So sweet and charming. I felt instantly at home in the village and felt fondly about the family even from the first chapter. I. Such a realistic but loving family, with all their little quirks and small arguments but overarching fondness for one another. Francis was so sweet and generous throughout--not the typical spoiled, snooty rich suitor but truly kindhearted and wanting his money to make others happy (admittedly, he did have some self-interest wanting to win Annaple over but his kindness toward her siblings and father was above and beyond). even with the wedding gifts Annaple's family, I think it truly did bring him joy to use his money to make others happy (he was observant, too, knowing what the boys would like!) The story was quiet, in a way, but also felt very immersive and I loved the focus just on the family and the gift-giving and the village life. It was a neat way to get to know the characters, through their reactions to the gifts and the ways in which they interacted with one another just over the short span of time from Christmas to Epiphany (the twelve days of Christmas). I also enjoyed learning about the different traditions for the Twelve Days of Christmas. I would have liked a bit more clarity in the author's note as she said some of the traditions were "just for this village" (I assume purely imaginary, invented by the author) and some were actually observed throughout England and also I did wonder about the exact time period, but perhaps the author kept that a bit fuzzy so she could incorporate more traditions from different eras? The illustrations by Shirley Hughes are also excellent. I'm so glad I finally splurged and bought a copy of this cozy Christmas gem -- true pleasure to read.