What do you think?
Rate this book
Petra Luna #2
The Other Side of the River
A novel about building a new life in America. Strong and determined, Petra Luna returns in a story about the immigrant experience.
Petra Luna is in America, having escaped the Mexican Revolution and the terror of the Federales. Now that they are safe, Petra and her family can begin again, in this country that promises so much. Still, twelve-year-old Petra knows that her abuelita, little sister, and baby brother depend on her to survive. She leads her family from a smallpox-stricken refugee camp on the Texas border to the buzzing city of San Antonio, where they work hard to build a new life. And for the first time ever, Petra has a chance to learn to read and write.
Yet Petra also sees in America attitudes she thought she'd left behind on the other side of the Río Grande―people who look down on her mestizo skin and bare feet, who think someone like her doesn't deserve more from life. Petra wants more. Isn't that what the revolution is about? Her strength and courage will be tested like never before as she fights for herself, her family, and her dreams.
Petra Luna is in America, having escaped the Mexican Revolution and the terror of the Federales. Now that they are safe, Petra and her family can begin again, in this country that promises so much. Still, twelve-year-old Petra knows that her abuelita, little sister, and baby brother depend on her to survive. She leads her family from a smallpox-stricken refugee camp on the Texas border to the buzzing city of San Antonio, where they work hard to build a new life. And for the first time ever, Petra has a chance to learn to read and write.
Yet Petra also sees in America attitudes she thought she'd left behind on the other side of the Río Grande―people who look down on her mestizo skin and bare feet, who think someone like her doesn't deserve more from life. Petra wants more. Isn't that what the revolution is about? Her strength and courage will be tested like never before as she fights for herself, her family, and her dreams.
351 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2022
15 people are currently reading
1758 people want to read
About the author
Alda P. Dobbs
6 books77 followersAlda P. Dobbs' upcoming novel, BAREFOOT DREAMS OF PETRA LUNA, was inspired by her great-grandmother's experience during the Mexican Revolution in 1913. Alda was born in a small town in northern Mexico and moved to San Antonio, Texas as a child. She studied physics and worked as an engineer before pursuing her love of storytelling. She is as passionate about connecting children to their past, their communities, different cultures, science, and nature as she is about writing.
Alda's writings have won various awards including the Barbara Deming Memorial Fund Award and the Sustainable Arts Foundation Grant. She has also written articles for Highlights Children's Magazine, Guideposts, and La Prensa newspaper.
Alda lives with her husband and two children outside Houston, Texas.
Alda's writings have won various awards including the Barbara Deming Memorial Fund Award and the Sustainable Arts Foundation Grant. She has also written articles for Highlights Children's Magazine, Guideposts, and La Prensa newspaper.
Alda lives with her husband and two children outside Houston, Texas.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 57 reviews
June 29, 2022
I still remember what I felt the entire time while reading the author's first book. I went blindly into this new book as I already know I would love the writing and the characters would remain memorable once I get to know them.
Sure! My expectations lived to see the moment of joy as the book doesn't disappoint at all.
It is more than what the blurb says (it's okay to not read the blurb or know anything about the book before you pick it up). I can assure you the book is heartwrenching and would fill your being with hope.
Now my determination not to waste a morsel of food stands stronger. You will know why when you read this story.
This is the story of Petra Luna who's trying to survive; feed herself and her family by taking whatever small jobs she could find. I appreciate the gender role stereotype discussion at these parts.
The writing is beautiful. The characters, both adults and the main character, fits perfectly with the plot and their roles. Author, such a huge improvement in the second book! I find the characters are more well developed, the story more wholesome and detailed.
Hard times of poverty, hunger, migration and diseases you will get to know a lot more about the people in such situations. No child should work to feed themselves and no child should go hungry we say. But where are we for such children and their suffering families?
Amazing book!
Thank you, SOURCEBOOKS Kids, for tgmhe advance reading copy.
Sure! My expectations lived to see the moment of joy as the book doesn't disappoint at all.
It is more than what the blurb says (it's okay to not read the blurb or know anything about the book before you pick it up). I can assure you the book is heartwrenching and would fill your being with hope.
Now my determination not to waste a morsel of food stands stronger. You will know why when you read this story.
This is the story of Petra Luna who's trying to survive; feed herself and her family by taking whatever small jobs she could find. I appreciate the gender role stereotype discussion at these parts.
The writing is beautiful. The characters, both adults and the main character, fits perfectly with the plot and their roles. Author, such a huge improvement in the second book! I find the characters are more well developed, the story more wholesome and detailed.
Hard times of poverty, hunger, migration and diseases you will get to know a lot more about the people in such situations. No child should work to feed themselves and no child should go hungry we say. But where are we for such children and their suffering families?
Amazing book!
Thank you, SOURCEBOOKS Kids, for tgmhe advance reading copy.
January 3, 2023
What could have been an immigrant story of hardship and despair about Petra a young girl who finds herself in San Antonio with her abuelita (grandmother) and younger siblings after fleeing her home country during the Mexican Revolution turns out to be a story about the kindness of others, determination and a little bit of luck. If you like classic stories like Heidi with themes of overcoming adversity or uplifting stories like Ways to Make Sunshine or Piecing Me Together by Renee Watson, give this one a try.
July 11, 2023
I LOVED this book. I've always wanted to learn more about Mexican history and I don't think I've ever read a historical fiction book that focused on it like this one. I learned so much and it was all so wonderfully written - I would recommend this, especially for people who want to learn about the colonial aftermath of Spanish rule in Mexico - the tiered system that looked down on dark meztisos, or indigenous mixed people who were the majority of the makeup of Mexico and who built the haciendas that the rich dwelled in. I know that Mexico is big into colorism (*sarcastic yippee*) and this book explores the history of how that happened - as well as just general immigration story and how the US helped Mexicans who were fleeing violence during the Mexican Revolution.
August 13, 2022
Last year I read Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna by Alda P. Dobbs, and thoroughly enjoyed it - which is why I was super happy to find out that there was a sequel in the works! The Other Side of the River picks up from where Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna left off - in the refugee camp in Texas, on the other side of the river from the country Petra and her family were fleeing from. Petra and her family must now figure out how to survive in the US, while continuing to yearn for the Mexico they have lost and Petra’s father who was abducted by the federales.
Petra struggles to find work that will allow them to stay in the US, so she takes a chance and buys some tickets for San Antonio, where she and her family start to settle down. There is work, albeit not stable, and a place they can call home, as well as new friends, and a way for Petra to continue to aspire towards her dreams of learning to read and write.
You can’t help falling in love with Petra: she’s tough and resilient, constantly looking out for her family, but she is also still a child, and I love how the author maintains that balance through the narrative. I also love how the author provides an accurate and detailed history lesson into a part of Mexican and US history that I think is important for us all to understand - and this book also provides an outline for the fight that continues to take place in Mexico, where indigenous Mexicans are still treated like lesser citizens. I know that this book was written for children, but honestly it can be read and enjoyed by everyone - the writing is smart, inclusive, and makes you feel like you are right there with Petra and her family. Highly recommended, again!!
