What do you think?
Rate this book
The Boys of Fire and Ash
"The compelling mythology and dystopian setting will appeal to genre readers. Fans of James Dashner, Margaret Peterson Haddix, and Patrick Ness need look no further."-- Kirkus
Fans of Rick Riordan and Anthony Horowitz will want to read this action-filled debut novel that offers a new world to enjoy and a new underdog to root for.-- Booklist
Abandoned at birth, the Brothers of the Ikkuma Pit know no mothers. They fend for themselves, each training their Little Brother to survive until they turn sixteen, when it’s their Leaving Day. No boy knows what’s beyond the forest. But when Urgle’s Little Brother, Cubby, is carried off by troll-like predators, Urgle and two of his Brothers embark on a quest to rescue him from a place from which no one has ever returned.
More praise for The Boys of Fire and
"McIsaac’s debut fantasy novel is fast-paced and heartstopping. . . . This self-contained story is an entertaining read that will be enjoyed by many."-- School Library Journal
"The novel is urgently gritty, with rich worldbuilding and plenty of action."-- Publishers Weekly
"Contemplative readers will be left with questions to ponder and ethical decisions to mull as well as a satisfying and tense read."-- The Bulletin
From the Hardcover edition.
Fans of Rick Riordan and Anthony Horowitz will want to read this action-filled debut novel that offers a new world to enjoy and a new underdog to root for.-- Booklist
Abandoned at birth, the Brothers of the Ikkuma Pit know no mothers. They fend for themselves, each training their Little Brother to survive until they turn sixteen, when it’s their Leaving Day. No boy knows what’s beyond the forest. But when Urgle’s Little Brother, Cubby, is carried off by troll-like predators, Urgle and two of his Brothers embark on a quest to rescue him from a place from which no one has ever returned.
More praise for The Boys of Fire and
"McIsaac’s debut fantasy novel is fast-paced and heartstopping. . . . This self-contained story is an entertaining read that will be enjoyed by many."-- School Library Journal
"The novel is urgently gritty, with rich worldbuilding and plenty of action."-- Publishers Weekly
"Contemplative readers will be left with questions to ponder and ethical decisions to mull as well as a satisfying and tense read."-- The Bulletin
From the Hardcover edition.
336 pages, Library Binding
First published May 2, 2013
18 people are currently reading
762 people want to read
About the author
Meaghan McIsaac
8 books70 followersMeaghan McIsaac is the author of several books for young readers, including The Bear House (shortlisted for the Forest of Reading Red Maple Award 2023) and Movers (a Shining Willow Finalist for the Saskatchewan Young Readers’ Choice Awards). Meaghan completed a masters in Children’s Writing at the University of Winchester and now lives in Toronto, Ontario with her family.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 84 reviews
April 21, 2015
PJV Quickie: I was excited about The Boys of Fire and Ash by Meaghan McIsaac and then I began to read it. I put the book down, tried to pick it up again and just got lost in the strange world, dialect, and silly characters. I wanted the next MAZE RUNNER or the next LOST BOYS, what I got was a slow-going MAZE RUNNER wannabe.
Review: Boys are being raised in a volcano. They just appear and then are assigned to older boys to be raised as little brothers. At the age of 16 the boys have to leave. The main characters name is Urgle, and he has a younger brother named Cubby. Cubby is captured by goblins and the useless Urgle has to chase them into the unknown to get the brother back. In pursuit, a few of Urgle’s friends join him and then they are later joined by an older boy named Blaze when they get to the outside world. The outside world is, of course, all different and they find out all they believed to be was false. Typical “isolated” dystopian thread type of novel.
Typical. If the characters had more depth, if the storyline was expounded on better and the underlying concepts explained more, this could have been a competent story, but combine all of those issues, you just got a half-baked “just another dystopian” novel.
Recommendations: This is recommended for the non-discerning 14-year-old boy. If he just wants to read about a kid that has no parental influences and runs wild with a somewhat Northbound moral compass, there ya go. But, with such praising reviews from the School Library Journal and Booklist, who knows you might like it.
Review: Boys are being raised in a volcano. They just appear and then are assigned to older boys to be raised as little brothers. At the age of 16 the boys have to leave. The main characters name is Urgle, and he has a younger brother named Cubby. Cubby is captured by goblins and the useless Urgle has to chase them into the unknown to get the brother back. In pursuit, a few of Urgle’s friends join him and then they are later joined by an older boy named Blaze when they get to the outside world. The outside world is, of course, all different and they find out all they believed to be was false. Typical “isolated” dystopian thread type of novel.
Typical. If the characters had more depth, if the storyline was expounded on better and the underlying concepts explained more, this could have been a competent story, but combine all of those issues, you just got a half-baked “just another dystopian” novel.
Recommendations: This is recommended for the non-discerning 14-year-old boy. If he just wants to read about a kid that has no parental influences and runs wild with a somewhat Northbound moral compass, there ya go. But, with such praising reviews from the School Library Journal and Booklist, who knows you might like it.
May 18, 2015
**This review originally appeared on She Dreams in Fiction as part of a blog tour in which I received a copy in exchange for an honest review.**
The second I saw the synopsis, I knew this was going to be a book I wanted to check out. The Boys of Fire and Ash sounded like a great dystopian adventure that I could add to my list of books to recommend! So was my excitement for reading it well-deserved? I believe it was!
The whole idea that mothers would abandon their infant sons in a harsh landscape was positively gut-wrenching! How could any mother abandon their child, let alone a tiny baby, with no idea of whether or not they'd be able to survive? I was hoping there was some very important reason to do so, and not because they're just evil, like the boys all assume. Then again, you can't really blame the boys for thinking mothers evil. They have no information to go on to help them see things in any other light. I enjoyed getting to know a little about life in the Ikkuma Pit; I feel as though it helped illustrate just how alien things outside the Pit are to these isolated boys.
This story is told by Urgle and I immediately started to feel for him. He - and every other Brother in the Pit, it seems - feels he is nothing but useless because he has no real abilities. He is good at making daggers, though, so there's that at least. I found Urgle to be a rather realistic character. I liked the fact that he wasn't particularly good at hunting or tracking or anything else valued highly in the Pit; it made him more relate-able. He has a bit of a quick temper, with a tendency not to think things through, but again, that just makes him seem all the more believable. He does have a best friend, Av. Av is a good character and one we get to see a bit more development from as the story progresses. He's that friend that is good at everything and gets along with everyone. I think it an interesting contrast to Urgle, one that I enjoyed. In the Pit, when a new baby is dropped off, they get picked up by an older boy and taught about the ways of the Ikkuma Brothers. Urgle's little brother is Cubby. Cubby is so adorable, but Urgle is always annoyed by him. However, when Cubby gets kidnapped by goblin-like nasties called Tunrar, Urgle decides he will stop at nothing to rescue him. This is the time when we really get to see great character development. Urgle thinks he's completely useless, but he has such determination and a great depth of feeling that I personally value very highly.
