What do you think?
Rate this book
Mr. Darcy's Letter: A Pride & Prejudice Variation
A lady's reputation is a fragile thing. If anyone discovered Miss Elizabeth Bennet had received a letter from a single gentleman, she could be ruined... or forced to marry a man she detests. In this "Pride & Prejudice" variation, Elizabeth chooses the safe course and refuses to read Mr. Darcy's letter of explanation. Returning home unaware of Wickham's true nature, Elizabeth confesses everything to him, putting both Mr. Darcy and herself in grave danger from Wickham's schemes.
255 pages, Paperback
First published November 28, 2011
102 people are currently reading
839 people want to read
About the author
Abigail Reynolds
66 books779 followersAbigail Reynolds may be a nationally bestselling author and a physician, but she can’t follow a straight line with a ruler. Originally from upstate New York, she studied Russian and theater at Bryn Mawr College and marine biology at the Marine Biological Laboratory in Woods Hole. After a stint in performing arts administration, she decided to attend medical school, and took up writing as a way to retain her sanity during her years as a physician in private practice.
A life-long lover of Jane Austen’s novels, Abigail began writing variations on Pride & Prejudice in 2001, then expanded her repertoire to include a series of novels set on her beloved Cape Cod.Her most recent releases are A Matter of Honor, Mr. Darcy's Enchantment, and Conceit & Concealment. Her books have been translated into six languages. A lifetime member of JASNA, she lives on Cape Cod with her husband, her son and a menagerie of animals. Her hobbies do not include sleeping or cleaning her house.
A life-long lover of Jane Austen’s novels, Abigail began writing variations on Pride & Prejudice in 2001, then expanded her repertoire to include a series of novels set on her beloved Cape Cod.Her most recent releases are A Matter of Honor, Mr. Darcy's Enchantment, and Conceit & Concealment. Her books have been translated into six languages. A lifetime member of JASNA, she lives on Cape Cod with her husband, her son and a menagerie of animals. Her hobbies do not include sleeping or cleaning her house.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews
December 19, 2017
I edited a comment today. This review was originally published in November of 2014.
Well, after reading all 85 other reviews I have several things to say to all who read reviews. Yes, Abigail Reynolds is one of the best in the JAFF genre. And in coming up with one story after another, I know she is going to have to become very inventive with events in the P&P story line. And that is why I read her stories. I have every one of her stories, this one in both paperback and kindle and I paid full price for the paperback. Yes, she does have a seeming contradiction in that Lizzie would not read Darcy's letter but then she is alone with him and engages in sex. Let us consider: she is "not yet one-and-twenty" and he is, what? seven-and-twenty. I have no misgivings that through the generations, no matter what the conventions of society are, human bodies have the same urges. Just because I am now a grandmother does not mean that I don't remember how strong those urges were (and how glorious). No generation was exempt. So my only problem with this scene is that they didn't lock the door! (But they were caught up in the moment, I guess, and who has their head on straight when they have waited 27 years to find love? LOL) Hard to imagine that they were not afraid of Georgiana, much less the servants, walking in on them.
I found the twists very griping: oh, Bingley, can't you see past worrying about Caroline? Louisa is already married. I liked that Wickham had a different consequence and that Darcy actually fought a duel with him. And another brother who marries Lydia - great. Liked being in his head when he thinks that Darcy is snubbing him (and Lydia) in not inviting them to the wedding.
I read this novel just after it was published but have now re-read the complete novel so that I could post a review. (Sometimes I only read the "good" parts and by that I do NOT mean the sex scenes. I like angst and sexual tension the best.) I always look for the next Abigail Reynolds book to come out.
Well, after reading all 85 other reviews I have several things to say to all who read reviews. Yes, Abigail Reynolds is one of the best in the JAFF genre. And in coming up with one story after another, I know she is going to have to become very inventive with events in the P&P story line. And that is why I read her stories. I have every one of her stories, this one in both paperback and kindle and I paid full price for the paperback. Yes, she does have a seeming contradiction in that Lizzie would not read Darcy's letter but then she is alone with him and engages in sex. Let us consider: she is "not yet one-and-twenty" and he is, what? seven-and-twenty. I have no misgivings that through the generations, no matter what the conventions of society are, human bodies have the same urges. Just because I am now a grandmother does not mean that I don't remember how strong those urges were (and how glorious). No generation was exempt. So my only problem with this scene is that they didn't lock the door! (But they were caught up in the moment, I guess, and who has their head on straight when they have waited 27 years to find love? LOL) Hard to imagine that they were not afraid of Georgiana, much less the servants, walking in on them.
I found the twists very griping: oh, Bingley, can't you see past worrying about Caroline? Louisa is already married. I liked that Wickham had a different consequence and that Darcy actually fought a duel with him. And another brother who marries Lydia - great. Liked being in his head when he thinks that Darcy is snubbing him (and Lydia) in not inviting them to the wedding.
I read this novel just after it was published but have now re-read the complete novel so that I could post a review. (Sometimes I only read the "good" parts and by that I do NOT mean the sex scenes. I like angst and sexual tension the best.) I always look for the next Abigail Reynolds book to come out.
June 28, 2016
reread 6/27 -28 /16
Another book I neglected to review and deleted the plot from my memory so I was obligated to re-read.
Beginning immediately after the disastrous proposal at Hunsford when Mr. Darcy offers Elizabeth Bennet his letter she refuses it believing that he is attempting to entrap her in an engagement (Hey Lizzy you aren't that hot or desirable ) he later attempts to use Mrs. Collins as a go between but Dizzy Miss Lizzy will not be swayed. (Of course Mrs. Collins could have read the letter and related the details to Eliza but then this would be a short story and not a novel)
So utterly ignorant of Wickham's proclivities; she returns to Meryton and continues to interact with him. However Wickham is somehow unnerved and at their last meeting endeavors to lighten some of his charges against Darcy admitting that he did receive money in lieu of the specifics of the will; although he doesn't admit the amount.
Then we go back to the source, the Militia and Lydia go to Brighton, Lizzy and the Gardiners go to Derbyshire and run into Darcy at Pemberley. During the Mrs. Gardiner, Lizzy visit upon Georgiana Miss Bingley mentions the Militia and Lizzy responds with Wickham's name which distresses the Darcy Siblings. Soon after this Darcy learns that Lizzy burned his letter unread and he acquaints her with Wickham's history with Georgiana. Which makes her cry and him kiss her.
The Gardiners leave Pemberley and Darcy plans to call on Lizzy the next morning. He is late and sees the Gardiners driving away from Lambton with a weeping Elizabeth and he immediately concludes that she is still loathing him and goes back to Pemberley to sulk.
Weeks pass and Darcy receives a letter, albeit damaged and dirty, from an urchin that Lizzy wrote him but Pemberley's footmen wouldn't admit the child. (Hmm I'm thinking the 'best master' might be doing some bottom churning). The letter doesn't explain the reason for her sudden departure; only that she regrets that they will never meet again.