Petra struggles to find work that will allow them to stay in the US, so she takes a chance and buys some tickets for San Antonio, where she and her family start to settle down. There is work, albeit not stable, and a place they can call home, as well as new friends, and a way for Petra to continue to aspire towards her dreams of learning to read and write.
You can’t help falling in love with Petra: she’s tough and resilient, constantly looking out for her family, but she is also still a child, and I love how the author maintains that balance through the narrative. I also love how the author provides an accurate and detailed history lesson into a part of Mexican and US history that I think is important for us all to understand - and this book also provides an outline for the fight that continues to take place in Mexico, where indigenous Mexicans are still treated like lesser citizens. I know that this book was written for children, but honestly it can be read and enjoyed by everyone - the writing is smart, inclusive, and makes you feel like you are right there with Petra and her family. Highly recommended, again!!
August 29, 2022
In the year of 1913, Petra Luna and her family escaped the Federales in Mexico and made their way to safety in the United States. Upon their arrival, Petra, her abuelita, and younger sister and brother were then placed into a refugee camp along the Texas/Mexico border. Initially they were provided a place to stay, but now with smallpox and hunger raging through the camp, Petra was in need of a new plan. With the Federales being pushed out of the village nearby in Mexico, the camp made plans to close. Everyone who could work were offered jobs, and anyone left behind would need to return to Mexico. Then Petra learns of a train headed to San Antonio and makes a bargain for the remaining seats, hoping that they'll be able to build a better life there.
At twelve, almost thirteen, Petra was out looking for work as soon as they arrived in San Antonio and does land a job working for the Chili Queen, Dona Carmen. She also finds them a place to stay in a rundown apartment. Petra works hard at her new job, while her abuelita takes care of her siblings. They even manage to save some money with the pecans that her Abuelita shells. Then an unfortunate misunderstanding leads Petra to lose her job, and in dire need for an income, Petra turns to Sister Nora, a nun at the Wesley House for help and is offered a position as her assistant. As Petra begins to spend more time with Sister Nora, they begin to learn of the commonalities that they share, like how Sister Nora and her sister escaped the potato famine of Ireland, and they also begin to develop a strong friendship. The sister is also helpful in teaching Petra how to read and write, as well as opening up an opportunity for her to attend school for the first time. The story has a nice resolution and sees a positive future for Petra and her family.
The Other Side of the River is a continuation of the author's first book, Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna which was inspired by her great-grandmother's experience during the Mexican Revolution of 1913. I think it's important to have read Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna first to have the full picture of Petra's story. She's a really courageous girl and her determination and bravery to lead her family across the desert to safety in the United States is commendable and it's a story that shouldn't be skipped over.
This is the kind of historical fiction that will really resonate with the reader. Even now when I think of how very young Petra was, twelve years old, who can imagine working at that age? All the hardships she had to endure. Not to mention having three other people depend on your wages to sustain them. She's a really remarkable girl, and such a hard worker, even during difficult circumstances. While I was reading, her struggles feel like your struggles, and you want her to succeed. For her dreams of being able to read and write to come true. It really is a step back in time and a reflection of one girl's resilience. A really beautiful series and I enjoyed being immersed in Petra's new life in San Antonio. I also really enjoyed the authors note and learning of how the authors experiences growing up in Texas were incorporated into the story as well as the origins for the school mentioned. Favorite lines "There is great power in the written word..." "Spoken words are like old winter leaves-they're easily spun, blown away, and forgotten."
A huge thank you to Alda Dobbs for the review copy in exchange for an honest review.
At twelve, almost thirteen, Petra was out looking for work as soon as they arrived in San Antonio and does land a job working for the Chili Queen, Dona Carmen. She also finds them a place to stay in a rundown apartment. Petra works hard at her new job, while her abuelita takes care of her siblings. They even manage to save some money with the pecans that her Abuelita shells. Then an unfortunate misunderstanding leads Petra to lose her job, and in dire need for an income, Petra turns to Sister Nora, a nun at the Wesley House for help and is offered a position as her assistant. As Petra begins to spend more time with Sister Nora, they begin to learn of the commonalities that they share, like how Sister Nora and her sister escaped the potato famine of Ireland, and they also begin to develop a strong friendship. The sister is also helpful in teaching Petra how to read and write, as well as opening up an opportunity for her to attend school for the first time. The story has a nice resolution and sees a positive future for Petra and her family.
The Other Side of the River is a continuation of the author's first book, Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna which was inspired by her great-grandmother's experience during the Mexican Revolution of 1913. I think it's important to have read Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna first to have the full picture of Petra's story. She's a really courageous girl and her determination and bravery to lead her family across the desert to safety in the United States is commendable and it's a story that shouldn't be skipped over.
This is the kind of historical fiction that will really resonate with the reader. Even now when I think of how very young Petra was, twelve years old, who can imagine working at that age? All the hardships she had to endure. Not to mention having three other people depend on your wages to sustain them. She's a really remarkable girl, and such a hard worker, even during difficult circumstances. While I was reading, her struggles feel like your struggles, and you want her to succeed. For her dreams of being able to read and write to come true. It really is a step back in time and a reflection of one girl's resilience. A really beautiful series and I enjoyed being immersed in Petra's new life in San Antonio. I also really enjoyed the authors note and learning of how the authors experiences growing up in Texas were incorporated into the story as well as the origins for the school mentioned. Favorite lines "There is great power in the written word..." "Spoken words are like old winter leaves-they're easily spun, blown away, and forgotten."
A huge thank you to Alda Dobbs for the review copy in exchange for an honest review.
January 21, 2023
The Other Side of the River is the second book in the Petra Luna series and picks up minutes after the first book ends. Petra and her family have made it into the U.S. and they are being settled into a refugee camp. The camp is to find families work and send them on their way, or return them to Mexico if they can't find suitable work. Most of the contractors are looking for men and older children to employ, so Petra is in trouble. Her siblings and abuelita are not suitable for work, and noone is willing to hire a twelve year old girl who had three dependents. Once again, her resourcefulness plays in her favour and she is able to get train tickets to San Antonio. Once there, they find a place to live and she gets a job. Things are not easy, but she meets some people who want to help her and she finds a few good jobs. She learns to read and is able to take care of her family.
This is a wonderful book, but it is quite emotional. The things that Petra had to deal with were not pleasant, including the way she is treated by wealthy Mexican people. She worked hard from daybreak to sundown for a low wage, and when someone's relative comes along, she is quickly let go and left to flounder. These refugees wanted to work, they worked hard and were taking jobs that no one else wanted. This story also shows the importance of education and how hard Petra works to become educated to get ahead. This is a great middle grade book showing how many Mexican families ended up in the U.S. and became prosperous due to hard work. Once again the audiobook was narrated by Ana Osorio who does an excellent job with this story and makes it easy to listen to.
