What do you think?
Rate this book
Unhallowed Halls
A teen girl travels to an exclusive boarding school located deep within the Scottish moorlands after a deadly incident at her old school, but the wood-paneled halls of Agathion are built over centuries of secrets—including an ancient society which may have ties to demonic magic—in this dark academia fantasy perfect for fans of Curious Tides.
Page Whittaker has always been an outcast. And after the deadly incident that destroyed her single friendship at her old school, she needs a fresh start. Which is why when she receives a scholarship offer from Agathion College, an elite boarding school folded deep within the moors of Scotland, she doesn’t even consider turning it down.
Agathion is everything Page has ever a safe haven full of dusty books, steaming cups of tea and rigorous intellectual debate. And for the first time in her life, Page has even managed to become part of a close group of friends. Cyrus, Ren, Gideon, Lacey and Oak help her feel at home in Agathion's halls--the only problem is, they're all keeping secrets from her.
Page doesn't know it yet, but her perfect new school has dark roots--roots that stretch back to its crooked foundation, and an ancient clandestine society with rumored ties to demonic magic. Soon, Page will be forced to learn that not everyone at Agathion is who they say they are. Least of all, her friends.
Agathion claims to teach its students history…but some histories should stay buried.
Page Whittaker has always been an outcast. And after the deadly incident that destroyed her single friendship at her old school, she needs a fresh start. Which is why when she receives a scholarship offer from Agathion College, an elite boarding school folded deep within the moors of Scotland, she doesn’t even consider turning it down.
Agathion is everything Page has ever a safe haven full of dusty books, steaming cups of tea and rigorous intellectual debate. And for the first time in her life, Page has even managed to become part of a close group of friends. Cyrus, Ren, Gideon, Lacey and Oak help her feel at home in Agathion's halls--the only problem is, they're all keeping secrets from her.
Page doesn't know it yet, but her perfect new school has dark roots--roots that stretch back to its crooked foundation, and an ancient clandestine society with rumored ties to demonic magic. Soon, Page will be forced to learn that not everyone at Agathion is who they say they are. Least of all, her friends.
Agathion claims to teach its students history…but some histories should stay buried.
456 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 18, 2025
86 people are currently reading
6112 people want to read
About the author
Lili Wilkinson
33 books369 followersLili Wilkinson is the award-winning author of eighteen books for young people, including The Erasure Initiative and After the Lights Go Out. Lili has a PhD from the University of Melbourne, and is a passionate advocate for YA and the young people who read it, establishing the Inky Awards at the Centre for Youth Literature, State Library of Victoria. Her latest book is A Hunger of Thorns.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 309 reviews
February 18, 2025
"Unhallowed Halls" offers an enticing premise, plunging readers into the shadowy corridors of Agathion, a secluded boarding school steeped in mystery. The story follows Page Whittaker, a scholarship student with a troubled past, as she navigates the school's archaic traditions and befriends a group of enigmatic students. The atmospheric setting is richly drawn, creating a sense of foreboding that draws readers in.
The book's first half is its strongest, balancing an intriguing mystery with dark academia elements. Page's attempts to adapt to the rigid environment and her growing friendships with Cyrus, Lacey, and others are well-paced and engaging. The classical literature references add an intellectual layer, though they remain largely surface-level, missing opportunities to enhance the narrative's depth.
However, as the plot shifts towards the fantastical, the story begins to lose its footing. The introduction of supernatural elements, while intriguing, feels abrupt and poorly integrated. The pacing becomes uneven, with some plot points rushed and others dragging. Several characters, particularly Lacey and Cyrus, lack the development needed to make their arcs impactful.
The resolution ties up the main storyline but leaves a host of unanswered questions, such as the fate of certain characters and the implications of the school's darker secrets. While the book starts with promise, its second half struggles to maintain the tension and polish that made the beginning so compelling.
Overall, Unhallowed Halls is a mixed bag. It excels in atmosphere and setup, making it a potential favorite for fans of dark academia and younger readers new to the genre. However, its uneven execution and missed opportunities may leave seasoned readers wanting more.
medium blog
instagram
facebook
twitter
The book's first half is its strongest, balancing an intriguing mystery with dark academia elements. Page's attempts to adapt to the rigid environment and her growing friendships with Cyrus, Lacey, and others are well-paced and engaging. The classical literature references add an intellectual layer, though they remain largely surface-level, missing opportunities to enhance the narrative's depth.
However, as the plot shifts towards the fantastical, the story begins to lose its footing. The introduction of supernatural elements, while intriguing, feels abrupt and poorly integrated. The pacing becomes uneven, with some plot points rushed and others dragging. Several characters, particularly Lacey and Cyrus, lack the development needed to make their arcs impactful.
The resolution ties up the main storyline but leaves a host of unanswered questions, such as the fate of certain characters and the implications of the school's darker secrets. While the book starts with promise, its second half struggles to maintain the tension and polish that made the beginning so compelling.
Overall, Unhallowed Halls is a mixed bag. It excels in atmosphere and setup, making it a potential favorite for fans of dark academia and younger readers new to the genre. However, its uneven execution and missed opportunities may leave seasoned readers wanting more.
medium blog
February 9, 2025
A brooding slice of dark academia that ruthlessly criss-crosses genre boundaries. After a traumatic incident abruptly severed her connection with her girlfriend and turned her into a pariah, American teen Page is shocked to be offered a scholarship to elite boarding school Agathion College. Tucked away in remote, rural Scotland, Agathion has a reputation for housing “posh fuckups”. Built on a once-sacred, ancient hillside, Agathion seems to have created its own reality. Its pupils are beset by complex rules and arcane rituals: there’s no technology, students must leave personal possessions behind, and even nineteenth-century fiction’s considered too newfangled. Page strives to keep her chequered past hidden but soon realises her teachers and fellow students have their own sinister secrets to protect.
Lili Wilkinson, in an obvious nod to The Secret History, floods her novel with elements taken from Greek mythology and philosophy but adds in copious allusions to Shakespeare and gothic literature from The Mysteries of Udolpho to Northanger Abbey. Although these can be entertaining, the sheer number of references threatens to overwhelm the narrative – and the representation of Greek philosophy can be frustratingly unsophisticated. It also seems increasingly irrelevant, overwritten by aspects of pre-Christian Celtic and pagan belief systems that are instrumental in the transition into fantasy threaded through with strands of cosmic, Lovecraftian horror.