The world outside the Ikkuma Pit is vastly different. Watching Urgle and his quest brothers venture into this world was really interesting. Having the story told from Urgle's point of view was an excellent idea for this adventure. As the reader, we get to discover all these new things right along with Urgle. They're terrifying and wonderful and completely foreign to these boys. One of the things I found most funny was how Urgle perceived wrinkles. Being always surrounded by boys 16 and younger, he has never seen any mature adults, let alone elders. When he sees an old person, to him, their wrinkles make it seem like the person's face is melting. I found it hilarious! Melty ancient people. Amazing, right? Along their journey, the boys encounter many strange, scary and interesting people and landscapes. The Baublenotts is probably the place I find simultaneously the most interesting and terrifying. Just wait until you read about it and then you'll see what I mean! Urgle's interpretation of the outside world was very refreshing, which I think will aid younger readers in enjoying this novel very much.
When first starting the book, I was a little confused about the world-specific language. Even when they got outside of the Pit, I still got a little overwhelmed by all the new things presented to me. At first, I thought it might make me get frustrated with the novel and give up. However, with each new and unfamiliar thing that was introduced, I discovered I wanted to know more. I feel as though plunging the reader into an all new experience like that can either go horribly wrong or turn out okay. In this case, it turned out wonderfully because it helped the reader experience everything new right along with the boys! You get used to their personal lingo, then you add in all this new stuff, making you feel a part of the story. I honestly think younger readers will find this most gratifying. Other than getting a little lost in the lingo, there seemed to be some pacing issues. However, it didn't really deter me from enjoying the story and hoping for a happy ending.
Speaking of endings, there has to be a sequel! I didn't know if that was going to be a possibility or not, but I want more, so it needs to happen. Ahem. Overall, I definitely enjoyed reading The Boys of Fire and Ash. This journey I was able to take with Urgle was fraught with danger and excitement and even sadness, but it was one that I wouldn't have missed for anything. I am definitely intrigued by this debut novel and know that Meaghan McIsaac is an author to watch out for. As I mentioned before, I think this is a great novel for younger YA readers or older MG readers. Regardless of how old you are, I think there is adventure enough to capture your imagination and keep you reading late into the night. Now bring on that sequel, please!
The second I saw the synopsis, I knew this was going to be a book I wanted to check out. The Boys of Fire and Ash sounded like a great dystopian adventure that I could add to my list of books to recommend! So was my excitement for reading it well-deserved? I believe it was!
The whole idea that mothers would abandon their infant sons in a harsh landscape was positively gut-wrenching! How could any mother abandon their child, let alone a tiny baby, with no idea of whether or not they'd be able to survive? I was hoping there was some very important reason to do so, and not because they're just evil, like the boys all assume. Then again, you can't really blame the boys for thinking mothers evil. They have no information to go on to help them see things in any other light. I enjoyed getting to know a little about life in the Ikkuma Pit; I feel as though it helped illustrate just how alien things outside the Pit are to these isolated boys.
This story is told by Urgle and I immediately started to feel for him. He - and every other Brother in the Pit, it seems - feels he is nothing but useless because he has no real abilities. He is good at making daggers, though, so there's that at least. I found Urgle to be a rather realistic character. I liked the fact that he wasn't particularly good at hunting or tracking or anything else valued highly in the Pit; it made him more relate-able. He has a bit of a quick temper, with a tendency not to think things through, but again, that just makes him seem all the more believable. He does have a best friend, Av. Av is a good character and one we get to see a bit more development from as the story progresses. He's that friend that is good at everything and gets along with everyone. I think it an interesting contrast to Urgle, one that I enjoyed. In the Pit, when a new baby is dropped off, they get picked up by an older boy and taught about the ways of the Ikkuma Brothers. Urgle's little brother is Cubby. Cubby is so adorable, but Urgle is always annoyed by him. However, when Cubby gets kidnapped by goblin-like nasties called Tunrar, Urgle decides he will stop at nothing to rescue him. This is the time when we really get to see great character development. Urgle thinks he's completely useless, but he has such determination and a great depth of feeling that I personally value very highly.
The world outside the Ikkuma Pit is vastly different. Watching Urgle and his quest brothers venture into this world was really interesting. Having the story told from Urgle's point of view was an excellent idea for this adventure. As the reader, we get to discover all these new things right along with Urgle. They're terrifying and wonderful and completely foreign to these boys. One of the things I found most funny was how Urgle perceived wrinkles. Being always surrounded by boys 16 and younger, he has never seen any mature adults, let alone elders. When he sees an old person, to him, their wrinkles make it seem like the person's face is melting. I found it hilarious! Melty ancient people. Amazing, right? Along their journey, the boys encounter many strange, scary and interesting people and landscapes. The Baublenotts is probably the place I find simultaneously the most interesting and terrifying. Just wait until you read about it and then you'll see what I mean! Urgle's interpretation of the outside world was very refreshing, which I think will aid younger readers in enjoying this novel very much.
When first starting the book, I was a little confused about the world-specific language. Even when they got outside of the Pit, I still got a little overwhelmed by all the new things presented to me. At first, I thought it might make me get frustrated with the novel and give up. However, with each new and unfamiliar thing that was introduced, I discovered I wanted to know more. I feel as though plunging the reader into an all new experience like that can either go horribly wrong or turn out okay. In this case, it turned out wonderfully because it helped the reader experience everything new right along with the boys! You get used to their personal lingo, then you add in all this new stuff, making you feel a part of the story. I honestly think younger readers will find this most gratifying. Other than getting a little lost in the lingo, there seemed to be some pacing issues. However, it didn't really deter me from enjoying the story and hoping for a happy ending.
Speaking of endings, there has to be a sequel! I didn't know if that was going to be a possibility or not, but I want more, so it needs to happen. Ahem. Overall, I definitely enjoyed reading The Boys of Fire and Ash. This journey I was able to take with Urgle was fraught with danger and excitement and even sadness, but it was one that I wouldn't have missed for anything. I am definitely intrigued by this debut novel and know that Meaghan McIsaac is an author to watch out for. As I mentioned before, I think this is a great novel for younger YA readers or older MG readers. Regardless of how old you are, I think there is adventure enough to capture your imagination and keep you reading late into the night. Now bring on that sequel, please!
October 29, 2013
Baby boys are abandoned by their Mothers, left in the wilderness by the Ikkuma Pit to be cared for by older boys. These boys are their Big Brothers. They must teach their Little Brothers how to survive, until each in his turn leaves the Pit when reaching maturity. To be replaced by yet more babies...
