What do you think?
Rate this book
A Rip Through Time #2
The Poisoner's Ring
Edinburgh, 1869: Modern-day homicide detective Mallory Atkinson is adjusting to her new life in Victorian Scotland. Her employers know she’s not housemaid Catriona Mitchell―even though Mallory is in Catriona’s body―and Mallory is now officially an undertaker’s assistant. Dr. Duncan Gray moonlights as a medical examiner, and their latest case hits close to home. Men are dropping dead from a powerful poison, and all signs point to the grieving widows… the latest of which is Gray’s oldest sister.
Poison is said to be a woman’s weapon, though Mallory has to wonder if it’s as simple as that. But she must tread carefully. Every move the household makes is being watched, and who knows where the investigation will lead.
Poison is said to be a woman’s weapon, though Mallory has to wonder if it’s as simple as that. But she must tread carefully. Every move the household makes is being watched, and who knows where the investigation will lead.
341 pages, Hardcover
First published May 23, 2023
744 people are currently reading
7478 people want to read
About the author
Kelley Armstrong
303 books33.5k followersKelley Armstrong has been telling stories since before she could write. Her earliest written efforts were disastrous. If asked for a story about girls and dolls, hers would invariably feature undead girls and evil dolls, much to her teachers' dismay. All efforts to make her produce "normal" stories failed.
Today, she continues to spin tales of ghosts and demons and werewolves, while safely locked away in her basement writing dungeon. She's the author of the NYT-bestselling "Women of the Otherworld" paranormal suspense series and "Darkest Powers" young adult urban fantasy trilogy, as well as the Nadia Stafford crime series. Armstrong lives in southwestern Ontario with her husband, kids and far too many pets.
Today, she continues to spin tales of ghosts and demons and werewolves, while safely locked away in her basement writing dungeon. She's the author of the NYT-bestselling "Women of the Otherworld" paranormal suspense series and "Darkest Powers" young adult urban fantasy trilogy, as well as the Nadia Stafford crime series. Armstrong lives in southwestern Ontario with her husband, kids and far too many pets.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,140 reviews
May 5, 2023
In
The Poisoner's Ring
Kelley Armstrong combines a murder mystery and a time travel aspect in a historical setting in this second book in the Rip Through Time series. Since May 20, 2019, Vancouver homicide detective Mallory Atkinson was in Edinburgh, Scotland to be with her dying grandmother when she is attacked. It’s May 20, 1869 and housemaid Catriona Mitchell is discovered in a lane where she has been left for dead. It’s the exact spot where Mallory was attacked 150 years later. Mallory wakes up in Catriona’s body in 1869 and quickly has to adjust to being a housemaid to an undertaker in Victorian Scotland. The undertaker, Dr. Gray also assists Detective McCreadie in his police investigations.
Now that Dr. Gray and his sister Isla Ballantyne know what happened to Mallory, the situation is not as full of subterfuge within the house except around the maid and housekeeper. She is now officially an undertaker’s assistant. Men in Edinburgh are dying of poison, and the widows are thought responsible, the latest of which is Gray’s oldest sister Annis. Where will the investigation take them? Is Annis a murderer?
Mallory is a character with plenty of depth. She’s hardworking, kind, relatable, and makes for a strong female protagonist that readers can cheer on. However, she is also an independent thinker unafraid to speak her mind which isn’t normal for women in Victorian times. Gray is passionate about his work, enthusiastic, confident, occasionally relaxed and teasing. The supporting cast of characters are well-developed and provide insight into individuals in various roles in a Victorian household as well as those they interact with.
Kelley Armstrong has a fluid writing style that quickly brings readers into the well-paced story. They also get insight into the state of police forensics during this early era and a few insights into chemistry, diversity, and how servants are treated as well. Other themes include family, relationships, friendship, sanitary (and other) conditions, racism, gender identity, poverty, homesickness, and much more. There is a hint at a couple of potential romances, but nothing more. The world-building was wonderful and felt accurate for the times. The ending has plenty of action and wraps things up nicely.
Overall, this is well-written, engaging, and entertaining with complex characters in a historical setting. I am looking forward to reading the next book in the series. Understanding how Mallory gets to this time in history is explained in depth in book one so I recommend starting with it. However, if you accept the time travel situation, then this can be read as a standalone novel.
St. Martin’s Press – Minotaur Books and Kelley Armstrong provided a digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley and the opportunity to provide an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for May 23, 2023.
--------------------------------------------------------------
My 4.28 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
Now that Dr. Gray and his sister Isla Ballantyne know what happened to Mallory, the situation is not as full of subterfuge within the house except around the maid and housekeeper. She is now officially an undertaker’s assistant. Men in Edinburgh are dying of poison, and the widows are thought responsible, the latest of which is Gray’s oldest sister Annis. Where will the investigation take them? Is Annis a murderer?
Mallory is a character with plenty of depth. She’s hardworking, kind, relatable, and makes for a strong female protagonist that readers can cheer on. However, she is also an independent thinker unafraid to speak her mind which isn’t normal for women in Victorian times. Gray is passionate about his work, enthusiastic, confident, occasionally relaxed and teasing. The supporting cast of characters are well-developed and provide insight into individuals in various roles in a Victorian household as well as those they interact with.
Kelley Armstrong has a fluid writing style that quickly brings readers into the well-paced story. They also get insight into the state of police forensics during this early era and a few insights into chemistry, diversity, and how servants are treated as well. Other themes include family, relationships, friendship, sanitary (and other) conditions, racism, gender identity, poverty, homesickness, and much more. There is a hint at a couple of potential romances, but nothing more. The world-building was wonderful and felt accurate for the times. The ending has plenty of action and wraps things up nicely.
Overall, this is well-written, engaging, and entertaining with complex characters in a historical setting. I am looking forward to reading the next book in the series. Understanding how Mallory gets to this time in history is explained in depth in book one so I recommend starting with it. However, if you accept the time travel situation, then this can be read as a standalone novel.
St. Martin’s Press – Minotaur Books and Kelley Armstrong provided a digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley and the opportunity to provide an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for May 23, 2023.
--------------------------------------------------------------
My 4.28 rounded to 4 stars review is coming soon.
May 22, 2023
Time-traveling mystery with a bit of procedural and forensic in Victorian Scotland!
The Poisoner's Ring is a nice follow-up to book 1 in A Rip Through Time series. Men are poisoned and who would be killing them? Is it a work of a serial killer? Eventually, a death occurs close to one of the MCs.
Modern-day detective Mallory from Canada who is now in 1869 Edinburgh has to help find answers. Things are rather complicated when she's in a young housemaid's body!
I love the time travel element in this book. I also love how Mallory has to navigate many differences and expectations toward women in 1869. I think she hid it better in the first book while in book 2 she use modern terms in many instances to those closest to her. The first three parts were more interesting for me, I feel there's a bit pacing issue towards the ending. There's a tiny romance blossoming and overall very entertaining! I can't wait to read what's next for the characters. 3.5⭐
The audio narrated by Kate Handford was excellent and I very much enjoy her performance. I can't wait for the next one!
Thank you Macmillan Audio and Netgalley for my ALC.
Expected publication on May 23, 2023!
The Poisoner's Ring is a nice follow-up to book 1 in A Rip Through Time series. Men are poisoned and who would be killing them? Is it a work of a serial killer? Eventually, a death occurs close to one of the MCs.
Modern-day detective Mallory from Canada who is now in 1869 Edinburgh has to help find answers. Things are rather complicated when she's in a young housemaid's body!
I love the time travel element in this book. I also love how Mallory has to navigate many differences and expectations toward women in 1869. I think she hid it better in the first book while in book 2 she use modern terms in many instances to those closest to her. The first three parts were more interesting for me, I feel there's a bit pacing issue towards the ending. There's a tiny romance blossoming and overall very entertaining! I can't wait to read what's next for the characters. 3.5⭐
The audio narrated by Kate Handford was excellent and I very much enjoy her performance. I can't wait for the next one!
