. Derk is chosen to be this year's Darklord and must go out of his way to give the tourists the best possible epic thrillride.
Execution was nice too. Jones had a way of smooth prose and timing. This book was actually much darker than I'd expected (despite the title) and I'm not really sure I'd call it "YA", as the marketing has it. The light tone (though darker subject matter at times) and satirical approach might have played into that, but it certainly wasn't childish. Much.
There was a moment or two near the end that almost ruined the story somewhat, but things worked out fairly well by the end. The ending almost disappointed me too, but then I put into perspective the type of book I was reading. I'm actually giving extra props for Jones being able to make me take this story seriously enough to question that ending. Not to be vague, but I don't want to spoil any of it.
Anyway, this was an enjoyable read and I'm interested enough to consider the sequel.
This was a fun read. I liked it better than Howl's Moving Castle, which I'd read earlier in 2014. There was a nice mixture of wit and magic, and some characters I could really get behind.
The concept was absurdly brilliant - a fantasy world used as a theme park by Pilgrim Parties that come to live the adventure. Derk is chosen to be this year's Darklord and must go out of his way to give the tourists the best possible epic thrillride.
Execution was nice too. Jones had a way of smooth prose and timing. This book was actually much darker than I'd expected (despite the title) and I'm not really sure I'd call it "YA", as the marketing has it. The light tone (though darker subject matter at times) and satirical approach might have played into that, but it certainly wasn't childish. Much.
There was a moment or two near the end that almost ruined the story somewhat, but things worked out fairly well by the end. The ending almost disappointed me too, but then I put into perspective the type of book I was reading. I'm actually giving extra props for Jones being able to make me take this story seriously enough to question that ending. Not to be vague, but I don't want to spoil any of it.
Anyway, this was an enjoyable read and I'm interested enough to consider the sequel.
May 24, 2022
English version below
***************
Es gibt diese seltenen Bücher, bei denen schon auf der ersten Seite klar wird, dass man gerade beginnt, ein wundervolles Buch zu lesen. Dieses Buch ist eines jener Bücher und ich kann ihm nur ankreiden, dass es mir jetzt wieder schwer fällt, mich auf eine andere Lektüre einzulassen.
Der Roman wird als Kinderbuch beworben, wobei nicht klar ist, wieso eigentlich.
Ein Teil der Protagonisten sind Jugendliche, das Buch ist voller Humor, die Charakterentwicklung ist vielleicht nicht immer so tiefgehend wie man sich das bei ernsthafter High Fantasy wünscht, aber dennoch kann ich weder in der Ausgestaltung des Plots (na gut, er ist vielleicht nicht immer so besonders detailliert ausgeführt) noch im Schreibstil Merkmale erkennen, die eine Einordnung als Kinderbuch rechtfertigen würden. Damit will ich jedoch nicht sagen, dass Kinder oder Jugendliche keine Freude an diesem Buch haben können.
Ich habe mich bei dieser Geschichte um eine Fantasywelt, die von einem fiesen Geschäftemacher aus einer nicht-magischen Welt (alles deutet hier auf unsere hin) als Vergnügungspark ausgebeutet wird, ganz köstlich amüsiert und mich wundervoll und spannend unterhalten gefühlt. So ist es kein Wunder, dass ich hier glücklich und zufrieden 5 Sterne vergebe.
--------------
There are those rare books where it's clear from the first page that you're just beginning to read a wonderful book. This book is one of those books and I can only blame it for the fact that I now find it difficult to read anything else.
The novel is advertised as a children's book, although it is not clear why.
Some of the protagonists are teenagers, the book is full of humour, the character development may not always be as deep as one would like serious high fantasy to be, but I can neither in the setup of the plot (well, it may not always be so particularly detailed) nor in the writing style recognize features that would justify classification as a children's book. That's not to say, however, that children or young people can't enjoy this book.
This story about a fantasy world that is being exploited as an amusement park by a nasty profiteer from a non-magical world (everything points to ours here) was deliciously amusing and I felt wonderfully and excitingly entertained. So it's no wonder that I'm happy and satisfied assigning 5 stars here.
***************
Es gibt diese seltenen Bücher, bei denen schon auf der ersten Seite klar wird, dass man gerade beginnt, ein wundervolles Buch zu lesen. Dieses Buch ist eines jener Bücher und ich kann ihm nur ankreiden, dass es mir jetzt wieder schwer fällt, mich auf eine andere Lektüre einzulassen.
Der Roman wird als Kinderbuch beworben, wobei nicht klar ist, wieso eigentlich.
Ein Teil der Protagonisten sind Jugendliche, das Buch ist voller Humor, die Charakterentwicklung ist vielleicht nicht immer so tiefgehend wie man sich das bei ernsthafter High Fantasy wünscht, aber dennoch kann ich weder in der Ausgestaltung des Plots (na gut, er ist vielleicht nicht immer so besonders detailliert ausgeführt) noch im Schreibstil Merkmale erkennen, die eine Einordnung als Kinderbuch rechtfertigen würden. Damit will ich jedoch nicht sagen, dass Kinder oder Jugendliche keine Freude an diesem Buch haben können.
Ich habe mich bei dieser Geschichte um eine Fantasywelt, die von einem fiesen Geschäftemacher aus einer nicht-magischen Welt (alles deutet hier auf unsere hin) als Vergnügungspark ausgebeutet wird, ganz köstlich amüsiert und mich wundervoll und spannend unterhalten gefühlt. So ist es kein Wunder, dass ich hier glücklich und zufrieden 5 Sterne vergebe.
--------------
There are those rare books where it's clear from the first page that you're just beginning to read a wonderful book. This book is one of those books and I can only blame it for the fact that I now find it difficult to read anything else.
The novel is advertised as a children's book, although it is not clear why.
Some of the protagonists are teenagers, the book is full of humour, the character development may not always be as deep as one would like serious high fantasy to be, but I can neither in the setup of the plot (well, it may not always be so particularly detailed) nor in the writing style recognize features that would justify classification as a children's book. That's not to say, however, that children or young people can't enjoy this book.
This story about a fantasy world that is being exploited as an amusement park by a nasty profiteer from a non-magical world (everything points to ours here) was deliciously amusing and I felt wonderfully and excitingly entertained. So it's no wonder that I'm happy and satisfied assigning 5 stars here.
February 7, 2019
Das Cover hat mich hier total neugierig gemacht, dazu der Klappentext, der auf witzige Fantasy schließen lässt, waren ausschlaggebend um es mit der Autorin zu versuchen. Sie hat ja schon einige sehr bekannte Werke geschrieben wie auch "Das wandelnde Schloss", das als Anime verfilmt wurde - mein Interesse war jedenfalls definitiv geweckt und meine Erwartungen hoch.
Wahrscheinlich etwas zu hoch.
Während ich am Anfang noch mit großer Begeisterung gelesen hab, hat sie sich immer mehr zurückgezogen.
Zu Beginn nimmt man als Leser an einer Ratssitzung teil, durch die man schon viel über das Dilemma erfährt, das die Menschen und Magier schon seit Jahrzehnten durchleiden: Die Touristen-Touren, die der kaltherzige Mr. Chesney jedes Jahr plant, fordern zu viel Tribut an Kraft, Ressourcen und ja, auch Menschenleben und deshalb beschließen die Könige und Kanzler, dem endlich ein Ende zu bereiten.