A sickening thought. And yet, this is the premise of a new children's/young adult book. I really wasn't sure what I was expecting when I started this. There is the 'Stand by Me' aspect of comradeship through adversity and adventure. There is the Knife of Never Letting Go aspect of the new disorientating world and setting, the violence and evil.
Urgle is a bit of a failure as a Big Brother - his vision, hearing, aim are all below average, his Little Brother Cubby made fun of by association. But when Cubby is taken away, Urgle must leave the Pit, his home, for the first time and use the skills he has to find and protect his Brother.
It's a whole new world, new languages, names, mythologies. All along I was actually expecting a twist of the 'First Book of Calamity Leek' or 'The Village' nature, but it's much more of a straight-up adventure/chase/growing-up saga. Some of the revelations aren't that unexpected, but the character of Urgle and his travelling companions, other Brothers are quite well-drawn and developed.
The writing is good, it rattles along, there's lots to keep the interest of the reader and it doesn't pull any punches when it comes to the fate of its young characters. This would be a good read for someone who likes The Hobbit but isn't ready for Lord of the Rings. It could be classed as sci-fi/fantasy.
Interesting read, and a good debut.
A sickening thought. And yet, this is the premise of a new children's/young adult book. I really wasn't sure what I was expecting when I started this. There is the 'Stand by Me' aspect of comradeship through adversity and adventure. There is the Knife of Never Letting Go aspect of the new disorientating world and setting, the violence and evil.
Urgle is a bit of a failure as a Big Brother - his vision, hearing, aim are all below average, his Little Brother Cubby made fun of by association. But when Cubby is taken away, Urgle must leave the Pit, his home, for the first time and use the skills he has to find and protect his Brother.
It's a whole new world, new languages, names, mythologies. All along I was actually expecting a twist of the 'First Book of Calamity Leek' or 'The Village' nature, but it's much more of a straight-up adventure/chase/growing-up saga. Some of the revelations aren't that unexpected, but the character of Urgle and his travelling companions, other Brothers are quite well-drawn and developed.
The writing is good, it rattles along, there's lots to keep the interest of the reader and it doesn't pull any punches when it comes to the fate of its young characters. This would be a good read for someone who likes The Hobbit but isn't ready for Lord of the Rings. It could be classed as sci-fi/fantasy.
Interesting read, and a good debut.
April 30, 2015
Instantly, this book kind of reminded me of Lord of the Flies. Yet there is no cannibalism happening in this book. Well not between the boys anyways. However there are deaths. The world that Meaghan has built for this story was what I absolutely loved about this book. It felt futuristic but real at the same time as if I could imagine this world really existing. All of the boys were good. Yet there were some stand out stars like Blaze, Urgle, and even Urgle's little brother, Cubby. Although, I have to admit that my favorite was Urgle. He really immerged as the hero of the whole story. There is every in this book from an intriguing world, great characters, a believable storyline, action and intrigue, and a good ending. Worth your time to check out.
January 8, 2019
Seriously wanted to dnf this book like 60 pages into the story. The pace picked up later on, but I couldn't really find it in me to care for any of the characters much at all. And the ending was total crack. It felt like the author got lazy and didn't want to make it into a series so she pulled a quick, emotional 'epilogue' as a way to wash her hands of this.
May 13, 2015
'The Boys of Fire and Ash' is an action packed young adult fantasy debut novel that will have fans of the genre hanging on every word. The majority of the novel takes place in what is called the Ikkuma Pit - which is described like a huge crater at the base of volcanic mountains. Down in the Pit, there's a group of boys who refer to themselves as the Brothers of the Ikkuma Pit. Each one was left at the Pit when they were an infant and then raised by an older boy who becomes his Big Brother. The Big Brother is responsible for raising his Little Brother - teaching him everything needed in order to survive in their world. When a boy turns sixteen, he announces that he will be leaving the group as soon as the next baby is dropped off. He then goes off into the unknown world outside the Pit - never to be seen or heard of again.
Our main character, Urgle, is a teenage Big Brother who sees himself as nothing more than a useless coward. He's not good at hunting, standing up for himself or others, and has no real strengths to speak of. The one thing he is good at is making daggers, which he takes pride in. Urgle is the Big Brother to Cubby - a kind, devoted, and annoying kid who looks up to Urgle and Av - Urgle's best friend. Strange things begin to happen when Av, Urgle, and Cubby witness a man fall down into the Pit after being attacked by creepy looking creatures that definitely aren't human. After looking him over and seeing the scar that marks him as a Brother, the boys bring the man back to their home. Everyone is in awe of the stranger - they've never seen anyone as old as him and nobody has ever returned after leaving the Pit. Urgle, however, is immediately suspicious of him and doesn't get what the fuss is about. Everything comes to a breaking point when Cubby is taken by the creepy creatures they had seen chasing the man. Knowing what he must do, Urgle decides to go after Cubby in order to rescue him and bring him home. Joined by two other Brothers, including Av, Urgle ventures out into the unknown in search of Cubby. What he and the other Brothers see and experience outside of the Pit is unlike anything he could have ever dreamed.
Urgle was a good main character for the story. He definitely undergoes a lot of character growth throughout the story. For example, at the beginning of the book he's seen as a coward who's basically useless to the rest of the group. After Cubby is taken, Urgle must mature and gather courage and strength in order to get him back. Urgle's definitely an underdog of a hero, which makes his growth all the more apparent and his character more realistic. The story is told in first person point of view with Urgle as the narrator, so we get to know him really well by the end of the book. We get an inside peek into his mind - his thoughts, emotions, fears, doubts, hopes, etc. - which makes him easy to identify with right from the beginning. The world building was well done with detailed descriptions and vivid imagery that allows the reader to easily envision Urge's world - and to slip inside of it alongside him. I enjoyed reading about the different places the boys encounter, from the ones they're familiar with to the parts that they have never seen before.
The plot was reasonably original - I haven't read a book quite like this before. It takes awhile to slip into Urgle's world and to feel familiar with everything that's happening. I was actually unable to fully immerse myself into the world inside the book, which took a toll on my reading experience. I just couldn't get into the story on several levels - the characters didn't really grab my interest, the plot felt slow and drawn out in several places, and there were some other aspects I can't quite put my finger on that wouldn't allow me to fully experience the story. This is entirely my opinion and other readers are sure to have a different experience than mine. As I mentioned, the writing was well done except for a few issues with flow and pace. I personally didn't connect with any of the characters, which is a bit thing for me - especially when the book is told in the first person POV - but that again is a personal issue on my end. Overall, I think that I just might not have been in the right mindset or mood when I read the book - which obviously makes a huge difference. I'll more than likely go back to it another time and give it another read - hopefully at that point I'm in the right state of mind and will have a completely different experience. I still definitely recommend this book to fans of the genre along with readers who enjoy science fiction, dystopia, action, and adventure novels.