Thank you Macmillan Audio and Netgalley for my ALC.
Expected publication on May 23, 2023!
May 1, 2023
Book 2 of A Rip Through Times series, you must read the first book in order to understand this one.
Mallory, a modern day woman cop trapped in the body of a 19 year old Scottish Victorian girl in 1869. Her employer and friend Dr. Duncan Gray is aware of who Mallory really is, and while she there she serves as his assistant. When a series of murders occurs via poisoning, Mallory and Duncan find the case hits closer to home than either one realized.
Kelley Armstrong is one of my all time favorite authors and this series just reminds me of why. We get a time travel mystery that is set in Victorian times but with modern eyes. There's a hint of romance, but Armstrong notably is a slow burn writer as her books focus more on the mysteries abound instead.
I liked how in this book we were able to focus more on Mallory's police work instead of her having to hide who she truly was. At some point side characters were also calling her Mallory instead of Katrina (sorry if that is spelled wrong, I listen to the audio version) and I wondered if I missed a big reveal? I even rewound it to be sure I didn't hear wrong.
I think one of my favorite things Armstrong does with this series is tackle topics such as racism, Sapphic romance, transgender community, and more in a Victorian era. I loved that Mallory as a more modern woman was able to recognize things in a way people of the time might not have and was able to address everyone with kindness and respect. All of these topics existed back then as well as today and I enjoyed those elements being incorporated into the book.
My one regret is reading these books as they were released and now I have to wait probably another year for the next book. But I am sure it will be worth it as I have already grown to love these characters.
ALC provided by Libro.fm as a part of their Librarian ALC program
Mallory, a modern day woman cop trapped in the body of a 19 year old Scottish Victorian girl in 1869. Her employer and friend Dr. Duncan Gray is aware of who Mallory really is, and while she there she serves as his assistant. When a series of murders occurs via poisoning, Mallory and Duncan find the case hits closer to home than either one realized.
Kelley Armstrong is one of my all time favorite authors and this series just reminds me of why. We get a time travel mystery that is set in Victorian times but with modern eyes. There's a hint of romance, but Armstrong notably is a slow burn writer as her books focus more on the mysteries abound instead.
I liked how in this book we were able to focus more on Mallory's police work instead of her having to hide who she truly was. At some point side characters were also calling her Mallory instead of Katrina (sorry if that is spelled wrong, I listen to the audio version) and I wondered if I missed a big reveal? I even rewound it to be sure I didn't hear wrong.
I think one of my favorite things Armstrong does with this series is tackle topics such as racism, Sapphic romance, transgender community, and more in a Victorian era. I loved that Mallory as a more modern woman was able to recognize things in a way people of the time might not have and was able to address everyone with kindness and respect. All of these topics existed back then as well as today and I enjoyed those elements being incorporated into the book.
My one regret is reading these books as they were released and now I have to wait probably another year for the next book. But I am sure it will be worth it as I have already grown to love these characters.
ALC provided by Libro.fm as a part of their Librarian ALC program
June 3, 2023
3.5 stars rounded down. The second outing for detective Mallory and Dr. Gray & Co. was just not as engaging as #1 - “A Rip in Time”. It felt a bit long & like there was just something missing 🤷🏻♀️ That said, I really enjoyed the Victorian Scotland setting a lot. I’m undecided on #3 …
November 12, 2025
*2.5* I went in hoping for a continuing historical mystery, but instead I got another round of the fmc forcing modern social issues onto characters who lived 150 years ago.
I’m not saying racism, sexism, classism, or homophobia didn’t exist back then (they absolutely did) but the way they’re brought up here feels completely out of place for everyday working-class people who were mostly just trying to survive. Why are we using pronouns and discussing crossdressing in 1869? It pulled me out of the story every single time.
Duncan, Isla, and McCready all know about her body-swapping and time-travel situation, yet none of them seem all that shocked or skeptical. These characters were raised in the 1800s, and their worldviews should clash hard with Mallory’s modern sensibilities. Instead, they just… go along with it?
The pacing also drags. The mystery gets bogged down in repetitive detail, and while there’s plenty of snark, Mallory’s humor feels far too modern and often grating for the era. Her voice comes across as disrespectful, she’s literally flipping off Dr. Gray at one point.
How has she not been tossed into an asylum yet? For a detective, Mallory’s loose-lipped about her secret in ways that make me question her detective training. I couldn’t help thinking of the Outlander series where Claire had to constantly watch herself to avoid being branded a witch. Here, Mallory just barrels through Victorian society with zero consequences.
I do believe the author plans an eventual romance between Mallory (30s in modern time, but in a 19-year-old-woman’s body in 1869) and Dr. Gray. I wish them well, doubtful I’ll continue the series.
*Kate Handford did an excellent job at narrating the audiobook.
I’d recommend this author’s Rockton (Casey Duncan) series and Otherworld series over this one.
I’m not saying racism, sexism, classism, or homophobia didn’t exist back then (they absolutely did) but the way they’re brought up here feels completely out of place for everyday working-class people who were mostly just trying to survive. Why are we using pronouns and discussing crossdressing in 1869? It pulled me out of the story every single time.
Duncan, Isla, and McCready all know about her body-swapping and time-travel situation, yet none of them seem all that shocked or skeptical. These characters were raised in the 1800s, and their worldviews should clash hard with Mallory’s modern sensibilities. Instead, they just… go along with it?
The pacing also drags. The mystery gets bogged down in repetitive detail, and while there’s plenty of snark, Mallory’s humor feels far too modern and often grating for the era. Her voice comes across as disrespectful, she’s literally flipping off Dr. Gray at one point.
How has she not been tossed into an asylum yet? For a detective, Mallory’s loose-lipped about her secret in ways that make me question her detective training. I couldn’t help thinking of the Outlander series where Claire had to constantly watch herself to avoid being branded a witch. Here, Mallory just barrels through Victorian society with zero consequences.
I do believe the author plans an eventual romance between Mallory (30s in modern time, but in a 19-year-old-woman’s body in 1869) and Dr. Gray. I wish them well, doubtful I’ll continue the series.
*Kate Handford did an excellent job at narrating the audiobook.
I’d recommend this author’s Rockton (Casey Duncan) series and Otherworld series over this one.
May 21, 2023
The Poisoner’s Ring by Kelley Armstrong
A Rip through Time series #2.
Homicide Detective Mallory Atkinson accidentally went through a time-slip and is stuck in the body of an eighteen year old maid in Edinburgh Scotland in the year 1869. Fortunately her employer, Doctor Duncan Gray is aware she’s not really the maid and she is able to help him in his job as medical examiner and undertaker. There seems to be a Poisoner’s Ring in the city as a few men are found dead, one making a widow of Duncan’s sister. The widow is always the first suspect and they need to beat the police in solving the puzzle or the widows will all end up in the gallows.
Mallory and Duncan trade quips and work around the language differences from 1869 to contemporary current day. He is quick to either pick up the meaning or ignore what Mallory says and moves on. As her stay in the time lengthens, they grow comfortable together. Respect, and friendship grow as they help the widows in their investigations.
Intriguing scenarios of investigative work in a time when finger prints are a science yet to come. And ice boxes. And women’s cinched clothing which I would abhor.
🎧I listened to an audiobook narrated by Kate Handford who also did the first book in this series. The performance is well done with distinct voices for Mallory and Duncan as well as a few of the secondary characters. The emotions are clearly expressed as the narrative turns from internal to danger and discussions of discovery of medical trends between Mallory and Duncan. The audio kept me involved and listening.
My preferred speed is approximately 1.4 and that was where I stayed for the majority of the recording.
Excerpt:
“I like your brain just the way it is.”
He opens his mouth, pauses, then says “That is oddly flattering.”
“As it should be. I’ve never said that to anyone else.”
Excerpt from The Poisoner’s Ring by Kelley Armstrong
I received a copy of the book from NetGalley and Macmillan Audio. This is an auto buy author for me.