Hier erfährt man schon einiges über das Land und die Probleme, die es zu lösen gilt und wandert dann auch direkt weiter zum Hexenmeister Derk aus Derkholm, der in diesem Jahr den "Dunklen Fürsten" spielen soll und somit für die Organisation der Touren verantwortlich ist.
Ab jetzt ging ich davon aus, dass Derk im Mittelpunkt steht, denn er soll viel magisches Potenzial haben und ungewöhnliche Ideen, ich hab eine Flut von Touristen erwartet, die Abenteuer erleben in dieser magischen Welt und wie sich alle im Netz der Intrigen verfangen ... aber es fokussiert sich alles auf die Familie von Derk: seine Frau Mara, seinen Sohn Blade und seiner Tochter Shona. Aber es gibt noch einige mehr Personen im Hause Derk, denn die magischen Fähigkeiten des Hexenmeisters haben ihn zu vielerlei Experimenten mit Tieren verführt, denen er allerlei skurrile Eigenschaften angedeihen ließ. Neben fliegenden Schweinen und intelligenten Gänsen gibt es noch einige Greife, die in seinem Haushalt leben und die dem Rang seiner Kinder gleichstehen.
Ein wahres Sammelsurium, das leider auch die einzelnen Figuren etwas verblassen lässt und man sich erstmal an die vielen Namen und Gestalten gewöhnen muss. Und ich tu mich ansonsten wirklich leicht mit vielen Charakteren.
Sie alle geben ihr Bestes, um ihren Vater bei den Vorbereitungen zu unterstützen, denn Mr. Chesney versteht keinen Spaß, wenn es um seine Einnahmequelle der Touristen geht und schreckt dabei auch nicht davor zurück, unliebsame Querulanten aus dem Weg zu räumen.
So ist man also ziemlich lange mit den kleinen und großen Problemen der einzelnen Familienmitglieder beschäftigt, die auch ungewöhnliche Lösungswege kommen und an Ideen mangelt es hier wahrlich nicht.
Da aber immer mehr Figuren involviert werden, bleiben sie im Einzelnen auch im Lauf der Geschichte zu flach und auch wenn vieles auf eine witzige Art erzählt wurde, war der Humor einfach nicht so meins.
Die Handlung wurde mir viel zu lange reduziert auf die kleinen und für mich uninteressanten Unabwägbarkeiten, bevor es etwas mehr an Fahrt aufgenommen hat, aber leider fand ich es zwischendurch immer wieder ganz schön zäh ... Dabei hätte es wirklich Potenzial gehabt und eine Unmenge an Ideen, die für mich nicht ausgeschöpft wurde.
Trotzdem gab es einige Figuren, die trotz der eher nebensächlichen Rolle eine doch dominate Position gewonnen und mein Herz erobert haben.
Was ich auch noch positiv hervorheben möchte ist der Schreibstil. Durch die etwas zähe Handlung hat er leider an Schwung verloren, trotzdem waren die Wortspielereien und Satzkonstruktionen sehr unterhaltsam.
Weltenwanderer
Wahrscheinlich etwas zu hoch.
Während ich am Anfang noch mit großer Begeisterung gelesen hab, hat sie sich immer mehr zurückgezogen.
Zu Beginn nimmt man als Leser an einer Ratssitzung teil, durch die man schon viel über das Dilemma erfährt, das die Menschen und Magier schon seit Jahrzehnten durchleiden: Die Touristen-Touren, die der kaltherzige Mr. Chesney jedes Jahr plant, fordern zu viel Tribut an Kraft, Ressourcen und ja, auch Menschenleben und deshalb beschließen die Könige und Kanzler, dem endlich ein Ende zu bereiten.
Hier erfährt man schon einiges über das Land und die Probleme, die es zu lösen gilt und wandert dann auch direkt weiter zum Hexenmeister Derk aus Derkholm, der in diesem Jahr den "Dunklen Fürsten" spielen soll und somit für die Organisation der Touren verantwortlich ist.
Ab jetzt ging ich davon aus, dass Derk im Mittelpunkt steht, denn er soll viel magisches Potenzial haben und ungewöhnliche Ideen, ich hab eine Flut von Touristen erwartet, die Abenteuer erleben in dieser magischen Welt und wie sich alle im Netz der Intrigen verfangen ... aber es fokussiert sich alles auf die Familie von Derk: seine Frau Mara, seinen Sohn Blade und seiner Tochter Shona. Aber es gibt noch einige mehr Personen im Hause Derk, denn die magischen Fähigkeiten des Hexenmeisters haben ihn zu vielerlei Experimenten mit Tieren verführt, denen er allerlei skurrile Eigenschaften angedeihen ließ. Neben fliegenden Schweinen und intelligenten Gänsen gibt es noch einige Greife, die in seinem Haushalt leben und die dem Rang seiner Kinder gleichstehen.
Ein wahres Sammelsurium, das leider auch die einzelnen Figuren etwas verblassen lässt und man sich erstmal an die vielen Namen und Gestalten gewöhnen muss. Und ich tu mich ansonsten wirklich leicht mit vielen Charakteren.
Sie alle geben ihr Bestes, um ihren Vater bei den Vorbereitungen zu unterstützen, denn Mr. Chesney versteht keinen Spaß, wenn es um seine Einnahmequelle der Touristen geht und schreckt dabei auch nicht davor zurück, unliebsame Querulanten aus dem Weg zu räumen.
So ist man also ziemlich lange mit den kleinen und großen Problemen der einzelnen Familienmitglieder beschäftigt, die auch ungewöhnliche Lösungswege kommen und an Ideen mangelt es hier wahrlich nicht.
Da aber immer mehr Figuren involviert werden, bleiben sie im Einzelnen auch im Lauf der Geschichte zu flach und auch wenn vieles auf eine witzige Art erzählt wurde, war der Humor einfach nicht so meins.
Die Handlung wurde mir viel zu lange reduziert auf die kleinen und für mich uninteressanten Unabwägbarkeiten, bevor es etwas mehr an Fahrt aufgenommen hat, aber leider fand ich es zwischendurch immer wieder ganz schön zäh ... Dabei hätte es wirklich Potenzial gehabt und eine Unmenge an Ideen, die für mich nicht ausgeschöpft wurde.
Trotzdem gab es einige Figuren, die trotz der eher nebensächlichen Rolle eine doch dominate Position gewonnen und mein Herz erobert haben.
Was ich auch noch positiv hervorheben möchte ist der Schreibstil. Durch die etwas zähe Handlung hat er leider an Schwung verloren, trotzdem waren die Wortspielereien und Satzkonstruktionen sehr unterhaltsam.
Weltenwanderer
October 12, 2025
4.99/5 Stars ⭐💫
It's been more than 15 years since I last read this book, so I was concerned that it might not hold up. Fortunately, as an adult, I find this book even more engaging and fulfilling than when I connected with Blade and Kit as a child. Now, I relate to the beleaguered Derk even more.
Diana Wynne Jones mastered a story structure best described as loading all the Chekhov's guns then firing them at the end.
