Certainly the most definitive biography of Mary Shelley available, Seymour covers all of the bases with literary flair. I walk away thinking we perhaps will never truly know Mary Shelley, and the tragedy of her life is not that her husband died so early, but that Mary had to live through 30 years of savagery of her morality and reputation.
From the moment of her birth, literally, Mary was oppressed. She was never allowed to forget that her sainted and lauded mother died from puerperal infection after giving birth to her. She had a remote and sometimes stern father of surpassing literary genius in William Godwin. She spent a good deal of time away from home after her father remarried, unhappily for Mary. Her stepsister, "Clare", would be one of the banes of her life. She would always carry the shadow of her husband and their social reputation with her to her final days. And yet, she produced one of the most controversial novels of all time in Frankenstein and one could argue that her reputation surpasses her poet husband's in today's age.
By the time of her death, everyone had turned against her. All of the existing correspondence indicates she had a terrible reputation both professionally, socially, and even within her own family, other than her son and daughter-in-law. Seymour covers all of this in detail, and yet, I was still left with the question why? Why would Mary cling so closely to her son in her adulthood? Why would she be considered so cold and distant by all of her closest acquaintances?
She clung because she was always abandoned. Left with the guilt of her mother's death, she was never consoled on that fact and often felt like the stepsister rather than the true daughter after Godwin remarried so quickly. She was shipped out to relatives and made to fend for herself. No wonder she was seduced by Shelley. Once she made the fateful decision to run off with a married man (who surely adored her in those early days), her fate was sealed. She would never escape the calumny of "eloping" with a married man nor of his radical political views. She lost multiple children, enhancing her deficient sense of the dangers of childbirth, so when she lost Percy Shelley himself, she clung to the only thing that reminded her of a stable household, her only surviving child that bore her husband's name. It was all she had left.
Seymour also does a great job of quickly but thoroughly delineating all of the biographical evidence that was destroyed throughout the years, as well as how those clues were inferred or re-discovered. Yet, I am left with the impression that Mary has more in common with the creature in Frankenstein than I previously knew: desperate to be acknowledged as a valuable human being, outcast, judged and blamed for catastrophes, and still hard to fathom after all these years. That I thirst for more is a credit to Seymour.