During the last four years or so, I've been both catching up on my manga backlog, and taking an effort to find newer titles to try, and--ideally--follow long-term. When available, I sample three volumes of a new discovery before deciding whether to buy more of it. (And that's why half of my [admittedly small] front hall is amassing a growing stack of boxes full of manga I read and/or sampled, and decided not to keep and/or continue with.)
If the star rating of this volume didn't give it away for you already, this is a series that didn't quite work for me.
I'd say that alt-history is a hard sell for me, but I'm thoroughly enjoying Ooku, which is exactly that. Both this and Ooku have a good amount of violence and grim events. So it isn't those elements in themselves that are making this story a tough one for me to enjoy.
I kind of hate war stories--or, at best, tolerate war scenes in stories where I appreciate the characters--and this is all war, all the time. The "one size fits all" medieval Europe-like setting doesn't particularly help its cause, either, but I've read enough isekai and villainess stories, with their incredibly generic settings, that that doesn't bother me all that much any more...
The art's fairly good, if somewhat lacking in distinctive flair, and there are some awesome full-page set pieces. Julius and Aleks are character types that would normally be a heady dose of catnip for me, but here... not really. Maybe it's because, very early on, the story established that death and betrayal are always just around the corner, making me unsure of any given character's longevity, and therefore reluctant to grow attached to them. Or maybe there's something lacking in the storytelling that makes me unable to feel the characters' bonds with each other strongly enough.
Well, who knows. I can spend some more time trying to figure out why I'm indifferent to this title, or I can acknowledge that not every single one is going to sink its claws in me, and press on to the dozens of others that are waiting for my attention. I sampled this series based on a complimentary YouTube review by someone whose tastes match mine fairly closely, and I can easily see this appealing to readers with a taste for stories about strength in adversity.