What do you think?
Rate this book
Dark Gothic
Seduced by a Stranger
Destitute and desperate, Catherine Weston accepts the summons from her childhood friend Madeline St. Aubyn to attend her at Cairncroft Abbey, a place of secrets, lies and murder. Madeline's health is in a poor state and she is terrified of her cousin, Gabriel. But Gabriel has quite a different effect on Catherine, stirring longings and desires she believed long buried.
Gabriel St. Aubyn is haunted by the horrors of both his past and his present, horrors he conceals behind a remote, unapproachable facade. He is drawn to Catherine, but is determined to protect her from the tragedies that yet have claws sunk deep in his soul.
Then a young woman is found dead, and Madeline's ravings point to a link between this horrific crime and Gabriel—and Catherine must decide if he is a man worthy of her love or a sinister stranger determined to make her his next victim.
Gabriel St. Aubyn is haunted by the horrors of both his past and his present, horrors he conceals behind a remote, unapproachable facade. He is drawn to Catherine, but is determined to protect her from the tragedies that yet have claws sunk deep in his soul.
Then a young woman is found dead, and Madeline's ravings point to a link between this horrific crime and Gabriel—and Catherine must decide if he is a man worthy of her love or a sinister stranger determined to make her his next victim.
352 pages, Kindle Edition
First published September 1, 2009
280 people are currently reading
1318 people want to read
About the author
Eve Silver
46 books1,537 followersNational bestselling author Eve Silver has been praised for her "edgy, steamy, action-packed" books, darkly sexy heroes and take-charge heroines. Her work won the OLA Forest of Reading White Pine Award 2015, was shortlisted for the Monica Hughes Award for Science Fiction and Fantasy 2014, was listed as a 2013 American Bookseller's Association Best Book for Children and a Canadian Children's Book Centre Best Books for Kids and Teens. She has garnered starred reviews from Publishers Weekly, Library Journal, and Quill and Quire, two RT Book Reviews Reviewers' Choice Awards, Library Journal's Best Genre Fiction Award, and she was nominated for the Romance Writers of America® RITA® Award.
Eve lives with her husband and two exuberant border collie/Australian shepherds.
Contact Eve through her website at http://www.evesilver.net
Eve lives with her husband and two exuberant border collie/Australian shepherds.
Contact Eve through her website at http://www.evesilver.net
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 113 reviews
June 22, 2020
To get a glimpse into what the mind of a serial killer might be like (quite certain is mostly like) is chilling and scary.
This is a very well written, what I would consider a book that fits into a few genes (mystery, suspense, love story). It very easily kept my attention throughout and “who dun it”isn’t revealed until the very end, keeping one in suspense and wondering throughout. Listening to how the killer likes to stalk, choose, torture, kill and then keep as trophies, was chilling.
The story is sad with a lot of suffering and loss (not all from the killer). The main characters are Beth a woman who holds much fear in her and is afraid of the dark, being confined in small places, has panic attacks she’s learned to for the most part, hide. She’s traveling to a new job as a teacher. Then there’s Griffin a man with his own secrets and rumors running wild about him. He’s not a man to be trifled with, he’s has an air of danger and darkness about him.
They meet, when Griffin arrives to pick Beth up after her long journey to her new job. During everything that is going on during the story, they become close, seeing a lot of themselves in each other. Then Beth finds out that the little girl, who reminds her of herself when she was young, is Griffins daughter. A girl who stays to herself, doesn’t talk, nor participate and is teased by the other students. A girl Beth is taken by, but can she make a difference in the child? Help her and Griffin form a relationship?
There’s a lot of different facets going on and overlapping at the same time. A great story that unravels before your eyes. There is beauty and ugliness in this story, but we have to take the good with the bad in life. It’s a story with grit, rot and disgusting, along with beauty, acceptance and trust. Of course ending with lots of love. This was book one, which I guess you could stop after, I will be reading on.
This is a very well written, what I would consider a book that fits into a few genes (mystery, suspense, love story). It very easily kept my attention throughout and “who dun it”isn’t revealed until the very end, keeping one in suspense and wondering throughout. Listening to how the killer likes to stalk, choose, torture, kill and then keep as trophies, was chilling.
The story is sad with a lot of suffering and loss (not all from the killer). The main characters are Beth a woman who holds much fear in her and is afraid of the dark, being confined in small places, has panic attacks she’s learned to for the most part, hide. She’s traveling to a new job as a teacher. Then there’s Griffin a man with his own secrets and rumors running wild about him. He’s not a man to be trifled with, he’s has an air of danger and darkness about him.
They meet, when Griffin arrives to pick Beth up after her long journey to her new job. During everything that is going on during the story, they become close, seeing a lot of themselves in each other. Then Beth finds out that the little girl, who reminds her of herself when she was young, is Griffins daughter. A girl who stays to herself, doesn’t talk, nor participate and is teased by the other students. A girl Beth is taken by, but can she make a difference in the child? Help her and Griffin form a relationship?
There’s a lot of different facets going on and overlapping at the same time. A great story that unravels before your eyes. There is beauty and ugliness in this story, but we have to take the good with the bad in life. It’s a story with grit, rot and disgusting, along with beauty, acceptance and trust. Of course ending with lots of love. This was book one, which I guess you could stop after, I will be reading on.