I know it may sound like a cliché, but I must confess that I am a fan of traditional fantasy, particularly the classic trope of chosen one farmboys. I typically read two or three of these types of books each year, as they evoke a sense of nostalgia, even when I delve into books that may not be considered "good." 'Dark Lord of Derkholm' falls into this category,
🧙♂️🐉🔮
It's been more than 15 years since I last read this book, so I was concerned that it might not hold up. Fortunately, as an adult, I find this book even more engaging and fulfilling than when I connected with Blade and Kit as a child. Now, I relate to the beleaguered Derk even more.
Diana Wynne Jones mastered a story structure best described as loading all the Chekhov's guns then firing them at the end.
I know it may sound like a cliché, but I must confess that I am a fan of traditional fantasy, particularly the classic trope of chosen one farmboys. I typically read two or three of these types of books each year, as they evoke a sense of nostalgia, even when I delve into books that may not be considered "good." 'Dark Lord of Derkholm' falls into this category,
🧙♂️🐉🔮
Read
May 20, 2021Često zaboravljam da je u stvari *ovo* prva knjiga Dajane Vin Džouns koju sam ikad čitala jer mi se nije previše dopalo i ubrzo sam je zaboravila. Ni ovo drugo čitanje nije mnogo popravilo stvari - iako je jasno da ovaj roman predstavlja odgovor na pitanje "a kome bi i kada bio stvarno neophodan The Tough Guide to Fantasyland ?" ipak je radnja i dalje nekako rasuta a likovi previše ocrtani lakom rukom a da bismo se stvarno saživeli sa njihovim vrlo ozbiljnim problemima. I dalje je prijatno čitati je, ali prosto previše često izaziva reakciju "pa čekaj, ovo zahteva jaču razradu".
December 4, 2015
It took me some time to get into this book, which is likely my fault. I find it hard to read anything with more depth than your average bubblegrum wrapper when I have a head cold, so it probably isn't a coincidence that this book finally clicked with me the same day that I started to feel better. Because really, this book is often funny, wonderfully inventive, and features characters I came to care about a great deal. A literal family of characters! I love constructed families in my fiction, but I can also really get behind a loving biological family, too.
November 2, 2019
Imagine being able to take tours of another world, another world that appears to be evil and sinister. Seeing demons and dragons, battles. Except this world isn't really like that and the people who reside are getting tired of the act they have to put on each tour.
I found this book to be delightful, entertaining and funny. I felt so bad for our main character, Wizard Derk, now this years Dark Lord. Derk is a kind wizard, who just wants to breed different animals and zero interest in pretending to be evil.
I found this book to be delightful, entertaining and funny. I felt so bad for our main character, Wizard Derk, now this years Dark Lord. Derk is a kind wizard, who just wants to breed different animals and zero interest in pretending to be evil.
July 20, 2023
4.5 stars rounded up.
My first impression of this book reminded me very much of Terry Pratchett’s work, with its mix of humor and social commentary – and that was, happily, quite accurate! I had great fun with this…and, considering that I was reading it while on vacation, it also sparked a lot of thoughts about the ethics of tourism.
You see, the gist of this story is that an earth capitalist named Mr. Chesney has, via a deal with a demon, gained monopoly access to a real fantasy world and has turned it into a D&D tourist trap. All the residents HATE this, for various reasons, but haven’t been able to figure out how to get out of their contracts. Querida - the tiny, vaguely reptilian sorceress currently heading the magical university – decides to ask the oracles for advice. This results in the wizard Derk – a mild-mannered fellow mostly interested in creating magical beasts - being named as this year’s Dark Lord. Querida presumes that the oracles pointed to him because he’s bound to botch it, and sets about making sure she and Derk’s wife, Mara, screw things up even more!
“ ‘What’s your opinion of the great Mr. Chesney?’ ‘If I ever bred a piranha with a hyena, I’d call it a Chesney,’ Derk said. ‘That’s right,’ said Querida… ‘You aren’t a fool, whatever else you are. Did you know those sheep eat meat? There’s one over there munching a sparrow.’ ‘They do,’ Derk admitted. ‘I got them wrong somewhere’”
We mainly see the story from the POVs of Querida, Derk, and Derk’s eldest human son, Blade. I say “human son”, because Derk and Mara have two human children and five griffin children. There are also talking flying horses and non-talking flying pigs, some very sarcastic geese, and other critters, which provides a charming if slightly chaotic family environment. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a middle-aged wizard MC worrying about his marriage and arguing with his teenage children before, and that was quite fun.
“It did not take much thinking to work out that Mr. Chesney was making more money in a year than there was in Blade’s whole world. And Blade’s people were the one who did the work. ‘But that’s not fair!’ he murmured, and went to sleep at last, as if his mind had been waiting for him to arrive at saying that before it would let him stop thinking.”
In the broader world, there’s also an ancient dragon who is not quite up on the times (but, once he catches up to what’s been going on, is NOT having it!), a weirdly intense elf prince, the horse girl to end all horse girls, an unexpectedly helpful demon (always a favorite of mine), and a bunch of gold-toting dwarfs who end up camping in Derk’s kitchen.
“‘We’ve got his army - they’re 600 murderers really…But they won’t move.’… ‘Leave them there, then,’ said the dragon. 'We can’t said Blade. There’s a timetable…Besides, if we did leave them, they’d probably all escape and start murdering everyone.’ ‘I thought murdering was what soldiers and battles did,’ said the dragon.”
Overall, highly enjoyable. Though, warning: may leave the reader wanting to join a union. Or, hopefully, at least avoid the more colonial types of tourism where most of the money fails to reach the locals.
(I jest a little. This isn't a deep critique of capitalism as a whole. But it's DEFINITELY a critique of it at it's worst...)
My first impression of this book reminded me very much of Terry Pratchett’s work, with its mix of humor and social commentary – and that was, happily, quite accurate! I had great fun with this…and, considering that I was reading it while on vacation, it also sparked a lot of thoughts about the ethics of tourism.
You see, the gist of this story is that an earth capitalist named Mr. Chesney has, via a deal with a demon, gained monopoly access to a real fantasy world and has turned it into a D&D tourist trap. All the residents HATE this, for various reasons, but haven’t been able to figure out how to get out of their contracts. Querida - the tiny, vaguely reptilian sorceress currently heading the magical university – decides to ask the oracles for advice. This results in the wizard Derk – a mild-mannered fellow mostly interested in creating magical beasts - being named as this year’s Dark Lord. Querida presumes that the oracles pointed to him because he’s bound to botch it, and sets about making sure she and Derk’s wife, Mara, screw things up even more!
“ ‘What’s your opinion of the great Mr. Chesney?’ ‘If I ever bred a piranha with a hyena, I’d call it a Chesney,’ Derk said. ‘That’s right,’ said Querida… ‘You aren’t a fool, whatever else you are. Did you know those sheep eat meat? There’s one over there munching a sparrow.’ ‘They do,’ Derk admitted. ‘I got them wrong somewhere’”
We mainly see the story from the POVs of Querida, Derk, and Derk’s eldest human son, Blade. I say “human son”, because Derk and Mara have two human children and five griffin children. There are also talking flying horses and non-talking flying pigs, some very sarcastic geese, and other critters, which provides a charming if slightly chaotic family environment. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a middle-aged wizard MC worrying about his marriage and arguing with his teenage children before, and that was quite fun.
“It did not take much thinking to work out that Mr. Chesney was making more money in a year than there was in Blade’s whole world. And Blade’s people were the one who did the work. ‘But that’s not fair!’ he murmured, and went to sleep at last, as if his mind had been waiting for him to arrive at saying that before it would let him stop thinking.”
