What do you think?
Rate this book
Dune Universe
Sands of Dune: A Collection
Collected for the first time, these Dune novellas by bestselling authors Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson shine a light upon the darker corners of the Dune universe. Spanning space and time, Sands of Dune is essential reading for any fan of the series.
The world of Dune has shaped an entire generation of science fiction. From the sand blasted world of Arrakis, to the splendor of the imperial homeworld of Kaitain, readers have lived in a universe of treachery and wonder.
Now, these stories expand on the Dune universe, telling of the lost years of Gurney Halleck as he works with smugglers on Arrakis in a deadly gambit for revenge; inside the ranks of the Sardaukar as the child of a betrayed nobleman becomes one of the Emperor’s most ruthless fighters; a young firebrand Fremen woman, a guerrilla fighter against the ruthless Harkonnens, who will one day become Shadout Mapes.
The world of Dune has shaped an entire generation of science fiction. From the sand blasted world of Arrakis, to the splendor of the imperial homeworld of Kaitain, readers have lived in a universe of treachery and wonder.
Now, these stories expand on the Dune universe, telling of the lost years of Gurney Halleck as he works with smugglers on Arrakis in a deadly gambit for revenge; inside the ranks of the Sardaukar as the child of a betrayed nobleman becomes one of the Emperor’s most ruthless fighters; a young firebrand Fremen woman, a guerrilla fighter against the ruthless Harkonnens, who will one day become Shadout Mapes.
176 pages, Hardcover
First published June 30, 2022
135 people are currently reading
826 people want to read
About the author
Brian Herbert
170 books2,122 followersBrian Patrick Herbert is an American author who lives in Washington state. He is the elder son of science fiction author Frank Patrick Herbert.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews
October 29, 2023
This never really grabbed me. I am one of those stubborn readers who is distinctly "down" on those authors, family or not, who pick up stories and characters from original writing from dead authors.
As such, I never felt these stories were of real merit and, as some other GR reviewers have also said, they smacked of pushing out books for a franchise [Dune] to gather in the cash.
As such, I never felt these stories were of real merit and, as some other GR reviewers have also said, they smacked of pushing out books for a franchise [Dune] to gather in the cash.
July 16, 2022
Being a big fan of Frank Herbert’s Dune books I was always a wee bit frustrated how his last Dune novel ended on a everlasting open ending.
Then his son took over and instead of finishing the open ending he and his co-writer started building the Duneverse before finally taking up the expected seventh story with the ideas Frank had originally, this has split the fandom in various fractions with a few very loud voices not accepting Brian’s new input.
I never enjoyed the 7th & 8th novel completing Franks vision. I have really enjoyed most of their output in the Duneverse.
Three of the new short stories concern the timeline around the original Dune novel, one of them currently being released in comic as well (waters of Kanly). The first one goes back to the early stories about House Atreides and it’s troubles with the Harkonnen family.
Overal it is a nice collection for the Dune fan, which I have been when I was fourteenish and read Frank Herbert for the first time and surprised my English teacher who was not aware of Book 5 & 6. We shared our Dune interest and what I did not understand he tried to explain me. Still books like Tolkien of whom I also have various editions on my shelves and get reread on occasion.
Then his son took over and instead of finishing the open ending he and his co-writer started building the Duneverse before finally taking up the expected seventh story with the ideas Frank had originally, this has split the fandom in various fractions with a few very loud voices not accepting Brian’s new input.
I never enjoyed the 7th & 8th novel completing Franks vision. I have really enjoyed most of their output in the Duneverse.
Three of the new short stories concern the timeline around the original Dune novel, one of them currently being released in comic as well (waters of Kanly). The first one goes back to the early stories about House Atreides and it’s troubles with the Harkonnen family.
Overal it is a nice collection for the Dune fan, which I have been when I was fourteenish and read Frank Herbert for the first time and surprised my English teacher who was not aware of Book 5 & 6. We shared our Dune interest and what I did not understand he tried to explain me. Still books like Tolkien of whom I also have various editions on my shelves and get reread on occasion.
July 1, 2022
This was fun, the first story was my favourite for sure.
June 27, 2022
Absorbing!
Ok, it’s been many years since I’ve read the Dune series (think the 70’s) and I’m still as enamoured as I was then.
These four novellas by Herbert and Anderson shed light on the back story of Gurney Halleck and other major figures of the Dune pantheon. A younger Shadeout Mapes, the relentless training of the Sardaukar represented by Bashar Jopati Koloa (with a curious finale), Willem Atreides and the of the conflict between the Houses of Atreides and Harkonnen.
We follow individual paths for revenge and freedom against the uncaring, debauched, power hungry elite of the Kaitain Empire and the implacable feuding outcomes of the various Houses spanning many worlds. Betrayal, determination, vengeance and the shifts of power balances stalk the pages.
A must read for Dune aficionados. Indeed I enjoyed these novellas so much I’m considering a Dune series reread.
A Macmillan-Tor/Forge ARC
Ok, it’s been many years since I’ve read the Dune series (think the 70’s) and I’m still as enamoured as I was then.
These four novellas by Herbert and Anderson shed light on the back story of Gurney Halleck and other major figures of the Dune pantheon. A younger Shadeout Mapes, the relentless training of the Sardaukar represented by Bashar Jopati Koloa (with a curious finale), Willem Atreides and the of the conflict between the Houses of Atreides and Harkonnen.
We follow individual paths for revenge and freedom against the uncaring, debauched, power hungry elite of the Kaitain Empire and the implacable feuding outcomes of the various Houses spanning many worlds. Betrayal, determination, vengeance and the shifts of power balances stalk the pages.
A must read for Dune aficionados. Indeed I enjoyed these novellas so much I’m considering a Dune series reread.
A Macmillan-Tor/Forge ARC
November 27, 2023
Sands of Dune collects four unrelated novellas by Brian Herbert and Kevin Anderson from the Dune Universe. One offers the backstory of Fremen Shadout Mapes, who had a brief role when the Atriedes first came to Arrakis. One offers a backstory of one of the Sardauker who disguised as a Harkonnen when the Atriedes were betrayed. One offers a story of Gurney Halleck working with the smugglers after the Atriedes were defeated. The final novella gives a sense of the Atriedes-Harkonnen feud going back thousands of years. This publication is designed more for those familiar with the Dune universe.
August 20, 2024
"Sands of Dune" was really good. It is a short collection of four short stories all set during different periods of history of the Dune saga.
"The Edge of A Cryskinfie" takes place roughly 56 years before the events of "Dune" and we meet a young Mapes and we learn about her struggle against the Harkonnens. It explains why she was working in the Atreides palace. A great story and one that explains much.