A Rip through Time series #2.
Homicide Detective Mallory Atkinson accidentally went through a time-slip and is stuck in the body of an eighteen year old maid in Edinburgh Scotland in the year 1869. Fortunately her employer, Doctor Duncan Gray is aware she’s not really the maid and she is able to help him in his job as medical examiner and undertaker. There seems to be a Poisoner’s Ring in the city as a few men are found dead, one making a widow of Duncan’s sister. The widow is always the first suspect and they need to beat the police in solving the puzzle or the widows will all end up in the gallows.
Mallory and Duncan trade quips and work around the language differences from 1869 to contemporary current day. He is quick to either pick up the meaning or ignore what Mallory says and moves on. As her stay in the time lengthens, they grow comfortable together. Respect, and friendship grow as they help the widows in their investigations.
Intriguing scenarios of investigative work in a time when finger prints are a science yet to come. And ice boxes. And women’s cinched clothing which I would abhor.
🎧I listened to an audiobook narrated by Kate Handford who also did the first book in this series. The performance is well done with distinct voices for Mallory and Duncan as well as a few of the secondary characters. The emotions are clearly expressed as the narrative turns from internal to danger and discussions of discovery of medical trends between Mallory and Duncan. The audio kept me involved and listening.
My preferred speed is approximately 1.4 and that was where I stayed for the majority of the recording.
Excerpt:
“I like your brain just the way it is.”
He opens his mouth, pauses, then says “That is oddly flattering.”
“As it should be. I’ve never said that to anyone else.”
Excerpt from The Poisoner’s Ring by Kelley Armstrong
I received a copy of the book from NetGalley and Macmillan Audio. This is an auto buy author for me.
July 23, 2023
I loved A Rip through Time and was excited to read the second book The Poisoner’s Ring in this time travel mystery, with a very slow burn romance.. Kelley Armstrong doesn’t disappoint with captivating, witty well developed characters, that leap from the pages. Armstrong creates a powerful atmosphere I.felt transported to Victorian Scotland.
I love watching the relationship between Mallory and Isla grow stronger my patience at the slow burn romance between Duncan and Mallory is fraying my nerves, the chemistry is palpable. between them.
I enjoyed trying to solve the new case and, the mystery behind it. That includes my favourite characters Mallory, Duncan, Detective Hugh McCreadie and Isla. Dr. Grey and Isla’s sister Annis who isn’t close to the family is accused of poisoning her husband Lord Leslie so she runs to her family for help., but Lord Leslie dies before the lawyer could make changes to his will and he’s in a locked room alone. Two other men have been murdered by poison,are the cases linked? It was hard to say goodbye to my favourite characters. I’ll be anxiously awaiting the next instalment in The Rip Through Time series.
A special thanks to St. Martin’s Press, Minotaur books and NetGalley for the ARC of The Poisoner’s Ring by Kelley Armstrong in exchange for a honest review.
I love watching the relationship between Mallory and Isla grow stronger my patience at the slow burn romance between Duncan and Mallory is fraying my nerves, the chemistry is palpable. between them.
I enjoyed trying to solve the new case and, the mystery behind it. That includes my favourite characters Mallory, Duncan, Detective Hugh McCreadie and Isla. Dr. Grey and Isla’s sister Annis who isn’t close to the family is accused of poisoning her husband Lord Leslie so she runs to her family for help., but Lord Leslie dies before the lawyer could make changes to his will and he’s in a locked room alone. Two other men have been murdered by poison,are the cases linked? It was hard to say goodbye to my favourite characters. I’ll be anxiously awaiting the next instalment in The Rip Through Time series.
A special thanks to St. Martin’s Press, Minotaur books and NetGalley for the ARC of The Poisoner’s Ring by Kelley Armstrong in exchange for a honest review.
June 2, 2023
The Poisoner’s Ring (A Rip Through Time, #2) was the first book that I have read by author, Kelley Armstrong. It was a time travel historical mystery that took place in Victorian Edinburgh. I usually don’t read time travel novels but this one worked for me. It was fast paced, had touches of humor, likable characters and kept me guessing until the end. I listened to the audiobook that was very well narrated by Kate Handford. She did a good job distinguishing between the characters. It was rather a long audiobook that required almost 15 hours of listening time. I had not had the opportunity to read the first book in this series. Although I wished I had had the chance, The Poisoner’s Ring can be read as a stand-alone book.
Mallory inhabited the body of a young maid who resided and worked at the home of Dr. Duncan Gray and his sister Isla. Before being transported back to Victorian Edinburgh, Mallory had been a homicide detective in Canada until she was attacked. Mallory, trapped in the body of maid Catriona Mitchell, an employee of the Gray’s, now found herself immersed in the roles of Dr. Gray’s assistant and maid. Dr. Duncan Gray was an undertaker. He was the half brother of Isla and Annis, his two older half sisters. The three siblings shared the same father but Duncan’s mother had been Indian which accounted for Duncan’s dark skin pigmentation. When Duncan’s biological mother died, his father brought his illegitimate son to his home to be raised by his wife. Duncan inherited the family funeral business. He had trained as a doctor but his questionable skin color prevented him from becoming a doctor. Isla, a chemist and widow resided in the family house that she shared with her brother. Annis, the oldest sister, estranged from her two younger siblings, was married and lived with her husband.
One night, Dr. Gray solicited Mallory’s help in a new case. There was talk of a poisoner’s ring. Several men had been reported to have died from poisoning. Their wives were the main suspects. When Dr. Gray’s own brother-in-law fell victim, Dr. Gray and Mallory knew that they needed to find the person that was responsible for poisoning all the men victims. There had to be a connection between the victims but it was not immediately obvious. Dr. Gray and Mallory sought help from Dr. Gray’s childhood friend, Detective Hugh McCreadie. Isla was also called upon to analyze the contents of the poison. Would Dr. Gray and Mallory be able to identify the person that was responsible for the poisoning and clear Annis’s name in time?
The Poisoner’s Ring was told from Mallory’s POV. This allowed her to interject observations and explanations that stemmed from her experience in the future. Mallory was able to enlighten Dr. Gray and Isla about things that had not yet occurred. I enjoyed the hint of attraction between Mallory and Duncan even though Mallory wished to return to her own time period and life more than ever. This was a fun mystery and I look forward to reading the next book in this series. I highly recommend this series.
Thank you to Macmillan Audio for allowing me to listen to the audiobook of The Poisoner’s Ring by Kelley Armstrong through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Mallory inhabited the body of a young maid who resided and worked at the home of Dr. Duncan Gray and his sister Isla. Before being transported back to Victorian Edinburgh, Mallory had been a homicide detective in Canada until she was attacked. Mallory, trapped in the body of maid Catriona Mitchell, an employee of the Gray’s, now found herself immersed in the roles of Dr. Gray’s assistant and maid. Dr. Duncan Gray was an undertaker. He was the half brother of Isla and Annis, his two older half sisters. The three siblings shared the same father but Duncan’s mother had been Indian which accounted for Duncan’s dark skin pigmentation. When Duncan’s biological mother died, his father brought his illegitimate son to his home to be raised by his wife. Duncan inherited the family funeral business. He had trained as a doctor but his questionable skin color prevented him from becoming a doctor. Isla, a chemist and widow resided in the family house that she shared with her brother. Annis, the oldest sister, estranged from her two younger siblings, was married and lived with her husband.
One night, Dr. Gray solicited Mallory’s help in a new case. There was talk of a poisoner’s ring. Several men had been reported to have died from poisoning. Their wives were the main suspects. When Dr. Gray’s own brother-in-law fell victim, Dr. Gray and Mallory knew that they needed to find the person that was responsible for poisoning all the men victims. There had to be a connection between the victims but it was not immediately obvious. Dr. Gray and Mallory sought help from Dr. Gray’s childhood friend, Detective Hugh McCreadie. Isla was also called upon to analyze the contents of the poison. Would Dr. Gray and Mallory be able to identify the person that was responsible for the poisoning and clear Annis’s name in time?
