For a kid friendly, beginner reading book, I think this pretty much does what it’s intended to do.
I appreciate that The book is very blunt about how terrible the gold rush was. It was terrible for the actual prospectors, and the book details how people were tricked out of a lot of money, prospectors murdered one another because there was no law, everything was extremely expensive and a lot of people died.
I enjoyed that it touched on marginalized people, including Women, Chinese, and Native Americans. I think it could’ve probably done a little bit more with those groups. In particular, even though the book is very frank that The experience of Native Americans was very bad, it kind of insinuates most natives simply died of disease, when the state of California put out an active bounty on killing as many natives as possible and actually getting paid money from the state for bringing in scalps. Maybe not the greatest subject For a beginning reader book, but I think there is probably a more tactful weight to explain that The natives simply died because of disease.
Still, it was a very realistic look at history, without glamorizing this incredibly greedy period of American history. Even the very first person to find golden California and it up having a much worse life after the fact, and I think that is an important subject for kids to know, that The pursuit of riches, especially easy riches, is often very terrible for everyone involved