"Blood of the Sardaukar" takes place during "Dune" and is the story of the assault of the Atreides Palace as told by a Sardaukar Commander. This is another excellent story and one that points out the strict code of honor the Sardaukar also adheres to.
"The Waters of Kanly" takes place during the events of "Dune" and follows Gurney Hallaeck's adventures right after the fall of the Atreides. A good story, but not to the level of the other ones. Still, I did like it.
"Imperial Court" takes place thousands of years before the events of "Dune" and happens slightly after the Battle of Corrin (during the Machine Crusade of the Butlerian Jihad) as a newly enthroned Emperor must choose a Chamberlin between a Harkonnen and an Atreides. A good story showing the conflicts of the Imperial Court and the ever-present hatred between these Harkonnens and Atreides.
All of these stories are very enjoyable, but I would advise someone to be read up on the original series, as well as the newer novels in order for these stories to make sense.
"The Edge of A Cryskinfie" takes place roughly 56 years before the events of "Dune" and we meet a young Mapes and we learn about her struggle against the Harkonnens. It explains why she was working in the Atreides palace. A great story and one that explains much.
"Blood of the Sardaukar" takes place during "Dune" and is the story of the assault of the Atreides Palace as told by a Sardaukar Commander. This is another excellent story and one that points out the strict code of honor the Sardaukar also adheres to.
"The Waters of Kanly" takes place during the events of "Dune" and follows Gurney Hallaeck's adventures right after the fall of the Atreides. A good story, but not to the level of the other ones. Still, I did like it.
"Imperial Court" takes place thousands of years before the events of "Dune" and happens slightly after the Battle of Corrin (during the Machine Crusade of the Butlerian Jihad) as a newly enthroned Emperor must choose a Chamberlin between a Harkonnen and an Atreides. A good story showing the conflicts of the Imperial Court and the ever-present hatred between these Harkonnens and Atreides.
All of these stories are very enjoyable, but I would advise someone to be read up on the original series, as well as the newer novels in order for these stories to make sense.
January 2, 2025
This is a short story collection of 4 short story/novellettes by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson. 1 of the stories is a prequel to Dune, 2 of the stories are interquels to Dune, and the last story is a sequel to the "Schools of Dune" trilgoy.
The longest story "Edge of a Crysknife" is probably the best story in the collection. It tells the story of Shadout Mapes and shows her journey of fighting the Harkonnen's in her youth and middle age.
The second story, "Blood of the Sardaukar", features a Sardaukar warrior during the Harkonnen retakover of Dune who has every reason to hate the Atreides.
The third story "The Waters of Kanly" features Gurney Halleck, who is hellbent on revenge and launches an attack on a shipment to Dune.
The fourth story "Imperial Court" features the Atreides, Corrinos, and Harkonnen's of 10,000 years earlier as mysterious poisonings lead to changes in court.
All of these stories are competently handled, but none of them are particularly fantastic. They are simply short stories that add some context to the greater Dune universe, but none of that context is particularly necessary. I enjoyed parts of it, but I do believe this is the weakest book by Herbert and Anderson in the series. It's length at 160 pages does not really warrant its' hardcover release, but if you're a Dune fan and find the book in paperback it might be worth a read.
Overall, I'll give the book a 5.5 out of 10. It's just an ok book.
The longest story "Edge of a Crysknife" is probably the best story in the collection. It tells the story of Shadout Mapes and shows her journey of fighting the Harkonnen's in her youth and middle age.
The second story, "Blood of the Sardaukar", features a Sardaukar warrior during the Harkonnen retakover of Dune who has every reason to hate the Atreides.
The third story "The Waters of Kanly" features Gurney Halleck, who is hellbent on revenge and launches an attack on a shipment to Dune.
The fourth story "Imperial Court" features the Atreides, Corrinos, and Harkonnen's of 10,000 years earlier as mysterious poisonings lead to changes in court.
All of these stories are competently handled, but none of them are particularly fantastic. They are simply short stories that add some context to the greater Dune universe, but none of that context is particularly necessary. I enjoyed parts of it, but I do believe this is the weakest book by Herbert and Anderson in the series. It's length at 160 pages does not really warrant its' hardcover release, but if you're a Dune fan and find the book in paperback it might be worth a read.
Overall, I'll give the book a 5.5 out of 10. It's just an ok book.
December 24, 2022
I've always been a fan of the Dune saga although in recent years the continuous (or so it felt) publication of new books did feel as though we were seeing a lot unnecessary or just plain padding to the original works.
However each time I dip in to the new work (and I will admit the original is still the first and true work) I am reminded that there is a whole universe and thousands of years to play with and really there is space for all.
This collection of stories ranging through the time lines and political groups and although really only act a supporting notes to the great events still all colour and depth to this incredible universe. So yes this book is not key to saga but it certainly does add a little colour
However each time I dip in to the new work (and I will admit the original is still the first and true work) I am reminded that there is a whole universe and thousands of years to play with and really there is space for all.
This collection of stories ranging through the time lines and political groups and although really only act a supporting notes to the great events still all colour and depth to this incredible universe. So yes this book is not key to saga but it certainly does add a little colour
June 27, 2022
SANDS OF DUNE collates four "behind-the-scenes" stories and backstories from the incredibly vast DUNE Universe created by Frank Herbert. Kevin J. Anderson and Brian Herbert have giftedly expanded the DUNE Universe, and here provide readers with side-trip adventures, deepening our understanding of the planetary systems, cultures, socioeconomics, while providing character revelation and bringing these seemingly "alien" species and cultures into vivid and vibrant life. SANDS OF DUNE provides exciting views into the ever-expanding Universe of DUNE.
June 5, 2022
As a huge fan of the Dune universe, including all of the prequels and sequels, I devoured the 4 novellas in Sands of Dune. The novellas give us insight to some of the side characters of Dune and also takes us back to where it all began.
We get the backstory of the housekeeper, Shadout Mapes, as a young woman and her life as a Fedaykin warrior (my personal favorite of the 4 stories!).
Next is a novella about a Sardaukar bashar which gives us all kinds of insight into what drives the Sardaukar.
Gurney Halleck has a story set about a year after the fall of the Atreides when he’s with the smugglers as he tries to get his revenge on the Harkonnens.
And last, back to the beginning in the imperial court when we find out even more about the blood feud between House Atreides and House Harkonnen.
Since I can never seem to get enough of the Dune books, this book of 4 novellas was perfect to continue feeding my Dune obsession and I enjoyed it immensely.
