I've been reading British Library ghost story collections out loud to my husband, and this was another winner. I was glad to see so many humorous entries, more than there were in the other collections I've read.
Here's the rundown.
The Phantom Coach, by Amelia B. Edwards
3.5 stars
I liked the narrator and the snowy setting. The title pretty much gives away what's going to happen, but I was surprised his time with the scholarly hermit didn't have more significance. I guess he was just there to point him toward the road?
Jerry Bundler, by W. W. Jacobs
4 stars
The group of men in this story getting freaked out by ghost stories and pairing off so they didn't have to sleep alone was so endearing, but the ending was a bummer. This is what comes of horseplay, people.
Bone to His Bone, by E.G. Swain
4 stars (I had already read this in a different collection--below is my previous summary)
Swain patterned his main character Mr. Batchel, after himself and wrote a series of ghost stories featuring him, which I think is fun. This one was atmospheric but not scary, I think because Batchel was never afraid of the ghost in the story.
Oberon Road, by A. M. Burrage
5 stars
A fantastical tale full of sweetness and light. The ghosts weren't mean, and I liked the gentle, humorous tone.
The Last Laugh, by D. H. Lawrence
1 star
Lame. I've never read Lawrence before now, but this unpleasant, inscrutable story doesn't make me want to read any more.
Dr. Browning’s bus, by E. S. Knights
3.5 stars
Nice stormy setting with vivid description. Very similar to The Phantom Coach, except I didn't like how this one ended. I loved the scene when the doctor found his housekeeper in a room with 7 lamps and 9 candles because she was freaked out.
Whittington’s Cat, by Eleanor Smith
4 stars
So creepy, extra strange, and original. I did not know where it was going, but I was glad about how it ended.
The Earlier Service, by Margaret Irwin
3 stars
Not as scary as her terrifying story "The Book," which I read in a different collection. She did a nice job building the fear and tension, only to end the thing very abruptly.
Christmas Honeymoon, by Howard Spring
5 stars
Romantic and spooky, with fantastic description and a humorously opinionated narrator. Loved it!
The Cheery Soul, by Elizabeth Bowen
3 stars
Not a whole lot to it, and not as funny as the introduction made me think it would be. It was still kind of cute.
Between Sunset and Moonrise, by R. H. Malden
5 stars
Nice, traditional ghost(ish) story that drew me in right away with its first-person narration and vivid description.
The Mirror in Room 22, by James Hadley Chase
5 stars
Sometimes the really short ones don't feel finished or developed enough, but this little ditty was perfect, with a funny twist at the end.
At the Chalet Lartrec, by Winston Graham
4 stars
Not really a ghost story, but it had a swell twist. I guessed there would be something, but I didn't guess what it was.
Account Rendered, by W. F. Harvey
4 stars
I liked the writing style, and I was intrigued by the mysterious request to be anesthetized at the exact time every year, but I'm not sure I got the final explanation.
The Wild Wood, by Mildred
3 stars
Not a ghost story, but it was super creepy and disturbing. I wasn't a fan of the ending, but points for the twist.
The Waits, by L. P. Hartley
3.5 stars
Ominous Christmas carolers and melodramatic exclamations! The fact that no one brought a buddy when they went to the door (after the first person to go got freaked out) struck me as a little silly.
Deadman’s Corner, by George Denby
4 stars
Traditional ghost story with lots of dialogue in dialect. It was short and had a nice rhythm to it.
Don’t Tell Cissie, by Celia Fremlin
I loved the breezy, sassy tone of the narrator, Lois. Great twist at the end.