The Poisoner’s Ring was told from Mallory’s POV. This allowed her to interject observations and explanations that stemmed from her experience in the future. Mallory was able to enlighten Dr. Gray and Isla about things that had not yet occurred. I enjoyed the hint of attraction between Mallory and Duncan even though Mallory wished to return to her own time period and life more than ever. This was a fun mystery and I look forward to reading the next book in this series. I highly recommend this series.
Thank you to Macmillan Audio for allowing me to listen to the audiobook of The Poisoner’s Ring by Kelley Armstrong through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
December 27, 2023
This is a well-written, entertaining, time travel mystery. It has a likeable, intelligent, strong and capable female protagonist, intrigue, suspense, a touch of humor, a diverse group of characters, a slow burn romance, twists and turns, and a satisfying conclusion. This is the second entry in Ms. Armstrong's A Rip Through Time series, and it is best when read in order. I am looking forward to reading the next entry with great anticipation.
May 28, 2025
Check out all my reviews at: https://www.avonnalovesgenres.com
THE POISONER’S RING (A Rip in Time Book #2) by Kelley Armstrong is the second book in this historical mystery/time-travel romance mash-up featuring a modern-day female homicide detective who is sent back in time into the body of a Scottish Victorian house maid. These books, at least books one and two, I feel need to be read in order because the first book focuses more on all the character development, how they all interact, and the problems caused by the time-travel, while the second book is focused more on a historical murder mystery.
Mallory is still carrying out the role of house maid for Dr. Duncan Gray and his sister, Isla, while she really wants to be more of an assistant to Duncan who is an undertaker, who also moonlights as a medical examiner. Duncan becomes involved with a case of a supposed poisoning ring which soon includes his older sister when she is accused of poisoning her husband. Mallory, Isla, and Duncan all work together to investigate the murders to exonerate Duncan and Isla’s sister to save her from the hangman’s rope.
I enjoyed the first book, but I liked this one even more because the characters are more settled in their belief in Mallory’s time-travel and the focus was more on a very well-paced and plotted Victorian murder mystery. It kept me guessing until almost the end and was a satisfying solution. The characters make me keep coming back for more. While they follow the rules for their time in Scottish Victorian history, they are also educated and open minded not only to Mallery’s story, but also for their time. Ms. Armstrong brings in serious topics such as racism, varied sexual orientations, and extreme poverty and handles each with not only comparisons between Duncan’s Victorian feelings and beliefs, but also Mallory’s more modern understanding. The chemistry and dialogue between Duncan and Mallory lead to not only serious discussions, but also humorous moments. I am looking forward to following their partnership and relationship in future books.
I highly recommend this mash-up series with memorable characters and intriguing historical mysteries.
THE POISONER’S RING (A Rip in Time Book #2) by Kelley Armstrong is the second book in this historical mystery/time-travel romance mash-up featuring a modern-day female homicide detective who is sent back in time into the body of a Scottish Victorian house maid. These books, at least books one and two, I feel need to be read in order because the first book focuses more on all the character development, how they all interact, and the problems caused by the time-travel, while the second book is focused more on a historical murder mystery.
Mallory is still carrying out the role of house maid for Dr. Duncan Gray and his sister, Isla, while she really wants to be more of an assistant to Duncan who is an undertaker, who also moonlights as a medical examiner. Duncan becomes involved with a case of a supposed poisoning ring which soon includes his older sister when she is accused of poisoning her husband. Mallory, Isla, and Duncan all work together to investigate the murders to exonerate Duncan and Isla’s sister to save her from the hangman’s rope.
I enjoyed the first book, but I liked this one even more because the characters are more settled in their belief in Mallory’s time-travel and the focus was more on a very well-paced and plotted Victorian murder mystery. It kept me guessing until almost the end and was a satisfying solution. The characters make me keep coming back for more. While they follow the rules for their time in Scottish Victorian history, they are also educated and open minded not only to Mallery’s story, but also for their time. Ms. Armstrong brings in serious topics such as racism, varied sexual orientations, and extreme poverty and handles each with not only comparisons between Duncan’s Victorian feelings and beliefs, but also Mallory’s more modern understanding. The chemistry and dialogue between Duncan and Mallory lead to not only serious discussions, but also humorous moments. I am looking forward to following their partnership and relationship in future books.
I highly recommend this mash-up series with memorable characters and intriguing historical mysteries.
December 7, 2022
The more I read by Kelley Armstrong the more I feel that she is one of my favorite authors. I love her versatility, her character development, and world building. While this is only book two in this series, this is becoming one of my favorites. I love the mystery and the element of time travel/displacement. I liked how Duncan and Mallory’s relationship (personal and professional) is developing. I also really liked that this mystery involved Annis as it fleshed out the family dynamics a little more. Several men have been murdered by poison so the police are trying to find if there is a poisoner’s ring (women exchanging information about poison to do away with their men). Mallory and Duncan are investigating when Annis summons Duncan because her husband is dying of being poisoned and the case takes a personal turn.
April 7, 2023
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.
Expected publication date: May 23, 2023
When we last left her, homicide detective Mallory Atkinson was trying to survive as a scullery maid, after falling through a portal and ending up in Edinburgh in 1869. Her employer, undertaker Dr. Duncan Grey, hired her on as his assistant, and she ended up involved in some of the country’s biggest murders. In this novel, Grey and his family are aware of Mallory’s true identity, which comes in very handy when men in the community start to drop dead from an apparent poisoner. Now, Duncan and Mallory must investigate, while still trying to keep Mallory’s real identity a secret from the outside world, and everyone that Mallory has come to know are the prime suspects.
“The Poisoner’s Ring” is book two in the “A Rip Through Time” series, by Canadian author Kelley Armstrong. I thoroughly enjoyed the first novel, both for its Victorian Scotland setting and it’s time travel plot, and was really excited to explore book two. Mallory and Duncan are just as lovable as ever, and now they’re investigating a suspicious group of murders, caused by poison, while avoiding the obvious romantic tension and chemistry that is evident between them.
With short chapters, each ending with a cliff-hanger, this novel was tough to put down. Mallory is acerbic and sarcastic (which makes her downright hilarious) and I laughed loudly and often at her biting comments. Armstrong manages to make a historical fiction plot relevant and modern, by including a woman named “Jack”, and the stigma of a Black man taking a job as an undertaker since he cannot practice medicine due to his race.
Armstrong has many novels under her belt, of various genres, but her “A Rip Through Time” series, in my opinion, is one of her best. Although the novel has strong “Outlander” vibes, it is a great read in its own right and Armstrong deserves full credit for her creativity and plot development.
The ending provided just enough to leave me feeling satisfied, while still leaving me excited for the future “Time” novels that Armstrong will undoubtedly deliver. I look forward to more Mallory, more Duncan, and of course, more Scotland!
Expected publication date: May 23, 2023
When we last left her, homicide detective Mallory Atkinson was trying to survive as a scullery maid, after falling through a portal and ending up in Edinburgh in 1869. Her employer, undertaker Dr. Duncan Grey, hired her on as his assistant, and she ended up involved in some of the country’s biggest murders. In this novel, Grey and his family are aware of Mallory’s true identity, which comes in very handy when men in the community start to drop dead from an apparent poisoner. Now, Duncan and Mallory must investigate, while still trying to keep Mallory’s real identity a secret from the outside world, and everyone that Mallory has come to know are the prime suspects.
“The Poisoner’s Ring” is book two in the “A Rip Through Time” series, by Canadian author Kelley Armstrong. I thoroughly enjoyed the first novel, both for its Victorian Scotland setting and it’s time travel plot, and was really excited to explore book two. Mallory and Duncan are just as lovable as ever, and now they’re investigating a suspicious group of murders, caused by poison, while avoiding the obvious romantic tension and chemistry that is evident between them.