June 28, 2021
Gothic romance as a genre is such a lure for me, a forbidding mansion, the suspense and mystery surrounding the inhabitants of the place, the naive heroine who stumbles into the darkness and the eerie vibe, and of course the romance with a hero who is until the end not clearly depicted as a positive character, there’s so much that attracts me in the genre that I simply adore reading them.
Seduced By A Stranger, is book #5 in the Dark Gothic Series by Eve Silver, and what a fantastic story in this genre that was gripping and menacing from the first chapter itself. I believe, all the books in the series can be perfectly read as standalone and I remember reading book #1 and liking it enough to add this author to my toppling TBR.
Fair warning to readers, this book has very gruesome and gory murder details that can be off-putting for some and the tone of the story is honestly a little depressing. The secrets that hide in the past of both the hero and heroine are painful to read. I absolutely loved the slow seduction that Gabriel employs with Catherine and the romance was maddeningly steamy. The play of words between them was another exciting factor. There’s this whole chill and aloof persona on the surface but Eve Silver manages to convey the passion that is waiting to spill over every single time they face each other.
OK, I did guess the mystery element of the story, well, reading non-stop would probably cause that effect for most thrillers, though I did enjoy the unraveling of the entire tale with the mystique of St. Aubyn estate.
Deliciously creepy ⛈️ ⛈️ ⛈️ ⛈️ ⛈️
This review is published in my blog https://rainnbooks.com/, Goodreads, Amazon India, and Twitter.
Seduced By A Stranger, is book #5 in the Dark Gothic Series by Eve Silver, and what a fantastic story in this genre that was gripping and menacing from the first chapter itself. I believe, all the books in the series can be perfectly read as standalone and I remember reading book #1 and liking it enough to add this author to my toppling TBR.
Fair warning to readers, this book has very gruesome and gory murder details that can be off-putting for some and the tone of the story is honestly a little depressing. The secrets that hide in the past of both the hero and heroine are painful to read. I absolutely loved the slow seduction that Gabriel employs with Catherine and the romance was maddeningly steamy. The play of words between them was another exciting factor. There’s this whole chill and aloof persona on the surface but Eve Silver manages to convey the passion that is waiting to spill over every single time they face each other.
OK, I did guess the mystery element of the story, well, reading non-stop would probably cause that effect for most thrillers, though I did enjoy the unraveling of the entire tale with the mystique of St. Aubyn estate.
Deliciously creepy ⛈️ ⛈️ ⛈️ ⛈️ ⛈️
This review is published in my blog https://rainnbooks.com/, Goodreads, Amazon India, and Twitter.
April 29, 2016
3.5 stars
It was simply eight words. 'Please come. I beg of you. Please come.'
Catherine Westin had known Madeline St. Aubyn from her days at the Browning School For Girls. At the time, each of them were estranged from their families but their circumstances were different. Then a horrific accident occurred and Madeline saved Catherine's life. For this reason alone, she would travel the long distance to attend to her old friend.
The year was 1828. A wicked person was lurking the streets of London and murder was on this demented person's mind. The author did a wonderful job causing some 'What the...?!?' moments. I had to go back and re-read several passages for a clue I thought I had missed.
He made her uncomfortable. A kind of darkness swirled about him; she had been warned to keep him at a distance. Away from Gabriel St. Aubyn, with his fierce looks and patience: his allure. Their relationship became a game of chess, each one thinking of the next play. Or fencing with words instead of swords, outsmarting the other with clipped answers and cool looks. It was give and take and being careful. Oh, so very careful. Catherine and Gabriel had some secrets that they did not want the other to know.
And then there was the crumbling St. Aubyn estate. Was Madeline correct when she told Catherine she thought she was being poisoned? And what was the reason that the housekeeper, Mrs. Bell, was frosty and hateful? And why did Catherine feel shivers travel up her spine when she just knew she was being watched?
If you are looking to take a break from the cushy historical romances you have been reading as of late, try Seduced by a Stranger. It contains a very dark theme with some mysterious elements, steamy sensuality, an anti-hero and his savior. *But be warned, this suspenseful gothic-like story is not for those that are faint of heart.*
It was simply eight words. 'Please come. I beg of you. Please come.'
Catherine Westin had known Madeline St. Aubyn from her days at the Browning School For Girls. At the time, each of them were estranged from their families but their circumstances were different. Then a horrific accident occurred and Madeline saved Catherine's life. For this reason alone, she would travel the long distance to attend to her old friend.
The year was 1828. A wicked person was lurking the streets of London and murder was on this demented person's mind. The author did a wonderful job causing some 'What the...?!?' moments. I had to go back and re-read several passages for a clue I thought I had missed.
He made her uncomfortable. A kind of darkness swirled about him; she had been warned to keep him at a distance. Away from Gabriel St. Aubyn, with his fierce looks and patience: his allure. Their relationship became a game of chess, each one thinking of the next play. Or fencing with words instead of swords, outsmarting the other with clipped answers and cool looks. It was give and take and being careful. Oh, so very careful. Catherine and Gabriel had some secrets that they did not want the other to know.
And then there was the crumbling St. Aubyn estate. Was Madeline correct when she told Catherine she thought she was being poisoned? And what was the reason that the housekeeper, Mrs. Bell, was frosty and hateful? And why did Catherine feel shivers travel up her spine when she just knew she was being watched?