This is a wonderful book, but it is quite emotional. The things that Petra had to deal with were not pleasant, including the way she is treated by wealthy Mexican people. She worked hard from daybreak to sundown for a low wage, and when someone's relative comes along, she is quickly let go and left to flounder. These refugees wanted to work, they worked hard and were taking jobs that no one else wanted. This story also shows the importance of education and how hard Petra works to become educated to get ahead. This is a great middle grade book showing how many Mexican families ended up in the U.S. and became prosperous due to hard work. Once again the audiobook was narrated by Ana Osorio who does an excellent job with this story and makes it easy to listen to.
January 8, 2023
My son is participating in a “Book Quiz Bowl” sponsored by our library and one of the books assigned was “The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna”, the first in this series. I read along with him so I could help him prepare for the quiz.
I immediately fell in love with the characters, the drama, the history of “Barefoot Dreams”. And when I learned there was a sequel, I immediately got my hands on a copy of “The Other Side of the River.”
“Barefoot Dreams” was based on the author’s great grandmother’s experiences during the Mexican Revolution, while “River” imagines what life may have been if her great-grandmother had stayed in the US. Before reading either of these books, I knew astonishingly little about this period in American history, especially from the perspective of Mexican refugees. Both books do an excellent job of presenting this subject matter in an age-appropriate manner that ignites curiosity and encourages conversation and additional research. To me, that’s exactly what historical fiction should do - excite the reader to learn more about a specific time and place.
Many sequels of classic children’s lit don’t hold up, but “River” is not one of those. The characters are just as complex and the pacing and drama are just as intense as in “Barefoot Dreams”. And this book, like the last, leaves us on a bit of a cliffhanger, so I hope Alda P. Donna is working on the third installment of Petra Luna!
I immediately fell in love with the characters, the drama, the history of “Barefoot Dreams”. And when I learned there was a sequel, I immediately got my hands on a copy of “The Other Side of the River.”
“Barefoot Dreams” was based on the author’s great grandmother’s experiences during the Mexican Revolution, while “River” imagines what life may have been if her great-grandmother had stayed in the US. Before reading either of these books, I knew astonishingly little about this period in American history, especially from the perspective of Mexican refugees. Both books do an excellent job of presenting this subject matter in an age-appropriate manner that ignites curiosity and encourages conversation and additional research. To me, that’s exactly what historical fiction should do - excite the reader to learn more about a specific time and place.
Many sequels of classic children’s lit don’t hold up, but “River” is not one of those. The characters are just as complex and the pacing and drama are just as intense as in “Barefoot Dreams”. And this book, like the last, leaves us on a bit of a cliffhanger, so I hope Alda P. Donna is working on the third installment of Petra Luna!
November 28, 2022
This is the follow-up to Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna and is even better. Dobbs continues the story with rich details of finding “home” when one is a refuge. Petra, a plucky 12 year old, fulfills a promise to her Papa to keep the family safe by finding work, friends, and hope. Especially moving is her relationship with Sister Nora, a nun who came to America from Ireland as a child and whose story parallels Petra’s. This book is ripe for discussion with middle graders and young teens.
May 1, 2022
Such a great addition to Petra's story. As a reader, I love historical fiction, but I especially love the connections to learning, refugees, and Texas history that can be found in this follow-up to The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna. Happy to finish this ARC before sharing with a student I know will love it.
August 29, 2022
A moving sequel to Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna. Such a moving account of the plight of immigrants from Mexico during the revolution. In this second book we see what happens to Petra and her family once they are safely in the US after crossing the river. As the situation in their home country is favoring the revolutionaries, should they go back? Petra and Abuelita decide to try to find work and take a train to San Antonio. Highlights from the times include the Chili Queens, harvesting pecans, and plans to establish a school for the displaced peoples like Petra's family. The work ethic and tenacity of Petra and her family are so inspiring. You can't help but root for her to persist and thrive. It is not easy. One of my favorite scenes is the opening of Sister Nora's hidden foot locker filled with albums and books and other treasures. When a Victrola is found to play those records on, they have a proper dance party. I can see an Irish nun kicking up her heels to do an jig, but have a hard time believing she would be a promoter of Darwin's evolutionary theories. That detail seemed out of character. All in all, though, such an insightful look into the early 21st century on our southern border.
Thank you to Sourcebooks and Edelweiss+ for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.
Thank you to Sourcebooks and Edelweiss+ for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.
September 18, 2023
What a necessary portrayal of the immigrant experience. Another great YA read!
April 27, 2023
Petra, her sister, baby brother, and Abuelita have made it to the US on the other side of the river. But now what? The refugee camp will only be set up for a limited amount of time. Petra needs to find a job to support her family and get them a more permanent place to live. It's a lot of pressure on her shoulders, and what about her dreams to learn to read and write?
Alda Dobbs does an amazing job of making the plight of refugees, the messiness of Mexican revolution, and Austin, Texas of 1913 come to vivid life. It is hard for someone from a stable home life and country not torn apart by war to imagine a tween girl being the breadwinner for a family. It is heartbreaking but still a reality in several places in the world today. Petra has a rough road in this novel but it never gets too overwhelmingly hard; there are rays of hope and kind people, like the Irish American nun, Sister Nora. Abuelita is a loving grandmother but she is also a bit superstitious (usually mixing traditional Aztec beliefs with Catholicism, which accurately reflects the beliefs of some people from her culture and time period) and this sometimes adds to Petra's stress. And unfortunately, Abuelita's life experience has led her to believe that all "people like them" are good for is hard labor, not anything above that; and she sometimes hinders Petra's chances of getting better jobs because of this. When it comes to guiding Petra through priorities and character, though, Abuelita shines. Petra has a steep uphill climb, and she still doesn't know if her father is dead or alive since he was conscripted into the army. That said, Petra is a hard worker, she loves her family, and she does meet kind people. The story is ultimately hopeful and will likely make many readers realize what a privilege it is to have all your basic needs taken care of and to be able to get an education. It should also grow empathy for refugees. I liked learning about 1913 Austin and the hot pot of cultures that were there at that time. The book highlights the mix of American, Mexican, German, Irish, and Chinese people in Austin during this time period. Overall, a very satisfying follow up to Petra's first story.
Notes on content: No swearing. Petra and others have degrading and racist comments directed at them, but the book does a good job of speaking to all of these. No sexual content. Someone shares with Petra what it was like to fight in the war and the use of child soldiers going on in Mexico. This isn't anywhere near as descriptive as it could have been. It is sobering and the horror of war is conveyed without many gory details. An accident that results in a bad cut is part of the story. The Irish potato famine is brought up, and how that affected people. Deaths from disease are mentioned, and one is mildly described. Petra faces discrimination because of her gender and age as well as ethnicity and social status.
