I just finished watching the complete first (and only) season of the NBC TV show “Constantine”, based on the long-running DC comic book series that started in the ‘80s. It was disappointing, to say the least.
The fault does not lie with the casting, as Matt Ryan was superb as the chain-smoking, snarky British exorcist/paranormal expert/master of the occult.
I honestly don’t know who to blame for the show’s failure, although I would agree with Ryan, who, in a recent interview, said that the show might have had better success on a different network. Based on some of the recent excellent shows I have seen that DC Universe has been putting out on their streaming service (“Swamp Thing”, “Doom Patrol”, and “Titans”, to name three), I would argue that “Constantine” would fare far better if allowed to have fewer boundaries that a major network like NBC probably enforces. John Constantine, the character, never had any boundaries, so why should his TV show?
The fault may lie, however, with DC itself. Keep in mind, I’m saying this as someone who has only recently come back to reading comic books after a 20-plus-year hiatus, and also someone who didn’t read a lot of DC. There is a lot of DC history of which I am ignorant, I fully admit.
For example, I am only vaguely aware that nine years ago, DC conducted a major overhaul of nearly every title in its inventory, an event entitled the New 52. I know nothing else about this, other than the fact that several characters from the DC Vertigo line (Constantine being one of them) were incorporated into the DC Universe. It was, essentially, a company-wide reboot, much like the reboot of the Star Wars universe when Disney bought the rights.
From a business standpoint, the New 52 may have been a wise move, but, in my opinion, a character, and a series, like Constantine didn’t need a revamp. Part of what fans liked about him was his unwillingness toward change. He was set in his ways, and he was okay with that. So were his fans.
I decided to give this revamped “Constantine” a try by reading the 2014 series “The Spark and the Flame”, written by Ray Fawkes and Jeff Lemire and illustrated by Renato Guedes and Fabiano Neves.
Like the TV show, it was disappointing, but it’s hard to point your finger at precisely where it went wrong. The story—about Constantine’s search for a magical compass that has been split into three parts and scattered across the globe and is also being sought by parties with more malevolent and nefarious purposes—-is all rather boilerplate. It’s not horrible, but for a Constantine storyline, it’s pretty tame and unsexy.
It’s missing the high stakes that made the Vertigo run so good. Hellblazer fans knew that Constantine was risking more than his own life. In most cases, he was risking all of humanity. He was the sole (soul?) barrier between our world and a world potentially being overrun by Hell itself.
It’s hard to take this new Constantine seriously when he looks like a blonde Henry Cavill and mucks about with DC has-been superheroes like The Spectre and Shazam. Seriously?
Constantine was borne of a specific time (the Thatcher/Reagan Era) and place (lower-class England) and a culmination of all the fears and problems that embodied the ‘80s. Sadly, many of those fears and problems still exist and/or were resurrected in the Trump Era, so this new re-vamped Constantine could have really been something extraordinary.
As it is, it’s merely okay. I haven’t given up on the comic series, though. I’m hoping it finds its groove as the series progresses.
I feel the same way about the TV show, too. It would be cool if another network or streaming service like Netflix or Amazon Prime decided to pick it up. It definitely had potential.