If you are looking to take a break from the cushy historical romances you have been reading as of late, try Seduced by a Stranger. It contains a very dark theme with some mysterious elements, steamy sensuality, an anti-hero and his savior. *But be warned, this suspenseful gothic-like story is not for those that are faint of heart.*
April 4, 2022
Seduced by a Stranger
3 Stars
Eve Silver's Dark Gothic series has been very entertaining with each installment either alluding to or referencing 19th century classics, such as Jane Eyre or Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. In this installment, readers are introduced to Catherine Weston who travels tp Cairncroft Abbey at the behest of a childhood friend, Madeline St. Aubyn. Upon her arrival, Catherine meets her friend's enigmatic cousin, Gabriel, whose cold faćade conceals a myriad of secrets and horrors.
The first couple of chapters are excellent and establish the compelling gothic tone of the narrative. Unfortunately, the pacing of the subsequent chapters is slower and it takes time to become immersed in the story. Thankfully, the final 3rd ratchets up the tension and suspense. That said, the big twist is revealed far too early and this diminishes the excitement of the tale.
In terms of the romance, Gabriel and Catherine have great chemistry and their backstories are heartwrenching. One cannot help but sympathize with their traumas and applaud their ability to find love and happiness together.
Overall, a well-written and enjoyable gothic romance despite the issues outlined.
3 Stars
Eve Silver's Dark Gothic series has been very entertaining with each installment either alluding to or referencing 19th century classics, such as Jane Eyre or Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde. In this installment, readers are introduced to Catherine Weston who travels tp Cairncroft Abbey at the behest of a childhood friend, Madeline St. Aubyn. Upon her arrival, Catherine meets her friend's enigmatic cousin, Gabriel, whose cold faćade conceals a myriad of secrets and horrors.
The first couple of chapters are excellent and establish the compelling gothic tone of the narrative. Unfortunately, the pacing of the subsequent chapters is slower and it takes time to become immersed in the story. Thankfully, the final 3rd ratchets up the tension and suspense. That said, the big twist is revealed far too early and this diminishes the excitement of the tale.
In terms of the romance, Gabriel and Catherine have great chemistry and their backstories are heartwrenching. One cannot help but sympathize with their traumas and applaud their ability to find love and happiness together.
Overall, a well-written and enjoyable gothic romance despite the issues outlined.
December 19, 2014
4.5 stars
Excellent mix of romance and dark, gothic mystery; even though I felt sure I had guessed the answer to the mystery puzzle, the answer managed to take me by surprise in the end. Plus, I loved the marriage proposal:)
Great book with fast plot, witty dialogues, clever strong heroes and interesting secondary characters. Not much in the steam department, but I enjoyed the sexual tension that too many modern books seem to be missing, and their one and only love scene. Highly recommended to fans of clever romances/mysteries.
Excellent mix of romance and dark, gothic mystery; even though I felt sure I had guessed the answer to the mystery puzzle, the answer managed to take me by surprise in the end. Plus, I loved the marriage proposal:)
Great book with fast plot, witty dialogues, clever strong heroes and interesting secondary characters. Not much in the steam department, but I enjoyed the sexual tension that too many modern books seem to be missing, and their one and only love scene. Highly recommended to fans of clever romances/mysteries.
November 9, 2009
For about the first quarter to half of this book, I was puzzled about the book being deemed a "historical romance". It seemed more along the lines of a dark mystery with a possible romance side plot. This was my first book by Eve Silver and boy, does she know how to ramp up the spooky factor using atmosphere.
There are several mysteries going on throughout this book:
1. The heroine, Catherine, has a horrible secret and harbors a deep pain. What is her secret?
2. Catherine's friend, Madeline's, health is deteriorating and she seems quite delusional one moment and sane the next. When she is warning Catherine of danger lurking around every corner - is she sane or is it a side-effect of her paranoid delusions?
3. There is someone killing and taking apart women that Catherine knows... who is doing the killing and for what purpose?
4. The hero - again, he didn't seem much like hero material for most of the book - Gabriel, is cold and harbors secrets even more successfully than Catherine. Can she trust this man? Is he the killer? Are Madeline's ramblings about him true? What're his secrets and what has caused him to become so cold and in control of his emotions?
I formulated a guess early on in the book as to who the killer was and I was right. But this didn't disappoint me because when the story behind the killer is revealed late in the book, I was surprised. The mysteries in this book were very solid.
I had two minor problems with this book which caused me to lower the grade from 5-stars to 4-stars.
1. Again, deeming this book a "historical romance" is misleading. In my opinion, this book is more mystery than romance. Yes, there is romance and some sexing near the end of the book, but it isn't integral to the plot.
2. The author included the killer's POV when he was doing the killing. These were very disturbing parts of the book because the murders are graphic and sick. The killer is sick and the author really captured his joy at torturing these poor women. The descriptions could have been scaled back and the story wouldn't have lost anything.
And on that note, I would like to finish off with a warning for potential readers: This book contains scenes of explicit violence against animals and women. Not for the faint of heart who are bothered with dismemberment, torture, and sadistic descriptions of violence.