In the broader world, there’s also an ancient dragon who is not quite up on the times (but, once he catches up to what’s been going on, is NOT having it!), a weirdly intense elf prince, the horse girl to end all horse girls, an unexpectedly helpful demon (always a favorite of mine), and a bunch of gold-toting dwarfs who end up camping in Derk’s kitchen.
“‘We’ve got his army - they’re 600 murderers really…But they won’t move.’… ‘Leave them there, then,’ said the dragon. 'We can’t said Blade. There’s a timetable…Besides, if we did leave them, they’d probably all escape and start murdering everyone.’ ‘I thought murdering was what soldiers and battles did,’ said the dragon.”
Overall, highly enjoyable. Though, warning: may leave the reader wanting to join a union. Or, hopefully, at least avoid the more colonial types of tourism where most of the money fails to reach the locals.
(I jest a little. This isn't a deep critique of capitalism as a whole. But it's DEFINITELY a critique of it at it's worst...)
May 5, 2012
I've only read a couple Diana Wynne Jones books before so I wasn't too sure what to expect. Lately I've not been reading reviews or even blurbs before starting a book because I want to go into it with a completely open mind. Unfortunately my previous experiences with her books led me to believe this would be aimed at a younger audience so as things started getting a bit darker I was a tad perplexed.
Eventually I managed to get my mindset in the right place and realise that this book was intended for young adults and the dark behaviours seemed less out of place. And at times it could be rather grim and a little unsettling. Derk has a little bit of a Dr Moreau meets Dr Doolittle feel about him. Blade needed (and I think at the end of the book still does) a good kick in the ass. That character annoyed me the most. I quite liked the griffins and Scales. I would have liked to have seen more of Mara and Shona. They got relegated to the sidelines for the most part.
Apart from requiring me to shift my preconceptions out this book was really enjoyable and I can see why Diana Wynne Jones was such an acclaimed author. I look forward to reading more of her work.
Eventually I managed to get my mindset in the right place and realise that this book was intended for young adults and the dark behaviours seemed less out of place. And at times it could be rather grim and a little unsettling. Derk has a little bit of a Dr Moreau meets Dr Doolittle feel about him. Blade needed (and I think at the end of the book still does) a good kick in the ass. That character annoyed me the most. I quite liked the griffins and Scales. I would have liked to have seen more of Mara and Shona. They got relegated to the sidelines for the most part.
Apart from requiring me to shift my preconceptions out this book was really enjoyable and I can see why Diana Wynne Jones was such an acclaimed author. I look forward to reading more of her work.
October 29, 2010
The first page of Diana Wynne Jone's novel Dark Lord of Derkholm felt like I had just turned on the TV to the fantasy channel in the middle of an episode half way into the forth or fith season of a new series I had never heard about. There I was sitting in the middle of a council of some type talking about a Mr. C-something that was repressing them. Various characters spoke out, even made allusions to past situations I obviously would not understand mid-way into the series. Unfortunately, the book continued like this throughout most of its pages. I was on my own as to figure out exactly what was going on, piece together a history of the civilization and make sense of the characters. I wished that she could have started the book with its pilot episode.
August 20, 2007
YA Fantasy. The inhabitants of a magical world fight the evil forces of tourism. This book couldn't seem to get the bat off its shoulder -- baseball bat, not Chiroptera bat -- there was a lot of stuff going on, with a lot of different narrators, and I still didn't have the entire story. What's worse is that I wasn't satisfied once I did have it, thanks to the (anti-)climactic drawing room scene where the characters finally expose all the secrets they'd kept from me over the course of the book. Throw in the more or less ignored issues of genetic engineering, lousy parenting, and war for the sake of capitalism, and this just didn't feel put together right.
Two stars. Not Jones' best work.
Two stars. Not Jones' best work.
January 3, 2025
The premise of this book is hilarious. Somehow, a businessperson from our world has managed to capture a demon, which gives him the power to cross into a fantasy world. With a nose for profit, he sets up a tourism business. People from our world can take a fantasy tour of their world. With the power of the demon he has captured, the people in the fantasy world cannot refuse. Therefore, every year, they must designate someone to play the role of the Dark Lord to organize the events for the tours. Of course the people of this world are not happy about this, since people die in the tours and property is destroyed all in the name of tourism.
This story revolves around Derk, a wizard who specializes in creating fantasy animals. He is probably the least dark person in the story, so it is hilarious that the role of Dark Lord falls to him. Chaos ensues as the plans for the tours fall to pieces. Overall, the story pokes fun at fantasy tropes in a way that fans of fantasy can appreciate.
This story revolves around Derk, a wizard who specializes in creating fantasy animals. He is probably the least dark person in the story, so it is hilarious that the role of Dark Lord falls to him. Chaos ensues as the plans for the tours fall to pieces. Overall, the story pokes fun at fantasy tropes in a way that fans of fantasy can appreciate.
January 20, 2011
What an excellent book! This is the fastest-paced DWJ book I've ever read, and several of the revelations at the end truly surprised me without seeming unreasoned. There were many powerful moments, both action- and emotion-based, and some great characters. There's a cast of zillions, but you get the hang of everyone pretty well. And of course, the book is full of Diana Wynne Jones' perfect word choices ("a tuft of flame"), neat critters and spells (Friendly Cows!), and great descriptions of feelings. I love that she's not afraid to make good characters feel jealous of other good characters who are stronger, smarter, etc. They feel jealous, and they feel bad about feeling jealous of someone so nice or helpful - just the way a real person would. I like that good characters can genuinely like, respect, and appreciate each other and still fight and feel envious or annoyed. The jumping not-quite-omniscient point of view, while sometimes frustrating to me, shows this pretty well.
The grittiness, too, is staggeringly well-done - I really get the exhaustion of the characters during the long marches. And the plot itself is sheer brilliance.
*SPOILERS*
Like pretty much all DWJ books, this one has a sudden series of revelations at the end. Because the book is longer than many, this scene of discoveries is both longer and more intricate. Half the characters turn out to be other people, two-thirds of them provide answers to questions or solutions to problems, and everything is tied up in an incredibly complicated package. I'm actually really impressed by some stuff here - the Deucalion revelation and Geoffrey and Sukey's parentage, in particular, seem well set up but I never would have guessed. (I also never saw Barnabas' betrayal coming.) Brilliant.
I also think Kit's fake death is one of the most convincing I've ever read. I'm enough of a longtime fantasy reader to know that if you don't see a body, possibly with the head ten feet away, he ain't dead. This one is very well done, though. What's more, Kit's family's grief is so strong that I found my cynicism slipping - it's hard to keep saying, "Well, I know he's alive and will reappear later," when his family is sure (with good reason) that he's dead and they're so sad!
That's most of what I have to say, but I will conclude with a brief list of people who got better in the end than I thought they deserved.
1. Querida. The crazy crusty magical old bat bespells Mara into leaving her husband, tries to kidnap Callette, and mercilessly dooms Derk to fail in every way. It's only through luck and the intervention of other beings that half of Derk and Mara's family didn't die for real. I think Querida's new job, fixing their world, could be made to sound like just a little bit more of a punishment - after all, it's going to be a lot of work and trouble - but in a sense, they almost make it seem like a reward, what with her extended life and apparent new strength. And personally, if I'd been Mara or Derk (or any of their kids), I'd have thrown a pig at Querida's head. I guess they're just too happy to be back together.