So Darcy immediately calls for his horse and rides for Meryton. Nah, he talks Bingley into going to Meryton to visit and find out what's going on. Bingley learns that Lydia... (you know the story) and the good people of Meryton are shunning the Bennets. When further news is discovered that Lydia has returned to the Gardiners unmarried Jane refuses Bingley's 1/2 hearted proposal and they quit the area.
When Darcy eventually learns of the problems; Bingley's letter goes astray and Georgiana didn't feel it was her place to discuss the problem with her brother, he immediately goes to the Gardiners. Lydia knows she must marry but refuses to marry anyone but Wickham. And Wickham is reported to have left for Canada. But have no fear because Darcy has a trick up his sleeve
Lizzy goes to London and continues to misunderstand Darcy who in turn misunderstands her. And both think that each loathe the other; irredeemably. Even an intervention by Mr. Gardiner can't seem to motivate change. But eventually Darcy goes to Longbourn and proposes and Lizzy accepts. But the author still isn't finished putting ODC or the reader through the wringer. There are plenty of troubles, problems, misunderstandings and danger to come.
There are several steamy scenes and ODC anticipate their vows in the library at Netherfield.
Another book I neglected to review and deleted the plot from my memory so I was obligated to re-read.
Beginning immediately after the disastrous proposal at Hunsford when Mr. Darcy offers Elizabeth Bennet his letter she refuses it believing that he is attempting to entrap her in an engagement (Hey Lizzy you aren't that hot or desirable ) he later attempts to use Mrs. Collins as a go between but Dizzy Miss Lizzy will not be swayed. (Of course Mrs. Collins could have read the letter and related the details to Eliza but then this would be a short story and not a novel)
So utterly ignorant of Wickham's proclivities; she returns to Meryton and continues to interact with him. However Wickham is somehow unnerved and at their last meeting endeavors to lighten some of his charges against Darcy admitting that he did receive money in lieu of the specifics of the will; although he doesn't admit the amount.
Then we go back to the source, the Militia and Lydia go to Brighton, Lizzy and the Gardiners go to Derbyshire and run into Darcy at Pemberley. During the Mrs. Gardiner, Lizzy visit upon Georgiana Miss Bingley mentions the Militia and Lizzy responds with Wickham's name which distresses the Darcy Siblings. Soon after this Darcy learns that Lizzy burned his letter unread and he acquaints her with Wickham's history with Georgiana. Which makes her cry and him kiss her.
The Gardiners leave Pemberley and Darcy plans to call on Lizzy the next morning. He is late and sees the Gardiners driving away from Lambton with a weeping Elizabeth and he immediately concludes that she is still loathing him and goes back to Pemberley to sulk.
Weeks pass and Darcy receives a letter, albeit damaged and dirty, from an urchin that Lizzy wrote him but Pemberley's footmen wouldn't admit the child. (Hmm I'm thinking the 'best master' might be doing some bottom churning). The letter doesn't explain the reason for her sudden departure; only that she regrets that they will never meet again.
So Darcy immediately calls for his horse and rides for Meryton. Nah, he talks Bingley into going to Meryton to visit and find out what's going on. Bingley learns that Lydia... (you know the story) and the good people of Meryton are shunning the Bennets. When further news is discovered that Lydia has returned to the Gardiners unmarried Jane refuses Bingley's 1/2 hearted proposal and they quit the area.
When Darcy eventually learns of the problems; Bingley's letter goes astray and Georgiana didn't feel it was her place to discuss the problem with her brother, he immediately goes to the Gardiners. Lydia knows she must marry but refuses to marry anyone but Wickham. And Wickham is reported to have left for Canada. But have no fear because Darcy has a trick up his sleeve
Lizzy goes to London and continues to misunderstand Darcy who in turn misunderstands her. And both think that each loathe the other; irredeemably. Even an intervention by Mr. Gardiner can't seem to motivate change. But eventually Darcy goes to Longbourn and proposes and Lizzy accepts. But the author still isn't finished putting ODC or the reader through the wringer. There are plenty of troubles, problems, misunderstandings and danger to come.
There are several steamy scenes and ODC anticipate their vows in the library at Netherfield.
November 27, 2016
Dear reader,
Have you ever wondered what would happen if Elizabeth refused to read Darcy's letter, believed Wickham and only belatedly realised that all she held dear was a complete fabrication?
Deeply regretting believing such falsehoods,
and anxious to make a better impression after inadvertently hurting Georgiana,Darcy and Elizabeth seem to have been gifted a second chance,only for Fate,in the guise of Lydia's elopement with Wickham,to thwart their plans.
Elizabeth,wishing to save Darcy from any future embarrassing alliance with his nemesis,flees Lambton without explaining what has suddenly befallen her family.
Darcy,in turn,believing the worst,thinks that she wants no further contact with him,and is heartbroken.
Thus dear reader,are we privy to the first in a series of wilful misunderstandings,troubling trials and tribulations as ODC navigate the oft times angst filled path to true love.
This was a wonderful story,one that I found hugely compelling and quite enjoyable.
I loved the part the Gardiners played in uniting ODC,especially the rather frank if underhand discussion Mr Gardiner had with Darcy! There are none so blind as those who will not see!!
I also thought Darcy's proposal quite unusual and the fact that they got a chance to talk and clear up past misunderstandings, a lovely touch.
I was delighted and thought quite clever the way Lydia's saviour was sourced,the fact that he met all her necessary requirements in a husband and that while being very authoritarian and strict,was happily the perfect husband for her.
Yes,Lydia found happiness and contentment with her knight in shining armour,or should I say,a red coat,a man willing to allow her very little leeway in her childish dreams and endeavours,a father figure,if you like,willing to exert his control,when needed!
I recommend this story to all lovers of JAFF.
Please note that there is a scene centred on Darcy and Elizabeth,shortly after coming to an understanding and faced with immediate separation,anticipating their wedding vows.
Usually I would discount this as being beneath the Darcy and Elizabeth that I hold dear to my heart,however,under the circumstances,their actions are understandable and didn't detract from my overall enjoyment of this story.
I trust you will enjoy it as I did!
Have you ever wondered what would happen if Elizabeth refused to read Darcy's letter, believed Wickham and only belatedly realised that all she held dear was a complete fabrication?
Deeply regretting believing such falsehoods,
and anxious to make a better impression after inadvertently hurting Georgiana,Darcy and Elizabeth seem to have been gifted a second chance,only for Fate,in the guise of Lydia's elopement with Wickham,to thwart their plans.
Elizabeth,wishing to save Darcy from any future embarrassing alliance with his nemesis,flees Lambton without explaining what has suddenly befallen her family.
Darcy,in turn,believing the worst,thinks that she wants no further contact with him,and is heartbroken.
Thus dear reader,are we privy to the first in a series of wilful misunderstandings,troubling trials and tribulations as ODC navigate the oft times angst filled path to true love.
This was a wonderful story,one that I found hugely compelling and quite enjoyable.
I loved the part the Gardiners played in uniting ODC,especially the rather frank if underhand discussion Mr Gardiner had with Darcy! There are none so blind as those who will not see!!