There are several mysteries going on throughout this book:
1. The heroine, Catherine, has a horrible secret and harbors a deep pain. What is her secret?
2. Catherine's friend, Madeline's, health is deteriorating and she seems quite delusional one moment and sane the next. When she is warning Catherine of danger lurking around every corner - is she sane or is it a side-effect of her paranoid delusions?
3. There is someone killing and taking apart women that Catherine knows... who is doing the killing and for what purpose?
4. The hero - again, he didn't seem much like hero material for most of the book - Gabriel, is cold and harbors secrets even more successfully than Catherine. Can she trust this man? Is he the killer? Are Madeline's ramblings about him true? What're his secrets and what has caused him to become so cold and in control of his emotions?
I formulated a guess early on in the book as to who the killer was and I was right. But this didn't disappoint me because when the story behind the killer is revealed late in the book, I was surprised. The mysteries in this book were very solid.
I had two minor problems with this book which caused me to lower the grade from 5-stars to 4-stars.
1. Again, deeming this book a "historical romance" is misleading. In my opinion, this book is more mystery than romance. Yes, there is romance and some sexing near the end of the book, but it isn't integral to the plot.
2. The author included the killer's POV when he was doing the killing. These were very disturbing parts of the book because the murders are graphic and sick. The killer is sick and the author really captured his joy at torturing these poor women. The descriptions could have been scaled back and the story wouldn't have lost anything.
And on that note, I would like to finish off with a warning for potential readers: This book contains scenes of explicit violence against animals and women. Not for the faint of heart who are bothered with dismemberment, torture, and sadistic descriptions of violence.
January 8, 2021
This one deserves all the stars, and the moon, and the planets, and all the dark, black holes. *sighs* This is how you write a love story. This is how to write tension, and intriguing characters, and a plot that never lets up. This author really has a talent for words and she knows how to string them together like music. GAH! I'm riding such a high right now.
January 21, 2015
I am not sure why, but I have decided to read Eve Silver's Dark Gothic series backwards, starting with number five. I've had some of them on my TBR pile for nearly ten years. Time to jump in!
I love Gothic romances, this one being set in Regency England. Ooo, and it was dark. Gruesome even, with a sick and twisted killer on the loose. Catherine, the heroine, is summoned to Cairncroft Abbey to care for her ailing childhood friend, Madeline. Poor Catherine brought some very heavy emotional baggage with her. Madeline's cousin, Gabriel, is lord of the manor, and the two have an uneasy relationship. Catherine soon finds out that mysterious Gabriel is just as damaged as she, but that doesn't stop her obsession with him.
I enjoyed this book very much. The writing was smart with sophisticated language, and I loved how everything came full-circle, from the unnerving opening scene to the exciting ending. Woven into the plot were many twists, surprising revelations, and red herrings that kept things interesting. What else to say, other than I'm looking forward to reading the previous books in this series. 4 stars!
I love Gothic romances, this one being set in Regency England. Ooo, and it was dark. Gruesome even, with a sick and twisted killer on the loose. Catherine, the heroine, is summoned to Cairncroft Abbey to care for her ailing childhood friend, Madeline. Poor Catherine brought some very heavy emotional baggage with her. Madeline's cousin, Gabriel, is lord of the manor, and the two have an uneasy relationship. Catherine soon finds out that mysterious Gabriel is just as damaged as she, but that doesn't stop her obsession with him.
I enjoyed this book very much. The writing was smart with sophisticated language, and I loved how everything came full-circle, from the unnerving opening scene to the exciting ending. Woven into the plot were many twists, surprising revelations, and red herrings that kept things interesting. What else to say, other than I'm looking forward to reading the previous books in this series. 4 stars!
October 18, 2012
I was in the mood for Gothic, and picked this because it was supposedly steamy (which I was also in the mood for). However, it was disappointing, because it was mostly really gross with detailed descriptions of nasty crimes. More bloody than steamy, I'd say. Took me a long time to read it, because I could only take so much at once, and was generally reluctant to return to it. Hero and heroine are also chockablock with personal issues and scars (literal and figurative) from their respective terrible pasts. It was all a bit much. The prospect for a HEA seemed dim to me.
October 21, 2016
The fifth book in the Dark Gothic series by Eve Silver. Set in England in 1812, this novel has a dark, gothic feel to it. One of the better books I've read by Eve Silver.
July 4, 2021
I’m still traumatized by the bird.
October 14, 2019
I'm rounding up. Capital D.A.R.K. with the Gothic! I enjoyed it but had issues. Saving all my comments for coffee with Lesley and Christina. :D
June 13, 2011
After having read and loved Eve Silver's Otherkin series, I decided to purchase Seduced by a Stranger. This book is not a paranormal romance but a very dark and twisty gothic. The grim tone is set at the very beginning of the book with the heroine, Catherine Weston, buried alive and slowly being crushed to death until rescued by another child, Madeline St. Aubyn, who also attends the same school. Then in another scene the reader is exposed to a budding serial killer. A few readers may find the violence disturbing. (The graphic scenes are similar to Nora Roberts/J.D. Robb.)
In this story, Catherine receives a letter from a very ill Madeline requesting her company at Cairncroft Abbey, which is the residence of Gabriel St. Aubyn. Catherine is greeted by a gloomy and perplexing household. The staff also whisper of curses and insanity. As Catherine cares for her friend she must endure the company Madeline's cousin Gabriel. He is provoking and odd. They both wear masks and both seem broken and/or scarred by events in their past. In the meantime the killer finds another victim.