2. Geoffrey. I don't actually have problems with Big G; I just don't see much reason to like him other than his making Shona happy. He's bossy and seems sort of too shiny and great. The only indication of his being less than "perfect" is that his feet blister after weeks of marching. What? :P Seriously, he kind of takes the Party over from Blade right away, steals Shona's attention with his dazzling-yet-totally-undeveloped character, and even bums Derk out by insisting on taking care of Shona himself. I didn't want anything actually bad to happen to him, and I'm fine with him staying with Shona; I just would have liked to see him fitting more neatly into her really cool family - maybe being forced to bow to the smarts/judgement/abilities of Blade or Derk.
3. Sukey. Again, not hating her, but I don't think she's one of DWJ's stronger examples of the seemed-to-be-annoying-but-really-isn't character, a type she ordinarily does really well.
4. Mr. Chesney. I would have thought his punishment was fair, except that Barnabas sets the bar pretty high by having his soul devoured by a demon in front of everybody. Barnabas is a total traitorous douche, yes, but Mr. Chesney could at least have been eaten by something . . .
I do really love the endings for Kit and Blade, the demons (Awww?), and Umru. This book is epic, and I was super-impressed. Go DWJ.
The grittiness, too, is staggeringly well-done - I really get the exhaustion of the characters during the long marches. And the plot itself is sheer brilliance.
*SPOILERS*
Like pretty much all DWJ books, this one has a sudden series of revelations at the end. Because the book is longer than many, this scene of discoveries is both longer and more intricate. Half the characters turn out to be other people, two-thirds of them provide answers to questions or solutions to problems, and everything is tied up in an incredibly complicated package. I'm actually really impressed by some stuff here - the Deucalion revelation and Geoffrey and Sukey's parentage, in particular, seem well set up but I never would have guessed. (I also never saw Barnabas' betrayal coming.) Brilliant.
I also think Kit's fake death is one of the most convincing I've ever read. I'm enough of a longtime fantasy reader to know that if you don't see a body, possibly with the head ten feet away, he ain't dead. This one is very well done, though. What's more, Kit's family's grief is so strong that I found my cynicism slipping - it's hard to keep saying, "Well, I know he's alive and will reappear later," when his family is sure (with good reason) that he's dead and they're so sad!
That's most of what I have to say, but I will conclude with a brief list of people who got better in the end than I thought they deserved.
1. Querida. The crazy crusty magical old bat bespells Mara into leaving her husband, tries to kidnap Callette, and mercilessly dooms Derk to fail in every way. It's only through luck and the intervention of other beings that half of Derk and Mara's family didn't die for real. I think Querida's new job, fixing their world, could be made to sound like just a little bit more of a punishment - after all, it's going to be a lot of work and trouble - but in a sense, they almost make it seem like a reward, what with her extended life and apparent new strength. And personally, if I'd been Mara or Derk (or any of their kids), I'd have thrown a pig at Querida's head. I guess they're just too happy to be back together.
2. Geoffrey. I don't actually have problems with Big G; I just don't see much reason to like him other than his making Shona happy. He's bossy and seems sort of too shiny and great. The only indication of his being less than "perfect" is that his feet blister after weeks of marching. What? :P Seriously, he kind of takes the Party over from Blade right away, steals Shona's attention with his dazzling-yet-totally-undeveloped character, and even bums Derk out by insisting on taking care of Shona himself. I didn't want anything actually bad to happen to him, and I'm fine with him staying with Shona; I just would have liked to see him fitting more neatly into her really cool family - maybe being forced to bow to the smarts/judgement/abilities of Blade or Derk.
3. Sukey. Again, not hating her, but I don't think she's one of DWJ's stronger examples of the seemed-to-be-annoying-but-really-isn't character, a type she ordinarily does really well.
4. Mr. Chesney. I would have thought his punishment was fair, except that Barnabas sets the bar pretty high by having his soul devoured by a demon in front of everybody. Barnabas is a total traitorous douche, yes, but Mr. Chesney could at least have been eaten by something . . .
I do really love the endings for Kit and Blade, the demons (Awww?), and Umru. This book is epic, and I was super-impressed. Go DWJ.
November 16, 2019
I don't think I've read this more than twice before. It's not one of Diana Wynne Jones' strongest books, though it's still excellent YA fantasy, but listening to the audiobook (the narrator is fantastic) slowed me down enough to appreciate it better. The concept is so good: a man from an industrialized world (it's never said that it's our world, but I like to think so) manages to enslave a world in which magic is powerful. He doesn't turn himself into its ruling lord. He doesn't take advantage of its magic--well, he does, but in a secondary way. No, he turns the world into a Fantasyland theme park. Every fall and winter, he brings "pilgrim parties" into the enslaved world to have a Fantasy Adventure, including war, enchantresses, wizards, slave girls, and a real-live Dark Lord.
What makes this work is that most readers of fantasy have at some point wished they could travel to one of the fantasy worlds in the books, and can you imagine a more exciting vacation? But DWJ chooses to tell the story from the POV of the people whose lives are annually turned upside down to cater to the tourists. Specifically, the POV of the current Dark Lord, Derk, and his family of humans and griffin children. Derk is a wizard who specializes in creating and modifying living creatures (hence the griffin children). He's at odds with most of the official wizards, but the Oracle decreed he should be chosen, and everything proceeds to go horribly wrong from there.
There's a lot of adorably ridiculous stuff going on in this book, all in a good way--flying pigs! the Friendly Cows! a 14-year-old wizard guide forced to grow a long white beard because Mr. Chesney, the slave master, insists that all wizards are male and have long white beards! And there's also a lot of serious stuff, some of which I don't think DWJ handles well.
But there are some great moments, such as Kit the griffin being made to face the reality of the battles he's planned so blithely, and how . I also am fond of the romances, though I'm a little sad they happen between non-POV characters. And the dragons are wonderful.
Now I'd like to borrow the other half of this idea, the one from the pilgrims' point of view, and tell a completely different story. If it turns out the sequel is read by the same narrator, I think I'll pick that one up.
What makes this work is that most readers of fantasy have at some point wished they could travel to one of the fantasy worlds in the books, and can you imagine a more exciting vacation? But DWJ chooses to tell the story from the POV of the people whose lives are annually turned upside down to cater to the tourists. Specifically, the POV of the current Dark Lord, Derk, and his family of humans and griffin children. Derk is a wizard who specializes in creating and modifying living creatures (hence the griffin children). He's at odds with most of the official wizards, but the Oracle decreed he should be chosen, and everything proceeds to go horribly wrong from there.
There's a lot of adorably ridiculous stuff going on in this book, all in a good way--flying pigs! the Friendly Cows! a 14-year-old wizard guide forced to grow a long white beard because Mr. Chesney, the slave master, insists that all wizards are male and have long white beards! And there's also a lot of serious stuff, some of which I don't think DWJ handles well.
But there are some great moments, such as Kit the griffin being made to face the reality of the battles he's planned so blithely, and how . I also am fond of the romances, though I'm a little sad they happen between non-POV characters. And the dragons are wonderful.