Despite the obvious tropes and mish-mash of influences, I was completely caught up in this, at least until the mystery that dominated the first half was solved. Wilkinson’s cast of characters is pleasingly diverse even if the queer rep could feel a bit superficial at times. There’s some stirring imagery and a wealth of atmospheric, arresting scenes - I particularly enjoyed the startling blend of absurd and grotesque in the banquet episode. But in the second half there’s a disappointing shift in tone and pace. There’s a series of frenzied plot developments and an emphasis on overly detailed, slightly muddled, action sequences. All of which came close to derailing my investment in Page and her fate. All in all, it was still a decent read but it could have been so much more.
Thanks to Netgalley and publisher Titan Books for an ARC
Lili Wilkinson, in an obvious nod to The Secret History, floods her novel with elements taken from Greek mythology and philosophy but adds in copious allusions to Shakespeare and gothic literature from The Mysteries of Udolpho to Northanger Abbey. Although these can be entertaining, the sheer number of references threatens to overwhelm the narrative – and the representation of Greek philosophy can be frustratingly unsophisticated. It also seems increasingly irrelevant, overwritten by aspects of pre-Christian Celtic and pagan belief systems that are instrumental in the transition into fantasy threaded through with strands of cosmic, Lovecraftian horror.
Despite the obvious tropes and mish-mash of influences, I was completely caught up in this, at least until the mystery that dominated the first half was solved. Wilkinson’s cast of characters is pleasingly diverse even if the queer rep could feel a bit superficial at times. There’s some stirring imagery and a wealth of atmospheric, arresting scenes - I particularly enjoyed the startling blend of absurd and grotesque in the banquet episode. But in the second half there’s a disappointing shift in tone and pace. There’s a series of frenzied plot developments and an emphasis on overly detailed, slightly muddled, action sequences. All of which came close to derailing my investment in Page and her fate. All in all, it was still a decent read but it could have been so much more.
Thanks to Netgalley and publisher Titan Books for an ARC
September 28, 2024
ARC for review. To be published February 18, 2025.
Page Whitacker had some major issues at her old school in Lakeland, Florida, but now she has received a scholarship to fancy Agathion, a school in England for rich kids with behavioral issues.
And what a school! There’s no tech allowed, everything is supplied to students and they are focused solely on classical Latin and Greek works.
Page meets Cyrus on her first day and wants to fit in with him and his crew, Ren, Gideon, Oak and Lacey. She actually does find a place within the group and then becomes privy to a secret that could change the whole school, may the whole WORLD, and will reveal who she really is.
The first half of the book is definitely YA for YA and I don’t know that adult readers would love it, but if those readers stick around for the second half this fantasy/dark academia books gets much wider in scope. It’s also a nice introduction to classic (meaning SUPER classical, think Cicero, not PRIDE AND PREJUDICE) literature for those unfamiliar. Fantasy is not my thing, but if it’s yours you may enjoy this one.
Page Whitacker had some major issues at her old school in Lakeland, Florida, but now she has received a scholarship to fancy Agathion, a school in England for rich kids with behavioral issues.
And what a school! There’s no tech allowed, everything is supplied to students and they are focused solely on classical Latin and Greek works.
Page meets Cyrus on her first day and wants to fit in with him and his crew, Ren, Gideon, Oak and Lacey. She actually does find a place within the group and then becomes privy to a secret that could change the whole school, may the whole WORLD, and will reveal who she really is.
The first half of the book is definitely YA for YA and I don’t know that adult readers would love it, but if those readers stick around for the second half this fantasy/dark academia books gets much wider in scope. It’s also a nice introduction to classic (meaning SUPER classical, think Cicero, not PRIDE AND PREJUDICE) literature for those unfamiliar. Fantasy is not my thing, but if it’s yours you may enjoy this one.
February 23, 2025
Dark academia gothic with demons! I found this a lot creeper than I anticipated and have discovered a new favourite read. Unhallowed Halls is the perfect combination of gothic and dark academia literary bliss.
Agathion College is set on a wild and remote Scottish moor! Yes you read that correctly. This lent to the most beautiful scenery and atmosphere.
Page finds herself at the prestigious college after a strange accident. Initially she feels like she has found the perfect place for herself until she discovers the college is home to a secret society based around old demonic magic that refuses to die.
I devoured this. It would be incredible to read on a cold, dreary day. It’s the sort of book you want to cosy up with and forget about the real world for a while.
A huge thank you to Allen & Unwin for my proof review copy and fantastic PR box. It was so much fun to open!
Agathion College is set on a wild and remote Scottish moor! Yes you read that correctly. This lent to the most beautiful scenery and atmosphere.
Page finds herself at the prestigious college after a strange accident. Initially she feels like she has found the perfect place for herself until she discovers the college is home to a secret society based around old demonic magic that refuses to die.
I devoured this. It would be incredible to read on a cold, dreary day. It’s the sort of book you want to cosy up with and forget about the real world for a while.
A huge thank you to Allen & Unwin for my proof review copy and fantastic PR box. It was so much fun to open!
Want to read
September 11, 2024Thank you NetGally and Delacorte Press for granting me an Advanced Reader’s Copy in exchange for my honest and personal opinion!!!
December 29, 2024
3 Stars
I was so disappointed, because this book should have been so good. In fact, the opening chapters were so good. But then it lost a bit of steam. It dragged for a bit. And then everything was happening too quickly. The mystery, the intrigue, the foggy setting all got set aside for plot resolution, and I just stopped caring. Because everything that made it so good to begin with was lost. And that's a real shame, because I really did want to get immersed in this magic school nestled in the Scottish highlands. And, well, I didn't get that.
That's not to say it's all wrong. In fact, this book got off to such a great start that others might have no problem carrying through to the end on that momentum. I just lost my enthusiasm partway through and had to force myself to that finish line. I'll dig more into why this one didn't work for me in my full review, which will be available at Gateway Reviews on February 7, 2025.
Note: I was provided with an ARC by the publisher through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions here are my own.
I was so disappointed, because this book should have been so good. In fact, the opening chapters were so good. But then it lost a bit of steam. It dragged for a bit. And then everything was happening too quickly. The mystery, the intrigue, the foggy setting all got set aside for plot resolution, and I just stopped caring. Because everything that made it so good to begin with was lost. And that's a real shame, because I really did want to get immersed in this magic school nestled in the Scottish highlands. And, well, I didn't get that.
