This series has such a cool concept (and awesome covers), and I love how it was marketed. I just wish it had been executed better. To me, the mark of a good children's book is that it can be enjoyed by anyone of any age, and no one is made to feel too old for it. But with this series it is so obvious that I'm not the intended demographic. The writing is so simple that it becomes tedious, and there's an abundance of "telling not showing" which usually doesn't bother me but oh boy, in this it did. James Phelan also writes adult books so I'd be interested to read some of those to see if his style is any different when he writes for a different age group.
I didn't love the first book but decided I'd give the series another chance before I passed judgement. Unfortunately, it seems this is a children's series that can only be enjoyed by children. Which is such a shame because this is the kind of plot that I usually love. Judging by most of the recent reviews here on goodreads, I'm not alone in feeling this.
DNF'd at page 28 of 185.