Now I'd like to borrow the other half of this idea, the one from the pilgrims' point of view, and tell a completely different story. If it turns out the sequel is read by the same narrator, I think I'll pick that one up.
July 28, 2020
This book came out a year after Ultima Online, a year before Everquest, and another few years before World of Warcraft. I wonder if Diana used to play enough video games to know what was going on, or if it was sheer serendipity. Either way, this book fits pretty well as an MMO parody from the angle of the final boss, who has to face like five raids a day and always respawns right after.
It's not the ha-ha-funny type of parody, though. It has very few laughs and most of the time is actually far more serious than you'd think from the premise.
It's not the ha-ha-funny type of parody, though. It has very few laughs and most of the time is actually far more serious than you'd think from the premise.
May 6, 2025
i read this after its sequel and it didn’t matter at all! i think i prefer it this way actually. anyway, i loved all the GIRLS in this...the juliet archetype who went gallivanting through the woods with her harp, the snooty lavender dragon, the flimsily-dressed glamorous ₊˚⊹♡ enchantress, the griffin who skulks away to make thingamabobs. there’s also a dwarf named galadriel, but he’s a boy...i loved the father-daughter relationships in this one and the priest’s storyline. and this has a super satisfying ending, which you know with DWJ is not always a given...🩷 i really didn’t expect much from this so i’m happily surprised
November 4, 2008
What I love about Diana Wynne Jones is how she can present a fantasy novel with a different angle than other fantasy novels with a standard plot - a boy or a girl, fated for something big, learning through ordeals, obtaining greatness.
In The Dark Lord of Derkholm , the world of magic had been forced to kneel down in front of a powerful force - namely, a Mr Chesney - and provide 'entertainment' every year for his Pilgrim Parties. These tourists from another world wanted to be involved in a fantastic adventure - fight bad wizards, fight fanatics, fight dragons etc. We might laugh at some of the rules Mr Chesney laid down for the ones organising the tours: Wizards must have long beards (well, we think of wizards as having a bushy appearance round the chin, eh?); normal name places must be converted into something sounding more fantastic like Gna'ash or the likes; etc. A bit of parody of the fantasy genre.
And the fights must be real. So real that cities were sacked down, people were killed, fields were destroyed.
After 40 years of devastation and slavery to Mr Chesney's moneymaking, the leaders of the world decided that they had had enough and went to the Oracles to consult for a way to end it all. It turned out that to banish Mr Chesney's Pilgrim Parties for all, they had to appoint an obscure wizard named Derk the Dark Lord of the year, and his son Blade as one of the Wizard Guides.
Well, Derk was not a household name in the world of wizardry. What he's interested in was creating new creatures: much like a geneticist. He had five griffin sons and daughters, apart from his two human children. He kept flying pigs, flying horses, friendly cows... how could this man succeed in playing the Dark Lord? He'd just fail miserably - wait, that could probably, eventually, put an end to Mr Chesney's tours. The problem was Derk tried hard to be a good Dark Lord...
I felt very entertained by this novel. It's not only about wizardry; it's also about family. Not only we observe how the whole world trying to organize the tours while trying to finish it at the same time, we also observe how Derk and his wife, Mara, and also their human-children and griffin-children, tried to stay together as a family. We may argue that the ending is a bit deus ex machina, but I think it still can be accepted by the way the story builds up to that ending.
In The Dark Lord of Derkholm , the world of magic had been forced to kneel down in front of a powerful force - namely, a Mr Chesney - and provide 'entertainment' every year for his Pilgrim Parties. These tourists from another world wanted to be involved in a fantastic adventure - fight bad wizards, fight fanatics, fight dragons etc. We might laugh at some of the rules Mr Chesney laid down for the ones organising the tours: Wizards must have long beards (well, we think of wizards as having a bushy appearance round the chin, eh?); normal name places must be converted into something sounding more fantastic like Gna'ash or the likes; etc. A bit of parody of the fantasy genre.
And the fights must be real. So real that cities were sacked down, people were killed, fields were destroyed.
After 40 years of devastation and slavery to Mr Chesney's moneymaking, the leaders of the world decided that they had had enough and went to the Oracles to consult for a way to end it all. It turned out that to banish Mr Chesney's Pilgrim Parties for all, they had to appoint an obscure wizard named Derk the Dark Lord of the year, and his son Blade as one of the Wizard Guides.
Well, Derk was not a household name in the world of wizardry. What he's interested in was creating new creatures: much like a geneticist. He had five griffin sons and daughters, apart from his two human children. He kept flying pigs, flying horses, friendly cows... how could this man succeed in playing the Dark Lord? He'd just fail miserably - wait, that could probably, eventually, put an end to Mr Chesney's tours. The problem was Derk tried hard to be a good Dark Lord...
I felt very entertained by this novel. It's not only about wizardry; it's also about family. Not only we observe how the whole world trying to organize the tours while trying to finish it at the same time, we also observe how Derk and his wife, Mara, and also their human-children and griffin-children, tried to stay together as a family. We may argue that the ending is a bit deus ex machina, but I think it still can be accepted by the way the story builds up to that ending.
October 12, 2010
Wow. After waiting excitedly to get to the fantasy unit, I was grossly disappointed by this parody of fantasy. The idea was clever, showing how stale and cliche the fantasy genre was at the time, but the book really consisted of about a thousand characters doing nothing but planning. There were some really good scenes and exciting parts, but they were so few and far between that by the time you got to one, you'd lost the last one amid the pages and pages (it's a long book) of tedious planning and traveling from place to place. The basic idea of the parody is that an American businessman, Mr. Chesney, owns a business where he sends tourist groups into the fantasy world where the book takes place. Each year, the citizens of this fantasy world have to set up an elaborate "quest" for each of the groups to go on. Derk, an oddball wizard, is called to be the Dark Lord and his son Blade (one of his human children- some of them are griffins) is assigned as a wizard guide. Things start out all right, but soon the whole show begins to unravel, and the whole land is panicked about how Mr. Chesney will react. Some bright spots and a clever idea, but overall a chore to read.
July 12, 2020
This was such a cozy, feel-good read. Perfect for rainy days, when you cuddle under the blanket and drink your favorite tea. The idea of Pilgrim Parties for profit to a magical world was unique (guilty as charged, I would participate as well) and the magical world itself was great. Dragons, dwarves, magicians, witches, elves – it had everything. Derk’s family was so precious and I found myself wanting a gryphon sibling as well. While the story wasn’t exactly gripping, I was constantly smiling or outright laughing. This book had such a subtle humor, not the slap-in-your-face comedy that many fantasy authors nowadays use. And those reveals at the end of the book! There were plenty and I didn't see them coming at all.
June 30, 2023
And if I say this book exploring the consequences of worldwide mandatory LARPing is a fantasy masterpiece that achieves completely original feats within the genre? What then?
The closest comparison to it in terms of creating a detailed, expansive world to parody classic fantasy tropes would of course be Terry Pratchett’s awesome Discworld series, but I feel like Diana Wynne Jones writes with enough emotional sincerity and gravity beneath her playful irony to create a distinctly unique impact. The characters are so compelling, and their day-to-day problem solving choices are so grounded that even the farcical plot of a tourist manager overlord feels utterly real. I came to care so much about this human/griffin family, and I was so invested in their journey to stage-manage and star in this insidious piece of continent-wide live theater and also to metaphorically burn the script to ash so they’d never have to do it again.