I also thought Darcy's proposal quite unusual and the fact that they got a chance to talk and clear up past misunderstandings, a lovely touch.
I was delighted and thought quite clever the way Lydia's saviour was sourced,the fact that he met all her necessary requirements in a husband and that while being very authoritarian and strict,was happily the perfect husband for her.
Yes,Lydia found happiness and contentment with her knight in shining armour,or should I say,a red coat,a man willing to allow her very little leeway in her childish dreams and endeavours,a father figure,if you like,willing to exert his control,when needed!
I recommend this story to all lovers of JAFF.
Please note that there is a scene centred on Darcy and Elizabeth,shortly after coming to an understanding and faced with immediate separation,anticipating their wedding vows.
Usually I would discount this as being beneath the Darcy and Elizabeth that I hold dear to my heart,however,under the circumstances,their actions are understandable and didn't detract from my overall enjoyment of this story.
I trust you will enjoy it as I did!
December 6, 2024
Good
Another good story from Abigail Reynolds. A stubborn Elizabeth refuses to read Darcy’s letter after his failed proposal at Hunsford. Wickham has a brother? I liked him. Bingley is a wimp— this May be my least favorite portrayal of him, and Jane is just as weak accepting him in the end. Darcy lets his passions run away from him in this tale, as does Elizabeth.
November 25, 2023 - Audiobook
Pearl Hewitt does a marvellous job with the narration and performance, and I like her a lot. The one voice she does that I have a little problem with is Darcy’s. It’s not bad, but I’m not enamoured with it.
Another good story from Abigail Reynolds. A stubborn Elizabeth refuses to read Darcy’s letter after his failed proposal at Hunsford. Wickham has a brother? I liked him. Bingley is a wimp— this May be my least favorite portrayal of him, and Jane is just as weak accepting him in the end. Darcy lets his passions run away from him in this tale, as does Elizabeth.
November 25, 2023 - Audiobook
Pearl Hewitt does a marvellous job with the narration and performance, and I like her a lot. The one voice she does that I have a little problem with is Darcy’s. It’s not bad, but I’m not enamoured with it.
March 26, 2018
Another intriguing 'what if' from this author's clever and poignant arsenal of Pride & Prejudice variations. What if Elizabeth Bennet never read Mr. Darcy's letter?
Yes, I was very curious to know how the dominoes would tumble over that one. And, because I felt such excitement over that question and it is, of course, the beginning of this new plot trail, I hesitate to address the summary so I don't spoil the story. She doesn't read the letter so she goes home with her perspective unchanged- and how does this alter the events in the story?
Let's just say that I was both satisfied with some matters and a tad let down with others. I was looking for a larger deviation as a result, I guess. But, I did love seeing how the romance still manages to progress. Darcy is quite the dashing, loyal and persistent lover in spite of greater challenges and a more beguiling Wickham. Now, that said, he pretty much had to be all those things because if it could be misunderstood or misconstrued or not even communicated about then this Darcy and Lizzy were the champs at jumping to conclusions- particularly Lizzy. I have to say that probably fifty pages of this book wouldn't exist if she'd just stop jumping to conclusions. Gossip in the newspaper... oh, that must be gospel truth even though he's standing there trying to tell her that circumstances weren't what they appeared and he's suddenly turned into a liar and a rake. Argh!
And, while I'm on the subject, Bingley's wishy-washy action was annoying, too. Oh, I get the validity of the argument that is explored more deeply here- can he really marry Jane Bennet and still have his family accepted into polite society? Is it enough to conquer the taint of his money and position coming from trade? But seeing him approach her, leave, approach her, leave, and... approach her, leave, approach her. Man up, guy!
I will say that one of the most delightful surprises in this book was the addition of a character the author created- another Wickham! Truly, he was probably my favorite part. What if George Wickham had a dashing relation to give him a run for his money in the charm and looks department? Well... he does in this one.
So, while some aspects were merely meh, other elements held some real sparkle and shine. I can't praise this author's creative variation work enough.
Yes, I was very curious to know how the dominoes would tumble over that one. And, because I felt such excitement over that question and it is, of course, the beginning of this new plot trail, I hesitate to address the summary so I don't spoil the story. She doesn't read the letter so she goes home with her perspective unchanged- and how does this alter the events in the story?
Let's just say that I was both satisfied with some matters and a tad let down with others. I was looking for a larger deviation as a result, I guess. But, I did love seeing how the romance still manages to progress. Darcy is quite the dashing, loyal and persistent lover in spite of greater challenges and a more beguiling Wickham. Now, that said, he pretty much had to be all those things because if it could be misunderstood or misconstrued or not even communicated about then this Darcy and Lizzy were the champs at jumping to conclusions- particularly Lizzy. I have to say that probably fifty pages of this book wouldn't exist if she'd just stop jumping to conclusions. Gossip in the newspaper... oh, that must be gospel truth even though he's standing there trying to tell her that circumstances weren't what they appeared and he's suddenly turned into a liar and a rake. Argh!
And, while I'm on the subject, Bingley's wishy-washy action was annoying, too. Oh, I get the validity of the argument that is explored more deeply here- can he really marry Jane Bennet and still have his family accepted into polite society? Is it enough to conquer the taint of his money and position coming from trade? But seeing him approach her, leave, approach her, leave, and... approach her, leave, approach her. Man up, guy!
I will say that one of the most delightful surprises in this book was the addition of a character the author created- another Wickham! Truly, he was probably my favorite part. What if George Wickham had a dashing relation to give him a run for his money in the charm and looks department? Well... he does in this one.
So, while some aspects were merely meh, other elements held some real sparkle and shine. I can't praise this author's creative variation work enough.
February 4, 2022
I loved the premises of this book. It was great. What happens when Elizabeth doesn't read the letter from Mr. Darcy. What if her opinion of him doesn't change after leaving Rosengs. This book was great. I enjoyed seeing how this played out. I do love that Elizabeth still has such a dislike for Darcy when they meet at Pemberly. I felt horrible for both Mr and Ms Darcy during that fateful tea, but I loved the interaction between Mr Darcy and Elizabeth afterwards. I hate Wickham and how he is such a sleaze, I did love his brother. It was nice to see an honorable man with that last name. There were a ton of misunderstandings but it was also great to see them work through those at the same time.
I wasn't a big fan of Mr Bingley in this book, though. He is so wishy washy that Jane deserved much better. I don't think I would have taken him back if it was me. Mr Darcy at least never stopped his feelings for Elizabeth and based on his side of things he never would have left her when everything went to crap.
I liked this version of Ms. Darcy as well. She had a spine and actually stood up to Mrs. Bingley it was amazing.
A must read, if you can handle the angst.
I wasn't a big fan of Mr Bingley in this book, though. He is so wishy washy that Jane deserved much better. I don't think I would have taken him back if it was me. Mr Darcy at least never stopped his feelings for Elizabeth and based on his side of things he never would have left her when everything went to crap.
I liked this version of Ms. Darcy as well. She had a spine and actually stood up to Mrs. Bingley it was amazing.