With short chapters, each ending with a cliff-hanger, this novel was tough to put down. Mallory is acerbic and sarcastic (which makes her downright hilarious) and I laughed loudly and often at her biting comments. Armstrong manages to make a historical fiction plot relevant and modern, by including a woman named “Jack”, and the stigma of a Black man taking a job as an undertaker since he cannot practice medicine due to his race.
Armstrong has many novels under her belt, of various genres, but her “A Rip Through Time” series, in my opinion, is one of her best. Although the novel has strong “Outlander” vibes, it is a great read in its own right and Armstrong deserves full credit for her creativity and plot development.
The ending provided just enough to leave me feeling satisfied, while still leaving me excited for the future “Time” novels that Armstrong will undoubtedly deliver. I look forward to more Mallory, more Duncan, and of course, more Scotland!
March 8, 2025
This is the 17th book I have read by Kelley Armstrong. Suffice it to say that I am a fan of her work. Armstrong is a really good writer and storyteller and I am really enjoying this series of a 30yr old, 21st century cop from Canada, who was visiting her dying grandmother in Scotland, when she was transported back to the 19th century in the body of a 19yr old house maid. I like Mallory – a lot! Her struggles with acclimating to her new persona, surroundings and predicament are at times hilarious and entertaining, especially now that her employers, Isles and her brother Duncan, are aware of who she is and where she’s from. Mallory’s educated, 30yr old cop brain and personality is still struggling to pull off the 19yr old, uneducated, housemaid, Catriona, and she is constantly behaving outside of her “station” according to the 19th century, rich, Scottish, upper class.
The gang is all back along with Duncan’s and Isla’s older sister, Annis, and the nonbinary, Jack, who seems to know more about the investigation of the poison ring than anyone else related to the investigation knows. Frankly, Jack seems to know more about a lot of things than most anyone else in the story. I suspect that we will see more of these two characters in future installments. They both added intrigue and entertainment to this installment.
The book summary is really vague and basically just introduces the primary storyline. What the book summary doesn’t mention is the whole other scheme underlining the entire story. While it may look like pissed off wives are killing their abusive, philandering and unscrupulous husbands, there is something much more sinister going on behind the scenes, and the players are many and conniving, and some with their own separate agendas than the one they are pretending to have.
For most of the story, I was flip flopping between two different characters as the killer and while I was right about one of them, I was completely off the mark for the killer’s motivation. In a whirlwind of intense and scary scenes, the ending got a little messy but came to a satisfying conclusion. I LOVED the finale!!! Oh, can’t wait until the next installment to see how THAT plays out!
The continuing character development of Mallory, Duncan and Isla was well done and, once again, really enjoyed the introduction to some possible new characters. The pacing was mostly steady up to the end that seemed to come fast. The storyline was interesting too. The writing was ok, but there were so many passages that I had trouble with the transition from one character to another. I listened to the audiobook and this may be part of the problem. So many times, I had to rewind to listen to a passage again because I couldn’t tell who was saying what in a conversation. The transition from one speaker to another was either absent or poorly identified/placed. It got a little annoying towards the end. This is more of a medium issue than a storyline because the book probably does read that way. I don’t know that for certain; I’m just speculating. Anyway, I’m looking at an overall rating of 3.9 that I will be rounding up to a 4star review.
The gang is all back along with Duncan’s and Isla’s older sister, Annis, and the nonbinary, Jack, who seems to know more about the investigation of the poison ring than anyone else related to the investigation knows. Frankly, Jack seems to know more about a lot of things than most anyone else in the story. I suspect that we will see more of these two characters in future installments. They both added intrigue and entertainment to this installment.
The book summary is really vague and basically just introduces the primary storyline. What the book summary doesn’t mention is the whole other scheme underlining the entire story. While it may look like pissed off wives are killing their abusive, philandering and unscrupulous husbands, there is something much more sinister going on behind the scenes, and the players are many and conniving, and some with their own separate agendas than the one they are pretending to have.
For most of the story, I was flip flopping between two different characters as the killer and while I was right about one of them, I was completely off the mark for the killer’s motivation. In a whirlwind of intense and scary scenes, the ending got a little messy but came to a satisfying conclusion. I LOVED the finale!!! Oh, can’t wait until the next installment to see how THAT plays out!
The continuing character development of Mallory, Duncan and Isla was well done and, once again, really enjoyed the introduction to some possible new characters. The pacing was mostly steady up to the end that seemed to come fast. The storyline was interesting too. The writing was ok, but there were so many passages that I had trouble with the transition from one character to another. I listened to the audiobook and this may be part of the problem. So many times, I had to rewind to listen to a passage again because I couldn’t tell who was saying what in a conversation. The transition from one speaker to another was either absent or poorly identified/placed. It got a little annoying towards the end. This is more of a medium issue than a storyline because the book probably does read that way. I don’t know that for certain; I’m just speculating. Anyway, I’m looking at an overall rating of 3.9 that I will be rounding up to a 4star review.
May 28, 2023
4.0 Stars
Video Review: https://youtu.be/6Cu2IGMhVy4
After loving book one, I was thrilled for the opportunity to continue on with this historical mystery series. I found the mystery in this book to be a little less interesting than the mystery in the first. However, where this one excelled was continuing the character and relationship development that started in the first book.
I would recommend this series for anyone looking for an escapist time travel story.
Disclaimer I received a copy of this book from the publisher.
Video Review: https://youtu.be/6Cu2IGMhVy4
After loving book one, I was thrilled for the opportunity to continue on with this historical mystery series. I found the mystery in this book to be a little less interesting than the mystery in the first. However, where this one excelled was continuing the character and relationship development that started in the first book.
I would recommend this series for anyone looking for an escapist time travel story.
Disclaimer I received a copy of this book from the publisher.
June 8, 2023
I have been looking forward to this book since finishing book 1 last year. I’m disappointed that the author felt the need to cram today’s gender ambiguity mantra into what started out as a fun Victorian mystery with a time travel twist.
February 16, 2023
I absolutely adored the first book, it was just so much fun, so interesting, and completely hard to put down. I have been eagerly awaiting book two and I am so happy to report that it didn't disappoint. If possible, it was even better than the first. It was filled with action. adventure, a tiny hint of romance, and an amazing setting and time that I just adore. This really did have a bit of it all and I am so glad too because I can quickly see this series, these characters, and this storyline, becoming a fast favorite.
*ARC provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*
*ARC provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.*
May 23, 2023
Thanks to Netgalley and St. Martin's Press - Minotaur for gifting me an early copy. Below is my honest review.
This one was a rollercoaster! I had my suspicions of the killer, then changed my mind, then changed it back, then changed it again, then... over and over. Armstrong had me spinning and I love that!
It was an intriguing mystery, surrounding a confidence scheme, an interesting new poison, and some major players in Mallory's new locale.
I think my favorite part of this book was actually the development in character relationships that Mallory has, along with some new ones that have some familial ties to her current situation.
Honestly, I have to admit... I really am not rooting for Mallory to find a way home. I like her where she is now. Hash-tag shame on me, right?
Highly recommended, but please read the first one before picking this up.
This one was a rollercoaster! I had my suspicions of the killer, then changed my mind, then changed it back, then changed it again, then... over and over. Armstrong had me spinning and I love that!
It was an intriguing mystery, surrounding a confidence scheme, an interesting new poison, and some major players in Mallory's new locale.
I think my favorite part of this book was actually the development in character relationships that Mallory has, along with some new ones that have some familial ties to her current situation.
Honestly, I have to admit... I really am not rooting for Mallory to find a way home. I like her where she is now. Hash-tag shame on me, right?
Highly recommended, but please read the first one before picking this up.
May 18, 2023
This mystery series is a fusion of historical fiction and time travel. Series plot scenario: Mallory was attacked in a dark alley in Edinburgh, Scotland in the present day and woke to find herself inhabiting another woman's body in 1869, the body of a young housemaid in an undertaker/forensic-scientist's home. During book one in the series, Mallory finds herself forced to reveal her true identity to her employer Dr Duncan Gray, his sister Isla, who is a chemist, and Detective Hugh McCreadie of the local police force. They allow her to join in some of their investigative work as Gray's assistant--at least until she can figure out how to get back to the future...