Alda Dobbs does an amazing job of making the plight of refugees, the messiness of Mexican revolution, and Austin, Texas of 1913 come to vivid life. It is hard for someone from a stable home life and country not torn apart by war to imagine a tween girl being the breadwinner for a family. It is heartbreaking but still a reality in several places in the world today. Petra has a rough road in this novel but it never gets too overwhelmingly hard; there are rays of hope and kind people, like the Irish American nun, Sister Nora. Abuelita is a loving grandmother but she is also a bit superstitious (usually mixing traditional Aztec beliefs with Catholicism, which accurately reflects the beliefs of some people from her culture and time period) and this sometimes adds to Petra's stress. And unfortunately, Abuelita's life experience has led her to believe that all "people like them" are good for is hard labor, not anything above that; and she sometimes hinders Petra's chances of getting better jobs because of this. When it comes to guiding Petra through priorities and character, though, Abuelita shines. Petra has a steep uphill climb, and she still doesn't know if her father is dead or alive since he was conscripted into the army. That said, Petra is a hard worker, she loves her family, and she does meet kind people. The story is ultimately hopeful and will likely make many readers realize what a privilege it is to have all your basic needs taken care of and to be able to get an education. It should also grow empathy for refugees. I liked learning about 1913 Austin and the hot pot of cultures that were there at that time. The book highlights the mix of American, Mexican, German, Irish, and Chinese people in Austin during this time period. Overall, a very satisfying follow up to Petra's first story.
Notes on content: No swearing. Petra and others have degrading and racist comments directed at them, but the book does a good job of speaking to all of these. No sexual content. Someone shares with Petra what it was like to fight in the war and the use of child soldiers going on in Mexico. This isn't anywhere near as descriptive as it could have been. It is sobering and the horror of war is conveyed without many gory details. An accident that results in a bad cut is part of the story. The Irish potato famine is brought up, and how that affected people. Deaths from disease are mentioned, and one is mildly described. Petra faces discrimination because of her gender and age as well as ethnicity and social status.
July 20, 2022
The immediacy and danger of the Mexican Revolution launched twelve-year-old Petra Luna unceremoniously into a life in a new country on the other side of the Río Bravo. Instead of finding the peace and prosperity promised by her expectations of America, however, Petra and her family are shuttled into a refugee camp where the threats of hunger and smallpox are ever present. As time passes, Petra and her family make friends with others, and each new day teaches them more about this new country they call home. While the path forward is not always easy, Petra keeps a firm eye on her dreams and will stop at nothing to make them come true.
This continuation of Petra Luna’s story begins shortly after the first book ends and does an excellent job reminding readers of the highlights of the previous installment. It is not critical to have read the first book before engaging with this one, but the back story helps readers better connect to Petra and understand what has made her into the young woman she is becoming. Like in the first book, this story is filled with Spanish language and culture, both of which are woven expertly into the narrative. Readers are introduced to Spanish vocabulary with italics initially, and subsequent mentions of these words appear alongside their English cousins. While this may be unconventional in its approach, it gives readers the clear understanding that for Petra—and for many others—Spanish and English coexist in inextricable harmony.
Beautifully crafted, this story reads somewhat like a diary, immersing readers in Petra’s world as she matures beyond her years. As the oldest child in her family, she must shoulder many of the burdens of ensuring her kin have food to eat and a roof over their heads. Not to mention, Petra must learn all about a new culture and its intrinsic expectations in the process. Dobbs has built upon inspiration from her own family history in this novel that incorporates true events from 1913 with fictional characters that thoughtfully represent real people who lived during this tumultuous time. Filled with cultural references, traditional foods, Spanish language, and deep family connections, this narrative is rich and fulfilling for readers of all ages. This is not only a compelling extension of Petra’s initial tale; it is also an important addition to historical fiction collections for middle grade readers.
This continuation of Petra Luna’s story begins shortly after the first book ends and does an excellent job reminding readers of the highlights of the previous installment. It is not critical to have read the first book before engaging with this one, but the back story helps readers better connect to Petra and understand what has made her into the young woman she is becoming. Like in the first book, this story is filled with Spanish language and culture, both of which are woven expertly into the narrative. Readers are introduced to Spanish vocabulary with italics initially, and subsequent mentions of these words appear alongside their English cousins. While this may be unconventional in its approach, it gives readers the clear understanding that for Petra—and for many others—Spanish and English coexist in inextricable harmony.
Beautifully crafted, this story reads somewhat like a diary, immersing readers in Petra’s world as she matures beyond her years. As the oldest child in her family, she must shoulder many of the burdens of ensuring her kin have food to eat and a roof over their heads. Not to mention, Petra must learn all about a new culture and its intrinsic expectations in the process. Dobbs has built upon inspiration from her own family history in this novel that incorporates true events from 1913 with fictional characters that thoughtfully represent real people who lived during this tumultuous time. Filled with cultural references, traditional foods, Spanish language, and deep family connections, this narrative is rich and fulfilling for readers of all ages. This is not only a compelling extension of Petra’s initial tale; it is also an important addition to historical fiction collections for middle grade readers.
October 5, 2022
I’ll start my review by saying the cover of The Other Side Of The River is so beautiful. In this book, I meet Petra Luna because I didn’t know about Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna. The book reads fine as a stand alone, but I’m compelled to read the first book after finishing this one,
Petra, along with her younger brother and sister and her abuelita are now on the United States’ side of the border. They have bravely and daringly crossed from Mexico into the United States territory to escape the Mexican War.Petra Luna is only a young teen, yet she is now the family matriarch. She is desperately searching for work to provide shelter and food for her displaced family.
Now in San Antonio, Petra soon learns that on this side of the border, her dreams of opportunity and riches quickly diminish. She relates: “I had walked most of the streets in town, and none were paved with gold or sprinkled with diamonds like I’d once imagined. They were dull and muddy and made from packed earth like the ones back home” (p. 14).
In this new journey, Petra crosses paths with multiple immigrants and refugees who have traveled much further than she and her own family. One day Petra meets Don Wong, a Chinese store owner, and Sister Nora, an Irish Catholic nun who immigrated from Ireland to escape the potato famine. She reconnects with her own Mexican refugee cousin as he travels throughout the Western part of what is now the United States, working in the railroad system.
Petra sadly learns that American attitudes she thought she’d left behind on the other side of the Río Grande, in other words, the people who look down on her mestizo skin and bare feet, who think someone like her doesn’t deserve more from life. Petra is determined to get more out for life. She finds her strength and courage tested like never before as she fights for herself, her family, and her dreams.
Petra’s story is set on the streets of San Antonio in 1913. The relationship between Petra and her family is heartwarmig. She loves and protects her sister, but sometimes feels annoyed by her. Petra had to become very mature for her age at twelve, almost thirteen. She feels the pressure of being a provider for her family and keeping the promise to her father to keep the family safe.
A beautiful and touching work of historical fiction.