Disclosure: I received a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
Our main character, Urgle, is a teenage Big Brother who sees himself as nothing more than a useless coward. He's not good at hunting, standing up for himself or others, and has no real strengths to speak of. The one thing he is good at is making daggers, which he takes pride in. Urgle is the Big Brother to Cubby - a kind, devoted, and annoying kid who looks up to Urgle and Av - Urgle's best friend. Strange things begin to happen when Av, Urgle, and Cubby witness a man fall down into the Pit after being attacked by creepy looking creatures that definitely aren't human. After looking him over and seeing the scar that marks him as a Brother, the boys bring the man back to their home. Everyone is in awe of the stranger - they've never seen anyone as old as him and nobody has ever returned after leaving the Pit. Urgle, however, is immediately suspicious of him and doesn't get what the fuss is about. Everything comes to a breaking point when Cubby is taken by the creepy creatures they had seen chasing the man. Knowing what he must do, Urgle decides to go after Cubby in order to rescue him and bring him home. Joined by two other Brothers, including Av, Urgle ventures out into the unknown in search of Cubby. What he and the other Brothers see and experience outside of the Pit is unlike anything he could have ever dreamed.
Urgle was a good main character for the story. He definitely undergoes a lot of character growth throughout the story. For example, at the beginning of the book he's seen as a coward who's basically useless to the rest of the group. After Cubby is taken, Urgle must mature and gather courage and strength in order to get him back. Urgle's definitely an underdog of a hero, which makes his growth all the more apparent and his character more realistic. The story is told in first person point of view with Urgle as the narrator, so we get to know him really well by the end of the book. We get an inside peek into his mind - his thoughts, emotions, fears, doubts, hopes, etc. - which makes him easy to identify with right from the beginning. The world building was well done with detailed descriptions and vivid imagery that allows the reader to easily envision Urge's world - and to slip inside of it alongside him. I enjoyed reading about the different places the boys encounter, from the ones they're familiar with to the parts that they have never seen before.
The plot was reasonably original - I haven't read a book quite like this before. It takes awhile to slip into Urgle's world and to feel familiar with everything that's happening. I was actually unable to fully immerse myself into the world inside the book, which took a toll on my reading experience. I just couldn't get into the story on several levels - the characters didn't really grab my interest, the plot felt slow and drawn out in several places, and there were some other aspects I can't quite put my finger on that wouldn't allow me to fully experience the story. This is entirely my opinion and other readers are sure to have a different experience than mine. As I mentioned, the writing was well done except for a few issues with flow and pace. I personally didn't connect with any of the characters, which is a bit thing for me - especially when the book is told in the first person POV - but that again is a personal issue on my end. Overall, I think that I just might not have been in the right mindset or mood when I read the book - which obviously makes a huge difference. I'll more than likely go back to it another time and give it another read - hopefully at that point I'm in the right state of mind and will have a completely different experience. I still definitely recommend this book to fans of the genre along with readers who enjoy science fiction, dystopia, action, and adventure novels.
Disclosure: I received a copy of the book in exchange for an honest review.
May 18, 2015
Other than the ending, which I'm still having a bit of trouble accepting, I loved this book. It won't be for everyone, though! It has a science fiction(ish) kind of feel to it. Despite being completely different and unique from other stories out there, I couldn't help but think of the realm of Indiana Jones as I read it, with the myths, temples, rituals, and all. Peter Pan's "lost boys" went through my mind quite a bit, too. It's kind of a dark story, with action, fighting, and violence. There was only one disturbing scene, for me. (Of course, I'm a wimp!)
Another thing that I loved about this book, but I believe will be a turnoff for most, is the lack of romance. There is none, other than a bit of innocent girl/boy fascination. (The main characters have been separated from the opposite gender their whole lives.) I am becoming increasingly annoyed at corny romances, so, thank you, McIsaac, for creating such an awesome story, and leaving the corny romance behind AND for creating a clean story that I can freely recommend to friends and family.
The ending. When I first ended the book, I told my husband that while I should be used to it by now, I hate ending a book, only to realize that it's actually part of a series, and I'll have to wait another year for the next installment. After searching around, and thinking on the ending more, I realized that this may very well be a standalone. After discovering that this book *seems* to be a rewrite/republish for a self-published book titled "Urgle", I assume even more so that this is a standalone. If this is a standalone, I can see some beauty in it, even if I hope for another book. Everything isn't tied up in a nice, neat bow, so you're free to end things as you want to on certain things. There was one particular part that I especially didn't like, and I'd like to rewrite it. Still, I'd like the loose strings tied up a bit more for me, so I'm holding out hope for another book. (I've still been unable to find out for sure if this is a standalone, and not knowing is driving me insane, so if you know, please let me know.) :)
Overall, this is a treasure in the world of YA/middle grade books, and I will be grabbing anything else penned by McIsaac! It's a perfect read for both boys and girls that enjoy the science fiction realm. I'm an adult woman, and I loved it, too!
Content:
Very mild profanity. (I can actually only recall one word, and it happens to be the first word in the book.)
No sex(or even romance, for that matter)
Mild violence(one disturbing scene involving wasps or flying insects of some sort was disturbing, though it's probably mild for most)
*I was provided a review copy, in exchange for my honest opinion.
Another thing that I loved about this book, but I believe will be a turnoff for most, is the lack of romance. There is none, other than a bit of innocent girl/boy fascination. (The main characters have been separated from the opposite gender their whole lives.) I am becoming increasingly annoyed at corny romances, so, thank you, McIsaac, for creating such an awesome story, and leaving the corny romance behind AND for creating a clean story that I can freely recommend to friends and family.
The ending. When I first ended the book, I told my husband that while I should be used to it by now, I hate ending a book, only to realize that it's actually part of a series, and I'll have to wait another year for the next installment. After searching around, and thinking on the ending more, I realized that this may very well be a standalone. After discovering that this book *seems* to be a rewrite/republish for a self-published book titled "Urgle", I assume even more so that this is a standalone. If this is a standalone, I can see some beauty in it, even if I hope for another book. Everything isn't tied up in a nice, neat bow, so you're free to end things as you want to on certain things. There was one particular part that I especially didn't like, and I'd like to rewrite it. Still, I'd like the loose strings tied up a bit more for me, so I'm holding out hope for another book. (I've still been unable to find out for sure if this is a standalone, and not knowing is driving me insane, so if you know, please let me know.) :)
Overall, this is a treasure in the world of YA/middle grade books, and I will be grabbing anything else penned by McIsaac! It's a perfect read for both boys and girls that enjoy the science fiction realm. I'm an adult woman, and I loved it, too!
Content:
Very mild profanity. (I can actually only recall one word, and it happens to be the first word in the book.)
No sex(or even romance, for that matter)
Mild violence(one disturbing scene involving wasps or flying insects of some sort was disturbing, though it's probably mild for most)
*I was provided a review copy, in exchange for my honest opinion.