That's not to say it's all wrong. In fact, this book got off to such a great start that others might have no problem carrying through to the end on that momentum. I just lost my enthusiasm partway through and had to force myself to that finish line. I'll dig more into why this one didn't work for me in my full review, which will be available at Gateway Reviews on February 7, 2025.
Note: I was provided with an ARC by the publisher through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions here are my own.
February 6, 2025
This one was...okay. It was trying too hard from the outset, but I was willing to roll with it nevertheless. But once it had to start wrapping up plot, it went off the rails - and lost the gothic atmosphere that was most of what it had going for it to begin with. I'm not one to search for plot holes and pick them apart, but I had to work really, really hard not to highlight the whole book in frustrated annotations. And it suffers from what a lot of so-called dark academia suffers from these days - riding on the "these are my best friends, this place feels like home, this all matters so much" vibes without having sufficiently built them. (Not unique to dark academia, but I've definitely been noticing it a lot in this subgenre as it's trendy right now.) In short, it failed to develop enough of a foundation early on to support the plot that ends up crashing down on the reader.
Thank you to the publisher for the advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to the publisher for the advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
February 19, 2025
3.5 ⭐️
ive got mixed feelings about this mainly because the story did not make any sense to me whatsoever 😭
i don't really understand the whole thing about connecting with your body and body swap thing...like what was the reason for that?
i loved the characters and it was written so well but i hate how rude oak was at the start, i felt like that was uncalled for and weird.
i also loved the dark academia feel and period/endo representation! the plot was quite funky and all over the place but whatever i guess 🤷♀️
overall, this wasn't exactly amazing but still enjoyable if you're looking for weird book vibes!
thank you to netgalley and the publisher for the arc!!
ive got mixed feelings about this mainly because the story did not make any sense to me whatsoever 😭
i don't really understand the whole thing about connecting with your body and body swap thing...like what was the reason for that?
i loved the characters and it was written so well but i hate how rude oak was at the start, i felt like that was uncalled for and weird.
i also loved the dark academia feel and period/endo representation! the plot was quite funky and all over the place but whatever i guess 🤷♀️
overall, this wasn't exactly amazing but still enjoyable if you're looking for weird book vibes!
thank you to netgalley and the publisher for the arc!!
February 23, 2025
a dark academia, boarding school in scotland, and a magical mystery??? yeah.. this book ATE!
page, our main character, is the new girl at a boarding school in scotland. she’s never really had many friends until she meets a group of friends here. page though, is running from something in her past, and present.
this book was amazing. 10/10! chefs kiss, would actually read again! i am amazed! this book truly was everything you want in a ya fantasy and i love it so so much.
thank you so much Delacorte Press for the ARC!
page, our main character, is the new girl at a boarding school in scotland. she’s never really had many friends until she meets a group of friends here. page though, is running from something in her past, and present.
this book was amazing. 10/10! chefs kiss, would actually read again! i am amazed! this book truly was everything you want in a ya fantasy and i love it so so much.
thank you so much Delacorte Press for the ARC!
Want to read
March 2, 2025 [Teen girl is sent to] the Scottish moorlands after a deadly incident at her old school, to an exclusive boarding school with an ancient society that may have ties to demonic magic
Oh... yes, very much.
Oh... yes, very much.
December 20, 2024
This dark academic was an easy read. A book you can devour in one sitting. I think young adults would eat this up and I would also read from this author again
February 15, 2025
This was one of my most anticipated reads for this month. Everything about this book breathed my name. The setting, the plot, the cover, the characters. I had my copy pre-ordered for a long time already and then I saw that the book was also available through Netgalley. I didn't hesitate to request my copy and I was insanely thankful that Titan Books granted me a digital review copy. Since I prefer to release reviews shortly before the release date I could finally dive in last week.
There were a lot of things in this book I ended up loving. I was insanely glad that this book didn't just call its students highly intelligent, but allowed them to prove it too. The book was infused with nods towards classic Greek culture. Myths and Legends were mentioned and used as inspiration, philosophers and scientists were quoted and used to figure things out and the author never tries to explain every little detail. You get it or you don't.
I have to admit I was a little disappointed with the atmosphere of the story. I can't exactly pinpoint why, but it never really felt like I was there. I never really felt the tension and fear. I never really moved to the edge of my seat. Maybe the beginning was a little too slow, with our heroine not really involved in everything, but not really bothered by it either. Maybe the ending was too weird. Maybe the writing just didn't work for me. I just had a hard time feeling much when reading.
Just like I'm not entirely convinced by the plot. There is a lot going on. It's quite bizarre and the more you think about it, it's also quite horrific and gruesome. However, in a way I missed the emotional impact of everything. I guess the writing style of the author simply doesn't fit my reading style. The finale is quite spectacular and action-packed. I'm sure a lot of people are gonna love it. Especially because the characters all get their moment to shine.
I felt a little dissatisfied. I had simply wanted this book to be something it turns out it was not.
There were a lot of things in this book I ended up loving. I was insanely glad that this book didn't just call its students highly intelligent, but allowed them to prove it too. The book was infused with nods towards classic Greek culture. Myths and Legends were mentioned and used as inspiration, philosophers and scientists were quoted and used to figure things out and the author never tries to explain every little detail. You get it or you don't.
I have to admit I was a little disappointed with the atmosphere of the story. I can't exactly pinpoint why, but it never really felt like I was there. I never really felt the tension and fear. I never really moved to the edge of my seat. Maybe the beginning was a little too slow, with our heroine not really involved in everything, but not really bothered by it either. Maybe the ending was too weird. Maybe the writing just didn't work for me. I just had a hard time feeling much when reading.
Just like I'm not entirely convinced by the plot. There is a lot going on. It's quite bizarre and the more you think about it, it's also quite horrific and gruesome. However, in a way I missed the emotional impact of everything. I guess the writing style of the author simply doesn't fit my reading style. The finale is quite spectacular and action-packed. I'm sure a lot of people are gonna love it. Especially because the characters all get their moment to shine.
I felt a little dissatisfied. I had simply wanted this book to be something it turns out it was not.
October 28, 2025
4 ⭐️s
SpookTober read 2025
A fantasy world with a dark academia vibe. It blends Greek mythology with monster encounters, a body-switching plot and sacrificing students. Heck yeah, I was on board for this cracking good read.
Audiobook via BorrowBox
Published by Bolinda audio
Read by Imani Jade Powers
Duration: 13 hrs 33 min. 1.25x Speed
SpookTober read 2025
A fantasy world with a dark academia vibe. It blends Greek mythology with monster encounters, a body-switching plot and sacrificing students. Heck yeah, I was on board for this cracking good read.