And it is unequivocally an epic journey by the end, which means that Jones is interacting with the traditional sword and sorcery formula on two levels. The classic fantasy hero’s journey is, in-world, an elaborately constructed charade for the tourists; and yet, from another angle, it’s a pattern fulfilled in full by the story of Derk’s family as they embark on an adventure, struggle against a great foe, and return home having changed the world. Diana Wynne Jones has given us the unthinkable: the hero’s journey of destroying the hero’s journey.
In the same spirit, she pokes fun at the tourists—consumers from our world—for always wanting the same clichéd narrative devices in fantasy stories, but then delivers all those devices to us herself, having spun them into a totally new configuration. A malevolent overlord to oust, young people coming into their power, clever uses of wizard magic, confrontations with dragons and demons, bards and rogues and a scheming witch, hordes of evil soldiers to thwart—all these things appear in contexts completely unexpected. For this book to be parodying a thing (classic fantasy) and yet to be unabashedly, joyfully that thing as well...I think Susan Sontag would call that Camp.
And Camp is a fitting sensibility for a book so centered on the theme of artifice. Yes, they're perpetrating mass murder and destruction, but Mr. Chesney's Pilgrim Parties are a form of art more grandiosely widespread and fanatically immersive than anyone else has ever dared to enact, and that is kind of sexy and fun of him in a way that he's completely unaware of. Camp. Anyway, artifice: the performance of Archetypal Fantasyland that this entire society suffers to maintain for the tours is a well-constructed allegory for any of the socially mandated narratives we all strive to uphold at the expense of our own happiness in real life.
And in a more fantasy-specific way, the pretense reminds me of the joyless grimdark tendencies of much of the genre, especially in Jones’s era. The tour-mandated storyline is a spectacle of suffering, of misery and violence engineered for audience entertainment, and the people of this world are finally deciding they shouldn’t have to go through that over and over. Obviously neither I nor Jones are saying that fantasy books shouldn’t have conflict anymore, but in a fun way I see her as standing up for the fields razed and cities pillaged and “expendable” persons & horses killed by careless authors for mere set-dressing. And while the story of Derkholm contains enough family love and restorative justice and humor to make for an interesting counter-vision of the genre within this same book, I think its sequel, Year of the Griffin, is Jones’s ultimate answer to the question of how fantasy can treat its characters and environments with more care. How even a sword and sorcery romp can forgo monolithic evil and destruction to explore the complex ties of community, can champion progressivism in social and academic thinking, and can sing the transformative power of empathy.
Having taken down the hero’s journey in the first book, Diana Wynne Jones sets out to forge the all-new friend group’s journey in the second.
If I have successfully tricked you into reading what is obviously not a goodreads review but instead a half-baked analytical essay that I’ll never have scholastic occasion to write, my apologies and thanks for your attention.
The closest comparison to it in terms of creating a detailed, expansive world to parody classic fantasy tropes would of course be Terry Pratchett’s awesome Discworld series, but I feel like Diana Wynne Jones writes with enough emotional sincerity and gravity beneath her playful irony to create a distinctly unique impact. The characters are so compelling, and their day-to-day problem solving choices are so grounded that even the farcical plot of a tourist manager overlord feels utterly real. I came to care so much about this human/griffin family, and I was so invested in their journey to stage-manage and star in this insidious piece of continent-wide live theater and also to metaphorically burn the script to ash so they’d never have to do it again.
And it is unequivocally an epic journey by the end, which means that Jones is interacting with the traditional sword and sorcery formula on two levels. The classic fantasy hero’s journey is, in-world, an elaborately constructed charade for the tourists; and yet, from another angle, it’s a pattern fulfilled in full by the story of Derk’s family as they embark on an adventure, struggle against a great foe, and return home having changed the world. Diana Wynne Jones has given us the unthinkable: the hero’s journey of destroying the hero’s journey.
In the same spirit, she pokes fun at the tourists—consumers from our world—for always wanting the same clichéd narrative devices in fantasy stories, but then delivers all those devices to us herself, having spun them into a totally new configuration. A malevolent overlord to oust, young people coming into their power, clever uses of wizard magic, confrontations with dragons and demons, bards and rogues and a scheming witch, hordes of evil soldiers to thwart—all these things appear in contexts completely unexpected. For this book to be parodying a thing (classic fantasy) and yet to be unabashedly, joyfully that thing as well...I think Susan Sontag would call that Camp.
And Camp is a fitting sensibility for a book so centered on the theme of artifice. Yes, they're perpetrating mass murder and destruction, but Mr. Chesney's Pilgrim Parties are a form of art more grandiosely widespread and fanatically immersive than anyone else has ever dared to enact, and that is kind of sexy and fun of him in a way that he's completely unaware of. Camp. Anyway, artifice: the performance of Archetypal Fantasyland that this entire society suffers to maintain for the tours is a well-constructed allegory for any of the socially mandated narratives we all strive to uphold at the expense of our own happiness in real life.
And in a more fantasy-specific way, the pretense reminds me of the joyless grimdark tendencies of much of the genre, especially in Jones’s era. The tour-mandated storyline is a spectacle of suffering, of misery and violence engineered for audience entertainment, and the people of this world are finally deciding they shouldn’t have to go through that over and over. Obviously neither I nor Jones are saying that fantasy books shouldn’t have conflict anymore, but in a fun way I see her as standing up for the fields razed and cities pillaged and “expendable” persons & horses killed by careless authors for mere set-dressing. And while the story of Derkholm contains enough family love and restorative justice and humor to make for an interesting counter-vision of the genre within this same book, I think its sequel, Year of the Griffin, is Jones’s ultimate answer to the question of how fantasy can treat its characters and environments with more care. How even a sword and sorcery romp can forgo monolithic evil and destruction to explore the complex ties of community, can champion progressivism in social and academic thinking, and can sing the transformative power of empathy.
Having taken down the hero’s journey in the first book, Diana Wynne Jones sets out to forge the all-new friend group’s journey in the second.
If I have successfully tricked you into reading what is obviously not a goodreads review but instead a half-baked analytical essay that I’ll never have scholastic occasion to write, my apologies and thanks for your attention.
August 11, 2021
Mit „Fauler Zauber“ wagte ich mich nun in eine Welt, außerhalb der von Diana Wynne Jones erschaffenen „Howl-Saga. Die Spannung war groß, da nicht nur das Cover ein absoluter Eyecatcher war, sondern auch die Kurzbeschreibung von einem interessanten Szenario erzählte.
Denn nach Derkholm kommen jedes Jahr, Pilger, welche zwar meist viel Geld mitbringen, aber auch viel Schaden anrichten. Zudem obliegt es den Bewohnern dieser Welt ihre Gäste zu bespaßen und ihnen Abenteuer und Spannung zu bieten. Doch damals soll nun Schluss sein, denn die Bewohner können und wollen nicht mehr.
Nach den ersten Seiten eine verständliche Situation, denn hier zeigte sich welche Ausmaße die Pilgerfahrten auf die Bewohner, ihr Land und ihre Ernten haben. Um so spannender fand ich es nun die Welt an sich kennenzulernen und gleichzeitig etwas gegen Mr. Chesney zu unternehmen. Dabei zeigte sich auch, welche Hintergründe die Fahrten hatten und wie geschickt er Personen aus seiner Welt, in dieser einsetzte.