May 30, 2015
This book was amazing. At first I thought it was going to be another one of those boring crazy fantasy novels that make no sense, but this one wasn't. McIssac made the fantasy like setting seem regular and new, it also helped that the characters were also experiencing the new setting at the same time. After a short part in the beginning, showing the average life in their home, the Pit, the main theme starts to come in. Piece by piece, you learn more and more history of their mystical world outside of the Pit.
The main character, Urgle(just ignore the weird names) is named as useless in the Pit, unable to hunt, track, heal, fight, and also is lacking in the physical abilities. Yet, he is an older brother(once your older brother who teaches you has done their job, they leave and you get a little brother). His little brother, Cubby has never left his side and once an older brother returns to the Pit(which never happens), bad things begin to happen.
Cubby is captured by the evil "Beginners" who were following the returnee and Urgle will let nothing stop him from getting Cubby back, not even leaving the Pit. The unwelcome returned older brother, Blaze is the only option for Urgle to find the evil temple where the Beginners live and take Cubby back. Av, Urgle's best friend and suprisingly his evil nemesis, Fiver volunteer to help on the journey. The outside world is also very, lets use the word, different. Not to mention there are no girls in the Pit, in fact they are loathed for becoming Mothers and abandoning their sons time and time again at the pit.
For those who like books with more romance, I have to admit there isn't really much romance in this book, more like embarrassing stares from across the room and awkward holding hands. But, if there is anything that I am confident about is that if there is going to be a second book, that there will be at least a little more romance in the next book.
Over all, great book.
Read it.
The main character, Urgle(just ignore the weird names) is named as useless in the Pit, unable to hunt, track, heal, fight, and also is lacking in the physical abilities. Yet, he is an older brother(once your older brother who teaches you has done their job, they leave and you get a little brother). His little brother, Cubby has never left his side and once an older brother returns to the Pit(which never happens), bad things begin to happen.
Cubby is captured by the evil "Beginners" who were following the returnee and Urgle will let nothing stop him from getting Cubby back, not even leaving the Pit. The unwelcome returned older brother, Blaze is the only option for Urgle to find the evil temple where the Beginners live and take Cubby back. Av, Urgle's best friend and suprisingly his evil nemesis, Fiver volunteer to help on the journey. The outside world is also very, lets use the word, different. Not to mention there are no girls in the Pit, in fact they are loathed for becoming Mothers and abandoning their sons time and time again at the pit.
For those who like books with more romance, I have to admit there isn't really much romance in this book, more like embarrassing stares from across the room and awkward holding hands. But, if there is anything that I am confident about is that if there is going to be a second book, that there will be at least a little more romance in the next book.
Over all, great book.
Read it.
April 16, 2020
A disappointing read! Yes, the book has potential -- it has an interesting plot and some loveable characters but the ending is just BAD! Killing Cubby just like that?!? I felt betrayed towards the end of the book and my time investing to the characters was just wasted. I was waiting for Urgle to redeem himself somewhere in the story but it did not give him a chance to stop being an underdog and become a hero. In the end, the day was saved by his friends and some luck.
Going back to Cubby. Killing an adorable character just like that is just unfair. I put extra effort in reading the book because I was bored during the first part but I still continued reading it because I want the adorable Cubby to be saved. As the story progressed I got really excited until it left me underwhelmed again by reading the ending.
If ever this will have a sequel, hopefully the story will go like this: Urgle was the lost son of Blaze, it turns out that he has power over water (giving us the reason why he was so weak in the pit because he was surrounded by elements of fire), and Urgle finally saves the day solely because of him. Most importantly, Cubby has somehow survived and gets reunited with his big brother!
P.S If the author is reading this, I'm sorry for the bad review but I was just passionate about the story and I felt that it should've not ended that way.
Going back to Cubby. Killing an adorable character just like that is just unfair. I put extra effort in reading the book because I was bored during the first part but I still continued reading it because I want the adorable Cubby to be saved. As the story progressed I got really excited until it left me underwhelmed again by reading the ending.
If ever this will have a sequel, hopefully the story will go like this: Urgle was the lost son of Blaze, it turns out that he has power over water (giving us the reason why he was so weak in the pit because he was surrounded by elements of fire), and Urgle finally saves the day solely because of him. Most importantly, Cubby has somehow survived and gets reunited with his big brother!
P.S If the author is reading this, I'm sorry for the bad review but I was just passionate about the story and I felt that it should've not ended that way.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 5, 2017
Why on earth would the author make Cubby die in such a random way?!?!?!? What even?????? They spend the whole book to go save him, then you just kill him in like two sentences at the end. And by falling down a waterfall. What? Also, the women in the book were supposed to be like trained since they were little, so why was Lussit so useless. Ha Ha useless. Anyway, she should have been able to a) keep up when they were running, b) kicked some serious butt, and c) been able to swim against the current on her own. I did like the book though. The world that it was set up in was very interesting and how the different groups of people all related in their history was cool.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 18, 2017
This is just not well-written enough to use for book clubs.
There are a couple of major flaws that drove me crazy. One was that the viewpoint character really, really, really didn't understand what was happening. This made the whole book hard to follow. Some characters kept important secrets for no good reason, which is always annoying. A good infodump by Blaze on about page 50 would've made the whole book more tolerable. Instead, he dribbles out information, helps the main character for reasons that never make sense, and is a superwarrior except for when the plot needs him not to be.
There are a couple of major flaws that drove me crazy. One was that the viewpoint character really, really, really didn't understand what was happening. This made the whole book hard to follow. Some characters kept important secrets for no good reason, which is always annoying. A good infodump by Blaze on about page 50 would've made the whole book more tolerable. Instead, he dribbles out information, helps the main character for reasons that never make sense, and is a superwarrior except for when the plot needs him not to be.
September 11, 2016
And so is The Boys of Fire and Ash. Ever heard of a little series called The Maze Runner? Read that. It's much better.
May 3, 2019
I'm not buying books from the dollar tree anymore.
December 10, 2017
he book we are here to talk about today is Urgle by Meaghan McIsaac.
This book was published in 2013, it’s 340 pages long,
This is the first book of Meaghan’s that I have read.
This book has fantasy, dystopia, adventure and is young adult.
This book is about a boy called Urgle. he's not good at much.
Not the best at being a big brother to a 6 year old called Cubby.
Urgle is not a good hunter. he has no family to fall back on.
Urgle and Cubby live among the Brothers of the Ikkuma Pit.
Who have been abandoned as babies by their mothers to fend for themselves in the Pit. Which is a volcano.
As a baby they get assigned to older boys to be raised as little brothers.
They must teach their Little Brothers how to survive.
They spend their lives struggling to survive in an all-boys village.
To make room for the next baby who takes there place. The boys don't know what lies outside the Pit, because no one has ever went out and returned to talk about it. Until now.