The beinning third of this book is slow then the pace picks up.
There are three POVs presented in this novel. Catherine, Gabriel, and the killer. The mystery of the killer almost seemed clichéd but Eve Silver adds something fresh to the writing. Overall, I give it a 3.5 and give it 4 stars because I couldn't put it down towards the end.
One a side note - I would think Gabriel would have been more damaged from what he suffered. Plus, Mrs. Bell mysterious behavior was never explained. Did she know the first murder victim? Why did she stay?
In this story, Catherine receives a letter from a very ill Madeline requesting her company at Cairncroft Abbey, which is the residence of Gabriel St. Aubyn. Catherine is greeted by a gloomy and perplexing household. The staff also whisper of curses and insanity. As Catherine cares for her friend she must endure the company Madeline's cousin Gabriel. He is provoking and odd. They both wear masks and both seem broken and/or scarred by events in their past. In the meantime the killer finds another victim.
The beinning third of this book is slow then the pace picks up.
There are three POVs presented in this novel. Catherine, Gabriel, and the killer. The mystery of the killer almost seemed clichéd but Eve Silver adds something fresh to the writing. Overall, I give it a 3.5 and give it 4 stars because I couldn't put it down towards the end.
One a side note - I would think Gabriel would have been more damaged from what he suffered. Plus, Mrs. Bell mysterious behavior was never explained. Did she know the first murder victim? Why did she stay?
October 30, 2024
Overall: 2.5 stars.
Well, this was a kind of fun but not very satisfying gothic romance? A strange way to put it, perhaps, but I felt like the emotional payoff and plot resolutions just didn't feel as complete as I'd like. This book has some bonkers plot twists as well that don't fully make sense, but I've read other gothics that have that silliness that pull it off more effectively. In this genre, in my opinion, the plot twists don't necessarily have to make perfect rational sense; they just have to fit within the world of the story and feel like a satisfying conclusion for the reader.
In addition, the "final showdown scene" with the villain wraps up very quickly and then we're off to the epilogue and HEA with rapid speed. However, I did enjoy the set-up and initial chapters of this book which really channel those classic spooky gothic vibes.
There's some lovely love confessions and wonderfully weird, edgy banter between heroine and hero as well, and I liked our main characters, although the supporting cast and villain were....a lot. Also there's some villain POV chapters which is a pet peeve of mine that I hate, but YMMV.
CW: murder, torture, infanticide, mental ayslums
Well, this was a kind of fun but not very satisfying gothic romance? A strange way to put it, perhaps, but I felt like the emotional payoff and plot resolutions just didn't feel as complete as I'd like. This book has some bonkers plot twists as well that don't fully make sense, but I've read other gothics that have that silliness that pull it off more effectively. In this genre, in my opinion, the plot twists don't necessarily have to make perfect rational sense; they just have to fit within the world of the story and feel like a satisfying conclusion for the reader.
In addition, the "final showdown scene" with the villain wraps up very quickly and then we're off to the epilogue and HEA with rapid speed. However, I did enjoy the set-up and initial chapters of this book which really channel those classic spooky gothic vibes.
There's some lovely love confessions and wonderfully weird, edgy banter between heroine and hero as well, and I liked our main characters, although the supporting cast and villain were....a lot. Also there's some villain POV chapters which is a pet peeve of mine that I hate, but YMMV.
CW: murder, torture, infanticide, mental ayslums
January 1, 2020
First book of the decade for me! :D
Okay, so, this might've actually been my favorite from the series. It still maintains the same themes, which is a shame, but I loved that the heroine was definitely different from the others in this series (and honestly, also from most of historical romance heroines in general). And I'm definitely clear on the fact that the author did well to suddenly start doing multiple POVs since the last installment, as it breathed a fresh air into this.
The story was pretty predictable in general, and once again, everything was wrapped up probably way too nicely - but the book still introduced a lot of not-so-usual themes, with a heroine who was not a virgin anymore, or who couldn't have children (and the author didn't back out with this), or the hero who didn't want them. Which just made it all the better.
Okay, so, this might've actually been my favorite from the series. It still maintains the same themes, which is a shame, but I loved that the heroine was definitely different from the others in this series (and honestly, also from most of historical romance heroines in general). And I'm definitely clear on the fact that the author did well to suddenly start doing multiple POVs since the last installment, as it breathed a fresh air into this.
The story was pretty predictable in general, and once again, everything was wrapped up probably way too nicely - but the book still introduced a lot of not-so-usual themes, with a heroine who was not a virgin anymore, or who couldn't have children (and the author didn't back out with this), or the hero who didn't want them. Which just made it all the better.
September 26, 2017
3.75/5 rounded up.
This is a wonderfully dark Gothic romance. One plot twist I saw from the very beginning, but the other I was totally surprised by. Well done Ms, Silver! This isn't a four star read outright because I wanted a little more chemistry between Catherine and Gabriel and some of the plot elements were way over the top for my taste. (Though they are in keeping with Gothic literary traditions.)
Be warned this is not your typical historical romance; women are murdered on page and there are instances of animal cruelty. If you do like your historical romances with an element of horror/thriller, I would definitely recommend giving this a try!