*Thank you so much to Tor Books and NetGalley for the advance copy!*
We get the backstory of the housekeeper, Shadout Mapes, as a young woman and her life as a Fedaykin warrior (my personal favorite of the 4 stories!).
Next is a novella about a Sardaukar bashar which gives us all kinds of insight into what drives the Sardaukar.
Gurney Halleck has a story set about a year after the fall of the Atreides when he’s with the smugglers as he tries to get his revenge on the Harkonnens.
And last, back to the beginning in the imperial court when we find out even more about the blood feud between House Atreides and House Harkonnen.
Since I can never seem to get enough of the Dune books, this book of 4 novellas was perfect to continue feeding my Dune obsession and I enjoyed it immensely.
*Thank you so much to Tor Books and NetGalley for the advance copy!*
July 10, 2022
Muy disfrutable recopilación de 4 historias de Dune, cada una con sus virtudes.
Quizás la mejor sea la primera que cuenta la historia en 2 tiempos de Shadout Mapes (la criada Fremen que le da el Crisnife a Jessica en la pelicula de Villeneuve). Excelente su pasado como joven Fedaykin y las desgracias que la forjan en su constante batalla contra el dominion Harkonnen de Arrakis. Contiene una de las ejecuciones mas sádicas que recuerdo haber leído en bastante tiempo, Shai Huluds como armas de asalto y bueno, todo el buen percal para satisfacer al fan.
La segunda que es la creía que iba a ser la que mas me iba a gustar, nos pone en el punto de vista de un oficial Sardaukar con cuentas pendientes personales contra los Atreides durante el asalto Harkonnen a Arrakeen. Tira por lados que no esperaba, pero aun así aunque solo sea por las descripciones de como y donde se entrenan los Sardaukar, ya merece la pena.
Seguimos con la mas floja que cuenta una trama durante los años de contrabandista de Gurney Halleck tras el mentado ataque y caída de la casa Atreides. Es la mas floja, pero no deja de ser una afrenta Kanly llevada a su manera por Gurney contra los Harkonnen.
Y para finalizar nos vamos al pasado lejano justo tras La yihad butleriana, con la sucesión imperial y las intrigas palaciegas entre los candidatos de las grandes casas para que uno de sus miembros sea nombrado chambelán del nuevo emperados. Muy interesante, retorcido por parte de uno de los Harkonnen y sirve para que conozca, yo al menos, hechos sobre las vergüenza Harkonnen durante la Yihad y los feudos de sangre milenarios entre estos y los Atreides. Me ha gustado bastante mas de lo que esperaba.
En conclusión, disfrutable colección para todo fan.
Quizás la mejor sea la primera que cuenta la historia en 2 tiempos de Shadout Mapes (la criada Fremen que le da el Crisnife a Jessica en la pelicula de Villeneuve). Excelente su pasado como joven Fedaykin y las desgracias que la forjan en su constante batalla contra el dominion Harkonnen de Arrakis. Contiene una de las ejecuciones mas sádicas que recuerdo haber leído en bastante tiempo, Shai Huluds como armas de asalto y bueno, todo el buen percal para satisfacer al fan.
La segunda que es la creía que iba a ser la que mas me iba a gustar, nos pone en el punto de vista de un oficial Sardaukar con cuentas pendientes personales contra los Atreides durante el asalto Harkonnen a Arrakeen. Tira por lados que no esperaba, pero aun así aunque solo sea por las descripciones de como y donde se entrenan los Sardaukar, ya merece la pena.
Seguimos con la mas floja que cuenta una trama durante los años de contrabandista de Gurney Halleck tras el mentado ataque y caída de la casa Atreides. Es la mas floja, pero no deja de ser una afrenta Kanly llevada a su manera por Gurney contra los Harkonnen.
Y para finalizar nos vamos al pasado lejano justo tras La yihad butleriana, con la sucesión imperial y las intrigas palaciegas entre los candidatos de las grandes casas para que uno de sus miembros sea nombrado chambelán del nuevo emperados. Muy interesante, retorcido por parte de uno de los Harkonnen y sirve para que conozca, yo al menos, hechos sobre las vergüenza Harkonnen durante la Yihad y los feudos de sangre milenarios entre estos y los Atreides. Me ha gustado bastante mas de lo que esperaba.
En conclusión, disfrutable colección para todo fan.
August 17, 2023
A collection of DUNE stories set throughout the Imperium at different stages, this book is great for anyone looking for more content set in Frank Herbet's world. I found each one to be engaging and shocking, if grim at some points, which is standard for the DUNE universe.
Every story surrounded the concept of revenge and what people were willing to do in order to gain it. Shadout Mapes and Gurney Halleck's stories were my favourites, though the stories were balanced with tales of Harkonnen revenge against House Atreidies. It just shows that there are two sides to this conflict and that not everyone can be painted as a hero.
Perfect for fans of DUNE who want something short to read in between the series!
Every story surrounded the concept of revenge and what people were willing to do in order to gain it. Shadout Mapes and Gurney Halleck's stories were my favourites, though the stories were balanced with tales of Harkonnen revenge against House Atreidies. It just shows that there are two sides to this conflict and that not everyone can be painted as a hero.
Perfect for fans of DUNE who want something short to read in between the series!
May 17, 2024
Sooo good! I loved to get a glimpse into the lifes of minor characters. I only wished these stories would go on and on and on -- AMAZING.
Read
July 30, 2024in the words of timothee chalamet - Dune DUne DUNE dUNE dun3 DuNe DuuuuunE Dyune DYuuuuuuune Dyyyyyuuuunnneeeee Doon Duninator Dern Derndonn dernflerf Dernnnnnnnn DUNNNNE Dune DUUUUNE
November 14, 2022
An obvious 162 page money grab, but it wasn't terrible (and it gave me something to read while waiting for "Heir of Caladan" to pop next week).
I own 18 Dune books (I stopped at the unremarkable Caladan trilogy), so by law I was obligated to read this. I enjoyed the original 6 books by Frank, and the 3 Preludes by Brian. Not a fan of the 3 Legends, and I haven’t gotten around to the more recent 7 Chronicles/Heroes/Schools books (I just started reading "Sandworms of Dune", . . . I'm not super optimistic).
"Sands of Dune" is 4 short stories:
• A telling of a young Shadout Mapes (56 years before "Dune"), which seems unnecessary;
• A no-name Sardaukar that could've killed Duncan Idaho (during the fall of Duke Leto), pointless;
• A revenge plot by Gurney Halleck (after the fall of Duke Leto), not bad, good twist at the end;
• And Imperial jockeying between Atreides & Harkonnens (97 years after Battle of Corrin), is meh.
Try typing those sentences without spell-check fighting you every step of the way.