Now in book #2 in the series, there have been three deaths by poisoning and a poisoning ring is suspected. Is someone supplying wives with the means to kill their husbands? One wife runs away while a second is arrested. The third death happens to be Gray's brother-in-law, Lord Gord0n Leslie, and his wife, Gray's sister Annis, stands accused of murdering her husband. So the pressure is on to figure out what links all these crimes and prove these wives innocent.
It's fun and interesting to spend some time in Victorian Scotland and compare crime solving techniques in the past and present. Some things are pretty humorous, like Mallory trying to run in layers of skirts and catch her breath in a corset. But there's also how poorly women are treated in that era, how little personal freedom they have outside the home. And Dr Gray, who is biracial and often confronts bigotry, is rather shocked to learn things on that front haven't improved all that much 150 years into the future.
I've enjoyed this series so far and look forward to more episodes. Will Mallory want to go back to her 'real' life if/when the chance comes or will new emotional ties keep her rooted in the past? We'll see!
I received an arc of this new mystery from the author and publisher via NetGalley. Many thanks! My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.
Now in book #2 in the series, there have been three deaths by poisoning and a poisoning ring is suspected. Is someone supplying wives with the means to kill their husbands? One wife runs away while a second is arrested. The third death happens to be Gray's brother-in-law, Lord Gord0n Leslie, and his wife, Gray's sister Annis, stands accused of murdering her husband. So the pressure is on to figure out what links all these crimes and prove these wives innocent.
It's fun and interesting to spend some time in Victorian Scotland and compare crime solving techniques in the past and present. Some things are pretty humorous, like Mallory trying to run in layers of skirts and catch her breath in a corset. But there's also how poorly women are treated in that era, how little personal freedom they have outside the home. And Dr Gray, who is biracial and often confronts bigotry, is rather shocked to learn things on that front haven't improved all that much 150 years into the future.
I've enjoyed this series so far and look forward to more episodes. Will Mallory want to go back to her 'real' life if/when the chance comes or will new emotional ties keep her rooted in the past? We'll see!
I received an arc of this new mystery from the author and publisher via NetGalley. Many thanks! My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.
June 10, 2023
Too much preachiness about what should be thought about women, sexual identity etc. pull you out of and ruin the story.
May 8, 2025
In the first book, A Rip Through Time, we met Mallory Atkinson. A strange occurrence found her switching bodies with Catrina Mitchell, a housemaid in Edinburgh, Scotland in 1869. In the past month she has settled in as much as possible. Her employer, Dr. Duncan Gray performs unofficial medical examinations. He and his sister have learned and accepted that Mallory is indeed a homicide detective from the future.
Dr. Gray gets involved in what turns out to be a string of poisonings. Apparently, women in the city are joining together to kill their husbands! Then his other older and estranged sister shows up and tells them her husband is dying from poison! She is seeking their help.
Mallory and Dr. Gray meet a series of interesting people as they try to puzzle out what is happening in an attempt to save his sister. The two have a fun relationship… platonic and professional, but something is building between them. They of course put themselves in danger at various times but follow the clues and in the end everything is clear.
A few negatives: Mallory is continually bringing up words, technology, or concepts from her time… she thinks it’s fun to confuse or have fun with Dr. Gray in this way, but I thought it was overused a bit. And perhaps a bit longer than it needed to be. Positives: They really are fun and interesting characters, and I enjoyed seeing their relationships grow. And the overall concept and experiencing Edinburgh in the past is fun as well.
Overall 3.5 rounded to 4. I’m a sucker for a series with interesting characters 😊
Dr. Gray gets involved in what turns out to be a string of poisonings. Apparently, women in the city are joining together to kill their husbands! Then his other older and estranged sister shows up and tells them her husband is dying from poison! She is seeking their help.
Mallory and Dr. Gray meet a series of interesting people as they try to puzzle out what is happening in an attempt to save his sister. The two have a fun relationship… platonic and professional, but something is building between them. They of course put themselves in danger at various times but follow the clues and in the end everything is clear.
A few negatives: Mallory is continually bringing up words, technology, or concepts from her time… she thinks it’s fun to confuse or have fun with Dr. Gray in this way, but I thought it was overused a bit. And perhaps a bit longer than it needed to be. Positives: They really are fun and interesting characters, and I enjoyed seeing their relationships grow. And the overall concept and experiencing Edinburgh in the past is fun as well.
Overall 3.5 rounded to 4. I’m a sucker for a series with interesting characters 😊
July 5, 2024
The only reason why this book didn’t get 5 stars is because I WAS WAITING FOR A DR. GRAY ROMANCE THAT NEVER CAME! I’m so disappointed… in that factor alone, the rest of the book thoroughly entertained me. It’s so funny, it’s exciting, it’s mysterious and I was hooked all throughout. But please ……. Give me some Dr. Gray romance, I can’t take this much longer
dnf
July 3, 2023DNF @ 28%
Everyone who meets Mallory is way too accepting of her anachronistic behavior, even the ones who don’t know her true circumstances.
Everyone who meets Mallory is way too accepting of her anachronistic behavior, even the ones who don’t know her true circumstances.
May 26, 2023
This review can also be found at https://carolesrandomlife.com/
I loved this book! Once I started reading this book, I found it impossible to put it down. I liked this installment even more than the first book in the series. The mystery kept me guessing until very close to the end. I think that the way that the time travel aspect of the story is handled is rather unique and incredibly well done. This story entertained me from beginning to end.
I like how Mallory handles the situation that she has found herself in and doesn’t try to change her environment to accommodate her. Mallory, Gray, and the other key characters are intelligent and easy to like. I wanted to see things go well for them as they worked to solve the case. Mallory’s knowledge of the future is the key to solving this crime and I love the fact that Gray trusts her knowledge, although it seems like she should be the one in charge if only that time in history would allow it.
I listened to the audiobook and thought that Kate Handford did an excellent job bringing this story to life. I found her voice to be incredibly pleasant and enjoyed the voices that she used for the various characters. I thought that she added just the right amount of excitement to her reading and I found myself wanting to listen to the book for hours at a time. I am certain that her narration added to my enjoyment of this wonderful story.
I would not hesitate to recommend this book to others. This is the second book in the A Rip in Time series which I would recommend reading in order. This well-written book was filled with fantastic characters, a mystery that kept me guessing, and a vivid setting. I cannot wait to read more of this entertaining series.
I received a review copy of this book from Minotaur Books and St. Martin’s Press.
I loved this book! Once I started reading this book, I found it impossible to put it down. I liked this installment even more than the first book in the series. The mystery kept me guessing until very close to the end. I think that the way that the time travel aspect of the story is handled is rather unique and incredibly well done. This story entertained me from beginning to end.
I like how Mallory handles the situation that she has found herself in and doesn’t try to change her environment to accommodate her. Mallory, Gray, and the other key characters are intelligent and easy to like. I wanted to see things go well for them as they worked to solve the case. Mallory’s knowledge of the future is the key to solving this crime and I love the fact that Gray trusts her knowledge, although it seems like she should be the one in charge if only that time in history would allow it.
I listened to the audiobook and thought that Kate Handford did an excellent job bringing this story to life. I found her voice to be incredibly pleasant and enjoyed the voices that she used for the various characters. I thought that she added just the right amount of excitement to her reading and I found myself wanting to listen to the book for hours at a time. I am certain that her narration added to my enjoyment of this wonderful story.
I would not hesitate to recommend this book to others. This is the second book in the A Rip in Time series which I would recommend reading in order. This well-written book was filled with fantastic characters, a mystery that kept me guessing, and a vivid setting. I cannot wait to read more of this entertaining series.
I received a review copy of this book from Minotaur Books and St. Martin’s Press.