This is a wonderfully dark Gothic romance. One plot twist I saw from the very beginning, but the other I was totally surprised by. Well done Ms, Silver! This isn't a four star read outright because I wanted a little more chemistry between Catherine and Gabriel and some of the plot elements were way over the top for my taste. (Though they are in keeping with Gothic literary traditions.)
Be warned this is not your typical historical romance; women are murdered on page and there are instances of animal cruelty. If you do like your historical romances with an element of horror/thriller, I would definitely recommend giving this a try!
October 14, 2018
Loved it - and it really puts the 'dark' in dark gothic romance!
September 1, 2009
Seduced by a Stranger by Eve Silver
Historical Romance-Gothic- Sept 1st, 2009
4 stars
Eve Silver has written has out done herself with her latest gothic Seduced by a Stranger. This story kept me guessing until almost the very end! Seduced by a Stranger is without a doubt, her most terrifying and thrilling gothic to date. I was intensely drawn to the shadowy, tortured hero and the courageous heroine. This novel is guaranteed to scare and shock you with deliciously twisted turns and a diabolical murderer!
Catherine’s invitation to visit with an old school mate, Madeline seems like a Godsend. However, when she reaches Cairncroft Abbey she is dismayed by the lack of hospitality and warnings of doom should she stay. But Cathereine will not desert her friend. Poor Madeline is emaciated and confused. Her cousin, Sir Gabriel St. Aubyn is dark and forbidding. Although Catherine eventually comes to fear for herself and her friend, she has no where else to go. Unfortunately, complications from her past leave Catherine with few choices. She resolves to make the best of her situation and console Madeline. To add to her troubles, Catherine soon finds herself irresistibly drawn to the enigmatic and handsome Sir Gabriel even as she suspects he may be linked to a series of grisly murders.
This gothic was much darker and twisted that I had expected. Eve Silver also does an excellent job of creating characters with depth. Each has a past they would rather not reveal and I found their secret pasts added tremendously to the characters and the story line. As I discovered more about them I became caught in the stories of these 2 strong personalities, eager to discover the truth behind their suffering. The character development in Eve Silver’s hero and heroine are fully fleshed and extremely interesting. Gabriel is particularly fascinating and mysterious. I was impressed with Catherine’s determination and willingness to risk all for love. In addition, the villain in this novel was deliciously evil and diabolical. One of the cruelest I’ve read in a long time. Although I was fascinated by the mystery in the story the villain both fascinated and repelled me. At the suspenseful and tumultuous end, I was shocked by the murderer’s motives and cruelty.
This was a rare read. Gothic romance at its very best!
Reviewed by Steph from the Bookaholics Romance Book Club
Historical Romance-Gothic- Sept 1st, 2009
4 stars
Eve Silver has written has out done herself with her latest gothic Seduced by a Stranger. This story kept me guessing until almost the very end! Seduced by a Stranger is without a doubt, her most terrifying and thrilling gothic to date. I was intensely drawn to the shadowy, tortured hero and the courageous heroine. This novel is guaranteed to scare and shock you with deliciously twisted turns and a diabolical murderer!
Catherine’s invitation to visit with an old school mate, Madeline seems like a Godsend. However, when she reaches Cairncroft Abbey she is dismayed by the lack of hospitality and warnings of doom should she stay. But Cathereine will not desert her friend. Poor Madeline is emaciated and confused. Her cousin, Sir Gabriel St. Aubyn is dark and forbidding. Although Catherine eventually comes to fear for herself and her friend, she has no where else to go. Unfortunately, complications from her past leave Catherine with few choices. She resolves to make the best of her situation and console Madeline. To add to her troubles, Catherine soon finds herself irresistibly drawn to the enigmatic and handsome Sir Gabriel even as she suspects he may be linked to a series of grisly murders.
This gothic was much darker and twisted that I had expected. Eve Silver also does an excellent job of creating characters with depth. Each has a past they would rather not reveal and I found their secret pasts added tremendously to the characters and the story line. As I discovered more about them I became caught in the stories of these 2 strong personalities, eager to discover the truth behind their suffering. The character development in Eve Silver’s hero and heroine are fully fleshed and extremely interesting. Gabriel is particularly fascinating and mysterious. I was impressed with Catherine’s determination and willingness to risk all for love. In addition, the villain in this novel was deliciously evil and diabolical. One of the cruelest I’ve read in a long time. Although I was fascinated by the mystery in the story the villain both fascinated and repelled me. At the suspenseful and tumultuous end, I was shocked by the murderer’s motives and cruelty.
This was a rare read. Gothic romance at its very best!
Reviewed by Steph from the Bookaholics Romance Book Club
October 20, 2009
Eve Silver writes dark books. This is no exception. I don't expect to laugh when I read one of Eve's books, but I do expect to be enthralled with the dark, damaged characters searching for redemption and love (even if they don't know it yet) and Eve's incredible talent for writing a gothic atmosphere so palpable you can almost see the fog rolling in or feel the edge of the sharp blade the villain wields.
