I read the first novel and wasn't all that impressed. So why, you may ask, did I bother sticking around for the 2nd book? Well, third in the series, however, I refuse to read the non-canon books.
Well, you see, when you love something very much, you want to engage in as much of it as possible - be it six butchered Hollywood movies following a special snowflake(tm) character that was created for just that purpose or a series of poorly written books that somehow managed to become an entire series despite not being very, what's the word, good. Both of which throw canon to the wind.
That being said, I will admit that Perry did more research on City of The Dead compared to, say, The Umbrella Conspiracy (volume 1). This novel follows the A scenario of Leon and B scenario of Claire pretty well all things considered. The author did take some liberties here and there, which to me proved poor, I will get to that in a bit but that is ultimately the reason why I'm keeping my rating on the lower side of the spectrum.
As any Resident Evil fan will tell you, the 2nd game in the series starts out with Leon Kennedy driving to Raccoon City for, what he believes, to be his first day at work. Technically, game-Leon already knows something hinky is going on and was specifically told to stay away whereas book-Leon just thinks he's running late 'cause he stopped for a burger.
But that's not where the book starts, it starts out with Jill about to leave the city with Chris. Which begs the question, how in the world is the next novel, revolving around Resident Evil 3, supposed to take place then? Seeing as Jill has supposedly already left the city WITH Chris.
Trent, our enigmatic non-canon whatever-he-is, is still around and is as enigmatic as ever. I'll call it right away; we are never gonna learn what his deal is. Maybe in the non-canon books (the ones not following any game), however, I will specifically avoid those.
Police Chief Irons is here and, despite all his vile habits and murderous tendencies, Perry portrays him so strangely humane as if we're meant to feel sorry for him, which is the last thing you should. I enjoy the different point of views throughout the novel, especially Annette's since I feel like her part of the story, her grief, becomes more understandable. Irons, on the other hand, was a point of view I could've gone without. He is no Wesker, he has no motivation or import. He is just gross.
After reading the first novel, I was actually not holding any hopes up for most characters to actually make an appearance namely Sherry, Ada, the Birkins, and even Mr. X.
I am pleased to announce all of the above are included. I do not, however, appreciate them all equally. Sherry has more of an attitude than what seems realistic for a child in her situation (like how she points out boys her age are so immature so obviously she doesn't have a boyfriend ...she's 12!), originally Sherry was quite resourceful despite being a child, like the scenario when she runs away from Claire to help her father. In Sherry's story arc, she does very little on her own unless told specifically by Claire. I do like how Claire doesn't talk down to her as much as in the game though, even Sherry herself points this out.
Mr. X is actually decently looming and terrifying, at first I felt like Claire's encounters with him were lazy and very quickly dealt with, however, by the end they were becoming more of a threat and actually nervewrecking, which was a nice surprise. I cannot say the same for William Birkin, I remember very little from his encounters and even less about the actual threat he, too, poses. Aside from that, I will say that Claire's story arc was by far the most interesting and more enjoyable of the characters. She and Sherry has that sisterly dynamic that makes up their relationship, and I was pleased to recognize it here.
Ada, I think, is my biggest problem in this novel. She is a hardcore spy whose feelings hardly ever get in the way of her getting the job done. In the game, she hides her true identity by posing as a civilian looking for her boyfriend. Which is why I'm rather disappointed with her character being portrayed as nothing more than a lovestruck girl who uses her charm in an almost pitiful damsel-like manner to trick Annette or even to flirt with Leon.
Most of her character arc is her feeling bad about lying to Leon and what he may think of her when he discovers her motives and who she works for. Whether she has feelings for him in the games, I'm not about to go into details about except she does soften up to Leon as well as his helpfulness and company. But this is too sugary to fit into a Resident Evil plot, in my own honest opinion. Since Ada is such a self reliant character, it's sad to witness her being reduced to an emotional lady for the benefit of Leon's story. Like how she starts crying when she realizes she cannot shoot him? That's not the Ada Wong I know.
I will say, I am pleased that the author decided not to include puzzles in this novel, or not as heavily as in the first book, which was quite a hassle to read through. Unlike the first novel, the story actually progressed more smoothly all things considered.
And that's the that on that, I'll see you around for my review/complaint on Nemesis.