Faith, hunger, hardship, sickness, loss, and grief are strong threads through this story, though they failed to engage me as a reader. The mixing of the fictional leads, however, with the historical figures was well done. I found I quite liked the portrayals of Miles Standish, John Alden, and especially Priscilla Mullins. The fictional characters did not fare so well and I found I had little sympathy or liking for them.
As a draft, this would be fine, though in need of some work to give the story a good flow, enrich the descriptions, provide stronger motivations and make the dialogue more natural while making it have more of a feel for the actual speech, values, and behavior of the times. The author herself notes that she chose not to use language like 'thee' and 'thou' to make it more readable, and that does sometimes benefit the modern reader, but there seems to have also been a loss of authenticity in the dialogue as well as the story.
2.5 stars. Rather than transporting me to the 1600's, this story brought fourth grade social studies units to mind. If you are interested in this series, as I am, then this is worth a quick read as it is the foundational novel in a linked series.
My thanks to Barbour Books for allowing me to read an e-galley through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.