The heroine Catherine is summoned to help her friend Madeline who has fallen very ill. Along with Madeline lives her cousin Gabriel who has a lifetime of secrets behind him that make him hard and seemingly uncaring. There is a serial killer in London and evidence seems to point toward Gabriel. Catherine has secrets of her own, dark ones (of course), but she finds herself very attracted to Gabriel despite her better judgement. As the story progresses, we learn about Gabriel's past. In this section I was absolutely riveted. Gabriel's past is a novel unto itself and absolutely horrific (in the best way possible) and shows how his life changed against his will, therefore changing him forever.
This is a gothic/psychological suspense/horror novel in the form of a romance novel. Don't let the pink dress on the cover fool you! You're getting more grisly murders than fancy balls in this one -- and I loved it!
The heroine Catherine is summoned to help her friend Madeline who has fallen very ill. Along with Madeline lives her cousin Gabriel who has a lifetime of secrets behind him that make him hard and seemingly uncaring. There is a serial killer in London and evidence seems to point toward Gabriel. Catherine has secrets of her own, dark ones (of course), but she finds herself very attracted to Gabriel despite her better judgement. As the story progresses, we learn about Gabriel's past. In this section I was absolutely riveted. Gabriel's past is a novel unto itself and absolutely horrific (in the best way possible) and shows how his life changed against his will, therefore changing him forever.
This is a gothic/psychological suspense/horror novel in the form of a romance novel. Don't let the pink dress on the cover fool you! You're getting more grisly murders than fancy balls in this one -- and I loved it!
January 19, 2021
Darkly compelling plot of twists, secrets and revelations!
A truly well written tale grounded by tortured characters that you can't help but yearn for a spattering of happiness to find them. Instantly you are gripped as an eery and disturbing read emerges that will have you on edge and intrigued by the end of your first breath.
The complex and fleshy characters, that are well developed and shaped by their twisted pasts, (that are just as much engrossing and absorbing as they are horrifying and disturbing), pull you in and hold you in suspense and eager anticipation for their next revelation.
Gabriel and Catherine, both scarred by pasts laced with heinous suffering and torment, bond through instant unexpected attraction, building sexual tension and the shared recognition of having found a kindred spirit (in the emotional walls they erect) as they not only fight their draw to each other but to solve a host of gruesome murders, unravel malicious scheming and dark sinister secrets that if left alone can only breed mistrust and threaten to tear them apart.
A mixture of ensnaring chemistry and tormented characters interwoven into an unforgettable plotline of well written intrigue and disturbing happenings incased in one chillingly gothic surrounding - I just loved it!
A truly well written tale grounded by tortured characters that you can't help but yearn for a spattering of happiness to find them. Instantly you are gripped as an eery and disturbing read emerges that will have you on edge and intrigued by the end of your first breath.
The complex and fleshy characters, that are well developed and shaped by their twisted pasts, (that are just as much engrossing and absorbing as they are horrifying and disturbing), pull you in and hold you in suspense and eager anticipation for their next revelation.
Gabriel and Catherine, both scarred by pasts laced with heinous suffering and torment, bond through instant unexpected attraction, building sexual tension and the shared recognition of having found a kindred spirit (in the emotional walls they erect) as they not only fight their draw to each other but to solve a host of gruesome murders, unravel malicious scheming and dark sinister secrets that if left alone can only breed mistrust and threaten to tear them apart.
A mixture of ensnaring chemistry and tormented characters interwoven into an unforgettable plotline of well written intrigue and disturbing happenings incased in one chillingly gothic surrounding - I just loved it!
August 30, 2009
If you haven't read an Eve Silver Gothic historical, I would urge you to pick one up. She is simply an amazing story-teller. I have not read any thing that compares to the eerie tone that she sets in each of her books. She is one gifted author in the art of making your eyes widen, your blood curdle, your skin crawl, your heart to beat in anticipation, as each scene unfolds, engaging you further and further into the disturbing plot and the lives of each of the characters.
Without a doubt, Seduced by a Stranger is Eve Silver's darkest, most twisted tale to date. I wondered how she would top His Wicked Sins, and as I read this one I was amazed all over again at her uncanny ability to seduce you into the mysterious, dark and at times morbid lives of Gabriel, Geoffrey, Sebastien, Madeline and Catherine.
There is no need to go into any plot summary. Anything that is not in the blurb would be giving more away than should be given. This is one to read without knowing anything in order to get the true sense of intensity Eve Silver built, leading you to the culminating ending. If you want to read a little something dark, and completely riveting then this book is sure to meet your needs.
Without a doubt, Seduced by a Stranger is Eve Silver's darkest, most twisted tale to date. I wondered how she would top His Wicked Sins, and as I read this one I was amazed all over again at her uncanny ability to seduce you into the mysterious, dark and at times morbid lives of Gabriel, Geoffrey, Sebastien, Madeline and Catherine.
There is no need to go into any plot summary. Anything that is not in the blurb would be giving more away than should be given. This is one to read without knowing anything in order to get the true sense of intensity Eve Silver built, leading you to the culminating ending. If you want to read a little something dark, and completely riveting then this book is sure to meet your needs.
January 10, 2016
Uh.... I have never been so mentally exhausted from experiencing every character's EVERY woe and past trauma... WHEW. Glad that's over. I'd rather feel compassion for characters who aren't puppeteered for that response from the author. Don't tell me how/what to feel; I can do that on my own accord, thank you. I need no crowd of literary jeers/cheers to prompt mine.