Audiobook via BorrowBox
Published by Bolinda audio
Read by Imani Jade Powers
Duration: 13 hrs 33 min. 1.25x Speed
January 17, 2025
4.5 Stars
Decadently vivid and deliciously atmospheric—I couldn’t put down! Unhallowed Halls by Lili Wilkinson read like the Dark Academia, YA fantasy love child of The Secret History and Ninth House, which I absolutely loved! It genuinely kept me on my toes (and glued to my seat) until the very last page.
I was in awe at just how suspenseful (and brimming with the supernatural) this was! Drawing on Gaelic myth, and blending themes of friendship, identity and belonging into the intense, academic setting (complete with a crumbling gothic castle for a school, and misty Scottish moors to brood on); Wilkinson has crafted a gorgeously immersive and haunting novel (with prose to die for) that fans of gothic, dark academia are gonna enjoy.
I loved the found family-esque cast of characters (Cyrus, Oak, Gideon and Ren especially, but I did warm up to Lacey by the end) who were all as emotionally in-depth and intriguing as they were inclusive. Their banter was also top notch and the nuggets of kindness and connection they bestow Page, did help endear them to me.
Of all the characters though, it was Page I liked the most. As someone who grew up suffering from fairly painful menstrual cramps, I loved that endometriosis (which Page has) is not only highlighted but realistically portrayed too. Plus seeing her explain her symptoms and then experience them, will go a long way in helping to normalise how vey not normal severely painful periods actually are.
I also loved that she was a complex and endearing character, whose longing to belong (and finally find acceptance in a friend group) had me eager to see her succeed. Though, with the mystery surrounding her past, there was an edge of unreliability to her that did keep me guessing for a while.
And once that mystery begins to unravel, everything really starts to click into place. However, it was her resilience and self acceptance (in the face of such jaw dropping revelations) that really helped to cement her as my fave. I’m still impressed with how well she keeps her composure, as I would’ve been a complete mess in her shoes!
There’s soo much I want to say, but it’s wrapped up in the plot twists (which I don’t want to spoil.) So all I’ll say is, if you’re looking for an LGBTQIA inclusive novel: full of secrets, betrayals, friendship, a hint of romance and tons of magic (both plant based and dark) —then this is definitely the book for you. Though, I do suggest checking the TWs beforehand.
Also, a huge thank you to Titan Books UK for the stunning proof (and my spot on the tour.)
Decadently vivid and deliciously atmospheric—I couldn’t put down! Unhallowed Halls by Lili Wilkinson read like the Dark Academia, YA fantasy love child of The Secret History and Ninth House, which I absolutely loved! It genuinely kept me on my toes (and glued to my seat) until the very last page.
I was in awe at just how suspenseful (and brimming with the supernatural) this was! Drawing on Gaelic myth, and blending themes of friendship, identity and belonging into the intense, academic setting (complete with a crumbling gothic castle for a school, and misty Scottish moors to brood on); Wilkinson has crafted a gorgeously immersive and haunting novel (with prose to die for) that fans of gothic, dark academia are gonna enjoy.
I loved the found family-esque cast of characters (Cyrus, Oak, Gideon and Ren especially, but I did warm up to Lacey by the end) who were all as emotionally in-depth and intriguing as they were inclusive. Their banter was also top notch and the nuggets of kindness and connection they bestow Page, did help endear them to me.
Of all the characters though, it was Page I liked the most. As someone who grew up suffering from fairly painful menstrual cramps, I loved that endometriosis (which Page has) is not only highlighted but realistically portrayed too. Plus seeing her explain her symptoms and then experience them, will go a long way in helping to normalise how vey not normal severely painful periods actually are.
I also loved that she was a complex and endearing character, whose longing to belong (and finally find acceptance in a friend group) had me eager to see her succeed. Though, with the mystery surrounding her past, there was an edge of unreliability to her that did keep me guessing for a while.
And once that mystery begins to unravel, everything really starts to click into place. However, it was her resilience and self acceptance (in the face of such jaw dropping revelations) that really helped to cement her as my fave. I’m still impressed with how well she keeps her composure, as I would’ve been a complete mess in her shoes!
There’s soo much I want to say, but it’s wrapped up in the plot twists (which I don’t want to spoil.) So all I’ll say is, if you’re looking for an LGBTQIA inclusive novel: full of secrets, betrayals, friendship, a hint of romance and tons of magic (both plant based and dark) —then this is definitely the book for you. Though, I do suggest checking the TWs beforehand.
Also, a huge thank you to Titan Books UK for the stunning proof (and my spot on the tour.)
April 5, 2025
4.5 ⭐️
At first, I was fascinated by how emotionless the main character was, but then when she got out of her cool girl intro we see her struggling to fit in and to keep up with students who are as excellent as her.
The writing is also so beautiful, I couldn't stop reading.
The relationship between body and mind was interestingly explored. She made a good point of saying that they are equally important. But then we have a trans guy, what in definition separating body from mind. Then we have Oak saying his soul never felt like any gender. I mean? I guess? My doesn't either? But your body makes you what you are. That was supposed to be the point. Just like the trans guy felt weird when he was in cis body, because it wasn't his body. There is nothing against lgbtq+ but it just doesn't fit your side of the argument.
I came away with this sense that its not good to be in your little bubble of intellectuality —feelings need to be lived, expressed physically as well. As someone who always prided herself on her mind and intellect (and read a lot!), suddenly I want to experience it all.
At first, I was fascinated by how emotionless the main character was, but then when she got out of her cool girl intro we see her struggling to fit in and to keep up with students who are as excellent as her.
The writing is also so beautiful, I couldn't stop reading.
The relationship between body and mind was interestingly explored. She made a good point of saying that they are equally important. But then we have a trans guy, what in definition separating body from mind. Then we have Oak saying his soul never felt like any gender. I mean? I guess? My doesn't either? But your body makes you what you are. That was supposed to be the point. Just like the trans guy felt weird when he was in cis body, because it wasn't his body. There is nothing against lgbtq+ but it just doesn't fit your side of the argument.
I came away with this sense that its not good to be in your little bubble of intellectuality —feelings need to be lived, expressed physically as well. As someone who always prided herself on her mind and intellect (and read a lot!), suddenly I want to experience it all.