A must read, if you can handle the angst.
April 21, 2017
lovely story where Elizabeth refuses to read Mr. Darcy's letter after the proposal at the parsonage. however, she eventually learns that she has to read his letters ;)
4.5+ stars
too much misunderstandings even if they are already engaged and things have happened between them.
I love Mr and Mrs Gardiner, they are great :)
Poor Jane and Bingley, too much suffering and refusal.
4.5+ stars
too much misunderstandings even if they are already engaged and things have happened between them.
I love Mr and Mrs Gardiner, they are great :)
Poor Jane and Bingley, too much suffering and refusal.
December 22, 2011
Disappointed!! Three-quarters of the way through the book (that up to that point was pretty much a retelling of Pride & Prejudice with a few variations) she decides Elizabeth & Darcy will make mad, passionate love BEFORE marriage. How UN-Jane!!!!!!!
January 22, 2018
I would have given this book 5 stars if Lizzi had not been portraited a bit to stupid especially at the begining . Lizzi does not read Darcys letter and therefore are a bit to friendly with Wickham and hurts Georgiana at Pemberley. Bingley are very fickle in this book. I still recommend it though.
March 20, 2012
I love Ms Reynolds' other books. This book was a great disappointment. Lizzie would never have behaved like the Lizzie in this story. I didn't like Darcy or Lizzie. The only people I did like were the Gardiners and Darcy's cousin. Here's a fun game to play when you read the book, see how many time Ms Reynolds uses the word, "ameliorate!". Find other words that just don't fit in this type of story. Hire an editor!
July 10, 2024
Elizabeth burns Darcy's letter without reading it and carries a grudge against him a bit longer. Rather indiscreetly, she informs Wickham of Darcy's proposal, and Wickham starts to walk back of his earlier slander of Darcy, trying to persuade Elizabeth to reconsider her refusal, no doubt thinking about how he could use a connection with Darcy's wife. Later she meets Darcy et al at Pemberley. Darcy finds out that she didn't read the letter and blurts out the real scoop about Wickham. Miss Bingley is her usual snippy self and Lydia elopes in her usual manner. Darcy arranges for her to marry Wickham's brother Thomas who is just as good in flattery but somewhat more palatable character otherwise.
This was a pleasant read with the author's usual quality writing but this is one of those variations in which Elizabeth and Darcy constantly misunderstand each other and when Elizabeth gets hurt she tries to shut him out entirely without listening to him, and it sometimes gets a little tiresome because it's so predictable. Oh look, things are going well, quick, it's Lizzy's turn to assume the worst of him now. They anticipate their vows which may seem a little hypocritical right after being judgmental about Lydia. Bingley decamps on Jane twice, and still gets the girl. Poor Jane.
Rereading: I still think Jane should have noped on the Bing. He gets engaged to someone else and she still takes him back. Have some self-respect, girl.
This was a pleasant read with the author's usual quality writing but this is one of those variations in which Elizabeth and Darcy constantly misunderstand each other and when Elizabeth gets hurt she tries to shut him out entirely without listening to him, and it sometimes gets a little tiresome because it's so predictable. Oh look, things are going well, quick, it's Lizzy's turn to assume the worst of him now. They anticipate their vows which may seem a little hypocritical right after being judgmental about Lydia. Bingley decamps on Jane twice, and still gets the girl. Poor Jane.
Rereading: I still think Jane should have noped on the Bing. He gets engaged to someone else and she still takes him back. Have some self-respect, girl.
December 6, 2011
This alternative raises the question "what would of happened if Elizabeth Bennet didn't read Mr Darcy's letter"? She doesn't and of course her opinion of Wickhem doesn't change and neither does her opinion of Mr Darcy. How is Mr Darcy to protect her and change her opinion of him!! I really liked this alternative because everything stays the same but the info not given changes Elizabeth, Jane and even Lydia's lives. Of course this wouldn't be P&P if Darcy didn't save the day somehow. Anyway there is lots of angst and trials for our favorite couple and a new character who does surprise us with a little gallentry. Anyway I love Ms Reynolds books but my favorite of hers are the ones where Darcy and Elizabeth don't anticipate there vows and that is why I rated this book a 3 star. I just cringe when reading because I see Mr Darcy as being the strickist gentleman and would never take advantage of Elizabeth. Definitly worht reading
March 10, 2012
Darcy knew it was a breach of propriety to write Elizabeth Bennet a letter, he knew it would damage her reputation if it was ever discovered, but he knew it was the only way to protect her from misplacing her trust in Wickham. And so he behaves improperly, perhaps even scandalously, to protect the woman he loves. But will Elizabeth appreciate his care and concern?
Not in this variation! In Mr. Darcy's Letter Elizabeth Bennet refuses to accept Darcy's letter from him in the grove. Even when it is redelivered to her by Charlotte, Elizabeth, once again, declines reading it and feeds it to the flames. Why does Elizabeth do this? To protect her reputation? To thwart Darcy's supposed plan of forcing her hand? Or to avoid hearing any more insults from that infuriating man...
And thus begins Abigail Reynold's newest installment in her stellar and greatly admired Pemberley Variation series. If you are unfamiliar with this phenomenal series, it contains seven novels and one novella anthology that explore the many paths Jane Austen didn't take in Pride and Prejudice. The premise of Elizabeth not accepting Darcy's letter is entirely new to this reader and I was very intrigued to see how this would affect the plot and characters. Would Elizabeth fall prey to Wickham's lies? How will Elizabeth react when she sees Darcy at Pemberley? Would Wickham still attempt to elope with Lydia? There are so many avenues one can go with this premise!
To continue reading, go to: http://janeaustenreviews.blogspot.com...
Not in this variation! In Mr. Darcy's Letter Elizabeth Bennet refuses to accept Darcy's letter from him in the grove. Even when it is redelivered to her by Charlotte, Elizabeth, once again, declines reading it and feeds it to the flames. Why does Elizabeth do this? To protect her reputation? To thwart Darcy's supposed plan of forcing her hand? Or to avoid hearing any more insults from that infuriating man...
And thus begins Abigail Reynold's newest installment in her stellar and greatly admired Pemberley Variation series. If you are unfamiliar with this phenomenal series, it contains seven novels and one novella anthology that explore the many paths Jane Austen didn't take in Pride and Prejudice. The premise of Elizabeth not accepting Darcy's letter is entirely new to this reader and I was very intrigued to see how this would affect the plot and characters. Would Elizabeth fall prey to Wickham's lies? How will Elizabeth react when she sees Darcy at Pemberley? Would Wickham still attempt to elope with Lydia? There are so many avenues one can go with this premise!
To continue reading, go to: http://janeaustenreviews.blogspot.com...
April 8, 2020
Excellent story
A fairly deep story. Lizzy doesn’t read Darcy’s letter but burns it, as she should.
So she has no idea about the real Darcy.
And she has NO ONE in her life who will listen to her and will keep her safe. Her mother berates her constantly and would marry her off to anyone. Her father acts like he loves her but only loves a vision of young child Lizzy who adores him and never questions him.