I’m in the process of culling my library for when I move/retire, and it looks like I’m outtie on owning any of the new books (going to have to read the Schools/Heroes/Chronicles series to see if they make the cut). I'll probably read the next series (which with the new movies is inevitable) because I'm dumb like that.
Denis Villeneuve has made the best movie interpretation of "Dune" so far, so here's hoping he doesn't pooch "Dune pt.II" next year. He did a great job with "Arrival", but I don't know how to feel about "Blade Runner 2049" (it's blasphemy, but it's pretty to look at). Heard he's going to do "Rendezvous with Rama" which is so old (1973?), I remember reading my mother's copy.
Anybody want my 3 Legends books?
I own 18 Dune books (I stopped at the unremarkable Caladan trilogy), so by law I was obligated to read this. I enjoyed the original 6 books by Frank, and the 3 Preludes by Brian. Not a fan of the 3 Legends, and I haven’t gotten around to the more recent 7 Chronicles/Heroes/Schools books (I just started reading "Sandworms of Dune", . . . I'm not super optimistic).
"Sands of Dune" is 4 short stories:
• A telling of a young Shadout Mapes (56 years before "Dune"), which seems unnecessary;
• A no-name Sardaukar that could've killed Duncan Idaho (during the fall of Duke Leto), pointless;
• A revenge plot by Gurney Halleck (after the fall of Duke Leto), not bad, good twist at the end;
• And Imperial jockeying between Atreides & Harkonnens (97 years after Battle of Corrin), is meh.
Try typing those sentences without spell-check fighting you every step of the way.
I’m in the process of culling my library for when I move/retire, and it looks like I’m outtie on owning any of the new books (going to have to read the Schools/Heroes/Chronicles series to see if they make the cut). I'll probably read the next series (which with the new movies is inevitable) because I'm dumb like that.
Denis Villeneuve has made the best movie interpretation of "Dune" so far, so here's hoping he doesn't pooch "Dune pt.II" next year. He did a great job with "Arrival", but I don't know how to feel about "Blade Runner 2049" (it's blasphemy, but it's pretty to look at). Heard he's going to do "Rendezvous with Rama" which is so old (1973?), I remember reading my mother's copy.
Anybody want my 3 Legends books?
July 27, 2022
The moron bros fail once again.
January 29, 2024
Very happy to have revisited the world of dune! These stories were so much better than I expected them to be!
The first story about Shadout Mapes was by far the best one, I loved the tragedy and deeper delve into Fremen culture (especially their relation to the Harknonnen). Also really enjoyed the Sardakaur story and thought that the history between Atreides, the other houses and the Emperor was super interesting.
The story about Gurney was fine but I never really liked his character in the original book.
The last story was just political confusion to me.
Overall really enjoyed it and I think you should read it just for the first two stories.
The first story about Shadout Mapes was by far the best one, I loved the tragedy and deeper delve into Fremen culture (especially their relation to the Harknonnen). Also really enjoyed the Sardakaur story and thought that the history between Atreides, the other houses and the Emperor was super interesting.
The story about Gurney was fine but I never really liked his character in the original book.
The last story was just political confusion to me.
Overall really enjoyed it and I think you should read it just for the first two stories.
May 20, 2025
Fun little collection of stories from the world of Dune. I can understand a lot of the criticism behind Brian and Kevins writing- it does not get to the complexity of Franks original pieces. I did feel myself getting hyped at parts only to get the resolution in a page or two. But maybe this criticism isn’t fair considering they’re short stories.
Overall it was nice to dive lightly into a few stories happening in the Dune universe.
Overall it was nice to dive lightly into a few stories happening in the Dune universe.
July 28, 2022
Four short novellas from the universe of Arrakis.
More character studies than actual stories, each provides depth to the peripheral characters which are so vital to the progression of the plot of 'Dune' and its ancillary novels. Herbert and Anderson are confident in their writing and there are many highlights in what is, regrettably, an all too short volume for its price.
More character studies than actual stories, each provides depth to the peripheral characters which are so vital to the progression of the plot of 'Dune' and its ancillary novels. Herbert and Anderson are confident in their writing and there are many highlights in what is, regrettably, an all too short volume for its price.
May 24, 2024
Jumping from Chapterhouse: Dune to this was a sort of... jarring experience, as the way it's written is very different from Frank Herberts style.
The two stories I thought would be the best based on premise (the ones about Shadout Mapes and Gurney Halleck) were the most dissapointing ones - the one about Mapes just wasn't very interesting, and the one with Gurney felt like it just didn't fit very well - netiher with the character nor the world.
I was surprised by how much I enjoyed the one with the Sardaukar Bashar - - and the one placed at the Imperial Court was ok as well , showing some more of that Harkonnen ruthlessness.
The two stories I thought would be the best based on premise (the ones about Shadout Mapes and Gurney Halleck) were the most dissapointing ones - the one about Mapes just wasn't very interesting, and the one with Gurney felt like it just didn't fit very well - netiher with the character nor the world.
I was surprised by how much I enjoyed the one with the Sardaukar Bashar - - and the one placed at the Imperial Court was ok as well , showing some more of that Harkonnen ruthlessness.
February 6, 2024
A nice excursion back into the world of Dune. Some of the stories had a plot that was a bit cliché/predictable, but oh well. It was fun to get some backstory about the Shadout Mapes and Gurney. The Harkonnens are always so mustache-twirling evil it kicks you out of the story a bit. The first story about Mapes was the best because sandworms obviously.
May 11, 2025
Some of the stories were good, nothing extraordinary tho
July 27, 2024
the last story is up to his fathers standards
The rest was mid tbh
The rest was mid tbh
August 21, 2023
Dipping a toe (again, many years later) into the post Frank Herbert Dune books. Coattails. Weak writing that is distracted enough to make me edit sentences while I'm reading. And poor editing ignores repetition even in these novellas/short stories. The last story is the weakest by far and presents the exact same Harkonnen-Atreides conflict with zero new information and even less depth. So, yeah, I finished the collection only because it was so short.
