An incredibily evocative, intense, and impactful book that highlights the many faces of ‘racism’; the ugly kind, the misconceptions, and the hurt and anguish felt by those who suffer from it and those that are wrongly accused of it. A mine field for many authors but not Kia Abdullah who has this remarkable ability to write a story that can keep everyone on side as she focuses a much-needed lens on the many faces of the ‘war on prejudice’. A toxic story, but relevant, thought provoking and balanced, and although it is mostly concentrated on racism, it could apply to any form of bigotry or bias.
The Plot
The Dream House Move …. to the ideal suburban neighbourhood of Blenheim is a fresh start for Salma Khatun, her husband Bil, and their teenage son Zain. Although forced to move, their relocation is rewarded with a beautiful home, nice neighbours, and a great school, and when invited to the family barbecue next door the families, including the two sons realise, they have a lot in common.
Then things start to unravel when Salma witnesses her neighbour Tom knock over their ‘Black Lives Matter’ banner. To him it is justified for breaking the rules in displaying any banners in this ‘homogeneous’ neighbourhood, to Salma is was evidence of ‘racism’, and so begins…..
The Nightmare living beside ‘Those People Next Door’. As events spiral out of control so too do the accusations and repercussions for both families, which leads to someone losing their job, horrific life injuries and of course all played out on social media and ultimately in the court.
Review and Comments
A superb story with the trademark twists that kia Abdullah has become known for. I love love love the way she deals with sensitive issues, and subtly opens our eyes to how mis communication or lack of it can lead to so much harm and misunderstanding. Kia’s books are never preachy and so you will read this as a family drama / crime novel that is well written but balanced.
So many aspects of this book has been carefully considered, everything down to the title and use of the word ‘those’ to mean ‘different’ or even ‘antisocial’, but certainly not ‘us’.
Some of the key underlying messages from the story
- People who see themselves as different feel that way for a reason, and it can be as much about us as it is about the individual.
- Where there is a cause there is someone somewhere who will falsely claim to be a victim of it. There are even those who want to be offended. Most times I like to think ‘intolerance’ is a lack of understanding and you can see that in this story where all of the characters made mistakes, lacked objectivity and an ability to communicate effectively. So, none of them come out looking well. In fact, it makes them all unlikeable to some extent because they also lacked maturity, common sense and humility to admit when they got it wrong.
- However, where there is prejudice of any sort, it needs to be brought to the fore because our tolerance of it breeds it. Amidst the justifiable campaigns for race, sexual equality, disability etc.. sometimes you pick up prejudices in the most unlikely of places, which to me all comes down to the same thing – intolerance or at best a lack of understanding. I recall a young mother in the height of the Covid pandemic complain about having to isolate for fear of infecting the older generation. She went on to say “so what if they die – they have had their day and their lives and they are now ruining ours because we can’t go out in case we infect them”. This disgusting comment from a vile human being has stayed with me for obvious reasons, but it wasn't just the shameful comment, she felt ‘safe’ to make such an ageist comment on TV. Why was that???
Anyway, it is through books like this that we are reminded how things can spiral out of control if not managed and confronted. It also provides insight into the hurt racism can cause and feelings of isolation that is felt by victims of abuse, whilst at the same time showing us how easy it is to use a label like 'racism' for someone's actions when that's not the driver at all. All of comes down to tolerance and the need for effective communication.
I would highly recommend this book. A fabulous plot, a well written book with poignant messaging, and characters you might not like but you might have seen them!!!
Thought-provoking, gripping, reflective and extremely balanced in its messaging.