She says it is unwise to let Lydia go to Brighton and she was right. She tells him that no one should talk about Lydia when she is ruined and Lizzy is right. She tells him Darcy loves her and she loves Darcy and she is right. But in all cases he disagrees with her and ignores her. He will do nothing to protect the family.
So, in my mind, when she finally finds someone to love her and she is betrothed to him, it must feel like the first time she has ever been loved, respected and safe. I think this is the explanation why she would allow Darcy and she to ‘anticipate their wedding night’ in a physical way before the wedding.
Of course it was wrong in her society but she must feel he is the person in the world she can be safe with and trust implicitly. imagine how frightening her prior life was.
I think this was a marvelous story. I recommend it highly.
A fairly deep story. Lizzy doesn’t read Darcy’s letter but burns it, as she should.
So she has no idea about the real Darcy.
And she has NO ONE in her life who will listen to her and will keep her safe. Her mother berates her constantly and would marry her off to anyone. Her father acts like he loves her but only loves a vision of young child Lizzy who adores him and never questions him.
She says it is unwise to let Lydia go to Brighton and she was right. She tells him that no one should talk about Lydia when she is ruined and Lizzy is right. She tells him Darcy loves her and she loves Darcy and she is right. But in all cases he disagrees with her and ignores her. He will do nothing to protect the family.
So, in my mind, when she finally finds someone to love her and she is betrothed to him, it must feel like the first time she has ever been loved, respected and safe. I think this is the explanation why she would allow Darcy and she to ‘anticipate their wedding night’ in a physical way before the wedding.
Of course it was wrong in her society but she must feel he is the person in the world she can be safe with and trust implicitly. imagine how frightening her prior life was.
I think this was a marvelous story. I recommend it highly.
February 8, 2021
It's ok if you read a lot of JAFF, but if you are trying to choose discriminately this piece is forgettable
Synopsis:
Lizzy refuses to read Darcy’s letter, and continues in her friendship with Wickham. Many misunderstandings between ODC ensue as well as angst and longing.
Nothing terribly original but a respectable JAFF all the same.
What I enjoyed:
-I'm always a sucker for Darcy going to balls trying to meet ladies who all fall painfully short of Lizzy.
-My kink is Lydia not having to spend her life married to Wickham for a mistake in her youth.
It follows a course of events that logic might demand would ensue should the variable of Lizzy adhering to the propriety of not accepting a letter from a man were enacted. Although it is quite ironic she was trying to follow propriety since she drastically deviates from it soon thereafter..
The continued relevance and theme of letters to the story
What Displeased Me:
While I respect Reynolds writing and stories, she never manages to write witty Lizzy dialogue which is a shame, though I understand it’s hard to mimic.
Still she captures Lizzy’s other traits, her loyalty, love and determination.
Her Lizzy is always subdued and thus harder to love, though she did a better job with her in Mr. Darcy's Undoing: A Pride and Prejudice Variation, that's my favorite of hers.
She does well with other characters who do not require quippy dialogue, such as Jane and Bingley.
I would have liked the supporting cast to be more steady in their presence they appeared and disappeared as convenient but made for a less tangible story, Georgiana, Caroline, Lady Catherine, Richard, they all should have been more involved, in my opinion. The stage felt too empty and perchance due to this less exciting.
Later events didn’t seem relevant to story only added to create a false sense of risk and tension, but they fell flat.
Super cringe last lines tbh but that hardly signifies
Author could have taken more risks
Conclusion
Just pleasing, nothing out of the ordinary or exciting.
I wouldn't reread.
I measure the quality of a JAFF by three factors, as follows;
1. Did I feel the characters acted true to Austen's character framework (allowing for changed circumstance and scenario to offer some leeway)? Yes
2. Was I engaged during the reading and not bored? Yes, but I wasn’t terribly excited
3. Was the writing compelling/ intelligent and was there sufficient interaction/dialogue between the main characters? To a limited extent
Synopsis:
Lizzy refuses to read Darcy’s letter, and continues in her friendship with Wickham. Many misunderstandings between ODC ensue as well as angst and longing.
Nothing terribly original but a respectable JAFF all the same.
What I enjoyed:
-I'm always a sucker for Darcy going to balls trying to meet ladies who all fall painfully short of Lizzy.
-My kink is Lydia not having to spend her life married to Wickham for a mistake in her youth.
It follows a course of events that logic might demand would ensue should the variable of Lizzy adhering to the propriety of not accepting a letter from a man were enacted. Although it is quite ironic she was trying to follow propriety since she drastically deviates from it soon thereafter..
The continued relevance and theme of letters to the story
What Displeased Me:
While I respect Reynolds writing and stories, she never manages to write witty Lizzy dialogue which is a shame, though I understand it’s hard to mimic.
Still she captures Lizzy’s other traits, her loyalty, love and determination.
Her Lizzy is always subdued and thus harder to love, though she did a better job with her in Mr. Darcy's Undoing: A Pride and Prejudice Variation, that's my favorite of hers.
She does well with other characters who do not require quippy dialogue, such as Jane and Bingley.
I would have liked the supporting cast to be more steady in their presence they appeared and disappeared as convenient but made for a less tangible story, Georgiana, Caroline, Lady Catherine, Richard, they all should have been more involved, in my opinion. The stage felt too empty and perchance due to this less exciting.
Later events didn’t seem relevant to story only added to create a false sense of risk and tension, but they fell flat.
Super cringe last lines tbh but that hardly signifies
Author could have taken more risks
Conclusion
Just pleasing, nothing out of the ordinary or exciting.
I wouldn't reread.
I measure the quality of a JAFF by three factors, as follows;
1. Did I feel the characters acted true to Austen's character framework (allowing for changed circumstance and scenario to offer some leeway)? Yes
2. Was I engaged during the reading and not bored? Yes, but I wasn’t terribly excited
3. Was the writing compelling/ intelligent and was there sufficient interaction/dialogue between the main characters? To a limited extent
January 2, 2024
Disfrute mucho la lectura
June 2, 2020
Pride and Prejudice, but with ADDED misunderstandings, and also sexy times. The sexy bits were a little misplaced and decidedly unwise for the characters, and not really my cup of tea. As an example, Darcy was apparently largely silent in canon because he was overwhelmed with Elizabeth's sexiness. Um. Okay.
March 15, 2016
Loved it!!!!
Masters at misunderstanding each other, Darcy and Elizabeth go through a lot to be together. Amidst almost ruin, one sister's broken heart, rumors... you have to read it!!
Masters at misunderstanding each other, Darcy and Elizabeth go through a lot to be together. Amidst almost ruin, one sister's broken heart, rumors... you have to read it!!
March 29, 2017
Totally against the rules of society Darcy writes Elizabeth a letter after his failed proposal but Elizabeth never reads it and returns to Longbourn unaware of the truth of Wickham. But on hearing of the failed proposal Wickham believes it is in his best interests that they marry. Bur knowing the nature of both Darcy and Elizabeth is it possible for a happy ending, and what about Jane and Bingley.
Just about kept my interest, with the two main people constantly misunderstanding each other.