December 23, 2024
Sands of Dune comprises four short stories set in the world of Dune. Each short story is intended to flesh out some of the transitory characters and provide short vignettes revealing aspects of their lives that fall between the pages of the epic that is Dune. Before going into this book it is important to know that Brian Herbert (son of Frank Herbert) and Kevin J. Anderson are the authors of this collection, which is an important distinction in terms of what to expect of the craft of writing and its placement within the timeline of the original. Similarly to how Christopher Tolkien’s contributions to the world of The Lord of the Rings are based on his father’s manuscripts and unfinished works, Brian Herbert has made a name for himself reworking old drafts and spinning his own tales in the world of Dune. If you’re a purist, that might mean you interpret it as a fun but inconsequential spin-off, but for others it could be read within the Dune canon - I suppose it all depends on where you fall on that spectrum of readers. From a layman’s perspective though, if you want the majesty and the high stakes of the original, this might be a bit too simplistic; but, if you’re happy to read anything within the world of Dune without the need for overly cerebral or challengingly dense prose, this may be a safe bet for you. I knew this going into it, and trying to provide an unbiased perspective, I’ll be reviewing each of the short stories on their own merit.
The Edge of a Crysknife
This was a short story focused on Mapes, detailing aspects of her life prior to Baron Vladimir Harkonnen’s takeover of Arrakis. Without spoiling it, it provides her with some justification for infiltrating the houses that come to take over Arrakis and establish her clear motivations for her interactions with Jessica in the main series. Although it tries to be nuanced in how it writes women, with Mapes a warrior, lover, leader, and mother, it ultimately doesn’t add as much nuance to her character as it is trying to achieve and she does become pretty archetypal within the short character arc she is allowed. The writing is simplistic, but the fight scenes are enticing enough to make it a quick read.
Blood of the Sardaukar
This story follows Jopati Kolona, a sardaukar in the middle of battle to overthrow House Atreides and disguised as a Harkonnen soldier, as takes place in the original storyline. The focus is not on the present of this story though, but on the details of Jopati’s past that very much parallel the downfall of the Atreides. Whilst interesting to read from this perspective and the suggestions such a storyline makes to the machinations of Empire, I didn’t find it as attention-grabbing as it could have been as given the short story medium a lot of the detail had to be given quickly through some large chunks of recount. To me, this detracted quite a bit from the story and didn’t really allow me to fully sympathise with Jopati or fully appreciate the weight of his change in actions but the end of this short story.
The Waters of Kanly
This short story focuses on Gurney Halleck in his time after the downfall of the Atreides as a smuggler, exacting smaller and then larger scale acts of revenge on the Harkonnens. To me, this was the most effective of the short stories, perhaps because I had spent a bit of time from his perspective when reading Dune, so he was a better established character in my mind. The pacing was great and his motivations and follow through were quite effective for a short story. Without giving too much away, compared to Jopati’s story, this one had higher stakes and Gurney’s act of revenge served as good catharsis and felt like a better companion story to the original.
Imperial Court
The final short story is set before the events of Dune and serves to establish the enmity between the Harkonnen and Atreides families, with Willem Atreides and Danvis Harkonnnen both vying for the position of Imperial Chamberlain under Emperor Roderick Corrino. It establishes the chivalry, honour, and codes of conduct strictly followed by the Atreides, and the backstabbing and underhanded plays of the Harkonnens with some effectiveness, though as with other short stories in this book there’s not quite enough time to empathise with these characters. It might be a me thing and not a medium thing though, so if you’re interested in the beginnings of the empire, it’s an interesting enough companion piece.
So, there you have it. Ultimately a 3 star read solely for The Waters of Kanly, which to me was the most effective of the short stories. Make of this review what you will - I’d only recommend to those very enamoured with the world and who will salivate over anything set in it. It wasn’t quite what I was looking for but parts were enjoyable enough. It’s certainly quicker and easier to read than the original Dune books (I got somewhat up to God Emperor of Dune but gave up 100 pages in) - though, nothing beats the first book. I’ve kind of solidified my opinion that the one book read alone is all you really need to enjoy Frank Herbert in a palatable way. It admittedly does get pretty freaking weird.
The Edge of a Crysknife
This was a short story focused on Mapes, detailing aspects of her life prior to Baron Vladimir Harkonnen’s takeover of Arrakis. Without spoiling it, it provides her with some justification for infiltrating the houses that come to take over Arrakis and establish her clear motivations for her interactions with Jessica in the main series. Although it tries to be nuanced in how it writes women, with Mapes a warrior, lover, leader, and mother, it ultimately doesn’t add as much nuance to her character as it is trying to achieve and she does become pretty archetypal within the short character arc she is allowed. The writing is simplistic, but the fight scenes are enticing enough to make it a quick read.
Blood of the Sardaukar
This story follows Jopati Kolona, a sardaukar in the middle of battle to overthrow House Atreides and disguised as a Harkonnen soldier, as takes place in the original storyline. The focus is not on the present of this story though, but on the details of Jopati’s past that very much parallel the downfall of the Atreides. Whilst interesting to read from this perspective and the suggestions such a storyline makes to the machinations of Empire, I didn’t find it as attention-grabbing as it could have been as given the short story medium a lot of the detail had to be given quickly through some large chunks of recount. To me, this detracted quite a bit from the story and didn’t really allow me to fully sympathise with Jopati or fully appreciate the weight of his change in actions but the end of this short story.
The Waters of Kanly
This short story focuses on Gurney Halleck in his time after the downfall of the Atreides as a smuggler, exacting smaller and then larger scale acts of revenge on the Harkonnens. To me, this was the most effective of the short stories, perhaps because I had spent a bit of time from his perspective when reading Dune, so he was a better established character in my mind. The pacing was great and his motivations and follow through were quite effective for a short story. Without giving too much away, compared to Jopati’s story, this one had higher stakes and Gurney’s act of revenge served as good catharsis and felt like a better companion story to the original.
Imperial Court
The final short story is set before the events of Dune and serves to establish the enmity between the Harkonnen and Atreides families, with Willem Atreides and Danvis Harkonnnen both vying for the position of Imperial Chamberlain under Emperor Roderick Corrino. It establishes the chivalry, honour, and codes of conduct strictly followed by the Atreides, and the backstabbing and underhanded plays of the Harkonnens with some effectiveness, though as with other short stories in this book there’s not quite enough time to empathise with these characters. It might be a me thing and not a medium thing though, so if you’re interested in the beginnings of the empire, it’s an interesting enough companion piece.
So, there you have it. Ultimately a 3 star read solely for The Waters of Kanly, which to me was the most effective of the short stories. Make of this review what you will - I’d only recommend to those very enamoured with the world and who will salivate over anything set in it. It wasn’t quite what I was looking for but parts were enjoyable enough. It’s certainly quicker and easier to read than the original Dune books (I got somewhat up to God Emperor of Dune but gave up 100 pages in) - though, nothing beats the first book. I’ve kind of solidified my opinion that the one book read alone is all you really need to enjoy Frank Herbert in a palatable way. It admittedly does get pretty freaking weird.
July 9, 2022
Pulp fiction and not worth your time.