Leider war ab der Hälfte die Spannung ein wenig bei mir raus. Nicht wegen der Story an sich, sondern von den teils sehr verwirrenden Handlungen der Charaktere. Ich verstand nicht, wieso man nicht eine Horde Soldaten an ihren rechtmäßigen Platz zauberte, anstatt sie querfeldein durch Wald und Wiesen zu bugsieren und dann auch noch aufzupassen das sie nicht Reißaus nahmen. Hier fehlte mir hin und wieder die Logik.
Dafür hatte ich um so mehr Spaß mit dem Zauberer Derk, welcher ein Geschick dafür besaß Tiere zu kreuzen. Egal ob Greife mit menschlichen Zügen und Sprechgewohnheiten oder fliegenden Pferden, hier fand man eine ganze Menge interessanter Kombinationen, welche mal mehr und weniger Sinn ergaben. Unterhaltend war es trotzdem. Für mich wurde es hier nur schwierig, wenn es um Derks Kinder ging. Da er hier sowohl seine vollständig menschlichen, als auch die Greifen, welchen er einen Teil seiner DNA gab, meinte. Da man es hier aber mit mehr als 5 Kindern zutun hatte, verwechselte ich viele oftmals. Man sollte zwar meinen, das man einen Greif vom Menschen unterscheiden könne, da aber oftmals nur die Charaktereigenschaften angesprochen wurden, fiel mir dies aber wirklich sehr schwer.
Zum Ende hin nahm das Buch dann zum Glück noch einmal ordentlich Fahrt auf und bescherte mir tatsächlich einzigartige Momente. Hier zeigte sich dann auch wieder, dass die Autorin wunderschöne Enden schreiben kann und es schafft, viele Themen unter einen Hut zu bringen.
Fazit:
Und auch diesmal bewies Diana Wynne Jones das sie wundervolle Geschichte schreiben konnten. „Fauler Zauber“ bot mir ein wunderschönes Setting, gepaart mit einfallsreichen Charakteren und tollen Wendungen. Es machte einfach Spaß dieses Buch zu lesen, auch wenn gerade das zweite Drittel etwas langatmig daher kam und es hin und wieder ein paar Logiklücken gab.
Denn nach Derkholm kommen jedes Jahr, Pilger, welche zwar meist viel Geld mitbringen, aber auch viel Schaden anrichten. Zudem obliegt es den Bewohnern dieser Welt ihre Gäste zu bespaßen und ihnen Abenteuer und Spannung zu bieten. Doch damals soll nun Schluss sein, denn die Bewohner können und wollen nicht mehr.
Nach den ersten Seiten eine verständliche Situation, denn hier zeigte sich welche Ausmaße die Pilgerfahrten auf die Bewohner, ihr Land und ihre Ernten haben. Um so spannender fand ich es nun die Welt an sich kennenzulernen und gleichzeitig etwas gegen Mr. Chesney zu unternehmen. Dabei zeigte sich auch, welche Hintergründe die Fahrten hatten und wie geschickt er Personen aus seiner Welt, in dieser einsetzte.
Leider war ab der Hälfte die Spannung ein wenig bei mir raus. Nicht wegen der Story an sich, sondern von den teils sehr verwirrenden Handlungen der Charaktere. Ich verstand nicht, wieso man nicht eine Horde Soldaten an ihren rechtmäßigen Platz zauberte, anstatt sie querfeldein durch Wald und Wiesen zu bugsieren und dann auch noch aufzupassen das sie nicht Reißaus nahmen. Hier fehlte mir hin und wieder die Logik.
Dafür hatte ich um so mehr Spaß mit dem Zauberer Derk, welcher ein Geschick dafür besaß Tiere zu kreuzen. Egal ob Greife mit menschlichen Zügen und Sprechgewohnheiten oder fliegenden Pferden, hier fand man eine ganze Menge interessanter Kombinationen, welche mal mehr und weniger Sinn ergaben. Unterhaltend war es trotzdem. Für mich wurde es hier nur schwierig, wenn es um Derks Kinder ging. Da er hier sowohl seine vollständig menschlichen, als auch die Greifen, welchen er einen Teil seiner DNA gab, meinte. Da man es hier aber mit mehr als 5 Kindern zutun hatte, verwechselte ich viele oftmals. Man sollte zwar meinen, das man einen Greif vom Menschen unterscheiden könne, da aber oftmals nur die Charaktereigenschaften angesprochen wurden, fiel mir dies aber wirklich sehr schwer.
Zum Ende hin nahm das Buch dann zum Glück noch einmal ordentlich Fahrt auf und bescherte mir tatsächlich einzigartige Momente. Hier zeigte sich dann auch wieder, dass die Autorin wunderschöne Enden schreiben kann und es schafft, viele Themen unter einen Hut zu bringen.
Fazit:
Und auch diesmal bewies Diana Wynne Jones das sie wundervolle Geschichte schreiben konnten. „Fauler Zauber“ bot mir ein wunderschönes Setting, gepaart mit einfallsreichen Charakteren und tollen Wendungen. Es machte einfach Spaß dieses Buch zu lesen, auch wenn gerade das zweite Drittel etwas langatmig daher kam und es hin und wieder ein paar Logiklücken gab.
April 18, 2017
I first read this back in high school, and I had fond memories of it. Fond enough apparently that when I got Goodreads, I found this title and marked it as a 5 star.
Reading it in my late twenties, I honestly expected it to be a hilarious parody of the fantasy genre--a sort of fantasy The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. But... that's not what it is, at all. Parts of this book are straight up comedy (the introduction of this world's elves comes to mind), but other parts get quite dark. The worst part is a scene where gang rape (or at least serious sexual assault) is implied, but other bits are mixed in like that, horrible consequences that would happen if a world was enslaved for the purpose of entertainment.
For me, this book couldn't quite decide what it wanted to be. It could have gone the straight up parody route, or it could have taken this topic seriously (ala Hunger Games, maybe?) about how far people go for entertainment and at what cost. But wobbling back and forth between the two just left me feeling lost.
As for the characters... I loved them. But there were so many that none of them really got fully developed. Some of them we hardly saw at all.
So I'm afraid I'll have to demote this book a couple stars. I didn't recapture the magic as an adult. Still, because I loved it as a teenager, it holds some fond memories for me.
Reading it in my late twenties, I honestly expected it to be a hilarious parody of the fantasy genre--a sort of fantasy The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. But... that's not what it is, at all. Parts of this book are straight up comedy (the introduction of this world's elves comes to mind), but other parts get quite dark. The worst part is a scene where gang rape (or at least serious sexual assault) is implied, but other bits are mixed in like that, horrible consequences that would happen if a world was enslaved for the purpose of entertainment.
For me, this book couldn't quite decide what it wanted to be. It could have gone the straight up parody route, or it could have taken this topic seriously (ala Hunger Games, maybe?) about how far people go for entertainment and at what cost. But wobbling back and forth between the two just left me feeling lost.
As for the characters... I loved them. But there were so many that none of them really got fully developed. Some of them we hardly saw at all.
So I'm afraid I'll have to demote this book a couple stars. I didn't recapture the magic as an adult. Still, because I loved it as a teenager, it holds some fond memories for me.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,138 reviews