A dark fantasy mix of Greek myths and Alice in Wonderland vibes.
This one has a lot of good things going for it, but the destined-soulmates/instalove romance and all-around unlikable love interest kind of killed it for me.
THE GOOD:
The main character is headstrong, brave, the practical kind of smart, quick on her feet, and kind. She’s bold without being arrogant. She stands up for herself. She’s loyal and hardy enough to make morally gray decisions when no option is black or white. But, the romance eroded my respect for her. She’s not perfect. She can also be petty, hold grudges, and has truly terrible taste in men.
The rest of the main characters are some a**kicking women, each with their own personality and flavor of awesome, that I just loved and a male love interest I just didn’t love.
It’s got great dark fantasy world-building, with a Greek-mythology-inspired magic system and plenty of fresh twists on familiar myths. The Mirror Realm is creative, strange, fun, and dangerous. It’s the kind of world beyond the looking glass that you can’t help but want to visit and be scared to step foot in. It’s full of demons and wonders and the world turning itself upside down with every turn, drop, and jump (literally).
The author rides the line between dark fantasy and horror with skill. There’s serious creepy and eerie vibes, but no excessively graphic violence. The descriptive style captured the beauty and scariness of this tale. The story has good pacing that keeps you swept up in suspense, intrigue, or action from start to finish. The plot kept my interest with mysteries of Alice’s family’s past and the present world of Greek myths and mirrors that comes to her. The plot wasn’t rushed. The story was nothing if not unpredictable.
No cliffhanger ending. The ending was clearly meant to be happy, but I didn’t love it because by the end, I was hoping for was the male love interest’s messy and permanent demise.
THE BAD (READ: THE ROMANCE):
The romance was definitely instalove. Even for a story with the magical, fated soulmates trope, this romance felt very instant, very rushed, and never successfully made up for lost development later in the book. Since the leading romantic pair trying to save each other was a central part of the book’s plot, this really held the story back.
The love interest, Colin, was the worst part of the book. Even after finishing the book, I never felt a genuine spark between Alice and Colin or a reason for Alice to even like Colin. The way Colin treated Alice alternated between him being mean, controlling, patronizing, protective (in a creepy, patronizing, or stalkerey way), guilt-tripping, and just a jerk. He would kiss her, make physical advances, call her baby, and make general declarations of love. All the while, he would withhold information, continue to treat her badly, and treat her as a subordinate instead of an equal or a team member. He didn’t act like he trusted her. He used physical advances to avoid honesty or emotional talks. But, it’s all dreamy because Colin and Alice are soul mates, they find each other to be really hot, and apparently Colin’s more willing to risk his life for Alice than treat her with respect (or treat her as an equal).
His behavior is presumably all to push her away, protect her from everything (including herself), or protect himself from his intense love for her. He’s only patronizing because he wants to protect her and obviously knows better because he’s older and she’s sooo reckless and sooo ignorant of the magical world that she only just discovered. (Never mind that she’d be a lot less ignorant if he spent more time sharing info. Or that her bold actions are calculated risks in dangerous situations where you can’t win or survive by playing it safe. Or that her strategies could be a lot more calculated and a lot less risky with more information and training.)
The romance came off as toxic and Colin came off as both creepy and unlikeable. By the end, I was rooting against the couple ending up together.
THE VERDICT:
Mixed feelings. I loved the world and the characters (with the exception of the male love interest). The plot and mysteries kept me hooked until the end. I disliked the romance and the love interest. The romance even eroded away some of my respect for the protagonist. My dislike of the romance kept me from really loving the book. But, the story’s strengths made this a memorable read.
WARNINGS: mentions of attempted suicide (not the main character), violence, death, kidnapping, drugging
I received a free eARC of this book via NetGalley. I am writing this review completely honestly and voluntarily.