Just about kept my interest, with the two main people constantly misunderstanding each other.
January 3, 2018
Valutazione 3,5
Una "variazione" di piacevole lettura, vivace, rocambolesca con quel tocco passionale che contraddistingue la Reynolds ma che farebbe storcere il naso a più di qualche "purista austeniana". A parte questo la trama è molto ben strutturata e la consiglierei a chi ha curiosità di conoscere un'altra versione delle vicende di O&P e in genere a chi ama i derivati austeniani...
Una "variazione" di piacevole lettura, vivace, rocambolesca con quel tocco passionale che contraddistingue la Reynolds ma che farebbe storcere il naso a più di qualche "purista austeniana". A parte questo la trama è molto ben strutturata e la consiglierei a chi ha curiosità di conoscere un'altra versione delle vicende di O&P e in genere a chi ama i derivati austeniani...
June 10, 2018
3.5
Good story, but a bit scattered in places.
Good story, but a bit scattered in places.
March 21, 2017
A really interesting premise with a major change to the plot with Elizabeth refusing to read Darcy's letter. This makes for a very interesting twist with the path to true love being more tortuous not only for Elizabeth and Darcy but also Bingley. There is some sex in the book which is fine but shows a major change in Elizabeth's strong sense of propriety from when she refuses to read a letter from an unattached gentleman to when the deed occurs. However, a most enjoyable read.
March 6, 2015
http://labibliotecadieliza.blogspot.i...
E se... Quante volte leggendo un libro o guardando un film ci siamo fatti questa domanda?
Da questa semplice idea nasce questo libro e la serie di romanzi cui appartiene. Sono le variazioni di Orgoglio e Pregiudizio, uno Sliding Doors ambientato nelle pagine rese immortali da Jane Austen.
Il punto di svolta, nonché inizio del romanzo, è la decisione di Elizabeth Bennet di non leggere la lettera che Mr Darcy le scrive per discolparsi delle accuse che lei gli ha rivolto al momento del rifiuto della sua proposta di matrimonio. E' disdicevole per una ragazza nubile ricevere corrispondenza da un uomo non sposato...Cosa crede di fare il padrone di Pemberley scrivendole? Rovinarla davanti all'opinione pubblica? Costringerla ad un matrimonio indesiderato? Meglio consegnare alle fiamme la missiva incriminante! E la storia così cambia... Elizabeth non sa cosa ha tentato di fare Mr Wickham a Georgiana e non può capire quindi il comportamento di Mr Darcy. A cosa porterà questo?
Si può dividere il romanzo in due parti, con come spartiacque la visita di Elizabeth a Pemberley insieme agli zii. La prima parte, nonostante la mancata lettura della lettera, non si discosta molto dal romanzo della Austen, solo l'atmosfera è un po' più tesa e carica di dubbi.
La seconda parte invece è un'esplosione di novità, nuovi personaggi, scandali, duelli... Ebbene si, c'è un po' di tutto, ma niente è fuori posto o di troppo! Tutte queste novità arricchiscono il racconto e danno veramente il senso di "variazione"! La storia è credibile, nel senso che è coerente con quanto già scritto da Jane Austen, in particolare per quanto riguarda i personaggi. La Reynolds, infatti, non cerca di proporre i personaggi di Orgoglio e Pregiudizio come li vede lei, ma li riprende in consegna da Jane Austen nel momento in cui le due storie si toccano e li conduce per mano nel suo romanzo. In questo modo ci troviamo davanti a protagonisti credibili e coerenti. Naturalmente, vivendo nuovi momenti, scopriamo molto di più dei vari personaggi, Elizabeth è impaziente, Mr Darcy è impietoso e appassionato, e così via. Il rapporto tra Darcy e Lizzy risulta amplificato, più profondo, più intimo e più sensuale, dai rispettivi dubbi e incertezze nasce la necessità dell'uno e dell'altra. Anche il rapporto tra Darcy e la sorella Giorgiana è approfondito, e in particolare scopriamo qualcosa di più sul carattere delle ragazza, che seppur timida e fragile, ha anche un qualcosa di più, come una scintilla! Ma i personaggi che più mi hanno stupito sono due, uno nel bene e uno nel male. Lydia da frivola e sciocca ragazzina muta e si trasforma, cresce sotto la spinta di una guida energica...E mi piace questo momento di redenzione per una delle più civettuole ragazze viste sulla faccia della terra! Mr Bingley invece mi ha lasciata sconcertata per la mutevolezza dei suoi pensieri, per la poca forza di volontà che dimostra, spinto questa volta non solo dalla famiglia e dall'amico ad allontanarsi da Jane ma anche dalla società! Mi ha fatto venire in mente il Mr Bingley della fiction Lost in Austen: anche in quel caso ci trovavamo davanti ad un uomo debole, che rimane schiacciato dai propri errori, però in quel caso alla fine prendeva una decisione forte, contro corrente, dettata dal cuore. Qui no, o meglio, non del tutto! Mi è piaciuto molto anche il destino che viene dato a Mr Wickham; ho sempre pensato che gli fosse andata troppo bene; in fondo, dopo aver fatto quello che ha fatto, finiva con lo sposarsi Lydia, che magari non è una delle opzioni più allettanti, però Darcy gli paga i debiti e gli da dei soldi, insomma, visto il tipo non poteva lamentarsi! Nel libro della Reynolds il suo destino è invece un po' più cattivello, ma francamente se lo meritava tutto!!
In questi casi non si possono, e non si devono, fare paragoni tra la Austen e altri scrittori, soprattutto per quanto riguarda lo stile. Ebbene, nel caso della Reynolds devo dire che ho rivissuto le ambientazioni di Orgoglio e pregiudizio e anche lo stile mi è sembrato coerente, magari più in alcuni momenti che in altri: le lettere o i discorsi diretti sembrano veramente scritti in periodo regency, sembrano autentici! E rendono appieno lo stile e l'atmosfera del romanzo originale.
Se siete appassionati di Jane Austen come me, se volete scoprire nuovo aspetti di Mr Darcy ed Elizabeth Bennet, vi consiglio vivamente questo libro!
Spero veramente che la To Be Continued continui la pubblicazione di queste variazioni e che le porti in Italia!
E se... Quante volte leggendo un libro o guardando un film ci siamo fatti questa domanda?
Da questa semplice idea nasce questo libro e la serie di romanzi cui appartiene. Sono le variazioni di Orgoglio e Pregiudizio, uno Sliding Doors ambientato nelle pagine rese immortali da Jane Austen.
Il punto di svolta, nonché inizio del romanzo, è la decisione di Elizabeth Bennet di non leggere la lettera che Mr Darcy le scrive per discolparsi delle accuse che lei gli ha rivolto al momento del rifiuto della sua proposta di matrimonio. E' disdicevole per una ragazza nubile ricevere corrispondenza da un uomo non sposato...Cosa crede di fare il padrone di Pemberley scrivendole? Rovinarla davanti all'opinione pubblica? Costringerla ad un matrimonio indesiderato? Meglio consegnare alle fiamme la missiva incriminante! E la storia così cambia... Elizabeth non sa cosa ha tentato di fare Mr Wickham a Georgiana e non può capire quindi il comportamento di Mr Darcy. A cosa porterà questo?
