This is a trainwreck. I'm pretty sure I was hate reading for 90% of the book.
Hawkeswell, our so called hero, is a broke ass Earl who married a 19 year old heiress for her money. As soon as they married, she fled and no one knew if she was missing or dead. In the last book, Hawkeswell was a somewhat sympathetic character as he slightly worried at the fate of his bride and also struggled to hold his estates together without her fortune. Because she was missing and not declared dead, her fortune was withheld from him, but he was unable to marry another. While that seemed quite a pickle, I never fully warmed to him as we learned he had a volatile temper. I wondered if he had done something to make his bride run.
2 years later, Hawkeswell is with his friend Summerhays, the hero from the first book, as he retrieves his wife, Audrianna, our former heroine, from the home of the Rarest Blooms. This is a sort of home for wayward women, where they can flee and live happily with no questions asked about their pasts. Moments after arriving, Hawkeswell spots Lizzie, who in truth is his missing bride Verity. He gets pissed, she gets scared, but eventually they decide to go to Summerhays' home by the sea so they can sort it all out. She goes because she has a clever plan to get him to consent to an annulment. He has a counter plan that includes kissing her three times a day and staying married.
They get to the sea and Verity eventually makes him see the logic of her plan. She reveals that she was forced to marry him by her family in order to protect someone and ran when it turned out that protection was never given (Hawkeswell didn't know about any of that, but that's because ignorance is bliss for a fortune hunter). She explains that she will give Hawkeswell all the money he needs because she's now 21 and in charge of her own trust. She offers to pay him alimony and says they'll both get to live the lives they want. He's on the verge of agreeing when he gets her to give him a proper kiss. He pushes things along, gets her all hot and bothered and then declares he won't give her the annulment. Basically, her freedom matters less than the fact that he wants to have sex with her. His misogyny blazes through the story with multiple mentions of him owning her and doing whatever he wants to her because those are his rights.
Things do not get better from there. A broken Verity strains against the new prison she's found herself in and Hawkeswell pushes her into having sex so that she can't get an annulment. The sex scene comes VERY close to being a rape. Verity repeatedly tells the reader that she doesn't want what's happening to her to happen, but never actually says no to him once he starts touching her (he knows she doesn't want to have sex with him though). She feels pleasure from what he's doing so she's conflicted because she also hates him. Basically a naive 21 year old virgin is manipulated by a 31 year old man who knows exactly what he's doing and we have to read it. The heroine cries throughout this scene, but it is unclear if she is crying from pleasure, or if she's crying because he's raping her. I feel like it was a definite choice by the author to leave it murky. That sex scene was horrifying and definitely dubcon.
It's never a good thing when your hatred of the hero increases with each chapter, but mine certainly did for Hawkeswell. I was actively rooting for Verity to escape from him all the way to the very end. I was angry at her friends for enabling him and angry at him for being a terrible human. I was also furious when she finally began softening to him because it made no sense. As soon as she started to say nice things about him, I lost a lot of my interest in her.
The author's Herculean attempt at redeeming Hawkeswell does not pay off. He does all the right things for the last chunk of the book, but the damage was too extensive. There is also no romance in this pairing. This couple bonds over sex and that is all their relationship is built on. Sex is her only currency, which is probably true for the time period. If she needs something she performs a sexual act to get it. At one point, he thinks that he should tell her that he'd probably do what she asked even if she didn't do something sexual, but firmly decides its better for him if he doesn't let her know. Later he tells her he'll do something even without sex, but I didn't believe him (especially since they'd just been intimate). The author had him say it because she knew the game he was playing was messed up but it didn't ring true for the character she'd been writing for 300 pages.
Anyway, if it's not clear enough already, I disliked this couple. I hated the ending, and when I finished the book I literally imagined Hawkeswell dying young so that Verity could be free of him. Now, that would be a true HEA for the heroine.