Lee Child hasn’t published one of his own “Reacher” novels since 2019, after handing his bestselling series off to his brother Andrew. However, that hasn’t stopped him from being heavily involved with his internationally well-known character, both helping out with the popular Amazon streaming show and providing his brother feedback on the current novels.
First and foremost, this is not a work of fiction. Other than the short story “A Better Place” added in at the end (probably to add enough material to sell this work as a short novel rather than the novella length it really is, as well as to entice the reader with something new from Reacher’s creator).
Second, and more important, this is a work of non-fiction that Lee Child and Otto Penzler, owner of the Mysterious Press bookstore in New York and publisher of the same name, created to please the hardcore fans of both Reacher and his creator. Penzler tried for years to convince Child to let him publish a limited collector’s edition of the Reacher novels, and finally Child agreed to it. Penzler decided to push his luck and ask Child to write a new forward for each of the books. One that would add value and make each edition even more special for the hardcore fans by revealing literary and personal insights that went into the creation, plotting and writing each of the books.
The good news is that Child agreed to writing those forwards and purposely chose to turn the introductions into his own writer’s diary of not only what he was thinking, but also what was going on in his life during the writing of his novels. For me, this was a good decision and more than better approach. As much as I was interested and mesmerized by the behind the creative literary stories (I loved them), the addition of his personal life, happenings, and events, added an additional layer of quality and depth to the reading experience. It’s one thing to have read the Reacher novels for almost the last 30 years (and what a great adventure it has been), but now looking back and reflecting over them in this reflective reunion amplifies that emotional connection.
The result is this book, which is made up of (1) a new introduction from Child, (2) the 24 new forwards that he wrote for each of the limited-edition novels, (3) a new original Reacher short story, titled “A Better Place”, and (4) an afterward from the publisher, Otto Prenzler.
For me, this book is a perfect bookend to go with the other two non-fiction books that Andy Martin wrote with Lee Child - “Reacher Said Nothing: Lee Child and the Making of Make Me” and “With Child” – which all together cover pretty much all of Child’s life, his creation of the Reacher character, writing history and approach, and the phenomenal publishing history that made him an international bestselling author that walked away on his own terms. These three books provide all of the behind the scenes, key events, motivating factors, and writer’s secrets that you would ever want to know about Lee Child.
However, having said that, this book is not for everyone. Not everyone wants to know how the candy is made and the secret recipes that create it. Some people just want to enjoy the taste of the candy and that is satisfaction enough. If that is the case for you, then you may want to pass on this one.
As for me, I am very grateful that Penzler got Child to write these new introductions for each of his 24 Reacher novels, from the first – “The Killing Floor” – all the way to the last “Blue Moon”. I love hearing the thoughts on a writer’s creative process, especially when it involves a series and iconic character like Reacher that will more than likely stand the test of time in the world of literary fiction. This book allowed me to step behind the curtain and connect with one my favorite writers. It was sentimental and reflective for me. Enough said.
In closing, I share my personal thank you to Lee Child for opening up and sharing part of your writing and personal experiences, and a second thank you to Otto Penzler for sharing them with the public, which allowed me the chance to read them while being priced out of the limited collector’s editions. It left me feeling lucky and blessed.
As for a Goodreads rating, even though this is not a cohesive book, but more of a collection of essays, I will go with a 4 out of 5 stars for sentimental reasons.