“How much sense would a mind which is not our own make to us?”
Short stories about the clash of cultures, ideas and way of life. How to react meeting aliens? What to do when one does not understand the other?
Compassion? One would hope so! Action? Could well have adverse effects. Violence?
Sure that would be the last resort! All these reactions pass in these stories.
I gave them all 3*, but almost the whole bundle is 4*, as the whole is more than the sum of the parts. They are a good reflection of life’s choices when encountering species, humans one does not understand.
* The Horn of Time the Hunter (1963)
Space faring survivors look for remnants of ancient civilisations on a faraway planet. They do find traces. Ancient crumbling cities. But no traces of inhabitants. Where are they? And how did the downfall happen? 3*
* A Man to my Wounding (1959)
A world where war is replaced by assassinating each others leaders. Not the common man is slaughtered on the killing fields, but the people in charge. Seemingly a step forward? Regarding WWI and WWII one could think so. This story was written in the middle of the cold war. But where does that end?
We follow one of the secret government hitman on his quest to prevent an assassination. 3*
* The High Ones (1958)
Man’s first voyage beyond the sun. When they encounter a different, seemingly highly advanced species, things go wrong.
p.49: “How much sense would a mind which is not human make to us?”
Or, how far can a species (d)evolve? 3*
* The Man who came came Early (1956)
What to do when you’re transported back in time almost a 1000 years? How do you adapt? If at all.
Interesting in the sense that going back in time and meeting those people is simular to meeting alien cultures on far away planets: prone to misunderstanding and mishap.
A time travel story. 3*
* Marius (1957)
How to govern after you’ve won the war? Are generals the ones best suited to lead devastated countries out of misery? Or should it be left to the men with vision?
Two war generals, old friends, now on opposite sites, have a dramatic dispute which will decide the future. 3*
* Progress (1962)
In a post apocalyptic world, where civilisations start anew and are sort of isolated, a solution to prevent a cold war to even start, is narrated.
A plea for sustainability. More is not better.
p.144: “If industrialism was satisfying, why did the industrial world commit suicide?”
But is it not presumptuous to think that one knows best? 3*