Strange things begin to happen when Av, Urgle, and Cubby
witness a man fall down into the Pit after being attacked by creepy looking creatures that definitely aren't human. We later find out that the man is a brother, called blaze who has come back to Ikkuma, the group wants to know what he has seen since he left,
and what he knows about why they have all been abandoned.
So they throw blaze a welcome back celebration, with story telling and a huge feat.
Urgle, however, is immediately suspicious of him and doesn't get what the fuss is about.
He then hears screams and then finds that Cubby is missing.
We find out that Cubby is captured by goblins.
With his best friend Av. Digger the 2nd eldest now that blaze is there.
Fiver who is the one who nicknamed Urgle, useless.
chase after them into the unknown to get the brother back.
and then the boys start to realize that they are going to have to learn first-hand what the outside world is like. It's a whole new world, new languages, names
Are they prepared to learn the true story behind their exile? Will Urgle find Cubby?
I give this book 4.7/5
This book reminded me of the maze runner, Knife of Never Letting Go and lost boys but much more slower.This book just did not get into a lot of depth, I would of liked it even more if things were explained more and at a faster paste.
When first starting the book, I was a little confused about the world-specific language.
Even when they got outside of the Pit, I still got a little overwhelmed by all the new things but after awhile I got use to it. the character of Urgle and his friends, and the other Brothers are quite well-drawn and developed. There world felt real if I could imagine this world really existing.
All of the boys were good. I like Blaze, Urgle, av, fiver and even Urgle's little brother, Cubby.
Cubby is so adorable he reminded me of a smaller version of chuck from the maze runner
Although, I have to admit that my favourite was Urgle.
he thinks that he is completely useless, but he has such determination
and a great depth of feeling that I personally value very highly.
He really is the hero of the whole story.
I immediately started to feel for him.
He and every other Brother in the Pit, it seems feels he is nothing but useless
because he has no real abilities. He is good at making daggers, though,
I found Urgle to be a realistic character.
I liked the fact that he wasn't particularly good at hunting or tracking or anything else valued highly in the Pit
it made him more relateable. He has a bit of a quick temper,
with a tendency not to think things through, but again, that just makes him seem all the more believable. The world outside the Ikkuma Pit is really different. Watching Urgle and his brothers walk into this new world was really interesting.
This story is told by Urgle, Having the story told from his point of view I think was an good idea because As the reader, we get to discover all these new things that Urgle does.
I think there should be a sequel! Am not sure if there will be.
I would like this book into a Movie and I would definitely watch it.
This book was published in 2013, it’s 340 pages long,
This is the first book of Meaghan’s that I have read.
This book has fantasy, dystopia, adventure and is young adult.
This book is about a boy called Urgle. he's not good at much.
Not the best at being a big brother to a 6 year old called Cubby.
Urgle is not a good hunter. he has no family to fall back on.
Urgle and Cubby live among the Brothers of the Ikkuma Pit.
Who have been abandoned as babies by their mothers to fend for themselves in the Pit. Which is a volcano.
As a baby they get assigned to older boys to be raised as little brothers.
They must teach their Little Brothers how to survive.
They spend their lives struggling to survive in an all-boys village.
To make room for the next baby who takes there place. The boys don't know what lies outside the Pit, because no one has ever went out and returned to talk about it. Until now.
Strange things begin to happen when Av, Urgle, and Cubby
witness a man fall down into the Pit after being attacked by creepy looking creatures that definitely aren't human. We later find out that the man is a brother, called blaze who has come back to Ikkuma, the group wants to know what he has seen since he left,
and what he knows about why they have all been abandoned.
So they throw blaze a welcome back celebration, with story telling and a huge feat.
Urgle, however, is immediately suspicious of him and doesn't get what the fuss is about.
He then hears screams and then finds that Cubby is missing.
We find out that Cubby is captured by goblins.
With his best friend Av. Digger the 2nd eldest now that blaze is there.
Fiver who is the one who nicknamed Urgle, useless.
chase after them into the unknown to get the brother back.
and then the boys start to realize that they are going to have to learn first-hand what the outside world is like. It's a whole new world, new languages, names
Are they prepared to learn the true story behind their exile? Will Urgle find Cubby?
I give this book 4.7/5
This book reminded me of the maze runner, Knife of Never Letting Go and lost boys but much more slower.This book just did not get into a lot of depth, I would of liked it even more if things were explained more and at a faster paste.
When first starting the book, I was a little confused about the world-specific language.
Even when they got outside of the Pit, I still got a little overwhelmed by all the new things but after awhile I got use to it. the character of Urgle and his friends, and the other Brothers are quite well-drawn and developed. There world felt real if I could imagine this world really existing.
All of the boys were good. I like Blaze, Urgle, av, fiver and even Urgle's little brother, Cubby.
Cubby is so adorable he reminded me of a smaller version of chuck from the maze runner
Although, I have to admit that my favourite was Urgle.
he thinks that he is completely useless, but he has such determination
and a great depth of feeling that I personally value very highly.
He really is the hero of the whole story.
I immediately started to feel for him.
He and every other Brother in the Pit, it seems feels he is nothing but useless
because he has no real abilities. He is good at making daggers, though,
I found Urgle to be a realistic character.
I liked the fact that he wasn't particularly good at hunting or tracking or anything else valued highly in the Pit
it made him more relateable. He has a bit of a quick temper,
with a tendency not to think things through, but again, that just makes him seem all the more believable. The world outside the Ikkuma Pit is really different. Watching Urgle and his brothers walk into this new world was really interesting.
This story is told by Urgle, Having the story told from his point of view I think was an good idea because As the reader, we get to discover all these new things that Urgle does.
I think there should be a sequel! Am not sure if there will be.
I would like this book into a Movie and I would definitely watch it.
September 2, 2024
This was not at all what I expected this book to be! A Dystopian novel compared to The Maze Runner that published in the era of The Hunger Games and Divergent, I anticipated it to follow the same formula. It does NOT. It was something completely different and unique. I even read another review call this book a rip-off of The Maze Runner, and I could not disagree more! Aside from some similar vibes in the Ikkuma Pit and the Glade, the rest of the stories were completely different!
The adventure that Urgle and company went on was a beautiful Hero’s Journey, including so much action and edge-of-your-seat excitement. There were multiple times where I wondered how the boys would get out of the tough spot they were in, and the story did a great job drawing me in.
My one complaint is regarding character development. To start, I wish the exposition had been a tiny bit longer. Don’t get me wrong, I love when novels throw the reader into the action. In this case, though, the characters kept acting “unusually” according to the main character (like Az’s treatment toward Blaze), but I didn’t know this was unusual because I hadn’t gone to see the way Az normally acts. Fiver was supposed to be a sort of bully character to Urgle, but honestly most of the time I liked him better than Az, and I feel like that’s because the author didn’t show the way the boys interacted with each other before Blaze entered the story and changed Urgle’s normal sequence of events.