August 13, 2024
If you value Frank Herbert's Dune writing for more than just the scifi pewpew, take a *big* circle around this cash grabbing drivel.
I recently finished Frank Herbert's Dune series and these books are some of the more profound I have ever read. Beyond the core story of the Atreides family, the deeper themes of politics, religion, science and the human experience really made me think. Of course, you can't describe Herbert's writing as 'light', especially God Emperor of Dune and beyond. After I finished Heretics, I was craving more Dune.
I chose Sands of Dune since it's thin, and only a few short stories. It didn't seem as much of a commitment as say, starting with the Butlerian Jihad. So, even if it's bad, it wouldn't be a big waste. Also, it was conveniently sold at a bookstore I was in.
I had heard about Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson's works, and about the division they caused among fans of the franchise. I understood that these books weren't up to par with Frank Herbert's writing, but since Herbert Sr.'s writing is so lofty and deep, I thought it couldn't be too bad. Maybe just like a 'regular' sci-fi book then, and a bit more action oriented. That's fine, I thought. Even if it doesn't touch all the deeper themes of Frank Herbert's works, as long as it pays respects to the quality of the world he crafted, it could be quite entertaining. Kind of like the MCU.
Boy, was I wrong. This book reads like fan fiction written by a teenage girl. It blatantly pisses all over the carefully crafted world of Dune with basic, bland writing, predictable excuse for a plot and cringeworthy dialogue.
Let's look at some examples. Barely 10 pages in and we're greeted with this monstrosity (dialogue between Mapes and Rafir):
First, about Rafir's line - who the hell talks like that? These are two grown men but this sounds like how a pubescent horny teenager pictures a first date to go.
Second, if these are two Fremen, why on earth would they explain to *one another* how their culture works? It's expository dialogue of the worst kind.
The book is full of stuff like this. I could maybe read past it if at least the story was interesting, but that has just barely more depth than an episode of Paw Patrol:
At this point I had to stop reading. I just can't believe this made it past an editor! I'd understand if this was fan fiction written on some forum somewhere. Judged like that, it's passable, but as a published book, at quite the price point and with the name of Frank Herbert's son on the cover no less! It just screams "I'm squeezing every penny off my dad's franchise" in every single way. I can't believe Brian Herbert would stoop this low.
I recently finished Frank Herbert's Dune series and these books are some of the more profound I have ever read. Beyond the core story of the Atreides family, the deeper themes of politics, religion, science and the human experience really made me think. Of course, you can't describe Herbert's writing as 'light', especially God Emperor of Dune and beyond. After I finished Heretics, I was craving more Dune.
I chose Sands of Dune since it's thin, and only a few short stories. It didn't seem as much of a commitment as say, starting with the Butlerian Jihad. So, even if it's bad, it wouldn't be a big waste. Also, it was conveniently sold at a bookstore I was in.
I had heard about Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson's works, and about the division they caused among fans of the franchise. I understood that these books weren't up to par with Frank Herbert's writing, but since Herbert Sr.'s writing is so lofty and deep, I thought it couldn't be too bad. Maybe just like a 'regular' sci-fi book then, and a bit more action oriented. That's fine, I thought. Even if it doesn't touch all the deeper themes of Frank Herbert's works, as long as it pays respects to the quality of the world he crafted, it could be quite entertaining. Kind of like the MCU.
Boy, was I wrong. This book reads like fan fiction written by a teenage girl. It blatantly pisses all over the carefully crafted world of Dune with basic, bland writing, predictable excuse for a plot and cringeworthy dialogue.
Let's look at some examples. Barely 10 pages in and we're greeted with this monstrosity (dialogue between Mapes and Rafir):
First, about Rafir's line - who the hell talks like that? These are two grown men but this sounds like how a pubescent horny teenager pictures a first date to go.
Second, if these are two Fremen, why on earth would they explain to *one another* how their culture works? It's expository dialogue of the worst kind.
The book is full of stuff like this. I could maybe read past it if at least the story was interesting, but that has just barely more depth than an episode of Paw Patrol:
At this point I had to stop reading. I just can't believe this made it past an editor! I'd understand if this was fan fiction written on some forum somewhere. Judged like that, it's passable, but as a published book, at quite the price point and with the name of Frank Herbert's son on the cover no less! It just screams "I'm squeezing every penny off my dad's franchise" in every single way. I can't believe Brian Herbert would stoop this low.
February 27, 2024
I am a huge fan of the Dune books by Frank Herbert. Since I have such love for the original Dune series, I have continued to give the expanded universe by Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson a chance. I have found the expanded universe books to be really hit or miss. I don’t think that I really mesh with the writing style of the authors.
The Sands of Dune was no different for me. It is a short book containing four short stories. Three of the stories deal with events and characters from the original book while the fourth story takes the reader back to early days of the imperium looking at the animosity between House Atreides and House Harkonnen.
The Edge of the Crysknife brings back the intriguing character of The Shadout Mapes. In Dune, Mapes was a housekeeper in the Imperial Residence. Not much is known about her past, and she dies during the attack on Arrakeen by the Harkonnens. Mapes is a Fremen and there are hints about her past being steeped in blood. For me this is enough. I like her role in the Dune books and there is enough hinting at her past to make her actions in Dune seem appropriate. This story adds history where it is not needed. Overall, this story doesn’t add much to the character or give insight into Mapes and her beliefs. It doesn’t add to the superstitions or legends that Mapes believes in Dune. It just gives a fairly predictable story of personal loss.
The second story, Blood of the Sardukar, has a few points of interest. The story takes the reader to Salusa Secundus, the infamous prison planet of the emperor's fanatical Sardukar warriors. Learning more of what takes place on Salusa Secondus is always interesting. Even though you see Colonel Bashar Jopati Kolona survive the harsh planet it is really brief. The other interesting point is seen as the story jumps from the past to Kolona at the invasion of Arrakeen by the Sardaukar disguised as Harkonnen. Seeing the Sardaukar in action and seeing the valiant response of Atreides house soldiers adds to the story of the fall of House Atreides. The point I thought was not necessary was the personal history given to Colonel Bashar Jopati Kolona with House Atreides. This story gives a backstory to another Dune minor character. The Sardaukar who speaks for the emperor when the captured Duke Atreides is brought before Baron Harkonnen. There are aspects of this story that add to the Dune world but the history that ties Kolona and Atreides to each other feels too convenient. This story has good and bad. I just didn’t need this particular character from the original Dune to have a connection to the Atreides.