Si può dividere il romanzo in due parti, con come spartiacque la visita di Elizabeth a Pemberley insieme agli zii. La prima parte, nonostante la mancata lettura della lettera, non si discosta molto dal romanzo della Austen, solo l'atmosfera è un po' più tesa e carica di dubbi.
La seconda parte invece è un'esplosione di novità, nuovi personaggi, scandali, duelli... Ebbene si, c'è un po' di tutto, ma niente è fuori posto o di troppo! Tutte queste novità arricchiscono il racconto e danno veramente il senso di "variazione"! La storia è credibile, nel senso che è coerente con quanto già scritto da Jane Austen, in particolare per quanto riguarda i personaggi. La Reynolds, infatti, non cerca di proporre i personaggi di Orgoglio e Pregiudizio come li vede lei, ma li riprende in consegna da Jane Austen nel momento in cui le due storie si toccano e li conduce per mano nel suo romanzo. In questo modo ci troviamo davanti a protagonisti credibili e coerenti. Naturalmente, vivendo nuovi momenti, scopriamo molto di più dei vari personaggi, Elizabeth è impaziente, Mr Darcy è impietoso e appassionato, e così via. Il rapporto tra Darcy e Lizzy risulta amplificato, più profondo, più intimo e più sensuale, dai rispettivi dubbi e incertezze nasce la necessità dell'uno e dell'altra. Anche il rapporto tra Darcy e la sorella Giorgiana è approfondito, e in particolare scopriamo qualcosa di più sul carattere delle ragazza, che seppur timida e fragile, ha anche un qualcosa di più, come una scintilla! Ma i personaggi che più mi hanno stupito sono due, uno nel bene e uno nel male. Lydia da frivola e sciocca ragazzina muta e si trasforma, cresce sotto la spinta di una guida energica...E mi piace questo momento di redenzione per una delle più civettuole ragazze viste sulla faccia della terra! Mr Bingley invece mi ha lasciata sconcertata per la mutevolezza dei suoi pensieri, per la poca forza di volontà che dimostra, spinto questa volta non solo dalla famiglia e dall'amico ad allontanarsi da Jane ma anche dalla società! Mi ha fatto venire in mente il Mr Bingley della fiction Lost in Austen: anche in quel caso ci trovavamo davanti ad un uomo debole, che rimane schiacciato dai propri errori, però in quel caso alla fine prendeva una decisione forte, contro corrente, dettata dal cuore. Qui no, o meglio, non del tutto! Mi è piaciuto molto anche il destino che viene dato a Mr Wickham; ho sempre pensato che gli fosse andata troppo bene; in fondo, dopo aver fatto quello che ha fatto, finiva con lo sposarsi Lydia, che magari non è una delle opzioni più allettanti, però Darcy gli paga i debiti e gli da dei soldi, insomma, visto il tipo non poteva lamentarsi! Nel libro della Reynolds il suo destino è invece un po' più cattivello, ma francamente se lo meritava tutto!!
In questi casi non si possono, e non si devono, fare paragoni tra la Austen e altri scrittori, soprattutto per quanto riguarda lo stile. Ebbene, nel caso della Reynolds devo dire che ho rivissuto le ambientazioni di Orgoglio e pregiudizio e anche lo stile mi è sembrato coerente, magari più in alcuni momenti che in altri: le lettere o i discorsi diretti sembrano veramente scritti in periodo regency, sembrano autentici! E rendono appieno lo stile e l'atmosfera del romanzo originale.
Se siete appassionati di Jane Austen come me, se volete scoprire nuovo aspetti di Mr Darcy ed Elizabeth Bennet, vi consiglio vivamente questo libro!
Spero veramente che la To Be Continued continui la pubblicazione di queste variazioni e che le porti in Italia!
January 1, 2022
This is more of a 2.5 start book, but editing issues and a very anti-climactic and somewhat confusing ending leads me to round down where I normally might have gone up.
Pride and Prejudice spin-offs are always hard to judge, mainly because it's published fanfiction and therefore I WANT to love it, but sometimes it just falls flat. In this variation, Elizabeth chooses to protect her reputation and burns the letter Darcy gives her after refusing his proposal. This means she never learns about Wickham's true nature, or that at least part of the reason he kept Bingley from Jane was because he honestly believed she did not care for him.
My main issue with this premise is that, while events do occur differently, very little of it stems from the lack of letter reading. Not learning about Wickham changes literally nothing, as she'd told no one but Jane originally in any case, and Darcy still has the opportunity - albeit later in the plot - to explain about Jane. So while the plot does have twists and turns, I'm unconvinced the letter really had much to do with it at all.
As I said earlier, the ending also left much to be desired. Events came out of nowhere and seemed extremely unrealistic, and I just didn't feel that the last quarter of the plot flowed well at all. I also had severe issues with her characterization of Bingley throughout the whole book, which is odd, because normally this author doesn't have that problem.
All in all, a disappointing book from an author I normally trust to provide at least a pleasant read in this genre.
Pride and Prejudice spin-offs are always hard to judge, mainly because it's published fanfiction and therefore I WANT to love it, but sometimes it just falls flat. In this variation, Elizabeth chooses to protect her reputation and burns the letter Darcy gives her after refusing his proposal. This means she never learns about Wickham's true nature, or that at least part of the reason he kept Bingley from Jane was because he honestly believed she did not care for him.
My main issue with this premise is that, while events do occur differently, very little of it stems from the lack of letter reading. Not learning about Wickham changes literally nothing, as she'd told no one but Jane originally in any case, and Darcy still has the opportunity - albeit later in the plot - to explain about Jane. So while the plot does have twists and turns, I'm unconvinced the letter really had much to do with it at all.
As I said earlier, the ending also left much to be desired. Events came out of nowhere and seemed extremely unrealistic, and I just didn't feel that the last quarter of the plot flowed well at all. I also had severe issues with her characterization of Bingley throughout the whole book, which is odd, because normally this author doesn't have that problem.
All in all, a disappointing book from an author I normally trust to provide at least a pleasant read in this genre.
June 25, 2015
Quando si parla di Orgoglio e Pregiudizio si pensa sempre all'amore reverenziale e romantico che ne scaturisce dalle sue pagine. Una variazione della sua linea naturale dei fatti, si suppone, debba mantenere tali aspetti. Quello che cambia, si suppone sempre debbano essere i fatti in questo genere di libri.
Ed invece in questo romanzo accade tutto il contrario: a cambiare è tutto il romanticismo classico simbolo della famosa opera di Jane Austen. Riguardo alle vicende, beh, una leggera variazione.
Dunque, da dove partire? Dal momento in cui, in Orgoglio e Pregiudizio, Elizabeth Bennet riceve la lettera di Mr Darcy nella quale vi è scritto tutta la verità su Mr Wickham. [...]