Petra, along with her younger brother and sister and her abuelita are now on the United States’ side of the border. They have bravely and daringly crossed from Mexico into the United States territory to escape the Mexican War.Petra Luna is only a young teen, yet she is now the family matriarch. She is desperately searching for work to provide shelter and food for her displaced family.
Now in San Antonio, Petra soon learns that on this side of the border, her dreams of opportunity and riches quickly diminish. She relates: “I had walked most of the streets in town, and none were paved with gold or sprinkled with diamonds like I’d once imagined. They were dull and muddy and made from packed earth like the ones back home” (p. 14).
In this new journey, Petra crosses paths with multiple immigrants and refugees who have traveled much further than she and her own family. One day Petra meets Don Wong, a Chinese store owner, and Sister Nora, an Irish Catholic nun who immigrated from Ireland to escape the potato famine. She reconnects with her own Mexican refugee cousin as he travels throughout the Western part of what is now the United States, working in the railroad system.
Petra sadly learns that American attitudes she thought she’d left behind on the other side of the Río Grande, in other words, the people who look down on her mestizo skin and bare feet, who think someone like her doesn’t deserve more from life. Petra is determined to get more out for life. She finds her strength and courage tested like never before as she fights for herself, her family, and her dreams.
Petra’s story is set on the streets of San Antonio in 1913. The relationship between Petra and her family is heartwarmig. She loves and protects her sister, but sometimes feels annoyed by her. Petra had to become very mature for her age at twelve, almost thirteen. She feels the pressure of being a provider for her family and keeping the promise to her father to keep the family safe.
A beautiful and touching work of historical fiction.
August 26, 2022
For this and other book reviews, visit www.bargain-sleuth.com.
Last year, when I read #NetGalley #ARCReview: Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna by Alda P. Dobbs, I was blown away by this children’s book that didn’t read like a children’s book. That book was so good at bringing young Petra’s world to life, I was sure it would be short-listed for the Newbery. I was wrong, although the book was the New York Public Library Book of the Year.
Happily, I discovered a sequel, The Other Side of the River, whose publication date is September 6, 2022. I received an Advanced Reader’s Copy of the book from NetGalley and Sourcebooks in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
I did not think a sequel to The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna could be as good as the original. But in some ways, The Other Side of the River surpasses the original book. While the original book shared the plight of Petra’s family as they try to flee Mexico, the new book is completely different. Petra and her family are now in America, making their way to San Antonio, following the revolution in Mexico.
The trials and tribulations that Petra has to go through in this book are even greater than in the original book. Taking on the responsibilities of taking care of her family at such a young age, always hustling, always thinking, trying to better herself. These are all things that readers young and old can connect with. Dealing with an unfeeling boss, then finding a better place of employment, with better wages and benefits, is just one of the many life lessons one can learn from this book. The strength of family and caring for one another in unparalleled. To take on the burden of caring for a younger sister and brother as well as her grandmother is terrifying yet necessary to Petra’s growth as a person.
I don’t want to get into specifics here because I want you to be surprised at the book’s twists and turns as I did, but suffice it to say that once I was winding up this satisfying read, I could tell the door was open to a third book in the series, for which I was truly grateful. I hope I’m right, because this is the type of children’s book that needs to be written and read.
Last year, when I read #NetGalley #ARCReview: Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna by Alda P. Dobbs, I was blown away by this children’s book that didn’t read like a children’s book. That book was so good at bringing young Petra’s world to life, I was sure it would be short-listed for the Newbery. I was wrong, although the book was the New York Public Library Book of the Year.
Happily, I discovered a sequel, The Other Side of the River, whose publication date is September 6, 2022. I received an Advanced Reader’s Copy of the book from NetGalley and Sourcebooks in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own.
I did not think a sequel to The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna could be as good as the original. But in some ways, The Other Side of the River surpasses the original book. While the original book shared the plight of Petra’s family as they try to flee Mexico, the new book is completely different. Petra and her family are now in America, making their way to San Antonio, following the revolution in Mexico.
The trials and tribulations that Petra has to go through in this book are even greater than in the original book. Taking on the responsibilities of taking care of her family at such a young age, always hustling, always thinking, trying to better herself. These are all things that readers young and old can connect with. Dealing with an unfeeling boss, then finding a better place of employment, with better wages and benefits, is just one of the many life lessons one can learn from this book. The strength of family and caring for one another in unparalleled. To take on the burden of caring for a younger sister and brother as well as her grandmother is terrifying yet necessary to Petra’s growth as a person.
I don’t want to get into specifics here because I want you to be surprised at the book’s twists and turns as I did, but suffice it to say that once I was winding up this satisfying read, I could tell the door was open to a third book in the series, for which I was truly grateful. I hope I’m right, because this is the type of children’s book that needs to be written and read.
September 6, 2022
In September 2021, I closed Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna with mixed feelings. Relief came first when Petra, her little sister, her baby brother, and her abuelita formed part of the crowd escaping the Federales across the narrow bridge into the United States just before the gates were closed. Still, I impatiently wanted answers to other questions and mentioned in my review that I really needed for the sequel to come soon. Fortunately, the rest of the story was in progress, and Author Alda Dobbs read my review and took pity on my impatience. She was kind enough to send me an advance reading copy of The Other Side of the River to cut my wait for the rest of the story.
In this sequel, twelve-year-old Petra must find a way in this world that is totally new to her. First there is the immigrant camp with the double death threats of smallpox and hunger. Soon soldiers are putting up a fence around the camp which makes Petra wonder, “If the river was fierce enough to stop the Federales, why would we need a fence?” Her bargaining for a way to get to San Antonio trades one set of problems for another. The struggle in the city is real as Petra must sort out those she can trust as she tries to earn enough money to feed her family. She must face attitudes she thought she had left behind as people take more note of her bare feet and brown skin than of her abilities. Her dream of learning to read becomes a distant loss in the shuffle for survival until she meets Sister Nora.
The author’s note is not to be missed as she pays her own homage to the people who helped Petra, whose character is based on her great-grandmother, find her place in the new land. The entirety of Alda’s story draws much of its essence from her own family history. Her account of a real connection to Wilbur J. Knox who has a prominent place in this very realistic fiction brought tears to this retired teacher.
This is a book for those who love gritty protagonists who make their way through difficult circumstances. It is especially for those who love it when that way leads through a path of education.
In this sequel, twelve-year-old Petra must find a way in this world that is totally new to her. First there is the immigrant camp with the double death threats of smallpox and hunger. Soon soldiers are putting up a fence around the camp which makes Petra wonder, “If the river was fierce enough to stop the Federales, why would we need a fence?” Her bargaining for a way to get to San Antonio trades one set of problems for another. The struggle in the city is real as Petra must sort out those she can trust as she tries to earn enough money to feed her family. She must face attitudes she thought she had left behind as people take more note of her bare feet and brown skin than of her abilities. Her dream of learning to read becomes a distant loss in the shuffle for survival until she meets Sister Nora.