The third story is probably the best in the collection. The Waters of Kanly takes the reader to the missing years of Gurney Halleck. Years of time has elapsed between the fall of House Atreides and reunion of Paul with Gurney. What has Gurney Halleck been doing? This story shows Gurney as he works for revenge and the honor of House Atreides. Nothing too spectacular in the story but the guy you want to root for comes out on top. An adventure and revenge tale that adds to the character of Gurney Halleck without making you think about his portrayal in the original Dune.
The fourth story is the weakest. We know the Harkonnens are bad. We know that Atreides and Harkonnens hate each other. This has been going on for 10,000 years. This story adds nothing to the world or history of Dune.
I give the book 3 stars. Mostly because I will continue to read Dune books. If you are a diehard Dune fan and you enjoy the expanded universe you can probably find things to like in this short story collection.
The Sands of Dune was no different for me. It is a short book containing four short stories. Three of the stories deal with events and characters from the original book while the fourth story takes the reader back to early days of the imperium looking at the animosity between House Atreides and House Harkonnen.
The Edge of the Crysknife brings back the intriguing character of The Shadout Mapes. In Dune, Mapes was a housekeeper in the Imperial Residence. Not much is known about her past, and she dies during the attack on Arrakeen by the Harkonnens. Mapes is a Fremen and there are hints about her past being steeped in blood. For me this is enough. I like her role in the Dune books and there is enough hinting at her past to make her actions in Dune seem appropriate. This story adds history where it is not needed. Overall, this story doesn’t add much to the character or give insight into Mapes and her beliefs. It doesn’t add to the superstitions or legends that Mapes believes in Dune. It just gives a fairly predictable story of personal loss.
The second story, Blood of the Sardukar, has a few points of interest. The story takes the reader to Salusa Secundus, the infamous prison planet of the emperor's fanatical Sardukar warriors. Learning more of what takes place on Salusa Secondus is always interesting. Even though you see Colonel Bashar Jopati Kolona survive the harsh planet it is really brief. The other interesting point is seen as the story jumps from the past to Kolona at the invasion of Arrakeen by the Sardaukar disguised as Harkonnen. Seeing the Sardaukar in action and seeing the valiant response of Atreides house soldiers adds to the story of the fall of House Atreides. The point I thought was not necessary was the personal history given to Colonel Bashar Jopati Kolona with House Atreides. This story gives a backstory to another Dune minor character. The Sardaukar who speaks for the emperor when the captured Duke Atreides is brought before Baron Harkonnen. There are aspects of this story that add to the Dune world but the history that ties Kolona and Atreides to each other feels too convenient. This story has good and bad. I just didn’t need this particular character from the original Dune to have a connection to the Atreides.
The third story is probably the best in the collection. The Waters of Kanly takes the reader to the missing years of Gurney Halleck. Years of time has elapsed between the fall of House Atreides and reunion of Paul with Gurney. What has Gurney Halleck been doing? This story shows Gurney as he works for revenge and the honor of House Atreides. Nothing too spectacular in the story but the guy you want to root for comes out on top. An adventure and revenge tale that adds to the character of Gurney Halleck without making you think about his portrayal in the original Dune.
The fourth story is the weakest. We know the Harkonnens are bad. We know that Atreides and Harkonnens hate each other. This has been going on for 10,000 years. This story adds nothing to the world or history of Dune.
I give the book 3 stars. Mostly because I will continue to read Dune books. If you are a diehard Dune fan and you enjoy the expanded universe you can probably find things to like in this short story collection.
October 4, 2022
Very interesting albeit short collection. I am not sure why they say this book collects three short stories when it actually collects four, but OK.
Stories are interesting but suffer from lack of elegance that disappeared from Dune books after Children of the Dune. While Franks further works got stuck in some weird verbose mode that made Proust and Dumas look like masters of short prose, works made after the Frank Herbert's death suffer from what I can only call over-explanation (something that all big serials suffer from, i.e. Star Wars).
When you look at the first Dune novel (up to the moment when Paul Atreides becomes Emperor) it is quite big but elegant book. It does not insist on details - fights are present and felt but they live in ones head, we are not bombarded by technical details. Just recall assassination attempt of undercover Sardaukar when Gurney gets back with Paul, or Feyd Rautha's arena fight or moment when Tufir Hawath gets captured in the desert - everything is in, fire, blades, thopters falling from the sky, scenes are quite alive and dynamic, but prose is not, lets call it that way, heavy. This is something I am dearly missing from original Dune novels.
That being said.....
Shadout Mapes story is interesting. Of course considering the modern times, she is a strong female fighting to be recognized in the Fremen society (which is total crap considering that in Fremen society women play important role and are fighting shoulder to shoulder with their male counterparts - they are the ones who act as religious rulers and when they are capable (as in case of Jessica and later Aliya) they become warrior queens, very very deadly). That aside interesting story, shows how fight can be achieved in both overt and covert means. This is longest story in the book.
Story of the Sardaukar commander is a short one but very interesting. it sheds some light on this elite brotherhood, way they recruit and train. Interesting story about honor and duty.
Gurney Haleck's short story of revenge just shows how this warrior troubadour is deadly and blood hungry. While first two are stories set during longer time periods this one is set in period of couple of days and is very action oriented, very nice set-piece.
Final story is .... dont get me wrong .... quite pointless. If this story was chapter in a bigger book it would make more sense. This way it is [a very short] story that does not bring anything new - it is just one of the steps in Harkonnen-Atreides feud, cemented with several more dead bodies. For me this story was like 5 minute excerpt from a episode 10, Season 4 (out of say 15) of drama series (26 episodes each season). Absolutely not able to figure out the purpose of it. I am sure those who follow everything that comes out related to Dune universe will know what is going on, but I am left in the dark.
In any case very interesting collection of short stories. First three stories I think would play good introduction to the universe to a newcomer. For fans of Dune universe this would be equivalent to small snack and reunion with dear characters.
To general SF readers, I am not sure book would bring anything amazing (for anyone outside Dune universe, all four stories would seem rather generic) but I think it can act as elements to attract attention to the Dune universe in general (if mentioned SF readers never ventured into it).
For me this collection is 3.5 stars but for the inclusion of Sardaukar story I give it 4.
Recommended.
Stories are interesting but suffer from lack of elegance that disappeared from Dune books after Children of the Dune. While Franks further works got stuck in some weird verbose mode that made Proust and Dumas look like masters of short prose, works made after the Frank Herbert's death suffer from what I can only call over-explanation (something that all big serials suffer from, i.e. Star Wars).