September 16, 2023
I just could not get into the writing style of this book. It seemed really wordy, drawn out, and preachy.
June 21, 2023
i still find the premise (of a modern day police detective stuck in the victorian ages as a housemaid) fun, but the writing is hit-or-miss and makes the experience less enjoyable for me. mallory’s exposition is overly wordy and i find it tedious that so many of her paragraphs are full of padded fluff that doesn’t tell me anything important or interesting.
also she has a tendency to be preachy and holier-than-thou, but then again she’s stuck in a rather backwards time, so i find it hard to fault her for it.
the murder mystery itself wasn’t too bad though, even if there were so few suspects it’s hard not to be like “well i have no idea why this person would do any of it, but there isn’t really anyone left, so i suppose we’ll find out the motive later”
i still like isla, duncan, and hugh, but somehow i feel
like their interactions were more fun in book one. probably because they didn’t know mallory was mallory. of course it’s much better for her that she can be herself more now, but i feel like it’s less entertaining. her making hugh feel awkward with sex talk isn’t particularly funny to me and i don’t care about duncan being all sad she’s trying to get back to her time.
annis is a great addition though, she may not be a good person but she’s interesting to read about. i loved her line about mallory being terrible at pretending to be a housemaid, she doesn’t miss anything at all.
overall i didn’t like this as much as book 1, but it was fine. mallory solved the murders but made little to no progress on anything else, which makes me less inclined to read the sequel if it’s just gonna be more of the same, especially now that her voice is starting to annoy me. 2.5 stars.
also she has a tendency to be preachy and holier-than-thou, but then again she’s stuck in a rather backwards time, so i find it hard to fault her for it.
the murder mystery itself wasn’t too bad though, even if there were so few suspects it’s hard not to be like “well i have no idea why this person would do any of it, but there isn’t really anyone left, so i suppose we’ll find out the motive later”
i still like isla, duncan, and hugh, but somehow i feel
like their interactions were more fun in book one. probably because they didn’t know mallory was mallory. of course it’s much better for her that she can be herself more now, but i feel like it’s less entertaining. her making hugh feel awkward with sex talk isn’t particularly funny to me and i don’t care about duncan being all sad she’s trying to get back to her time.
annis is a great addition though, she may not be a good person but she’s interesting to read about. i loved her line about mallory being terrible at pretending to be a housemaid, she doesn’t miss anything at all.
overall i didn’t like this as much as book 1, but it was fine. mallory solved the murders but made little to no progress on anything else, which makes me less inclined to read the sequel if it’s just gonna be more of the same, especially now that her voice is starting to annoy me. 2.5 stars.
December 20, 2022
Big thanks to both Minotaur Books and NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review an early copy of The Poisoner's Ring!
Expected publication: May 23rd, 2023
A modern-day homicide detective is working as an undertaker's assistant in Victorian Scotland, when a serial poisoner attacks the men of Edinburgh and leaves their widows under suspicion.
This is the second book in the series and it can be read as a stand-alone, in my opinion. I loved The Poisoner's Ring, although not quite as much as I did A Rip Through Time. The wonderful characters from the first book (Isla, Duncan, Hugh, and of course Mallory!) are all in this book, as well, and I enjoyed learning more about them. The descriptions of Duncan make him absolutely swoon-worthy. (And, I don't swoon easily, haha!)
I struggled a bit with Mallory suddenly speaking in 21st-century vernacular. For me, it was understandable for that to happen within her inner circle, but it seemed as if she was doing so with one and all. It was a wee bit disappointing, as I had considered it to be HILARIOUS when Mallory tried to figure out how to speak as one would in the 19th century, in the first book.
Don't get me wrong. I still absolutely love this series, and will be tapping my foot impatiently as I wait for #3 to be written!!
Expected publication: May 23rd, 2023
A modern-day homicide detective is working as an undertaker's assistant in Victorian Scotland, when a serial poisoner attacks the men of Edinburgh and leaves their widows under suspicion.
This is the second book in the series and it can be read as a stand-alone, in my opinion. I loved The Poisoner's Ring, although not quite as much as I did A Rip Through Time. The wonderful characters from the first book (Isla, Duncan, Hugh, and of course Mallory!) are all in this book, as well, and I enjoyed learning more about them. The descriptions of Duncan make him absolutely swoon-worthy. (And, I don't swoon easily, haha!)
I struggled a bit with Mallory suddenly speaking in 21st-century vernacular. For me, it was understandable for that to happen within her inner circle, but it seemed as if she was doing so with one and all. It was a wee bit disappointing, as I had considered it to be HILARIOUS when Mallory tried to figure out how to speak as one would in the 19th century, in the first book.
Don't get me wrong. I still absolutely love this series, and will be tapping my foot impatiently as I wait for #3 to be written!!
March 18, 2023
Advance copy from NetGalley
Still having mixed feelings about this series, mainly a few problems with Mallory’s superhuman perception, her constant need to describe things as shitty, and how accepting the other characters are of everything she says. But I thought the mystery was really good—I didn’t come close to figuring it out until I was almost at the end. It felt like there was more historical detail this time around too, and I liked that. The author mentioned in the acknowledgements that she had gotten some things wrong in the first book, and some folks had set her straight.
So, Mallory. I’m not sure I’m convinced about how quickly she’s got everyone’s number. I know reading people is supposed to be one of her strengths, but it comes across almost as a superpower. She also makes a lot of modern pronouncements about things that Duncan, Isla, and McCready just seem to accept, I guess because she’s from the future? The characters who are in on her secret are open-minded types, true, but they’re still products of another time and culture—I would expect a little more pushback against some of what Mallory says, even with that knowledge.
That said, I do like the characters, even Mallory when she’s not being obnoxious. I thought maybe there would be some love stuff in this one, but alas, there are still only hints. Let’s get some smoochies going already, lady! Except then Mallory would overthink them and then she’d force a very modern conversation on Duncan about them, and…I don’t know, never mind.
No, just kidding. I for sure want smoochies. And Isla and McCready need to get busy too.
I’m curious where this will go with the time travel angle. I’m guessing something will happen in the next book that will clue us in to what happened in Mallory’s time after the switcheroo. I don’t know how many books are planned for this series, but I don’t think that aspect can be left hanging for much longer.
Still having mixed feelings about this series, mainly a few problems with Mallory’s superhuman perception, her constant need to describe things as shitty, and how accepting the other characters are of everything she says. But I thought the mystery was really good—I didn’t come close to figuring it out until I was almost at the end. It felt like there was more historical detail this time around too, and I liked that. The author mentioned in the acknowledgements that she had gotten some things wrong in the first book, and some folks had set her straight.
So, Mallory. I’m not sure I’m convinced about how quickly she’s got everyone’s number. I know reading people is supposed to be one of her strengths, but it comes across almost as a superpower. She also makes a lot of modern pronouncements about things that Duncan, Isla, and McCready just seem to accept, I guess because she’s from the future? The characters who are in on her secret are open-minded types, true, but they’re still products of another time and culture—I would expect a little more pushback against some of what Mallory says, even with that knowledge.
That said, I do like the characters, even Mallory when she’s not being obnoxious. I thought maybe there would be some love stuff in this one, but alas, there are still only hints. Let’s get some smoochies going already, lady! Except then Mallory would overthink them and then she’d force a very modern conversation on Duncan about them, and…I don’t know, never mind.
No, just kidding. I for sure want smoochies. And Isla and McCready need to get busy too.
I’m curious where this will go with the time travel angle. I’m guessing something will happen in the next book that will clue us in to what happened in Mallory’s time after the switcheroo. I don’t know how many books are planned for this series, but I don’t think that aspect can be left hanging for much longer.
May 29, 2023
I really was excited to read, and wanted to love, this novel set in Victorian Scotland featuring a strong female, time-traveling lead. I think what didn't work for me was the narrator and the drawn out wordiness of the story. It was tediously detailed and the humor seemed too snarky to work during the Victorian time period, even with knowing that there was time-travel involved.
