4.5*
This is, obviously, an incredibly tough novel to both read and review. It deals with such a prevalent and important topic, but it is a grievous one all the same, and - considering all of that - was brilliantly done.
This novel follows two characters. One, a boy who lost his brother in a school shooting, and who's life has since fallen off the rails. The other, a girl who lost her brother in the same school shooting. The two were best friends. Until the school shooting, because the girl's brother was the shooter. Years later, Skye (the girl) has moved back to the town of the shooting, and she's expecting some backlash. However, it's not long before she's being threatened, her safety in the balance - and nobody believes her but her ex(?) best friend. The boy who's brother her brother's shooting killed.
“Just growing up seems like an accomplishment. Not everyone gets that far.”
1) Writing
Armstrong's writing was good! She knew how to use semi-colons and commas to her advantage, and she knew how to weave emotions into the story. I don't specifically remember much about her writing, except that I really did enjoy it! This story had so many juxtaposing emotions, it was intense in some parts, viscerally heart-breaking in others, and even light, happy, and romantic sometimes. Armstrong's writing was able to cover all of that, and expertly too. You can see why she is a number one bestselling author, she writes everything very well.
Decrease: 0
Rating: 5 Stars
2) Characterization
The two main characters in this novel were absolutely incredible! I loved them, how they contrasted, how they felt about each other, everything was just so brilliant! The characters also felt wonderfully realistic. This felt like it was written about teenagers, and that was incredibly gratifying. I think this was a brilliant title for the Battle of the Books, it's one teens will really get something out of, because the characters are so realistic and raw and relatable. Skye. Skye is obviously not having a good time back at school, she is beyond bullied, she's threatened. Now, hopefully that's not something your average high schooler can relate to, but we can all understand what it's like to be bullied, and the emotion and trauma of that was real. I also felt that her grieving situation was so realistic. This grappled with the idea that her brother was a shooter, just because he died does not mean she gets to mourn him. Which is not correct at all, her brother was thought to be a monster, he didn't deserve her grief, but that didn't stop her from feeling it, and that was really wonderfully done. Now, the other boy (who's name I can't remember whoops) was so real too! He was dealing with so many emotions, grief, guilt, anger, and loneliness. His story felt equally real and enjoyable. Plus, he was just (even though he didn't always show it) a really good-hearted guy, and that was nice to read about. In the end, these characters were so real and in-pain, it made for a beautiful and emotional reading experience that I think many high schoolers in Troy will adore, too.
Decrease: 0
Rating: 5 Stars
3) Plot/Storyline/Setting
This story suffers a bit here. This was kind of a mystery on top of all its contemporary-grieving stuff. The characters were also trying to figure out who was threatening Skye and what really happened all those years ago at the shooting itself. However, this is one of those stories where the suspicion twist was better than the real one. At one point in this story, they suspected one person of doing all the things that were happening behind the scenes, and that blew me away! That would have made for such a good and unpredictable twist, but then the author goes and changes it to another person, and I had predicted who really did everything since I first met that person. It was obvious, and that's never good, but then it was made even more tragic by the fact that the first twist was so shocking...but it ended up not being a twist at all! This is a common error that truly tends to ruin a book's plot and this one suffered from an EXTREME case of that. The setting, however, was done remarkably well! The small town thing always adds a layer of dramatic affect, and it absolutely did with that one, a redeemable quality, to be sure.
Decrease: 0.5 Stars
Rating: 4.5 Stars
4) Interest
I never once lost interest in this book! I was hooked from the beginning, and found the whole mystery intrigue coinciding with the grief and the emotions at play was very well done! So many different ideas were all spinning around, but they were balanced well, and I enjoyed this and was never bored once throughout the entire reading experience, which is quite a blessing lately! I really appreciated how the mystery/thriller aspect of this kept the novel interesting, but she also didn't put in so much mystery that the grief felt fake or like she was trying to make a school shooting into an entertaining story. That was incredibly tough to balance, and she did so perfectly! I was never not wholly invested in this story.
Decrease: 0
Rating: 4.5 Stars
5) General Errors
This was, overall, a good category for Aftermath! I just wanted to critique one thing, the scene where those boys attacked Skye and the guy (ha I like that it rhymes) was kind of unnecessary and it didn't work so well as a red herring, but more of a distractor from the main storyline and idea. However, I can appreciate where the author was coming from, and one thing off in this category is pretty good!
Decrease: 0.25
Rating: 4.25 Stars
6) Feelings
This story following what it did, was very emotional and complex and feelsy. However, it was brilliantly so, I felt the grief right along side the characters, everything about it was just real and expert and super enjoyable!
Change: +0.25
Rating: 4.5
This novel dealt with an incredibly tough topic so well. I was worried going into this one that it would try to dramatize school shootings and make an emotional and awful thing into a thriller. It didn't, it made it into a realistic and emotional contemporary, with a good bit of mystery in the background. Adored this one.