When you look at the first Dune novel (up to the moment when Paul Atreides becomes Emperor) it is quite big but elegant book. It does not insist on details - fights are present and felt but they live in ones head, we are not bombarded by technical details. Just recall assassination attempt of undercover Sardaukar when Gurney gets back with Paul, or Feyd Rautha's arena fight or moment when Tufir Hawath gets captured in the desert - everything is in, fire, blades, thopters falling from the sky, scenes are quite alive and dynamic, but prose is not, lets call it that way, heavy. This is something I am dearly missing from original Dune novels.
That being said.....
Shadout Mapes story is interesting. Of course considering the modern times, she is a strong female fighting to be recognized in the Fremen society (which is total crap considering that in Fremen society women play important role and are fighting shoulder to shoulder with their male counterparts - they are the ones who act as religious rulers and when they are capable (as in case of Jessica and later Aliya) they become warrior queens, very very deadly). That aside interesting story, shows how fight can be achieved in both overt and covert means. This is longest story in the book.
Story of the Sardaukar commander is a short one but very interesting. it sheds some light on this elite brotherhood, way they recruit and train. Interesting story about honor and duty.
Gurney Haleck's short story of revenge just shows how this warrior troubadour is deadly and blood hungry. While first two are stories set during longer time periods this one is set in period of couple of days and is very action oriented, very nice set-piece.
Final story is .... dont get me wrong .... quite pointless. If this story was chapter in a bigger book it would make more sense. This way it is [a very short] story that does not bring anything new - it is just one of the steps in Harkonnen-Atreides feud, cemented with several more dead bodies. For me this story was like 5 minute excerpt from a episode 10, Season 4 (out of say 15) of drama series (26 episodes each season). Absolutely not able to figure out the purpose of it. I am sure those who follow everything that comes out related to Dune universe will know what is going on, but I am left in the dark.
In any case very interesting collection of short stories. First three stories I think would play good introduction to the universe to a newcomer. For fans of Dune universe this would be equivalent to small snack and reunion with dear characters.
To general SF readers, I am not sure book would bring anything amazing (for anyone outside Dune universe, all four stories would seem rather generic) but I think it can act as elements to attract attention to the Dune universe in general (if mentioned SF readers never ventured into it).
For me this collection is 3.5 stars but for the inclusion of Sardaukar story I give it 4.
Recommended.
July 13, 2022
This is a collection of four novellas from the Dune universe intended to add some perspective to the series’ mythos. The four stories are about events that took place outside of the tale told in the full novels by Frank Herbert and the team of Brian Herbert and Kevin J. Anderson.
In this volume, the four stories are:
The Edge of a Crysknife: What was the Shadout Mapes like before she became the head housekeeper for the Atreides? Well, she was a fierce Fremmen warrior. This is a great tale, and many say it is their favorite in the book.
Blood of the Sardukar: Even though the Padishah Emperor Shaddam IV is complicit in the Baron Harkonnen killing Duke Leto Atreides, he has ordered that the Duke not be tortured and made to suffer before he dies. A Sardukar warrior has taken it upon himself to see that Shaddam's wishes are carried out. Mostly seen as merciless killers, this particular Sardukar's background has allowed him to keep a certain amount of compassion.
The Waters of Kanly: In this tale, Gurney Halleck is at the center. He knows the Duke has been captured and killed and thinks the same has happened to the young Paul and his mother, the Lady Jessica. He has taken up with a band of smugglers and is using them to further his vow to avenge himself upon the Harkonnen for the Duke and Paul, as well as what they did to him before he came into the employ of the Atreides.
Imperial Court: A tale set ten-thousand years before the events in Frank Herbert's Dune, It chronicles more of what took place between the Atreides and Harkonnens to make them blood enemies.
I enjoyed all the four stories, but my favorite was The Waters of Kanly.
As one would expect, these are all well-written stories with a lot of action involving characters Dune fans would know, and some new ones we only see in this volume. It is well worth the time to pick this up if you are a fan of the extended Dune universe.
What I enjoyed the most was how well these stories dovetail right into the universe with the same feeling I get when reading any of the books in the saga. Whenever I pick up new material, I always feel like I am getting a visit from friends I haven’t seen for a while. The stories contained in this volume are all entertaining and after I finished reading, I wanted more.
Just a little side note here. I was recently in a local Starbucks for a coffee break. I happened to have on a t-shirt that depicted a sandworm and a group of Fremmen around it. On the back is printed the litany against fear. The young woman who was getting my order together asked me if my shirt was about Dune. Of course, I answered that it was, and we had a brief conversation about how both us enjoyed the new film. It would appear there is a Dune revival currently taking place, and no one is happier about that than I am.
My Highest Recommendations for Sands of Dune!
In this volume, the four stories are:
The Edge of a Crysknife: What was the Shadout Mapes like before she became the head housekeeper for the Atreides? Well, she was a fierce Fremmen warrior. This is a great tale, and many say it is their favorite in the book.
Blood of the Sardukar: Even though the Padishah Emperor Shaddam IV is complicit in the Baron Harkonnen killing Duke Leto Atreides, he has ordered that the Duke not be tortured and made to suffer before he dies. A Sardukar warrior has taken it upon himself to see that Shaddam's wishes are carried out. Mostly seen as merciless killers, this particular Sardukar's background has allowed him to keep a certain amount of compassion.
The Waters of Kanly: In this tale, Gurney Halleck is at the center. He knows the Duke has been captured and killed and thinks the same has happened to the young Paul and his mother, the Lady Jessica. He has taken up with a band of smugglers and is using them to further his vow to avenge himself upon the Harkonnen for the Duke and Paul, as well as what they did to him before he came into the employ of the Atreides.
Imperial Court: A tale set ten-thousand years before the events in Frank Herbert's Dune, It chronicles more of what took place between the Atreides and Harkonnens to make them blood enemies.
I enjoyed all the four stories, but my favorite was The Waters of Kanly.
As one would expect, these are all well-written stories with a lot of action involving characters Dune fans would know, and some new ones we only see in this volume. It is well worth the time to pick this up if you are a fan of the extended Dune universe.
What I enjoyed the most was how well these stories dovetail right into the universe with the same feeling I get when reading any of the books in the saga. Whenever I pick up new material, I always feel like I am getting a visit from friends I haven’t seen for a while. The stories contained in this volume are all entertaining and after I finished reading, I wanted more.
Just a little side note here. I was recently in a local Starbucks for a coffee break. I happened to have on a t-shirt that depicted a sandworm and a group of Fremmen around it. On the back is printed the litany against fear. The young woman who was getting my order together asked me if my shirt was about Dune. Of course, I answered that it was, and we had a brief conversation about how both us enjoyed the new film. It would appear there is a Dune revival currently taking place, and no one is happier about that than I am.
My Highest Recommendations for Sands of Dune!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 125 reviews