The author’s note is not to be missed as she pays her own homage to the people who helped Petra, whose character is based on her great-grandmother, find her place in the new land. The entirety of Alda’s story draws much of its essence from her own family history. Her account of a real connection to Wilbur J. Knox who has a prominent place in this very realistic fiction brought tears to this retired teacher.
This is a book for those who love gritty protagonists who make their way through difficult circumstances. It is especially for those who love it when that way leads through a path of education.
September 28, 2022
In 1913, thousands of Mexicans, including 12-year-old Petra Luna, her six-year-old sister, one-year-old brother, and her grandmother cross the Rio Grande into Texas to escape the violent civil war in Mexico. They stay in an overcrowded refugee camp with little food and a smallpox outbreak. When the revolutionists take back the Mexican border town, the refugees are given the option to go back to Mexico or get a job in the United States.
Petra is torn between a brighter future in America where she might get to learn to read, or going back to their destroyed village in hopes of reuniting with her father. They decide to stay in America. Her grandmother is crippled with arthritis and can do little more than watch baby Luisito. It’s up to Petra to support the family. But being a girl, and a barefoot one at that, finding work isn’t easy. A charity group gives Petra her first pair of shoes which allows her to get a job working in restaurants.
For a while, she’s making enough money to pay the rent and buy food, but she gets replaced by a 14-year-old boy. Their meagre savings dwindle while Petra tries to find work. Petra meets Sister Nora, an Irish nun with bright blue eyes, and a kind heart. Sister Nora hires Petra to help her with the cooking and cleaning in the Wesley House. The nun also begins teaching Petra to read and speak English.
This is the second book featuring Petra. In the first, The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna, her family travels across Mexico fleeing the murderous Federales army. This sequel is set in San Antonio in 1913 and gives the reader a vivid picture of the hardships faced by immigrants in a way that seems timeless and relevant.
Petra is one of the strongest, young characters that I’ve encountered, and I was excited to get to read a continuation of her story. Her fierce dedication to care for her family and her unending determination to become educated is inspiring. I highly recommend The Other Side of the River to readers ten and up and, this book’s excellent pacing would make it a wonderful classroom read-aloud. Even though this is a sequel, it’s not necessary to read the first book to enjoy this one.
Petra is torn between a brighter future in America where she might get to learn to read, or going back to their destroyed village in hopes of reuniting with her father. They decide to stay in America. Her grandmother is crippled with arthritis and can do little more than watch baby Luisito. It’s up to Petra to support the family. But being a girl, and a barefoot one at that, finding work isn’t easy. A charity group gives Petra her first pair of shoes which allows her to get a job working in restaurants.
For a while, she’s making enough money to pay the rent and buy food, but she gets replaced by a 14-year-old boy. Their meagre savings dwindle while Petra tries to find work. Petra meets Sister Nora, an Irish nun with bright blue eyes, and a kind heart. Sister Nora hires Petra to help her with the cooking and cleaning in the Wesley House. The nun also begins teaching Petra to read and speak English.
This is the second book featuring Petra. In the first, The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna, her family travels across Mexico fleeing the murderous Federales army. This sequel is set in San Antonio in 1913 and gives the reader a vivid picture of the hardships faced by immigrants in a way that seems timeless and relevant.
Petra is one of the strongest, young characters that I’ve encountered, and I was excited to get to read a continuation of her story. Her fierce dedication to care for her family and her unending determination to become educated is inspiring. I highly recommend The Other Side of the River to readers ten and up and, this book’s excellent pacing would make it a wonderful classroom read-aloud. Even though this is a sequel, it’s not necessary to read the first book to enjoy this one.
August 21, 2023
Lest middle-grade readers (or their elders) imagine that the plight of refugees at the U.S.-Mexico border is a 21st-century problem, this immensely affecting historical novel situated in 1913—a full 110 years ago—chronicles the struggles of Petra Luna, a plucky 12-year-old oldest sister (and now breadwinner, too) for her abuelita and two younger siblings in the very foreign world of San Antonio, Texas, to which they have sojourned to reconstruct a new life away from the danger and bloodshed of the Mexican Revolution that may have even claimed the life of their abruptly conscripted father. Though disheartened at many an unfair turn in this new country, Petra is indefatigable, a hard worker with a thirst to take in all the freelance learning she can manage along the way, all to ensure that the ones depending on her can rise out of their abject poverty, but her luck is running out. When she meets Sr. Nora, a sweet and sage nun who herself trekked to America as an orphan from Ireland decades before and is moved to take this special girl under her wing, Petra is a quick learner and makes epic strides toward her dreams for herself and her family. . .until an episode of volcanic frustration with the caste system that targets poor Indios like herself and has followed her to America from Mexico threatens to destroy all the progress Petra has made thus far, and, to her mind, the very life of her adored little sister, Amelia. The author’s personal family history has provided much of the rich soil, the heart, from which this spellbinding story blossoms; that it is so obviously a labor of love breathes extra-strong vigor and emotion into every page. This is a book we need now, and for future generations of readers, thinkers, and helpers, too.
July 27, 2022
Petra’s journey to a better life outside of war torn Mexico began in “Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna” and continues in “The Other Side of the River.” 12 year old Petra exhibited astounding courage and both mental and physical strength in book 1 as she led her abuela and younger siblings Amelia and Luisito from the hometown destroyed by the Federales through the desert and the banks of the Rio Grande River near Eagles Pass, TX. Those traits are still just as necessary now as Petra moves her family north to San Antonio and continues fighting for the basics of survival as well as reaching for her dream of a future where she can read and they all will be a vital part of a thriving community. Using the story of her great-grandmother fleeing from the Federales and her own immigration from Mexico to San Antonio, Alda Dobbs’ Petra will touch readers’ hearts and help them feel the passion of wanting something more, something better, and will hopefully leave them different by the end of these two remarkable works.
“I truly believe we’re more similar than we think and when we focus on these similarities, our community benefits. While we should celebrate our uniqueness, we must also unite to celebrate our commonalities. When we do this, we foster a power that drives us to accomplish the impossible.” Alda P. Dobbs, p. 347, “Note From the Author” section (Advanced Reader Copy).
Thanks for providing me with this ARC, Alda, Margaret Coffee, and Sourcebooks.
“I truly believe we’re more similar than we think and when we focus on these similarities, our community benefits. While we should celebrate our uniqueness, we must also unite to celebrate our commonalities. When we do this, we foster a power that drives us to accomplish the impossible.” Alda P. Dobbs, p. 347, “Note From the Author” section (Advanced Reader Copy).
Thanks for providing me with this ARC, Alda, Margaret Coffee, and Sourcebooks.