Read
January 29, 2025DNF Review (25%)
I really wanted to love this one but I just couldn’t connect with it. The premise started off intriguing and atmospheric, then leaned too heavily on the greek history angle for me. Maybe I should have read reviews first so it's partially on me - I based my choice on the blurb alone. It just wasn’t holding my interest enough to continue.
I really wanted to love this one but I just couldn’t connect with it. The premise started off intriguing and atmospheric, then leaned too heavily on the greek history angle for me. Maybe I should have read reviews first so it's partially on me - I based my choice on the blurb alone. It just wasn’t holding my interest enough to continue.
February 1, 2025
Thanks to NetGalley and HarperCollins for an advanced reader copy in exchange for my honest review.
Pain and Suffering.
No words can describe how difficult it was to finish this book.
I truly wish I had something positive to say about this book, but it was just a lot of pain and suffering. I'm seeing a lot of comparisons to Curious Tides which is honestly kind of annoying. Both books have a "Dark Academia" kind of setting but there were staggering differences that the comparison feels like the stretch of the century.
The plot of Unhallowed Halls was all over the place and while some of the characters had their moments I found all of them pretty unlikable.
I think I will recommend passing on this one folks.
Pain and Suffering.
No words can describe how difficult it was to finish this book.
I truly wish I had something positive to say about this book, but it was just a lot of pain and suffering. I'm seeing a lot of comparisons to Curious Tides which is honestly kind of annoying. Both books have a "Dark Academia" kind of setting but there were staggering differences that the comparison feels like the stretch of the century.
The plot of Unhallowed Halls was all over the place and while some of the characters had their moments I found all of them pretty unlikable.
I think I will recommend passing on this one folks.
September 1, 2024
E-arc provided to me by Edelweiss!
I was so excited to discover that Lili Wilkinson was releasing another book, ‘Unhallowed Halls.’ Wilkinson’s other fantasy books are both impressive feats of YA writing that I delight in recommending to young folks hunting for a quality read. Her characters are fantastically messy, her worlds lived-in and atmospheric, all darkness and whimsy mashed up together in a way that absolutely captivates my inner goblin.
‘Unhallowed Halls’ is the dark academia treat fantasy readers have been craving since the resolution of Naomi Novik’s ‘Scholomance’ series. Genre tropes are handled (and dissected) with love. We have our academy for troubled youth, an eerie castle on a lonely Scottish moor led by a staff of aptly-named “magisters” obsessed with ancient greek philosophy. Our supporting cast of endearingly pretentious, very special teenagers with names like “Oak” and “Gideon.” Our American transplant of a protagonist, aching to belong, who wrestles with self doubt… oh, and demons.
I loved every sinister twist and turn. (Cosmic horror, anyone?) I also must note the love with which Wilkinson writes authentic queer and trans characters. I can’t wait to recommend this book.
I was so excited to discover that Lili Wilkinson was releasing another book, ‘Unhallowed Halls.’ Wilkinson’s other fantasy books are both impressive feats of YA writing that I delight in recommending to young folks hunting for a quality read. Her characters are fantastically messy, her worlds lived-in and atmospheric, all darkness and whimsy mashed up together in a way that absolutely captivates my inner goblin.
‘Unhallowed Halls’ is the dark academia treat fantasy readers have been craving since the resolution of Naomi Novik’s ‘Scholomance’ series. Genre tropes are handled (and dissected) with love. We have our academy for troubled youth, an eerie castle on a lonely Scottish moor led by a staff of aptly-named “magisters” obsessed with ancient greek philosophy. Our supporting cast of endearingly pretentious, very special teenagers with names like “Oak” and “Gideon.” Our American transplant of a protagonist, aching to belong, who wrestles with self doubt… oh, and demons.
I loved every sinister twist and turn. (Cosmic horror, anyone?) I also must note the love with which Wilkinson writes authentic queer and trans characters. I can’t wait to recommend this book.
May 7, 2025
one of the characters unironically says “not today, Satan” — terrible
February 16, 2025
I read this book as part of the blog tour hosted by TBR & Beyond Tours. Special thanks to Delacorte Press for providing a digital ARC via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. 4 stars
TL;DR: Unhallowed Halls is a book that I had a very fun time reading! I came for the dark academia and mild supernatural horror vibes and Wilkinson delivered on both. The intimidating structure and cold halls of Agathion combined with the fog-enshrouded moor surrounding the campus created a wonderfully gothic and eerie atmosphere that set the tone well for the story. Our MC was so easy to root for and I enjoyed the found family vibes with the "elite clique" that she finds herself taken into. While the second half of the story was a large departure from the first half, I went with the vibes and found myself enjoying the tonally different and slightly ludicrous unfolding of events. It's batty but if you can just roll with it and suspend your disbelief, it's a fun time (at least, it was for me)! 😂
From the beginning, Wilkinson does a great job of setting the tone that "something just isn't quite right here" without readers being able to pinpoint what exactly that is. From the foggy moors to the austere halls of Agathion to the isolating school rules and strict Magisters to the demonic pig that almost kills our MC in one of the early scenes… There's a profound sense of wrongness that lingers around this boarding school castle set in the Scottish moors. This book was very much outside of my comfort zone although I'm glad that it was still at the level of supernatural horror/creepy that I could handle. The author does a great job in not only maintaining that bone-deep feeling of wrongness but also creating grotesque and horrifying scenes through imagery that sticks with you long after you turn the final page—at least, that's how it worked for me.
Our MC, Page, was an interesting character who I found easy to empathise with. There's a sense of mystery that surrounds her character as we begin to get glimpses of things that happened in her previous schools that seem like inexplicable supernatural events, and we learn that her parents kind of see her as this ticking time bomb that could go off at any minute. She has spent her life feeling out of place for being too smart and feeling like there was something profoundly wrong deep inside of her which she hopes Agathion can fix, only to realise she's a different kind of oddity in this school of poor little rich kids. Despite experiencing quite an awkward start with the friend group she eventually became a part of, and who came to play a significant role in this/her story, she slowly finds her place with them. I appreciated the growth that Page experiences and how she comes to embrace what makes her different and most importantly, learns to forgive herself for her past. She got the healing she deserved and I was happy for her!
I have to admit that the academic aspect of this story was slightly overwhelming with its philosophical discussions about the great dead Greeks—it straight up just made me feel dumb AF, haha. 🤣 If you love the "studying" aspect of dark academia, I think you'll enjoy how it's done here! I did love the Celtic mythology that's woven in as these are stories that I've not heard of before but looking it up led me down a mini-rabbit hole of internet searching to learn more. There were some great plot twists, some I (proudly) saw coming and a few others that took me by surprise! The unfolding of events picks up in pace as Page uncovers sinister secrets the more she hangs out with the clique.