Also on the note of character development—I see so many people mention feeling like they need a sequel, or feel like this should have a sequel to it. I think the reason it feels that way is because Urgle’s character arc feels incomplete. He spends so much time feeling useless, and that’s such an internal battle. Then, in the end, it feels like Urgle sort of did fail in his mission, and he never grows his self-confidence or decision making skills. It was getting close, but just when it felt like he was making progress, things fell apart in the end. I wouldn’t even care if the central conflict wasn’t fully resolved (I could see there being a really great cliff hanger for this novel), but I do feel like I need a sequel because Urgle is still growing as a person and character.
Overall, I loved the tone and vibes of the story, though personally felt the characters were not fully realized by the end.
The adventure that Urgle and company went on was a beautiful Hero’s Journey, including so much action and edge-of-your-seat excitement. There were multiple times where I wondered how the boys would get out of the tough spot they were in, and the story did a great job drawing me in.
My one complaint is regarding character development. To start, I wish the exposition had been a tiny bit longer. Don’t get me wrong, I love when novels throw the reader into the action. In this case, though, the characters kept acting “unusually” according to the main character (like Az’s treatment toward Blaze), but I didn’t know this was unusual because I hadn’t gone to see the way Az normally acts. Fiver was supposed to be a sort of bully character to Urgle, but honestly most of the time I liked him better than Az, and I feel like that’s because the author didn’t show the way the boys interacted with each other before Blaze entered the story and changed Urgle’s normal sequence of events.
Also on the note of character development—I see so many people mention feeling like they need a sequel, or feel like this should have a sequel to it. I think the reason it feels that way is because Urgle’s character arc feels incomplete. He spends so much time feeling useless, and that’s such an internal battle. Then, in the end, it feels like Urgle sort of did fail in his mission, and he never grows his self-confidence or decision making skills. It was getting close, but just when it felt like he was making progress, things fell apart in the end. I wouldn’t even care if the central conflict wasn’t fully resolved (I could see there being a really great cliff hanger for this novel), but I do feel like I need a sequel because Urgle is still growing as a person and character.
Overall, I loved the tone and vibes of the story, though personally felt the characters were not fully realized by the end.
November 3, 2017
The Boys of Fire and Ash is a YA fantasy novel that takes place in a dystopian society. The story is told through the eyes of Urgle, a teenage boy who lives in a volcano or pit with several other teen and preteen boys who were abandoned by their mothers at birth. Urgle introduces the audience to the Ikumma Boys' way of life as we discover that they have built their own self sufficient society in the pit where everyone has a job and takes care of a younger "brother". The boys have developed a deep rooted hatred for the mothers who have seemingly abandoned them. The audience is introduced to this hate through negative terms the boys call each other when angry or in jest such as "motherseeker". All of their ideas and beliefs are tested when they have to venture out into the outside world to save one of their brothers from an evil entity.
The Boys of Fire and Ash is a fantasy novel that would be best suited for grades 5 and up. There are some themes that are not appropriate for younger grades such as descriptions of relatively graphic violence. In my opinion, I could see this text being used to engage students who may not be as passionate about reading. This text is action packed and although it takes place in a fantasy world I could still see some elements of the book being relatable to teens and preteens. I would offer this book as a choice for student book clubs or read a portion of the text to students each day. This text could facilitate deeper thinking about elements such as a what it would be like to live in a dystopian society. There are also many characters in the book with a lot of subsistence and backstories that students could use to discuss character elements/traits and relate to themselves.
This book is a WOW book for me because it was not only very enjoyable but it challenged me to think. While reading the book I really felt as though I was Urgle and I was following him on his journey to find his little brother. I found myself thinking about the decisions I would make if I was in his situation. This is the kind of book that will make you buy the whole series.
The Boys of Fire and Ash is a fantasy novel that would be best suited for grades 5 and up. There are some themes that are not appropriate for younger grades such as descriptions of relatively graphic violence. In my opinion, I could see this text being used to engage students who may not be as passionate about reading. This text is action packed and although it takes place in a fantasy world I could still see some elements of the book being relatable to teens and preteens. I would offer this book as a choice for student book clubs or read a portion of the text to students each day. This text could facilitate deeper thinking about elements such as a what it would be like to live in a dystopian society. There are also many characters in the book with a lot of subsistence and backstories that students could use to discuss character elements/traits and relate to themselves.
This book is a WOW book for me because it was not only very enjoyable but it challenged me to think. While reading the book I really felt as though I was Urgle and I was following him on his journey to find his little brother. I found myself thinking about the decisions I would make if I was in his situation. This is the kind of book that will make you buy the whole series.
August 7, 2020
This Review is not telling you the plot, if that’s what you want that read the blurb
I’ve never felt so many feelings at one time after
reading a book. There is a lot wrong with this book but there is also a lot right with it.
The world is imaginative and confusing which is enjoyable most of the time.
The plot is in know way boring but it is not very well thought out.
The characters: Urgle, the eponymous character is a very frustrating lead to say the least. At times he does things to make me like him a bit but also a lot of the time he’s just downright annoying and never learns from his mistakes. But the other main characters are what keeps up the book for me. Fiver(my favorite) starts the book being a bully to Urgle but over the course of the book he grows so much on you, he’s a love able feisty dude who seems the only one who always keeps his eyes on the goal and keeps everyone else on track when they have other intentions. Then there’s Av who’s very sweet and kind. Urgles younger brother Cubby is probably already smarter than him even though he’s 8 years younger, he’s funny and sweet. Then there’s blaze the older brother who is the first ever to come back to the ikkuma pit. He’s mysterious and leaves you feeling unsure of what to think about him.
The ending to this book just makes me feel weird in side, I honestly can’t decide if it was right or not.
This book in three words: weird, confusing, unique.
I’ve seen this book lying on the shelf at my favorite secondhand book store for years and judging by the cover I thought it was going to be horror. I couldn’t of been more wrong I decided to just buy it because I’d seen it for probably 5 years. This book is best read knowing nothing. It’s definitely not a popular book because there’s not a single video on YouTube about it. If anyone is for some reason reading this and cares what I say, just read it. It’s probably only for a select group of people but it’s definitely not a bad book it’s actually quite good.
80%
P.S
(Fiver is a gaycon and no one can tell me either wise, it’s practically cannon at this point)
I’ve never felt so many feelings at one time after
reading a book. There is a lot wrong with this book but there is also a lot right with it.
The world is imaginative and confusing which is enjoyable most of the time.
The plot is in know way boring but it is not very well thought out.
