ABCOD for October, 2024
The Blue Girl by Charles de Lint
Attendees: DA, PH, SN, AL, DL, SI, EL
We talk about colleges for high schoolers.
EL: Wants to be first because she’s not done reading. THERE WAS NO AUDIOBOOK! She kept falling asleep when reading at night. About ⅓ in. Will use book club to determine if she should finish. It’s interesting. Like the level of magic - it’s there, integrated will, magical realism, character development good, liked switching of perspectives. Spoilers ok.
PH: I love it. Love book clubs - learning so many authors! Grew up with Heinlein, azamov, Zelazny. Now there’s a whole world. Is all De Lint’s stuff this good? He’s in his second teenage years right now (likes to nap and snack). Liked the gathering the gang - like a hard boiled detective mystery. In her old town she was in a gang but in a healthier way this time. It’s Halloween! How big is this town? Big or suburb?
AL: De Lint back in the 80s wrote in the Borderlands series. Have been meaning to go back and try some of his books. Plot was zero surprises but felt comforting in this case. Suited mood. If was in a different time, would be more critical. Neither mom was a villain - they were people. Storytelling was nice. Boyfriends were just lurking in the background - they didn’t have to be part of the resolution of the plot. Have read a fair amount of De Lint so recognize some characters from other writings.
SI: Has not read any of his works per Goodreads, but may have read some in the earlier days. Fun to have the different perspectives, but the two main characters kind of ran together even though they are different people. A nice book, not sure if it would be a reread. Comforting, seasonal, easy little thing. Maxine kind of does the teenage thing of trying on different personas. The way money played a role was interesting – thrift stores aren’t all that cheap, how did they get their money? Splitting money from reselling, buying the fairy outfits – that was a little weird. Interested in what other people thought. Her blood is also blue? What was the deal with that? Wouldn’t there be consequences of that??
DL: Really liked it, and wasn’t expecting to – no ebook, no audiobook – read 99 pages the first night before bed, while also reading another book THE SPARROW (“THAT is a grimdark book!) This was a fun read. It was really good! Better than the other de Lint book he’s read in the past. Got close to finishing it, finished it 5 minutes before club! A number of things that impressed him about it – the mothers, like how the mother looked her up and knew what was going on, etc. Liked how the football player thing worked out. Many things worked out better than they probably would in real life, which makes sense since it’s a YA book. The whole ghost plot was almost superfluous, but still connected and made sense. Other good books: MOONHEART.
SN: Felt much more lukewarm. It’s a “vibe” – probably better. Falls apart if you think about it. The prose is well-written, the characters were complicated, but the teenagers were too rational. How did she come out of the gang and be so rational? Saw the Easter Eggs, didn’t hate them, but they didn’t mean anything to her. Story was fine, too pat in the end. Who is this book for? As a teen, she didn’t need all the exposition, why was everything so explained? Not sure who the audience was. Fun vibe, urban fairy tale, good for harry potter readers, but not anyone else?
DA: Liked it. Didn’t purposefully pick as Halloween book but it was a fun read. Struck as a good fantasy gateway book. Harry Potter-ish, saw some fantasy on tv. Forgiving of explanations. Liked how it played with expectations but still met them. Cute bits - accidentally let him fall to his death - body for a night maybe make out with someone. Lot of REAL but layer of fantasy and seemed about right mix. Some urban fantasy has SO MUCH fantasy that how do people not notice? Like middle schoolers that are “old souls”. Loved the mom’s response was just “let’s talk about it” - my mom would not have responded that way. Have a few De Lint books - this made him want to reread. Held together as a later book in series.
Is it an adult book? Is it a YA book? Who is it geared towards? Pretty tame, death and domestic violence, it wasn’t gruesome. Not too lurid.
The ghost was not really key to the plot, but he was a gentleman when he had his body, and he added a whole element to the book that was nice.
This book had been taught in schools for a while. Potential topics - courage and bravery, amorality.
Imaginary friend came back from childhood but didn’t know all the “rules”
Did we have imaginary friends?
Was Christy going to be a villain? Figured he’s in other stories too. “Floating mentor”
There were a lot of helpful characters - usually not everyone is helpful. Thought some might be villains but weren’t.
Interesting how defeated the bad creatures. Was that a plan? NOPE.
But are there more than 3? Could others come after her?
Imogene was magically high. She was also special in a way that made things work out where things didn’t work out for others (Adrian).
Is this in Canada or the US?
Maxine was confused by pop-up chat.
DA says he would read a next book on these characters, or a tv show about this town.
Didn’t need then and now - could have just been chronological.
“There’s a looming doominess . . . but so what, it’s 2024, that’s life.” SI
The fairies are the cause of trouble in the whole book, and only because they weren’t given treats! They go straight to banishing. Like, really, can’t a secretary or the librarian just leave out milk and cookies? But it’s actually kind of a metaphor for us forgetting “the old things” like nature and that’s going to catch up to us.
Poor Pelly – I’ll remember you always, it wasn’t just a summer thing.
We all have books with the same cover!
Sami is up next. PH is serious about retirement.
Talk about AI created study guides, podcasts, articles.