--> LEGGI TUTTA LE RECENSIONE QUI: http://thebookishteapot.blogspot.it/2...
Ed invece in questo romanzo accade tutto il contrario: a cambiare è tutto il romanticismo classico simbolo della famosa opera di Jane Austen. Riguardo alle vicende, beh, una leggera variazione.
Dunque, da dove partire? Dal momento in cui, in Orgoglio e Pregiudizio, Elizabeth Bennet riceve la lettera di Mr Darcy nella quale vi è scritto tutta la verità su Mr Wickham. [...]
--> LEGGI TUTTA LE RECENSIONE QUI: http://thebookishteapot.blogspot.it/2...
September 12, 2012
Another great Abigail Reynolds read.
The only thing I didn't like was the fact that Elizabeth was WAY TOO...catty...about Darcy. I will admit: Elizabeth is NOT my favorite character of Austen's P&P. I always went for Darcy (gee, I wonder why??). But in this variation, Lizzy is so darned prejudiced against Darcy that she believed anything about Darcy that was bad. I think she would've believed that Darcy crucified Christ if it validated what she believed to be correct in her mind. I thought it was too far of a variation for Lizzy and it got to be incredibly annoying after awhile.
Otherwise I really enjoyed it. :)
The only thing I didn't like was the fact that Elizabeth was WAY TOO...catty...about Darcy. I will admit: Elizabeth is NOT my favorite character of Austen's P&P. I always went for Darcy (gee, I wonder why??). But in this variation, Lizzy is so darned prejudiced against Darcy that she believed anything about Darcy that was bad. I think she would've believed that Darcy crucified Christ if it validated what she believed to be correct in her mind. I thought it was too far of a variation for Lizzy and it got to be incredibly annoying after awhile.
Otherwise I really enjoyed it. :)
July 3, 2021
In this P&P variation, Elizabeth chooses the proper course of a gentleman's daughter and burns Mr. Darcy's letter without reading it. Therefore, she has no idea of Wickham's ways, and does not feel guilty about how she declined Darcy's proposal. Also, in this variation, Wickham has an older brother who is willing to come to Lydia's rescue. All in all, not a very surprising read if you have previously read P&P variations by Abigail Reynolds. I found it enjoyable and like how the variations added to the story without changing the inevitable ending.
February 24, 2015
While some of this story resembles other Abigail Reynolds works, I find that it's a better balance of angst, passion and romance. Darcy tries more than once to have Elizabeth read his letter after his disastrous proposal, but she never does. He thinks she has when they meet at Pemberley, and then low-and-behold Lydia runs off with Wickham. The story follows a familiar route, but I really enjoyed how the Lydia storyline played out. As usually Darcy and Elizabeth are expected to misunderstand each other at every opportunity which creates lots of drama.
I enjoyed it!
I enjoyed it!
dnf
December 15, 2012I'm not much for Austen fanfic, but the premise of this sounded intriguing. But here I am at a quarter through the book and the change in events has essentially made no difference at all to the plotline. Reynolds does a decent job of making her own words mesh with the ones of Austen's she reuses, but I don't see much point to this story. Also, it's getting into physical areas and I don't want to go there, so DNF.
July 17, 2020
Sadly, I did not enjoy this one. I have liked other Abigail Reynolds P&P vagaries, such as Alone with Mr Darcy, which was written four years later than this, so perhaps that explains why I found it vastly superior.
The premise of Mr Darcy's Letter is that Elizabeth refuses to read the letter Darcy gave her after his failed proposal at Hunsford, and this subsequently changes the events that follow. However, Elizabeth not reading the letter actually changed very little:
She continues to believe Wickham's tales of woe, and then Wickham himself tells the truth (for no apparent reason) about the financial compensation he receieved in lieu of the living, and during her Pemberley visit with the Gardiners, Darcy simply asks Elizabeth if she read his letter and when she says no, he tells her the facts instead.
...So not a whole heap of difference, except that we hate Elizabeth more for being annoying and even more judgemental of Darcy than usual.
Other differences were random and added nothing to the story - Darcy fixes the Lydia-Wickham issue later rather than sooner, for example, and in a slightly altered manner, but it amounted to the same thing as the original, only dragged out and therefore more boring. Darcy and Elizabeth both think the other despises them (for no reason) and other characters have to spell things out for them, which again added nothing but irritation at their stupidity, while taking hours from my life to get to the point.
Long passages of this vagary are taken verbatim from P&P, not just small snippets, which I found intrusive, and Elizabeth is an idiot who jumps to conclusions and thinks the worst of Darcy all the time: "He's trying to trap me into marriage!" "He's had sex with me, now he will abandon me!" "He's a cheat!" until I wanted to slap her and couldn't see why Darcy was so determined to marry the awful woman. Her wit and liveliness are all gone, replaced by constant weeping, anger and paranoia.
And yes, there is a sex before marriage scene, which I am not usually a fan of for P&P vagaries, but that wasn't so much of a problem as that I just really didn't like Elizabeth or Darcy very much in this version and had to listen to this audiobook on double speed to get through it, while grinding my teeth at almost everything.
This is definitely not Ms Reynolds best work. If you're new to her, I suggest trying Alone with Mr Darcy, and giving this one a miss.
The premise of Mr Darcy's Letter is that Elizabeth refuses to read the letter Darcy gave her after his failed proposal at Hunsford, and this subsequently changes the events that follow. However, Elizabeth not reading the letter actually changed very little:
She continues to believe Wickham's tales of woe, and then Wickham himself tells the truth (for no apparent reason) about the financial compensation he receieved in lieu of the living, and during her Pemberley visit with the Gardiners, Darcy simply asks Elizabeth if she read his letter and when she says no, he tells her the facts instead.
...So not a whole heap of difference, except that we hate Elizabeth more for being annoying and even more judgemental of Darcy than usual.
Other differences were random and added nothing to the story - Darcy fixes the Lydia-Wickham issue later rather than sooner, for example, and in a slightly altered manner, but it amounted to the same thing as the original, only dragged out and therefore more boring. Darcy and Elizabeth both think the other despises them (for no reason) and other characters have to spell things out for them, which again added nothing but irritation at their stupidity, while taking hours from my life to get to the point.
Long passages of this vagary are taken verbatim from P&P, not just small snippets, which I found intrusive, and Elizabeth is an idiot who jumps to conclusions and thinks the worst of Darcy all the time: "He's trying to trap me into marriage!" "He's had sex with me, now he will abandon me!" "He's a cheat!" until I wanted to slap her and couldn't see why Darcy was so determined to marry the awful woman. Her wit and liveliness are all gone, replaced by constant weeping, anger and paranoia.
And yes, there is a sex before marriage scene, which I am not usually a fan of for P&P vagaries, but that wasn't so much of a problem as that I just really didn't like Elizabeth or Darcy very much in this version and had to listen to this audiobook on double speed to get through it, while grinding my teeth at almost everything.
This is definitely not Ms Reynolds best work. If you're new to her, I suggest trying Alone with Mr Darcy, and giving this one a miss.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 109 reviews