The characters: Urgle, the eponymous character is a very frustrating lead to say the least. At times he does things to make me like him a bit but also a lot of the time he’s just downright annoying and never learns from his mistakes. But the other main characters are what keeps up the book for me. Fiver(my favorite) starts the book being a bully to Urgle but over the course of the book he grows so much on you, he’s a love able feisty dude who seems the only one who always keeps his eyes on the goal and keeps everyone else on track when they have other intentions. Then there’s Av who’s very sweet and kind. Urgles younger brother Cubby is probably already smarter than him even though he’s 8 years younger, he’s funny and sweet. Then there’s blaze the older brother who is the first ever to come back to the ikkuma pit. He’s mysterious and leaves you feeling unsure of what to think about him.
The ending to this book just makes me feel weird in side, I honestly can’t decide if it was right or not.
This book in three words: weird, confusing, unique.
I’ve seen this book lying on the shelf at my favorite secondhand book store for years and judging by the cover I thought it was going to be horror. I couldn’t of been more wrong I decided to just buy it because I’d seen it for probably 5 years. This book is best read knowing nothing. It’s definitely not a popular book because there’s not a single video on YouTube about it. If anyone is for some reason reading this and cares what I say, just read it. It’s probably only for a select group of people but it’s definitely not a bad book it’s actually quite good.
80%
P.S
(Fiver is a gaycon and no one can tell me either wise, it’s practically cannon at this point)
December 14, 2018
"The Boys of Fire and Ash" is an interesting book about people left in a pit by their mothers at their birth. One of their brothers, Cubby, gets taken by goblins. This book is about their journey to go rescue Cubby, and keep him safe. I would rate this book a 4/5 because it had a very interesting plot, and the plot twist really added to the story. It completely changed the story and the plot added suspense throughout the book. The only thing that I did not like was that there was a lot of unnecessary information. I felt like there was so much not needed information about their society, and those sections in the book became very boring for me.
July 18, 2020
4.5 Stars... I was not expecting to finish this so quickly.
I have avoided reading this book for a long time because I thought it was going to be blah..., BUT I was so wrong!!! This was a very pleasant surprise. I enjoyed it so much and I really liked all the main characters and the whole plot of the story. It was adventurous, fun, and just what I needed to help with a potential reading slump. The only reason I did not give it a 5 was because of the ending. I was disappointed that the ending did not tie up all the loose ends. It kind of just ended abruptly out of no where. We never really get to know what happens to the boys, Blaze, the Resistance, the mothers, or the Beginners (Did Urgle end up with Lussit, did Av end up with Farka or did Fiver... I want to know!) I don't really like series anymore, but I think this one should have a part two because I feel a bit cheated. I was rooting for these guys and wanted to see them win the war and reunited with the Mothers, but now I guess I will never know (WHY, how could you McIsaac???????!!!!).
Anyway, other than the ending, it really was a great book and I didn't find myself bored once. There is a lot jam packed in the 327 page book. I just wished it had at least been 100 pages longer just to tie everything up (Yes I am still not over that). I would recommend this one, but just know that the ending is not complete and there is no part 2---so it will all be left up to your imagination.
Content: no sex or anything like that. There is a lot of fighting and casualties.
Language: Very mild not much at all.
I have avoided reading this book for a long time because I thought it was going to be blah..., BUT I was so wrong!!! This was a very pleasant surprise. I enjoyed it so much and I really liked all the main characters and the whole plot of the story. It was adventurous, fun, and just what I needed to help with a potential reading slump. The only reason I did not give it a 5 was because of the ending. I was disappointed that the ending did not tie up all the loose ends. It kind of just ended abruptly out of no where. We never really get to know what happens to the boys, Blaze, the Resistance, the mothers, or the Beginners (Did Urgle end up with Lussit, did Av end up with Farka or did Fiver... I want to know!) I don't really like series anymore, but I think this one should have a part two because I feel a bit cheated. I was rooting for these guys and wanted to see them win the war and reunited with the Mothers, but now I guess I will never know (WHY, how could you McIsaac???????!!!!).
Anyway, other than the ending, it really was a great book and I didn't find myself bored once. There is a lot jam packed in the 327 page book. I just wished it had at least been 100 pages longer just to tie everything up (Yes I am still not over that). I would recommend this one, but just know that the ending is not complete and there is no part 2---so it will all be left up to your imagination.
Content: no sex or anything like that. There is a lot of fighting and casualties.
Language: Very mild not much at all.
June 16, 2017
Finished in one day. I couldn't out it down. The boys are abandoned by their mothers, as babies. An older, big brother cares for a younger one until he moved on to make room for a new baby. I loved the concept! The ending fell a little flat, it could have easily been fixed with a follow up book. Nevertheless, it was an enjoyable read.
July 11, 2019
A fun summer read!!! I would gladly gift this to any family with a middle school fantasy lover. The story moves quickly, has a rich landscape that is easy to get lost in and explores religion, family, love and loyalty. Characters stay with me and I'm deaperate for a second volume and hope she releases one soon!
September 6, 2017
I felt the death at the end was unnecessary. I didn't understand the purpose of killing Cubby. Perhaps he will reappear in a later book. This can't be the only book. There's too much unanswered. Beside that, this was a very good, fast-paced read.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
February 6, 2018
The main protagonist, Urgle, never grew out of being "useless" as all of the other boys referred to him. His character didn't seem to mature or gain knowledge to help him complete his quest which seemed to leave me feeling empty at the end. The world-building was decent, but I never felt a connection to Urgle, nor did I care about his need to find Cubby. The story seemed contrived and forced.
March 29, 2018
Loved this book! It's a little long, but is a super creative plot. there is a fair amount of alcohol though its never called by that name. The first word is "damn" and there are other minor swears, I would say this is more fantasy than sci-fi
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
June 22, 2019
It was a good book. It didn't catch my interest as much as I thought it would, therefore towards the end of the book I found myself struggling to read it. But overall a good storyline and would be a great book for younger people to read.
April 7, 2020
I mean, I liked the idea of the book, but I don’t think it was really thought out all the way. I was very confused most of the time, but I did like this world I was put into. I don’t think I would read it again though. I actually found this at the Dollar Tree. Go figure, right?
3/5
3/5
March 15, 2024
I liked the bool hated the ending. The boom literally cut off a whole freaking war going on do they even win i wouldn't know. No ine will ever know 😭😭. I'm so freaking upset and satisfied. Loved the writing and the story was very interesting. Though i wouldn't like it but surprisingly I loved it
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 12, 2025
I will give this book 3.5 ⭐. I would have rated it higher but I really disliked the way this book ended. I love the story and some of the Characters but the one main character really got on my nerves sometimes. I want more!!!
August 14, 2017
There was never a dull moment. I thought this book was beautifully written. The characters were well developed and you couldn't help but fall in love with the main character and his little brother.
October 26, 2017
I thought this was a very good adventure book. It kept me interested the whole time. The only thing I did not like about this book was the ending.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 84 reviews