Okay, I FINALLY finished this one. As I suspected I would, I came out of it with extremely mixed feelings, much of them due to my personal knowledge of the subject matter.
Full disclosure: I am a cochlear implant (CI) user, one of the first few hundred children who received an implant after the FDA approved it for use in children. I was six and had spent all of my life up to that point signing and deeply involved in the Deaf community. I still consider myself Deaf, with or without my CI. This really affects my perspective on Chorost's story.
I'll admit to being instantly repulsed by his view of his deafness. He goes as far to state that "deaf" is next to "dead" in the dictionary. His view--probably due to his heavily oral background--of his deafness is shrouded with darkness and negativity. This is in dramatic contrast to my view of my own deafness, which is an element of my personality and worldview. I wouldn't take it away for anything.
Another thing that put me off about this book was its obvious effort at "being deep and stuff." Chorost is clearly a very talented writer and an intelligent guy, but the constant references to cyborgs, Shakespeare, and such, just felt ... forced. I ended up feeling like he was trying really hard to prove that he was, in fact, smart.
This book, titled "How Becoming Part Computer Made Me More Human" is somewhat misleading. What he does is chronicle how he has gone full-force into dating as he learned how to deal with his cochlear implant. A lot of what he learned about relationships and relating to women are very apt things, but not really related to his cochlear implants. One could make the argument that the cochlear implant enabled him to talk--and hence have these realizations--to women, and that would be partly true, but Chorost's biggest problem with people was never his hearing. He admits to being very socially awkward and plagued with self-doubt ... all things that simply hearing doesn't solve. He has a tendency to blame his hearing loss for all of his problems, which fortunately, he learns not to by the end of the memoir.
His writing about the technology behind the CIs was one of the highlights of the book. Great, impeccable writing (although sometimes it did get a bit too technical).
I appreciated that Chorost does his very best to give the Deaf culture a fair shake in the CI debate. He even comments on the psychological benefits of the Deaf community: its intimacy, its closeness, its /tightness/. As an outsider, we can't blame him for the distant tone that he adopts as he discusses the problems that the Deaf community faces (he even uses the lower-case 'd' which isn't in keeping with the cultural norm). He speaks of Deafness--the emotional, cultural component of deafness--as an abstraction. He doesn't even appear to speak to any Deaf people face-ot-face, always observing them from afar (unlike children with CIs and CI manufacturers). He also doesn't address one of the reasons why the Deaf culture is outraged: Audio-Visual Therapy (AVT), the most prominent and used methodology for teaching children with CIs spoken language, actively /discourages/ sign language to the point that some parents are afraid that if they teach their children ASL, it'll interfere with their spoken language. There are a lot of other little things like that.
In the end, I feel like I read a prolonged stream of complaints about women from this dude who just happened to have gotten a cochlear implant. Not quite the book I expected.