Following the trail of scares from state to state with the American Chillers is fun, and in this book it's Wisconsin's turn to face a supernatural menace. Jeremy is an only child in suburban Madison, Wisconsin, but he has plenty of friends the same age living on his block. The story begins with them all playing hide-and-seek in the forest near their houses, Jeremy nestled in the perfect hiding spot to avoid detection by his friend Colette. He's bound to win this round...until, in the darkening evening, he spots a werewolf staring back at him, fangs dripping and a wild look in its eyes. Jeremy runs screaming to his group of friends—Colette, Brian Ludwig, Stuart Lester, James Barker—and describes the creature he saw. They're skeptical, but a trail of evidence the next morning leads them all to agree that a werewolf has taken up residence in the forest. Their parents won't believe such a claim, so what should Jeremy and his friends do about the problem?
Jeremy and Colette decide to research werewolves at the library, but they're disconcerted by the behavior of the new media specialist, who's filling in for Mrs. Owens, the regular librarian. He takes undue interest in Jeremy and Colette's study subject, hanging around and pretending not to watch them as they read. Is he connected with the werewolf in the forest? Jeremy and Colette ask Mrs. Owens about the man when she returns to work, but the usually gregarious librarian is tight-lipped where the new media specialist is concerned. She's not certain he should be trusted, and she advises caution. As Jeremy, Colette, and their friends launch a search in the forest where the werewolf was seen, Jeremy wonders what the consequences will be if they encounter the creature. Would their lives be at risk? It's time to discover who is turning into the werewolf and neutralize them, before this adventure morphs into a night of horror that will haunt Jeremy and his friends forever.
I like the vibe of Wisconsin Werewolves; it reminds me of Johnathan Rand's Adventure Club series, about a group of friends who get together to play games, have conversations, and go on adventures in and around their Midwestern hometown. The relationships add a touch of character and poignancy to the story. In most American Chillers you'll find at least one tongue-in-cheek reference to other books by the author, but I was surprised by the overt nature of the reference in Wisconsin Werewolves; on page one hundred thirty-eight, Colette states that what's happening "is like something out of my American Chillers books!" Touché, Mr. Rand. I rate Wisconsin Werewolves one and a half stars, but might have gone considerably higher if the logic were as consistent as the best American Chillers. Important narrative details don't line up as they should, a problem that could have been corrected with more work on the manuscript prior to publication. If you don't mind lack of cohesiveness, this might be the book for you, especially if you like the tone of the Adventure Club series. Even when marked by significant story flaws, American Chillers are enjoyable.