Now, while the first half of the story is perfectly mood-appropriate dark academia, the second half is where you'll really have to suspend your disbelief. If the first half is a slow and steady build, the second half is an unexpected explosion and while such a big tonal shift would normally irritate me, going with the flow ended up making this an intense yet oddly fun (and funny) supernatural romp! Let's just say that as the supernatural and mythological aspects get more intense, the wilder the events that happen in quick succession. There was also an added humorous aspect to one of the characters introduced later on that... I was not expecting in the least but the humour ended up growing on me although I can say it was very weird! 🤭
I can fully understand why some readers might not like the second half and how it may not work for many. There were also certain elements that I wish had been better explored. The 'found family' vibes from the friendship group were great but I wanted to learn so much more about them individually and to have seen more growth in their interactions and relationships with Page firsthand. They felt too much like simple plot devices for how central they are to this story! There is also a romance which, I didn't mind all too much but I would've liked to see more of that progress organically. I wouldn't necessarily say it's instalove but there were interactions between them that I think needed proper unpacking before they got to where they were emotionally in the end.
Overall though, I didn't expect to enjoy this as much as I did because it's so far outside of my comfort zone. Wilkinson does a fantastic job with setting the scene and creating an immersive atmosphere and while I don't know what her intention was with making the second half so drastically different, I'm glad that I found myself not minding it too much. 😂 I would say that if you like gothic dark academia vibes + mythology + demonology, I think you could enjoy this too!
TL;DR: Unhallowed Halls is a book that I had a very fun time reading! I came for the dark academia and mild supernatural horror vibes and Wilkinson delivered on both. The intimidating structure and cold halls of Agathion combined with the fog-enshrouded moor surrounding the campus created a wonderfully gothic and eerie atmosphere that set the tone well for the story. Our MC was so easy to root for and I enjoyed the found family vibes with the "elite clique" that she finds herself taken into. While the second half of the story was a large departure from the first half, I went with the vibes and found myself enjoying the tonally different and slightly ludicrous unfolding of events. It's batty but if you can just roll with it and suspend your disbelief, it's a fun time (at least, it was for me)! 😂
From the beginning, Wilkinson does a great job of setting the tone that "something just isn't quite right here" without readers being able to pinpoint what exactly that is. From the foggy moors to the austere halls of Agathion to the isolating school rules and strict Magisters to the demonic pig that almost kills our MC in one of the early scenes… There's a profound sense of wrongness that lingers around this boarding school castle set in the Scottish moors. This book was very much outside of my comfort zone although I'm glad that it was still at the level of supernatural horror/creepy that I could handle. The author does a great job in not only maintaining that bone-deep feeling of wrongness but also creating grotesque and horrifying scenes through imagery that sticks with you long after you turn the final page—at least, that's how it worked for me.
Our MC, Page, was an interesting character who I found easy to empathise with. There's a sense of mystery that surrounds her character as we begin to get glimpses of things that happened in her previous schools that seem like inexplicable supernatural events, and we learn that her parents kind of see her as this ticking time bomb that could go off at any minute. She has spent her life feeling out of place for being too smart and feeling like there was something profoundly wrong deep inside of her which she hopes Agathion can fix, only to realise she's a different kind of oddity in this school of poor little rich kids. Despite experiencing quite an awkward start with the friend group she eventually became a part of, and who came to play a significant role in this/her story, she slowly finds her place with them. I appreciated the growth that Page experiences and how she comes to embrace what makes her different and most importantly, learns to forgive herself for her past. She got the healing she deserved and I was happy for her!
I have to admit that the academic aspect of this story was slightly overwhelming with its philosophical discussions about the great dead Greeks—it straight up just made me feel dumb AF, haha. 🤣 If you love the "studying" aspect of dark academia, I think you'll enjoy how it's done here! I did love the Celtic mythology that's woven in as these are stories that I've not heard of before but looking it up led me down a mini-rabbit hole of internet searching to learn more. There were some great plot twists, some I (proudly) saw coming and a few others that took me by surprise! The unfolding of events picks up in pace as Page uncovers sinister secrets the more she hangs out with the clique.
Now, while the first half of the story is perfectly mood-appropriate dark academia, the second half is where you'll really have to suspend your disbelief. If the first half is a slow and steady build, the second half is an unexpected explosion and while such a big tonal shift would normally irritate me, going with the flow ended up making this an intense yet oddly fun (and funny) supernatural romp! Let's just say that as the supernatural and mythological aspects get more intense, the wilder the events that happen in quick succession. There was also an added humorous aspect to one of the characters introduced later on that... I was not expecting in the least but the humour ended up growing on me although I can say it was very weird! 🤭
I can fully understand why some readers might not like the second half and how it may not work for many. There were also certain elements that I wish had been better explored. The 'found family' vibes from the friendship group were great but I wanted to learn so much more about them individually and to have seen more growth in their interactions and relationships with Page firsthand. They felt too much like simple plot devices for how central they are to this story! There is also a romance which, I didn't mind all too much but I would've liked to see more of that progress organically. I wouldn't necessarily say it's instalove but there were interactions between them that I think needed proper unpacking before they got to where they were emotionally in the end.
Overall though, I didn't expect to enjoy this as much as I did because it's so far outside of my comfort zone. Wilkinson does a fantastic job with setting the scene and creating an immersive atmosphere and while I don't know what her intention was with making the second half so drastically different, I'm glad that I found myself not minding it too much. 😂 I would say that if you like gothic dark academia vibes + mythology + demonology, I think you could enjoy this too!
February 17, 2025
"Because ALMOST belonging is better than being alone."
✨Found Family
✨Secret Society
✨Demons and Cults
✨Dark Academia
✨Numerous Queer Characters
✨Gothic Vibes
✨Secluded Boarding School for 'Posh F#ckups'
✨Lovecraftian Elements
✨Lit Nerds in Love
This is a queer gothic dark academia dream come true—a story that ticks all the boxes for anyone who loves demons, cosmic horror, and a richly layered mystery. This novel follows Page, an intellectual outcast forced to leave her troubled past behind after a deadly incident, as she starts anew at Agathion College, an elite boarding school nestled deep within the Scottish moorlands. A boarding school that typically only allows rich troubled teens but offers her a full scholarship.