May 1, 2023
Before her father was forced to join the Federales during the Mexican Revolution, Petra made a vow to keep their family safe. Despite her age, 12-year-old Petra is determined to provide for what’s left of her family, which includes her grandmother, younger sister, and infant brother. They escape Mexico and make it safely across the Rio Grande. However, new challenges arise, including hunger, smallpox, and the pressures of finding a job. If she can’t, they’ll be sent back to Mexico. She also dreams about learning to read and write, but are “barefoot” dreams possible for a poor immigrant girl?
The Other Side of the River is a charming tale of courage and survival. Petra is a kind-hearted and impressionable narrator. She’s the only person in her family capable of working, so she must support a family of four on her own in a new country without speaking the language. Petra must also navigate cultural nuances, like the importance of wearing shoes. She’s determined, but this sometimes leads her to forget the purpose of her journey: family. Petra learns about loyalty, trust, and while you can’t escape prejudice, you can stand against it. A delightful middle-grade historical novel about the struggles of starting anew while never forgetting where you came from.
Review originally posted via the Historical Novel Society at https://historicalnovelsociety.org/re...
The Other Side of the River is a charming tale of courage and survival. Petra is a kind-hearted and impressionable narrator. She’s the only person in her family capable of working, so she must support a family of four on her own in a new country without speaking the language. Petra must also navigate cultural nuances, like the importance of wearing shoes. She’s determined, but this sometimes leads her to forget the purpose of her journey: family. Petra learns about loyalty, trust, and while you can’t escape prejudice, you can stand against it. A delightful middle-grade historical novel about the struggles of starting anew while never forgetting where you came from.
Review originally posted via the Historical Novel Society at https://historicalnovelsociety.org/re...
August 18, 2022
An MG historical fiction story set in 1913, of twelve year old Petra, who escapes the Federales in Mexico alongside her siblings and Abuelita. Leaving behind her father, who had to serve the Federales in order not to get killed and allowing his family to escape to San Antonio, America.
This is a story of displacement amidst the Mexican Revolution happening in Petra's hometown. I feel it is similar and associative to any displacement situations, only difference being the historical setting of 1913. A tale of strength and courage in times of uncertainty. Of Petra's grit to push on to keep her family alive during difficult times, hunger and a smallpox outbreak. Keeping everyone together. And also working towards her unbelievable dream of learning, despite the flak she received for having such a dream. Having that sense of hope that she will be able to save those around her if she was more literate. This story is rich in Mexican culture and peppered with the occasional Spanish language. There's a prequel to this, which i only found out upon seeing other reviews but as a sequel, TOSOTR still sits well as a standalone. But i think i might go find the first book to read the beginnings of Petra and her journey. Journey of grit, hope and exceptional bravery to survive. I will recommend this to MG readers who are ok with heavier content.
This is a story of displacement amidst the Mexican Revolution happening in Petra's hometown. I feel it is similar and associative to any displacement situations, only difference being the historical setting of 1913. A tale of strength and courage in times of uncertainty. Of Petra's grit to push on to keep her family alive during difficult times, hunger and a smallpox outbreak. Keeping everyone together. And also working towards her unbelievable dream of learning, despite the flak she received for having such a dream. Having that sense of hope that she will be able to save those around her if she was more literate. This story is rich in Mexican culture and peppered with the occasional Spanish language. There's a prequel to this, which i only found out upon seeing other reviews but as a sequel, TOSOTR still sits well as a standalone. But i think i might go find the first book to read the beginnings of Petra and her journey. Journey of grit, hope and exceptional bravery to survive. I will recommend this to MG readers who are ok with heavier content.
October 20, 2022
After I read BAREFOOT DREAMS OF PETRA LUNA last year, I knew I wanted to read more of Petra’s brave story and see what happened to her and her family. THE OTHER SIDE OF THE RIVER begins where BAREFOOT DREAMS ends, picking up with Petra Luna on the bridge, following her into a refugee camp, and on into a new life.
I love the way the story is paced. It gives time for readers to sink into the historical setting without lingering too long. I felt like I could picture what was happening and the streets of San Antonio in 1913. The relationship between Petra and her sister was also really great. She loves and protects her sister, but sometimes feels annoyed by her, too. I felt like the relationship played out in a very realistic way. Petra also feels very much her age at twelve, almost thirteen. She feels the pressure of being a provider for her family and keeping the promise to her father to keep the family safe. But she doesn’t feel like a tiny adult.
All in all, I loved this story– as much if not more than the first book. I think readers looking for historical fiction should absolutely check out THE OTHER SIDE OF THE RIVER. I don’t think you’d have to read BAREFOOT DREAMS first, but they’re both really good.
Note: I received a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions my own.
I love the way the story is paced. It gives time for readers to sink into the historical setting without lingering too long. I felt like I could picture what was happening and the streets of San Antonio in 1913. The relationship between Petra and her sister was also really great. She loves and protects her sister, but sometimes feels annoyed by her, too. I felt like the relationship played out in a very realistic way. Petra also feels very much her age at twelve, almost thirteen. She feels the pressure of being a provider for her family and keeping the promise to her father to keep the family safe. But she doesn’t feel like a tiny adult.
All in all, I loved this story– as much if not more than the first book. I think readers looking for historical fiction should absolutely check out THE OTHER SIDE OF THE RIVER. I don’t think you’d have to read BAREFOOT DREAMS first, but they’re both really good.
Note: I received a free copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions my own.
July 12, 2022
When I read The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna, I was so moved by Petra’s story that I didn’t think I would find another middle grade book that focused on this time period and the struggles the characters faced with as much emotional impact. When I saw this sequel, I was worried that it couldn’t be as good as the first book, but I had to read more about Petra’s story. I am so glad that I did, because Dobbs has written another masterpiece with The Other Side of the River. She remains true to the characters in this story, and I feel like I stepped right back into Petra’s life as this book picks up exactly where the first one left off. This time, though, we see Petra in America, specifically San Antonio, Texas, trying to take care of herself and her family, and continuing to dream big dreams about the life she wants so badly. We see her strength of character and her resolve, but we also witness her confusion about this new country and its customs. Once again, I cheered for Petra and I also wanted to cry for her. Sometimes she acts well beyond her years, but within a few paragraphs, she’s once again just a frightened young girl. Dobbs makes her struggle relatable, and that’s the real beauty of this story. I will absolutely be recommending this book to my middle school students this year! Thank you to NetGalley and Sourcebooks for the opportunity to read this amazing story.
January 11, 2023
I read the first book in this series, The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna, and loved it so much that I picked up the second novel, although I don't usually read Middle-Grade books.
The description:
Petra Luna is in America, having escaped the Mexican Revolution and the terror of the Federales. Now that they are safe, Petra and her family can begin again, in this country that promises so much. Still, twelve-year-old Petra knows that her abuelita, little sister, and baby brother depend on her to survive. She leads her family from a smallpox-stricken refugee camp on the Texas border to the buzzing city of San Antonio, where they work hard to build a new life. And for the first time ever, Petra has a chance to learn to read and write.
