I quite enjoyed this one, although I felt it was lacking something to make it really good.
The hero and heroine are a great pair of characters, who grew up together, and were firm friends. They both have issues with their families.
Having said that, the plot was a bit convoluted at times, and although the heroine's insecurities about her appearance were obviously important to her, it was overplayed, I thought.
Things I liked about this one:
- The hero and heroine are very likeable. They both have the best of intentions, but rest on the laurels of their friendship instead of accepting what they have, even if it is a marriage of convenience.
- The misunderstandings between the hero and heroine actually work fairly well for me. They seem reasonable, since physical insecurities and overwhelming attraction are things which people do have misunderstandings about. Also, the hero's complete lack of understanding of the heroine's insecurities are totally credible. He genuinely doesn't get that she thinks she's not attractive - he thinks she is the most attractive woman. It doesn't enter his mind that she would feel that way, since what she sees as faults, he views as perfections.
- The action stuff is very exciting and well-written. Too often the old kidnap-rescue thing is a bit stale, but I enjoyed it here
- The "flashbacks" to their childhoods and early adulthood were fabulous. They were short, but really added to the plot and the characters
Things I didn't like so much:
- I didn't get that the heroine's father would keep such a significant secret from her, and if he had, she would have learned it on her marriage. Also, how did the hero's father know the secret, but not the heroine? It didn't really make much sense to me.
- I didn't understand the added complication of moving the plot to France. It seemed to add very little to the overall story, and almost came out of nowhere. If the heroine was half-French and spoke it at home, there was no indication of that until more than half-way through the book.
- The fat-girl-who-can't-believe-the-hero-loves-her theme is OK, but I just don't buy that you can hang a whole story on to it. It ended up being over-worked and tired by the end. I just struggle to believe that any woman can't tell the difference between overwhelming lust and disgust in the eyes of someone looking at her, and that she can't accept that physical attraction comes in all shapes and sizes. I'm not saying I don't understand her insecurities, but insecurities about your body can coexist with actually quite liking the way you are made.
- Equally, I didn't understand why the hero didn't actually try and convince the heroine that he thought she was the best thing since sliced bread. I got that he thought they would lose their friendship if they hit the sack, but that part just didn't work for me.
- A minor detail, but the kindle formatting was a little bit confusing in places. I think it was missing some hard returns in a few places to separate out the points of view.
Anyway, I did enjoy this read, although not as much as I had hoped. 3 stars.