It made me think that she couldn't describe anything without actually pointing out the obvious or saying a word she's trying to describe.
I'm not skilled by any form in the art of writing, but as a reader I felt like Silver had the chart on what individual characters are supposed to be feeling at all times, but her prose washed out the feelings and you became tired of said feelings, because their endless feelz weren't withheld from the audiences view. It was like held-up flashcards of emotional display. The characters were supposed to be very austere and reserved, but you saw them masking it in the text; their true feelings behind the words and the author doesn't know how to convey them without giving it ALL up to you. The poker-face is bad with this bunch. We're not supposed to know the 'behind the scene' of every character in the text. Even if we are, I prefer subtle hints.
It made me think that she couldn't describe anything without actually pointing out the obvious or saying a word she's trying to describe.
I'm not skilled by any form in the art of writing, but as a reader I felt like Silver had the chart on what individual characters are supposed to be feeling at all times, but her prose washed out the feelings and you became tired of said feelings, because their endless feelz weren't withheld from the audiences view. It was like held-up flashcards of emotional display. The characters were supposed to be very austere and reserved, but you saw them masking it in the text; their true feelings behind the words and the author doesn't know how to convey them without giving it ALL up to you. The poker-face is bad with this bunch. We're not supposed to know the 'behind the scene' of every character in the text. Even if we are, I prefer subtle hints.
January 6, 2013
This book is more like a murder mystery (or maybe an attempt at a modern horrid novel?? Plenty of references to the novel Frankenstein) than a romance novel. Not much romance and not a good murder mystery.
I was frustrated with the evasions and lack of information in the first half of the book as it seemed that everyone introduced felt like "red herrings" including the cousin and the man who forced the maid.
Once the evil twin was introduced (past halfway throught he book) it was obvious he did it. That is so dishonest to wait so long to introduce the actual villain.
The hero is the typical, cold, don't feel, don't show emotion type. I had the feeling he knew who was responsible and yet he didn't do anything to really investigate. He kind of shrugged his shoulders and then went into his office.
For a change, the heroine is also the "don't show any emotion" type. Not mmuch to recommend her. Not for her lack of feelings, but for her lack of moral fiber. I just don't see her staying with the hero for more than a few years.
The ending wasn't a surprise and the hero never had his chance to confront the villain before his death so I felt cheated.
I was frustrated with the evasions and lack of information in the first half of the book as it seemed that everyone introduced felt like "red herrings" including the cousin and the man who forced the maid.
Once the evil twin was introduced (past halfway throught he book) it was obvious he did it. That is so dishonest to wait so long to introduce the actual villain.
The hero is the typical, cold, don't feel, don't show emotion type. I had the feeling he knew who was responsible and yet he didn't do anything to really investigate. He kind of shrugged his shoulders and then went into his office.
For a change, the heroine is also the "don't show any emotion" type. Not mmuch to recommend her. Not for her lack of feelings, but for her lack of moral fiber. I just don't see her staying with the hero for more than a few years.
The ending wasn't a surprise and the hero never had his chance to confront the villain before his death so I felt cheated.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 29, 2015
I have always loved those atmospheric, shivery, gothic romances – the spooky houses, the moody hero, the uncertainty of who is friend and who is foe. The only thing I found lacking was spice. Several years ago, I discovered author Eve Silver, who wrote a small (unfortunately) series of five gothics, which I adored. Her books were definitely sexy, and just what I was looking for. Eve soon moved on to be very successful in other genres, but I have never given up hope that she may have another gothic romance or two in her just waiting to burst free.
Seduced By a Stranger is a dark, sexy story. Both the hero and heroine have endured terrible experiences in their pasts. There is an evil twin, twists and turns, heart pounding excitement, love and healing, and a resolution that is perfect. If you’re a fan of this genre, or just like a darker historical romance, this book should be on your to-be-read list. I can also recommend Dark Desires, Dark Prince, His Dark Kiss, and His Wicked Sins.
http://t.co/0q5GowvB8H
Seduced By a Stranger is a dark, sexy story. Both the hero and heroine have endured terrible experiences in their pasts. There is an evil twin, twists and turns, heart pounding excitement, love and healing, and a resolution that is perfect. If you’re a fan of this genre, or just like a darker historical romance, this book should be on your to-be-read list. I can also recommend Dark Desires, Dark Prince, His Dark Kiss, and His Wicked Sins.
http://t.co/0q5GowvB8H
March 23, 2019
When in 1828 Catherine Weston is dismissed from his post as companion without a reference she readily accepts an offer from a childhood friend. Madeline St Aubyn, in poor health, has invited her to stay at Cairncrof Abbey. But what are the secrets that the Abbey hids, can the secrets from the past come to light.
An enjoyable Gothic mystery and romance
An enjoyable Gothic mystery and romance
October 6, 2023
Reading yet again because it's spooky season and Eve Silver delivers!
She never gets old! 🖤🖤
She never gets old! 🖤🖤
May 19, 2020
Hang in
I've read all the previous books in this series. This one took me a while to get into. I realize now why that is. Really good story, really good mystery.
I've read all the previous books in this series. This one took me a while to get into. I realize now why that is. Really good story, really good mystery.
October 27, 2022
A perfect mystery/thriller/romance to read during spooky season!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 113 reviews