I would say give it a chance, whether in print or audio, because the love of narrators is so subjective and the premise of the story seems good. Maybe it was just me?
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the audiobook ARC, which I very much appreciated the privilege of receiving in advance.
Publisher's Blurb: A modern-day homicide detective is working as an undertaker's assistant in Victorian Scotland when a serial poisoner attacks the men of Edinburgh and leaves their widows under suspicion.
Edinburgh, 1869: Modern-day homicide detective Mallory Atkinson is adjusting to her new life in Victorian Scotland. Her employers know she’s not housemaid Catriona Mitchell—even though Mallory is in Catriona’s body—and Mallory is now officially an undertaker’s assistant. Dr. Duncan Gray moonlights as a medical examiner, and their latest case hits close to home. Men are dropping dead from a powerful poison, and all signs point to the grieving widows… the latest of which is Gray’s oldest sister.
Poison is said to be a woman’s weapon, though Mallory has to wonder if it’s as simple as that. But she must tread carefully. Every move the household makes is being watched, and who knows where the investigation will lead.
I would say give it a chance, whether in print or audio, because the love of narrators is so subjective and the premise of the story seems good. Maybe it was just me?
Thank you to NetGalley and Macmillan Audio for the audiobook ARC, which I very much appreciated the privilege of receiving in advance.
Publisher's Blurb: A modern-day homicide detective is working as an undertaker's assistant in Victorian Scotland when a serial poisoner attacks the men of Edinburgh and leaves their widows under suspicion.
Edinburgh, 1869: Modern-day homicide detective Mallory Atkinson is adjusting to her new life in Victorian Scotland. Her employers know she’s not housemaid Catriona Mitchell—even though Mallory is in Catriona’s body—and Mallory is now officially an undertaker’s assistant. Dr. Duncan Gray moonlights as a medical examiner, and their latest case hits close to home. Men are dropping dead from a powerful poison, and all signs point to the grieving widows… the latest of which is Gray’s oldest sister.
Poison is said to be a woman’s weapon, though Mallory has to wonder if it’s as simple as that. But she must tread carefully. Every move the household makes is being watched, and who knows where the investigation will lead.
May 10, 2023
Poisonings in Victorian Edinburgh!
Some sort of time slip occurs and thirty year old Canadian police detective Mallory is trapped in someone else’s body in Victorian Edinburgh, 1869. As a maid in the Gray household! That is Dr. Duncan Gray, an undertaker and sometime forensic assistant to the crown, and his sister Isla who’s a chemist. An unusual household that ever since she’s come through some crack in time has welcomed Mallory, formerly Catroina.
Gray has allowed Mallory who had studied forensics in her previous life to become his assistant. The family is going to need all their wits about them and Mallory’s help when one of their own, their sister Annis’ husband, Lord Leslie is found murdered—poisoned.
Duncan, Mallory and Detective McCreadie have been following a series of fatal poisonings and Lord Leslie’s is the latest in the line. The victims have all been men whom it appears their wives have reason to be free of. The events take the poisonings to the next level—a poisoning ring!
Annis is high handed and estranged from her family. Her companion Sarah is assisting Annis but it is to her brother Duncan that Annis turns. What Duncan and Mallory discover is a poison but not arsenic, rather a heavy metal.
There’s a complicated cast of characters but each has its place in this intriguing, page turning saga.
I love the character of Mallory, street savvy, a fighter, but working in a body that’s not as fit as her 21st century body. She’s forever hampered by the clothing of the time, by not knowing the customs and expectations. This unknowing constantly trips Mallory up.
Dr. Duncan Gray is measured thoughtful and a fantastic foil for Mallory. Their relationship seems to be building in respect, possibly more, but there’s always Mallory’s thoughts of what happens when or if she’s wrenched back into her own time.
I’m not a fan of time slip stories but this second novel in the series has maintained the high standard of the first. I’m sold!
A St. Martin’s Press ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
Some sort of time slip occurs and thirty year old Canadian police detective Mallory is trapped in someone else’s body in Victorian Edinburgh, 1869. As a maid in the Gray household! That is Dr. Duncan Gray, an undertaker and sometime forensic assistant to the crown, and his sister Isla who’s a chemist. An unusual household that ever since she’s come through some crack in time has welcomed Mallory, formerly Catroina.
Gray has allowed Mallory who had studied forensics in her previous life to become his assistant. The family is going to need all their wits about them and Mallory’s help when one of their own, their sister Annis’ husband, Lord Leslie is found murdered—poisoned.
Duncan, Mallory and Detective McCreadie have been following a series of fatal poisonings and Lord Leslie’s is the latest in the line. The victims have all been men whom it appears their wives have reason to be free of. The events take the poisonings to the next level—a poisoning ring!
Annis is high handed and estranged from her family. Her companion Sarah is assisting Annis but it is to her brother Duncan that Annis turns. What Duncan and Mallory discover is a poison but not arsenic, rather a heavy metal.
There’s a complicated cast of characters but each has its place in this intriguing, page turning saga.
I love the character of Mallory, street savvy, a fighter, but working in a body that’s not as fit as her 21st century body. She’s forever hampered by the clothing of the time, by not knowing the customs and expectations. This unknowing constantly trips Mallory up.
Dr. Duncan Gray is measured thoughtful and a fantastic foil for Mallory. Their relationship seems to be building in respect, possibly more, but there’s always Mallory’s thoughts of what happens when or if she’s wrenched back into her own time.
I’m not a fan of time slip stories but this second novel in the series has maintained the high standard of the first. I’m sold!
A St. Martin’s Press ARC via NetGalley.
Many thanks to the author and publisher.
(Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.)
June 28, 2023
Another solid, well written and very entertaining novel in this series. I am loving this series, and I can’t wait until the next novel comes out! It’s definitely one of my new favorites.
I listened to the first novel once again, after receiving the second novel in the series from the library, and I wasn’t the slightest bit bored or anything. These characters are stellar, and really great to spend some time with.
My friend Luanne Ollivier wrote this wonderful review that I agree with in almost every way. I think you should go check it out:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
What I don’t agree with are these three things; 1) I think you should read these novels in order, but then again I’m a stickler for that kind of thing; 2) the character Mallory is Canadian and not American, and so the “inner American” accent that Luanne says the narrator uses for Mallory (the character) is Canadian, not American, and 3) - Mallory didn’t wake up in a hospital (in the first novel, but instead woke up in the guest bedroom of the Doctor that Catriona works for. Little things, I know. But like I said…. Stickler.
Kate Handford Is the amazing narrator for the audiobook version of this novel. I adore her many voice characterizations, accents, and wonderful acting while narrating. She is so emotive! I sincerely hope that Macmillan Audio not only keeps Handford on for the entirety of this series, but also gives Ms. Handford many more audiobooks to narrate in the future.
4 stars, and highly recommended.
I listened to the first novel once again, after receiving the second novel in the series from the library, and I wasn’t the slightest bit bored or anything. These characters are stellar, and really great to spend some time with.
My friend Luanne Ollivier wrote this wonderful review that I agree with in almost every way. I think you should go check it out:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
What I don’t agree with are these three things; 1) I think you should read these novels in order, but then again I’m a stickler for that kind of thing; 2) the character Mallory is Canadian and not American, and so the “inner American” accent that Luanne says the narrator uses for Mallory (the character) is Canadian, not American, and 3) - Mallory didn’t wake up in a hospital (in the first novel, but instead woke up in the guest bedroom of the Doctor that Catriona works for. Little things, I know. But like I said…. Stickler.
Kate Handford Is the amazing narrator for the audiobook version of this novel. I adore her many voice characterizations, accents, and wonderful acting while narrating. She is so emotive! I sincerely hope that Macmillan Audio not only keeps Handford on for the entirety of this series, but also gives Ms. Handford many more audiobooks to narrate in the future.
4 stars, and highly recommended.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,140 reviews