From the moment Page steps into the wood-paneled halls of Agathion, she’s drawn into an environment that feels both comfortably familiar and ominously mysterious. And it certainly sets the tone with her being attacked the the school's pig mascot. Eventually, she falls into a close-knit group of friends—Cyrus, Ren, Gideon, Lacey, and Oak—who do not seem certain that she can be trusted entirely. Despite that, she finally begins to feel at home. However, as the dark secrets of the school slowly unravel, including ties to an ancient clandestine society with rumored demonic magic, nothing is as it seems.
Wilkinson’s world-building is breathtaking, drawing from Greek philosophy, Scottish lore, and Celtic mythology to create a setting that’s as intellectually stimulating as it is eerie. The gradually escalating tension and the deeply intriguing magical elements kept me completely absorbed, resonating with my own experiences of isolation and the longing for acceptance during my younger school years. I suspect that it will resonate a great many readers. Especially those who adore dark academia.
This book isn’t just a mystery—it’s a journey of healing and acceptance, a bittersweet exploration of identity, and a reminder that even in the darkest halls, hope and love can be found. I cried, I gasped, and I cheered for Page and her friends every step of the way. If you’re looking for a deeply emotional, intellectually rich, and utterly captivating read, Unhallowed Halls is a must-read. Pick it up as soon as you can—this is pure perfection. This is for anyone who needs to heal their inner child just a little bit.
Thanks so much to TBR and Beyond Tours and the author for the complimentary copy. This review is voluntary and all opinions are my own.
✨Found Family
✨Secret Society
✨Demons and Cults
✨Dark Academia
✨Numerous Queer Characters
✨Gothic Vibes
✨Secluded Boarding School for 'Posh F#ckups'
✨Lovecraftian Elements
✨Lit Nerds in Love
This is a queer gothic dark academia dream come true—a story that ticks all the boxes for anyone who loves demons, cosmic horror, and a richly layered mystery. This novel follows Page, an intellectual outcast forced to leave her troubled past behind after a deadly incident, as she starts anew at Agathion College, an elite boarding school nestled deep within the Scottish moorlands. A boarding school that typically only allows rich troubled teens but offers her a full scholarship.
From the moment Page steps into the wood-paneled halls of Agathion, she’s drawn into an environment that feels both comfortably familiar and ominously mysterious. And it certainly sets the tone with her being attacked the the school's pig mascot. Eventually, she falls into a close-knit group of friends—Cyrus, Ren, Gideon, Lacey, and Oak—who do not seem certain that she can be trusted entirely. Despite that, she finally begins to feel at home. However, as the dark secrets of the school slowly unravel, including ties to an ancient clandestine society with rumored demonic magic, nothing is as it seems.
Wilkinson’s world-building is breathtaking, drawing from Greek philosophy, Scottish lore, and Celtic mythology to create a setting that’s as intellectually stimulating as it is eerie. The gradually escalating tension and the deeply intriguing magical elements kept me completely absorbed, resonating with my own experiences of isolation and the longing for acceptance during my younger school years. I suspect that it will resonate a great many readers. Especially those who adore dark academia.
This book isn’t just a mystery—it’s a journey of healing and acceptance, a bittersweet exploration of identity, and a reminder that even in the darkest halls, hope and love can be found. I cried, I gasped, and I cheered for Page and her friends every step of the way. If you’re looking for a deeply emotional, intellectually rich, and utterly captivating read, Unhallowed Halls is a must-read. Pick it up as soon as you can—this is pure perfection. This is for anyone who needs to heal their inner child just a little bit.
Thanks so much to TBR and Beyond Tours and the author for the complimentary copy. This review is voluntary and all opinions are my own.
March 26, 2025
Gifted by Allen & Unwin
This is a YA dark academia fantasy set in an exclusive boarding school nestled in the Scottish moorlands, Agathion. The general consensus is that Agathion is home to rich kids who have done something wrong and not-rich kids who have done something REALLY wrong. Page is the latter. She receives a scholarship after a deadly, inexplicable incident at her old school which is pieced together through flashbacks through the story. At first glance, Page settles in nicely and is ready to immerse herself in new academic challenges and, for the first time, a whole group of friends. She soon discovers things are not as idyllic as they seem when a secret society with questionable motives reveals itself to her.
Unhallowed Halls nails the moody atmosphere and the I-don’t-know-who-to-trust flavour of suspense that I need in dark academia. The character archetypes at play and they way they’re introduced is stock standard but executed well, including the menacing professors and mysterious rich kids. I do think the book would’ve been improved a bit with 1 less prominent character (no one in particular) because the last half felt a bit crammed with trying to evenly distribute the page time, if you will, and some of the storylines suffered as a result.
This book is steeped in strong queer and trans representation which is always great to see, particularly in fiction for young people. I really REALLY loved that the trans character is not just touted as ‘the trans character’, but a fully realised HUMAN with substantial value and plot influence beyond their gender.
I rated Unhallowed Halls 3.25 ⭐️ because I felt like it had a brilliant ‘a-ha!’ reveal halfway through that had me locked in but for the rest of the book lost focus on the settings and characters that I was invested in and was almost too plot-heavy?? I definitely prefer adult dark academia because I’ve found this is a common issue when the genre is written for a YA audience. I still think it’s a worthy addition to the magic-school niche.
This is a YA dark academia fantasy set in an exclusive boarding school nestled in the Scottish moorlands, Agathion. The general consensus is that Agathion is home to rich kids who have done something wrong and not-rich kids who have done something REALLY wrong. Page is the latter. She receives a scholarship after a deadly, inexplicable incident at her old school which is pieced together through flashbacks through the story. At first glance, Page settles in nicely and is ready to immerse herself in new academic challenges and, for the first time, a whole group of friends. She soon discovers things are not as idyllic as they seem when a secret society with questionable motives reveals itself to her.
Unhallowed Halls nails the moody atmosphere and the I-don’t-know-who-to-trust flavour of suspense that I need in dark academia. The character archetypes at play and they way they’re introduced is stock standard but executed well, including the menacing professors and mysterious rich kids. I do think the book would’ve been improved a bit with 1 less prominent character (no one in particular) because the last half felt a bit crammed with trying to evenly distribute the page time, if you will, and some of the storylines suffered as a result.
This book is steeped in strong queer and trans representation which is always great to see, particularly in fiction for young people. I really REALLY loved that the trans character is not just touted as ‘the trans character’, but a fully realised HUMAN with substantial value and plot influence beyond their gender.