The issues the main character faces are one's adults would face if they were refugees. How a twelve year navigates her way through problems illustrates her resiliency and determination as well as her moral compass and strength. The pacing is just right, and the settings are brought to life via the sensory details.
This immersive read could open up discussions in classrooms that teach History or English.
The description:
Petra Luna is in America, having escaped the Mexican Revolution and the terror of the Federales. Now that they are safe, Petra and her family can begin again, in this country that promises so much. Still, twelve-year-old Petra knows that her abuelita, little sister, and baby brother depend on her to survive. She leads her family from a smallpox-stricken refugee camp on the Texas border to the buzzing city of San Antonio, where they work hard to build a new life. And for the first time ever, Petra has a chance to learn to read and write.
The issues the main character faces are one's adults would face if they were refugees. How a twelve year navigates her way through problems illustrates her resiliency and determination as well as her moral compass and strength. The pacing is just right, and the settings are brought to life via the sensory details.
This immersive read could open up discussions in classrooms that teach History or English.
October 11, 2022
The Other Side of the River is an amazing follow up to The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna. In the last book, Petra and her grandmother and siblings made it from Mexico to the United States during the Mexican revolution. This book tells the story of their journey in the United States beginning with a stay at a refugee camp on this side of the Rio Grande River. When Petra learns of a man selling train tickets to San Antonio, she does everything she can to get her family there so they don’t have to go back to Mexico. When they finally make it to San Antonio, life doesn’t get much easier for awhile. Petra finally finds work, but learns that she is easily dispensable in the job market. Then she finds Sister Nora and her life in America begins to turn around. Petra is an amazing character with determination, resilience, and a love for her family. I loved reading this book and finding out what happened when Petra and her family were on the other side of the river.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance copy.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the advance copy.
December 15, 2022
This is the sequel to the Pura Belpré Honor book The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna. In it, we see Petra in the United States, poor, homeless, still trying to make good on her promise to her father that she would take care of her sister, baby brother and her Abuela. Through her resourcefulness, and without ever giving up, Petra finds her way to San Antonio where she finds jobs doing menial work, but still, is able to provide the major sustenance to her family. She works hard, overcomes obstacles and perseveres and finally achieves, against all odds, the dream of learning to read and write. Like all immigrants. For every forward step Petra takes, there are two back. This book is an important window into what Mexican immigrants who were displaced by the Mexican war went through in the early part of the century. And it is a great vehicle for building understanding and empathy for immigrants and their experience. I loved Dobbs’s lyrical language and her spunky heroine. Thank you to Source books for providing this book at NCTE
December 29, 2023
Now safely across the border into the United States, 12yo Petra Luna is desperate to keep her family together, she's a hard worker but she is only twelve and she's trying to support her little sister, baby brother and abuela. There are so many refugees in San Antonio and not enough work or housing for everyone. Petra will work on her days off just to keep her job. But the odds are against her, as soon as her employer finds someone a little older and a little stronger, Petra is let go. She thought life would be so much easier on the other side of the river.
A darling companion to "The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna," Dobbs continues the story, but the situation is so different, the plot isn't dependent on having read book 1. I loved Petra's resilience, and way the refugees of the Mexican revolution are portrayed. Although the story takes place more than 100 years ago, I found it interesting and relevant. Petra and her family are Mexican.
Cross-posted to http://kissthebook.blogspot.com
A darling companion to "The Barefoot Dreams of Petra Luna," Dobbs continues the story, but the situation is so different, the plot isn't dependent on having read book 1. I loved Petra's resilience, and way the refugees of the Mexican revolution are portrayed. Although the story takes place more than 100 years ago, I found it interesting and relevant. Petra and her family are Mexican.
Cross-posted to http://kissthebook.blogspot.com
July 28, 2022
The Other Side of the River takes place during the Mexican Revolution, a daughter, Petra has a promise to keep as she travels to a new place leaving behind her dad, but she is not alone. Petra is also traveling with her young sister and baby brother to her grandmother who is getting older. They meet very different people and explore very different places all the while trying their best to support themselves and stay together.
The strength, the fight, and the urge to survive are something that immigrants face today in all parts of the world. It is great to humanize the lives that have to flee their homes for reasons far beyond their control. The struggle and dealing with injustices from people taking advantage of those with less but with more humanity and fight than all of these selfish characters put together Petra has to deal with in this book. Alda P. Dobbs makes Petra's diamond such a token of hope, a talisman, and when it goes missing well you will have to read The Other Side of the River to find out.
The strength, the fight, and the urge to survive are something that immigrants face today in all parts of the world. It is great to humanize the lives that have to flee their homes for reasons far beyond their control. The struggle and dealing with injustices from people taking advantage of those with less but with more humanity and fight than all of these selfish characters put together Petra has to deal with in this book. Alda P. Dobbs makes Petra's diamond such a token of hope, a talisman, and when it goes missing well you will have to read The Other Side of the River to find out.
August 3, 2022
This book continues the story of Petra Luna who fled her homeland Mexico to escape slaughter by the Federales. Her story of escape, the camp experience and adjusting to a new country sound very much like current conditions and not 1913 when it takes place. Petra, her grandmother, younger sister and infant brother have made it across the Rio Grande to a camp on the other side in Texas where Petra struggles to find work or go back home to Mexico. She is smart and very resourceful given that she is only 12 and manages to get them all to San Antonio. Once again they seek refuge in the church and find family in the Mexican American community. Petra will work hard and try to honor the promise she made to her dad and even though she must grow up quickly she will learn much about her own promise and strength. Vibrant historical story of bravery, hard work and never giving up that will be enjoyed by middle grade and older readers. My thanks to the publisher for the advance copy.
November 25, 2022
This book is the companion book to Barefoot Dreams and continues Petra Luna's story. It's nice to read Barefoot Dreams first but not a necessity--each book stands on its own. In this second book, the year is 1913 and the main character, Petra Luna, and her grandmother, her sister Amelia, and her little brother Luisito have left Mexico during the Mexican Revolution and are now in America and settled in Texas.
While in Texas, Petra finds and loses housing, finds and loses jobs, and constantly watches the newspaper for word from her father. Despite all of these struggles (and without too many spoilers), Petra is moving toward finally being at the right place at the right time.
Highly recommended for all middle grade readers--I love stories that share little-known history, and Petra's story is based on the author's own family stories and actual events during the Mexican Revolution. This book belongs in classrooms, homes, and libraries.
While in Texas, Petra finds and loses housing, finds and loses jobs, and constantly watches the newspaper for word from her father. Despite all of these struggles (and without too many spoilers), Petra is moving toward finally being at the right place at the right time.
Highly recommended for all middle grade readers--I love stories that share little-known history, and Petra's story is based on the author's own family stories and actual events during the Mexican Revolution. This book belongs in classrooms, homes, and libraries.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 57 reviews