I rated Unhallowed Halls 3.25 ⭐️ because I felt like it had a brilliant ‘a-ha!’ reveal halfway through that had me locked in but for the rest of the book lost focus on the settings and characters that I was invested in and was almost too plot-heavy?? I definitely prefer adult dark academia because I’ve found this is a common issue when the genre is written for a YA audience. I still think it’s a worthy addition to the magic-school niche.
April 20, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley for this ALC. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I wanted to love this as it sounds like something that's right up my street, It's a magical school set in the Scottish highlands, but unfortunately it didn't hit the way I wanted it to. I'd say the strongest part of this book was the first half. The opening chapters were really good and drew me in but when you get to midway it lost steam and dragged a bit for me but then in a complete 180 everything began to happen so quickly, almost too quickly. The things that drew me into this in the beginning, the foggy setting, mystery. intrigue, all got put on the back burner for the sake of plot resoution and I just lot interest.
It's such a shame because it started really well, I just got bored and lost interest.
I wanted to love this as it sounds like something that's right up my street, It's a magical school set in the Scottish highlands, but unfortunately it didn't hit the way I wanted it to. I'd say the strongest part of this book was the first half. The opening chapters were really good and drew me in but when you get to midway it lost steam and dragged a bit for me but then in a complete 180 everything began to happen so quickly, almost too quickly. The things that drew me into this in the beginning, the foggy setting, mystery. intrigue, all got put on the back burner for the sake of plot resoution and I just lot interest.
It's such a shame because it started really well, I just got bored and lost interest.
February 24, 2025
3/3.5 🌟
Spoilerish!
This was a really interesting and at some times creepy read! I enjoyed pretty much the whole story, I don’t think I would read it again purely because it was just too long! It could’ve been a lot shorter and a lot more interesting.
Agathion was just all in all a bit weird especially how none of the student questioned a lot of what went on there - I just feel like a lot of it I would’ve been asking everyone what the fuck?! 😂 I enjoyed the ending and that it sort of was a circle back to the beginning but obviously with a lot of consequences 😂
This did keep me guessing and I had no idea it would end up where it did, if you are looking for dark academia & a mystery this would be right up your street!
Spoilerish!
This was a really interesting and at some times creepy read! I enjoyed pretty much the whole story, I don’t think I would read it again purely because it was just too long! It could’ve been a lot shorter and a lot more interesting.
Agathion was just all in all a bit weird especially how none of the student questioned a lot of what went on there - I just feel like a lot of it I would’ve been asking everyone what the fuck?! 😂 I enjoyed the ending and that it sort of was a circle back to the beginning but obviously with a lot of consequences 😂
This did keep me guessing and I had no idea it would end up where it did, if you are looking for dark academia & a mystery this would be right up your street!
March 18, 2025
Thank you @prhaudio for the audiobook!
This book started out so well!! Dark academia book set in a mysterious school in the moors in Scotland. It should have been a 6 star read for me from the dark academia books I’ve read in the past.
But about halfway through, it really started to lose me. I don’t know if it was the writing or just the story itself but I found myself not really caring about where the story was going. I also really liked the characters but wasn’t connecting with them as much as I wish I was.
Now there is really good things about this book! We have wonderful representation in this!!
Queer MC
Disability rep (endometriosis)
Trans characters
Queer side characters
Amazing setting / atmospheric
Trigger warning: Misgendering does not happen on page but talked about happening.
Audiobook narrator does an amazing job!!
This book started out so well!! Dark academia book set in a mysterious school in the moors in Scotland. It should have been a 6 star read for me from the dark academia books I’ve read in the past.
But about halfway through, it really started to lose me. I don’t know if it was the writing or just the story itself but I found myself not really caring about where the story was going. I also really liked the characters but wasn’t connecting with them as much as I wish I was.
Now there is really good things about this book! We have wonderful representation in this!!
Queer MC
Disability rep (endometriosis)
Trans characters
Queer side characters
Amazing setting / atmospheric
Trigger warning: Misgendering does not happen on page but talked about happening.
Audiobook narrator does an amazing job!!
March 5, 2025
This is an unsettling story that is creepy, enticing and well written. The atmosphere is masterfully created and I had a hard time putting this down. If you enjoy dark academia or horror, I would recommend this! Special Thank You to Lili Wilkinson,Random House Children's and NetGalley for allowing me to read a complimentary copy in exchange for an honest review.
March 10, 2025
This is an excellent example of it wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t good either. Wilkinson has written an interesting dark academia fantasy, but unfortunately, I’m just not the target audience for this book.
If you’re familiar with my reading taste, you’ll know that I don’t mind a YA book, but only when it is well-written and reasonably complex. For me, this book read in a very simple way, significantly lacking nuance and falling into quite a few cliches. Younger readers would probably really enjoy this one (definitely not an issue as it is a YA book), but I think that those of us that are mostly adult readers will struggle with the lack of nuance.
I did enjoy the dark academia atmosphere and the British boarding-school setting. I also think it’s great that Wilkinson included transgender, bisexual, and lesbian rep. Honestly, this book was fine and I would recommend it to young teen readers, but I don’t think it caters to a wider audience or was anything particularly special.
Make sure to check TWs before reading. 2/5
If you’re familiar with my reading taste, you’ll know that I don’t mind a YA book, but only when it is well-written and reasonably complex. For me, this book read in a very simple way, significantly lacking nuance and falling into quite a few cliches. Younger readers would probably really enjoy this one (definitely not an issue as it is a YA book), but I think that those of us that are mostly adult readers will struggle with the lack of nuance.
I did enjoy the dark academia atmosphere and the British boarding-school setting. I also think it’s great that Wilkinson included transgender, bisexual, and lesbian rep. Honestly, this book was fine and I would recommend it to young teen readers, but I don’t think it caters to a wider audience or was anything particularly special.
Make sure to check TWs before reading. 2/5
October 6, 2025
Great moody & gothic atmosphere, and I felt genuine affection for the characters, which was really nice.
I found the first half better than the second thanks to the mystery and the very neat dark academia setting on the moor, that slowly fades as we come closer to the resolution. The ending was dragged for a bit too long to my opinion but otherwise a very good book !
I found the first half better than the second thanks to the mystery and the very neat dark academia setting on the moor, that slowly fades as we come closer to the resolution. The ending was dragged for a bit too long to my opinion but otherwise a very good book !
October 28, 2024
Actual rating: 3.5 stars
Displaying 1 - 30 of 309 reviews